Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell him now or wait until he comes home

132 replies

LyncSync · 01/08/2023 08:27

Hello. So last week we found out that my DMIL was diagnosed with cancer. DH’s mum is late 70’s but it was still a shock to say the least. So fast forward a few days and I have found out that the doctors have only given my DMIL up to 3 months. I’m absolutely gutted but the worst part is my DH isn’t here currently, he’s away (UK) on holiday with our ds. DH was going to cancel the trip but his DM told him to go and she would be upset if didn’t as it’s not fair to let down our ds. So I’m now having a dilemma about what to do. I’ve been awake since 2.30 this morning as everything is weighing heavily on my mind. The small few friends and family I’ve spoken with have all said if it were them they wouldn’t tell DH until he gets home as after all there isn’t anything he can do right now and his DM is not only stable but actually looks really well, better than she has in months, but I’m not sure. If it were me and my DH didn’t tell me this kind of news I’d go ballistic but my DH doesn’t cope well with things like this, I’m not saying anyone does but he is more than likely autistic, as is our ds, so I get why. Him being away with ds is probably the last chance he has to have fun for a while as it’s going to be a difficult few months and although my heart says don’t tell him and let him enjoy the last few days of his holiday but then my head says tell him. I just don’t know what to do.

OP posts:
thereisnorightanswer · 01/08/2023 10:57

I wouldn't tell him, given he's looking after DS. It's not about him having a good time on holiday (he's already worried and on edge, so it's already spoilt). It's about making sure he doesn't accidentally or intentionally do anything stupid to endanger him or your child.

When I found out my parent was dying, I acted very calmly on the phone. That was perfectly in character: I'm the glue. I'm the one who always copes. Then, as soon as I hung up, I walked in circles for hours. It felt like the sky was falling in, and I had no idea what to do or where to go or how to react, so I just walked and walked and walked in giant loops, sobbing like a crazy woman. I'm sure people looked at me like I was off my rocker, but I couldn't see anyone or hear anyone, I was lost in my own spiral of misery, walking and walking.

I'm not sure what I was trying to do. I think that was the problem. I couldn't figure out what to do, so once I'd settled on something (walking), I couldn't take that thought any further, and without a planned destination, I just kept walking in circles. I suppose the issue was, as soon as I stopped, I'd have to go back to processing the news and dealing with it.

I'm actually crying now just at the memory. That's how painful it was finding out.

I'd say there's no good way to tell someone. It's shit news. So whatever you do, don't beat yourself up if it feels like you've got it wrong.

However, I would strongly caution against telling someone when they have no in-person adult support around them and when they are supposed to be busy being responsible for someone or something. I'm surprised at how badly I reacted, but I guess there's no playbook for what to do when you find out your parent is dying.

I'm not saying I would have deliberately harmed myself, but I could have easily had an accident given I couldn't really see or hear through the overwhelming grief. As your DH is solely in charge of your DS at the moment, I don't think it's right to tell him. Wait until they're both back, and you can hold your DH after you tell him. When you are in so much pain, human touch is the only thing that can take any of the hurt off.

In the end, a friend came to get me. I don't know how I would have made my own way home without her. Rationally, I knew where it was, I was just caught in a loop and couldn't make myself break it, go back to the reality, and go home.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 01/08/2023 10:47

LyncSync · 01/08/2023 09:00

He asked about his DM on the phone last night right after I’d got off the phone to SIL. I was in shock and didn’t know what to do so I lied and said that there was no change. I don’t feel proud about it but I was still processing things myself.

