Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell him now or wait until he comes home

132 replies

LyncSync · 01/08/2023 08:27

Hello. So last week we found out that my DMIL was diagnosed with cancer. DH’s mum is late 70’s but it was still a shock to say the least. So fast forward a few days and I have found out that the doctors have only given my DMIL up to 3 months. I’m absolutely gutted but the worst part is my DH isn’t here currently, he’s away (UK) on holiday with our ds. DH was going to cancel the trip but his DM told him to go and she would be upset if didn’t as it’s not fair to let down our ds. So I’m now having a dilemma about what to do. I’ve been awake since 2.30 this morning as everything is weighing heavily on my mind. The small few friends and family I’ve spoken with have all said if it were them they wouldn’t tell DH until he gets home as after all there isn’t anything he can do right now and his DM is not only stable but actually looks really well, better than she has in months, but I’m not sure. If it were me and my DH didn’t tell me this kind of news I’d go ballistic but my DH doesn’t cope well with things like this, I’m not saying anyone does but he is more than likely autistic, as is our ds, so I get why. Him being away with ds is probably the last chance he has to have fun for a while as it’s going to be a difficult few months and although my heart says don’t tell him and let him enjoy the last few days of his holiday but then my head says tell him. I just don’t know what to do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thereisnorightanswer · 01/08/2023 22:39

SilkyMint · 01/08/2023 16:23

Wow, I'm sorry you went through that.

I have first-hand experience, yes, of getting that news in my early-twenties. I can't say I've ever known anyone respond the way you describe. Of course it's tough. Sounds like a pretty intense response and I'm glad you weren't harmed.

I guess it was the straw that broke this camel's back.

The point is grief is unpredictable. And finding out someone is dying is a form of grief. They might still be with you, but you know you're on a timer. You know everything is going to come crashing to an end.

Because it is so unpredictable, I don't think it's a good idea to tell someone over the phone unless there's any other way, and I don't think you should tell someone if they don't have adequate support around them.

In this scenario, the risk is he would struggle to hold it in around his child, or he would lean too heavily on his child. Parents are supposed to look after their children - their children aren't supposed to take care of them.

I am famed for holding it together and never crying. I still reacted badly. The OP's DH is known for not holding it together... Yeah, I'd wait. I'm holding firm on that.

Yes, he might be upset with the OP for not telling him sooner. That will pass. Whatever the OP does or doesn't do, there is a risk he will say something wildly unreasonable and awful. When we're in pain, a lot of us lash out with our words. We shouldn't, but we do.

I suspect MIL has told the OP so she can process the news before OP's DH - because MIL thinks he is going to need to lean on her heavily.

BrawnWild · 01/08/2023 18:41

Dont tell. They're is nothing to be gained between now and Saturday.

Unless you think DH will genuinely stop working/any other activity from now until her death then as hard as it is, life does unfortunately have to carry on (from personal experience, not a callous comment).

I wouldnt want to get that information when I'm miles away and have to put on a brave face and look after a child alone, especially when I have no other adult there to hold my hand

Zanatdy · 01/08/2023 17:53

He needs to know this info. You don’t know for sure nothing will happen now, and if it did he wouldn’t forgive that. Neither would I

Seasideanticscanleadtosandybuckets · 01/08/2023 17:03

If your dh is to drive safely home with ds of course you don't tell him over the phone...

SilkyMint · 01/08/2023 16:23

thereisnorightanswer · 01/08/2023 15:56

Well, it happened to me. I broke down and it’s by fortune of where I was at the time that I didn’t cause myself or others any harm. If I had been near a road, I could have easily walked into it by mistake - I couldn’t see or hear. Everything was just one big awful traumatic blur.

And I normally cope well with everything, and I’d been half-expecting the news.

Hate to break it to you, but some sensible, grown-up adults do find the news of their parents dying to be so horrific that yes, they don’t act normally or rationally.

Have some compassion. Hearing your parent has a terminal illness is tough.

Wow, I'm sorry you went through that.

I have first-hand experience, yes, of getting that news in my early-twenties. I can't say I've ever known anyone respond the way you describe. Of course it's tough. Sounds like a pretty intense response and I'm glad you weren't harmed.

thereisnorightanswer · 01/08/2023 15:56

SilkyMint · 01/08/2023 11:37

Do people really... think that hearing a very elderly parent has a few months to live will put a grown adult in a position where they actually become a danger to themselves or others?

That seems a little extreme honestly, being upset is normal, crying is normal, but... dangerous? Is there a reason you might suspect that outcome, OP? Or just speculation from others? I know OP said he 'doesn't cope with things well' but I'm struggling to imagine how an adult would hear that news and become a danger.

Well, it happened to me. I broke down and it’s by fortune of where I was at the time that I didn’t cause myself or others any harm. If I had been near a road, I could have easily walked into it by mistake - I couldn’t see or hear. Everything was just one big awful traumatic blur.

And I normally cope well with everything, and I’d been half-expecting the news.

Hate to break it to you, but some sensible, grown-up adults do find the news of their parents dying to be so horrific that yes, they don’t act normally or rationally.

Have some compassion. Hearing your parent has a terminal illness is tough.

ThreeTrebles · 01/08/2023 13:51

NoTouch · 01/08/2023 10:12

It is your MILs decision, but if it was to be kept quiet from her own son until he returned the news should have been more contained.

Having been in the position where others made a decision for me that similarly upsetting news was held back, while family all discussed their opinions on not telling me, while they all started to come to terms with the initial upset I can tell you I did not appreciate it. I felt I was reeling, a week behind everyone else in absorbing it and I was a focal point that I did not want to be instead of working through emotions on the same timeline as everyone else.

I would be even more upset you were putting me in such an awkward position telling a "few friends" too before I knew my own mum was terminal with such a poor prognosis. I would find that hard to forgive.

While I understand wanting to protect your dh, I think you have discussed this with way too many people to still be keeping this from your dh now.

I completely agree with this.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 01/08/2023 12:35

Clearly wait until he gets home.

shams05 · 01/08/2023 12:25

I'm surprised he hasn't touched base with his mum considering he knows of the initial diagnosis but I still wouldn't tell him whilst he's away. It'll be difficult enough once they're home but if you tell him whilst they're away it'll taint their annual camping trip for ever.
Every time he takes your Ds away he'll think of the terrible news of his mum's imminent death which will be even worse for your autistic son.

sandyhappypeople · 01/08/2023 11:50

SilkyMint · 01/08/2023 11:37

Do people really... think that hearing a very elderly parent has a few months to live will put a grown adult in a position where they actually become a danger to themselves or others?

That seems a little extreme honestly, being upset is normal, crying is normal, but... dangerous? Is there a reason you might suspect that outcome, OP? Or just speculation from others? I know OP said he 'doesn't cope with things well' but I'm struggling to imagine how an adult would hear that news and become a danger.

I don't necessarily think that people automatically become a danger to themselves, but I would imagine it can invade your thoughts and lead to a lot of distraction? Especially if you don't cope well with things, I can compartmentalise my feelings and 'shelve' things if I need to, but some people it becomes all encompassing, only OP knows how her DH is likely to respond.

Do you ever do that thing where you're driving somewhere or walking somewhere and you don't remember the last few minutes? It normally happens when you're so deep in thought that your brain takes over the automatic stuff so you don't remember what happened, you don't run off the road or anything, your brain keeps you safe, but the bottom line is you're not giving your current task (e.g. driving) your full concentration.

CrotchetyQuaver · 01/08/2023 11:44

If he asks when you're speaking to him I'd tell him, but it's only a few days until he's home.

I was in a similar situation with my DDad a couple of years ago, he was undergoing tests and I knew he wasn't right and was very worried about him to the point I seriously considered not going on the long anticipated holiday for a week. Dad wanted me to go (and I had organised my adult DDs to keep an eye on him until my brother arrived to stay with him so he wasn't going to be all alone). Pancreatic Cancer spread to liver so stage 4 was diagnosed whilst I was away (I knew as GP phoned me whilst I was away). They said about 6 weeks to live, in fact it was 12 days. It's a hard one to call TBH. They may be very close and he wants to come home to be with her, or not, only you know that.

longtompot · 01/08/2023 11:41

LookItsMeAgain · 01/08/2023 09:45

What I would do is wait until Wednesday (they're both due back home on Saturday, right?) and say to your DH "Your mum got an update on her condition since we last spoke and while she is well, right now, the outlook isn't good. It's not even as good as we believed last week. She's doing well right now and is getting the best medical care available. Do you want to come home early or wait until Saturday so you and DS can have the last few days of your holiday?"

So, you're preparing him for bad news but not blurting it out. If he presses you for more details, you can tell him that his mum only has a few months left at that stage.

That's my advice.

Wishing you all the best getting through these coming months.

I think this sounds the best way to deal with an awful situation @LyncSync

I think the only way I'd tell someone early in their holiday about an ill relative was if they were given weeks & not months left. I guess with hindsight a quick chat about what he'd want to happen before he left might have been a good idea, but I guess if you'd all been thinking your MIL had lots longer left then it wouldn't have crossed your minds.

WolfFoxHare · 01/08/2023 11:41

LyncSync · 01/08/2023 08:35

We’ve also got to consider our son who is autistic. He knows his grandmother hasn’t been well and that she is in hospital but both me and dh decided not to tell him about the cancer until after their holiday as he would over think it constantly and it would be upsetting. I know it’ll be upsetting whenever we tell him but if I tell my dh over the phone today (which I really don’t want to) then he may chose to come home which would then upset our son who goes on this holiday every year with his dad and as he’s autistic he doesn’t cope well with change and has to know to the hour in advance when they’re going and when they’re coming back.