No, you have to tell him. At least IMO.

he is clearly already extremely worried, doesn’t have peace of mind.

finding out that my spouse lied about something like this - when I was asking a clear and direct question? I really think that it might shatter me / a lot of trust.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 01/08/2023 10:47

Ok, if your sil told you , why? Did you ask her why she burdened you with this whilst her brother was away ? Seems very odd. And not helpful at all.
ok, if op has close relationship to sil, and they were meeting/general phone cal
and sil was overcome with grief, it’s absolutely understandable . But for SIL to have expressly contacted op to tell her this whilst her brother was on holiday, on a holiday her mother had insisted on him going on, it seems a bit self centred and thoughtless. It was always just going to burden op with something that she isn’t actually the decision maker for

Appleofmyeye2023 · 01/08/2023 10:41

LyncSync · 01/08/2023 08:53

Oh and just to be clear. My DMIL has already said that she doesn’t want to be the one to tell my DH and my FIL and SIL are both currently in pieces so who else would you have tell my DH?

Did mil tell you? Or did someone else tell you?
if mil - visit and discuss your dilemma with her, see what she thinks and make your decision form there

personally, it’s Monday you were told so Saturday isn’t that long a time to hold off giving the news , given mil told dh to proceed with holiday

sandyhappypeople · 01/08/2023 10:32

Mistymountain · 01/08/2023 10:14

I think when he asked specifically I would have told him that the cancer seemed to be advanced, but that his mum wanted him to enjoy his holiday as nothing was likely to happen over the immediate future.
I wouldn't go into the prognosis though, maybe not even when he gets back, nothings definite.
I thought it was unusual for doctors to be so specific, perhaps your MIL is reading between the lines and no firm deadlines have actually been given.

I thought it was unusual for doctors to be so specific, perhaps your MIL is reading between the lines and no firm deadlines have actually been given.

In my experience when it comes to cancer, the doctors want you to know when it's terminal, and can be quite blunt about it, there's no point giving false hope and it gives the patient time to come to terms with it and put any arrangements in place that they need to.

Littlewhitecat · 01/08/2023 10:29

I wouldn't tell him because it's be worried about him having to pack up in a hurry and drive home whilst also explaining to your DS what was going on. If your MIL is currently ok and not suddenly taking a turn for the worse is wait until he was home. Just out of interest why is your DH calling you and asking about his mum and not actually calling his mum if he knows she's only just been diagnosed?

Spinet · 01/08/2023 10:26

I would go and tell him in person. That's what I would want in his position. Everyone's different but for me not being told things is really frightening because then anything could be happening at any point when you're supposed to be relaxing. BUT you know him and your son best.

nokidshere · 01/08/2023 10:24

It wouldn't even be a dilemma for me to be honest. There's no valid reason for telling him over the phone and while he's on holiday. Wait until he's home and you can all sit and talk together.

DisforDarkChocolate · 01/08/2023 10:23

If he's home on Saturday I'd wait until then. This is news for face to face. If he'll struggle with the news he may find the journey home difficult, especially if DS is upset. Love to you all.

Lilibert456 · 01/08/2023 10:23

Let him enjoy his holiday. It is only a few more days and there is nothing to be gained by telling him now except upsetting him when he is far from home. He will surely understand the reasoning behind your decision and may we'll be grateful for it.

Truemilk · 01/08/2023 10:22

I think personally if he asks over the phone again if there's any change you shouldn't lie to him again. If he's actively asking for updates then he himself wants to know what going on.

If he doesn't ask I wouldn't bring it up until he gets home though

Hbh17 · 01/08/2023 10:16

A few days will make no difference.
Your in laws have put you in a difficult position by telling you at all, quite frankly, and they should be giving the news to your son. But I agree with everyone else that your husband and son should enjoy their holiday in peace.

cunningartificer · 01/08/2023 10:15

He went on holiday knowing she had been diagnosed and processing that shock. I'd give him time to finish that before you lay this on him in a place where he's without support. It's not immediate. She wanted him to go. I'd wait and if he asks how she is say that she's had a good day, she's really happy he's on holiday and looking forward to hearing all about it when he comes back. Focus on the fact that he's on holiday partly because she wanted him to have that happy time and that is one of her last gifts to him. Perhaps talk to MIL about this and ask her if she would like him to come back for moral support--her voice either way might help you make the decision.

Mistymountain · 01/08/2023 10:14

I think when he asked specifically I would have told him that the cancer seemed to be advanced, but that his mum wanted him to enjoy his holiday as nothing was likely to happen over the immediate future.
I wouldn't go into the prognosis though, maybe not even when he gets back, nothings definite.
I thought it was unusual for doctors to be so specific, perhaps your MIL is reading between the lines and no firm deadlines have actually been given.

CoffeeBean5 · 01/08/2023 10:14

He needs to hear this from his mum or dad. When they feel up to it they can tell their son. They told his sister so they should tell him too.

NoTouch · 01/08/2023 10:12

It is your MILs decision, but if it was to be kept quiet from her own son until he returned the news should have been more contained.

Having been in the position where others made a decision for me that similarly upsetting news was held back, while family all discussed their opinions on not telling me, while they all started to come to terms with the initial upset I can tell you I did not appreciate it. I felt I was reeling, a week behind everyone else in absorbing it and I was a focal point that I did not want to be instead of working through emotions on the same timeline as everyone else.

I would be even more upset you were putting me in such an awkward position telling a "few friends" too before I knew my own mum was terminal with such a poor prognosis. I would find that hard to forgive.

While I understand wanting to protect your dh, I think you have discussed this with way too many people to still be keeping this from your dh now.

Sittingonabench · 01/08/2023 10:09

I’m so sorry your in this position but I would absolutely tell him. Doctors have given his mother 12 weeks - if my husband didn’t tell me for 5 days (and lied) I would feel robbed and betrayed. You’re right there’s nothing he can do to fix it but this is time which he can be spending processing and being with her. There will be fall out but by not telling him your relationship could be impacted.

laveritable · 01/08/2023 10:08

Please do NOT tell him!

FlamingoQueen · 01/08/2023 10:08

My way of thinking would be - how will he cope driving home after such news? This could be the last few normal days for some time for him and you dc so I think you are right to leave it. If his parents are okay with not telling him yet, I would go with that.
I am sorry you are going through this. Flowers

parliamoglesga · 01/08/2023 10:07

LyncSync · 01/08/2023 08:31

He’s back on Saturday. I’ve not seen his mum since Sunday but I’m hoping to go and see her today. FIL and SIL have said I can tell him if I want to but it’s not like anything is going to happen in the next few days so it’s my decision.

Tell him.

nolongersurprised · 01/08/2023 10:06

Tell him when you see him. It’s not about him having “a right to know” or deceiving him.

If you wait, you’re telling him in an environment where he doesn’t need to drive distressed and you can emotionally support him.

Your main reason for telling him now is because you are struggling with the emotional burden and want to offload, but don’t.

When he’s back tell him you wanted to tell him but didn’t, because you didn’t want them driving home in while he was emotionally distressed and distracted

Whatswhatwhichiswhich · 01/08/2023 10:01

It’s not your place to tell him, it’s your MIL. You cannot take away a dying woman’s wishes, that is beyond cruel.

Batalax · 01/08/2023 10:00

I’m torn. When I was much younger, dp’s didn’t tell me about an issue with my grandparent. I remember the annoyance/upset I felt.
OTOH you have your ds to consider too. And mil insisted he went.

I think if he asks again you can’t lie again. Perhaps you could try fudging it by saying.
”there have been some developments. We can talk about it when you get home”

Then if he wants to know he’ll push further and if he chooses to bury his head in the sand, he can do.

StinkyWizzleteets · 01/08/2023 09:59

Don’t tell him. Let him enjoy what he can of the holiday and he’ll be back in a few days.

you have to work out how to cope
with your own emotion and feelings around your mil being terminally ill without your husband. Ultimately when the time comes for her to die it has to be about him and his siblings & father. His being away is a really good time for you to come to terms with your own grief and to find a way to deal with it because he’s going to need you to be there for him when he gets back .

Winterscomingagain · 01/08/2023 09:59

It's only a short period of time and I particularly wouldn't want my child to get such awful news whilst away from home and not necessarily well supported if his father is really distressed.
I'd consider it a safety issue, 2 very distressed people negotiating travel etc would worry me.