I'd wait, given this additional information about your son. Your DH might or might not prefer to know immediately, but I do think you both need to prioritise your DS's mental well-being here.

Owl55 · 01/08/2023 11:40

If it’s only a few days and mil stable it would be better for your son and husband to have you there when you tell him , it will also give mil and sisters time to absorb this bad news and help your husband too . I would hate to be upset on the aero plane or whilst on holiday trying to hide their distress x

SilkyMint · 01/08/2023 11:37

Do people really... think that hearing a very elderly parent has a few months to live will put a grown adult in a position where they actually become a danger to themselves or others?

That seems a little extreme honestly, being upset is normal, crying is normal, but... dangerous? Is there a reason you might suspect that outcome, OP? Or just speculation from others? I know OP said he 'doesn't cope with things well' but I'm struggling to imagine how an adult would hear that news and become a danger.

lostinfusion · 01/08/2023 11:35

I would absolutely tell him, my DH would be really upset if he found out I knew & didn't tell him. But you know your DH better than anyone OP & everyone is different.

Someoneonlyyouknow · 01/08/2023 11:32

There's obviously a lot of emotion around this. I'm sure OP is struggling with shock and grief and anger and guilt. Part of her must want DH home so they can support each other. The harder and more selfless option is to not tell him because both he and DS will find it so difficult. Possibly dangerously so. Perhaps by the time he comes home his parents or sister will feel able to tell him themselves.

Some people say they would be angry they weren't told immediately but DH might be angry that OP has eased her pain by passing it to him

KajsaKavat · 01/08/2023 11:29

Tell him. I’ve personally been on the receiving end of not being told for my own good and it wasn’t nice.

itsmyp4rty · 01/08/2023 11:29

LyncSync · 01/08/2023 09:00

He asked about his DM on the phone last night right after I’d got off the phone to SIL. I was in shock and didn’t know what to do so I lied and said that there was no change. I don’t feel proud about it but I was still processing things myself.

I would try to avoid outright lying in future though, say things like 'she was looking really well when I saw her' or 'she was very chatty and talkative'. That sort of thing that doesn't reflect her prognosis.

itsmyp4rty · 01/08/2023 11:27

I wouldn't tell him for DS's sake, he's autistic and he needs this holiday especially if there is going to be really difficult times ahead for all of you. I'd put his needs first seeing as how there's nothing your DH can actually do about the situation - and that's how I'd break it to DH when he does come back.

I'd be very confident that you made the best choice you could in an impossible situation and that MIL wanted them to enjoy the holiday. Do not allow DH to make you feel bad about this - he should have been speaking to his mother during his time away if he didn't want you to handle any arising situations as you saw best. Do what's best for DS in this and know you did the right thing.

SilkyMint · 01/08/2023 11:08

Ooof. So you haven't just not told him, you've actually lied to him saying everything is fine.

I would be furious honestly if I were in the DH's position. Imagine hearing that your mum is doing okay, feeling that immense relief, enjoying the holiday safe in the knowledge that there's been no change for her, then coming home and finding out you're the last to know.

I personally would much rather know the situation to deal with it than be kept in the dark for my own perceived good. I think this thread is a lesson to us all to talk to our partners and ask their opinions on this sort of thing: if you're away and something bad happens, would you want to know? I know I would. Your MIL might not want the holiday impacted but realistically your DH might value knowing and being able to ring and talk to her to support her right now or considering coming home early to be with her. It's nobody's choice to make but him.

If my DH hid something like this from me it would really impact our trust, being treated like a child who can't cope with upsetting news. And yes, I've been there in my early twenties with my own mum dying.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 01/08/2023 11:07

Another one who is curious as to why on earth they told you. Surely they should have just rung your DH?

VictoriaVenkman · 01/08/2023 11:05

Sorry for the awful news OP Flowers

This is a case of dammed if you do and dammed if you don't. Your DH could be very angry you didn't tell him or he could understand your actions.

Personally I would not tell him. There is nothing to be gained by telling him the news now. He and your DS would be terribly upset and coming home with that news would be awful however I would also understand if he was very angry at the news being kept from him.

Cantthinkof1rightnow · 01/08/2023 11:05

@LyncSync I wouldn't tell him until he got home, mainly because your mil wanted them to enjoy the holiday, and your son will struggle with the change in routine, but also because driving home upset and grief stricken could result in an accident.

LadyLapsang · 01/08/2023 11:01

Do you normally facilitate your DH’s relationship with his parents, e.g. the phone calls? I think it is sad that your DMIL does not want to tell him herself. Given your son has ASD and you suspect your husband has ASD too, my initial reaction was to wait until they get back. However, not being honest in response to a straight question is more difficult.