Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say you shouldn't have a child to heal yourself?

67 replies

ncrelative · 01/08/2023 07:15

NC as outing
I have a relative who has sadly had a very unfortunate life in many respects. Poor upbringing, lack of ability to do things in life, emotional problems.

She is now in a relationship and wants to have a child. She is very positive about this as a way too heal her past life and experiences as she feels others have always had a lucky life and she has always been unlucky and not had what others have. I have been extremely supportive but in our last conversation I got a bit frustrated and told her as a parent it's not how she thinks it is, it is hard work and not about healing yourself but about raising a child who needs you to be their everything.

Her partner also has issues from being abused so neither of them have experience of how to raise a healthy child.

She got really angry at this saying I was privileged to have a family and all she wants is what we all were born having.

I said it was unfair but a child isn't therapy or a healing mechanism and that it's no one's right to have a child in order to heal themselves. Further, if you have never been raised with any idea of successful parenting it isn't right to bring a helpless child into the world to potentially repeat the cycle.

(In the past she has done things like bought a 10 year old relative a range of adult nail polish for Christmas, had no idea how to cook raw chicken at 23yo and thought you could cook it in the microwave, has never babysat or had any experience)

She is extremely angry and upset with me now and predictably won't speak to me. I want to apologise if I hurt her but at the same time I can't support having a child as a kind of therapy. AIBU?

OP posts:
LemonLight · 01/08/2023 09:15

Wow you've been extremely horrible to her! If I were her this would end the friendship for me. You are extremely judgemental and I think you need to get over yourself tbh!

Wertie · 01/08/2023 09:12

I wish her all the best. I know people that have had awful childhood experiences, and gone on to be fantastic parents. To be honest I think you just need to leave her alone. Judgement is just going to destroy the self esteem she builds up. Leave her be

Wertie · 01/08/2023 09:11

It’s callous and unpleasant. Frankly she’s doing better than many, planning and thinking for what will be a wanted child.
If it were my relative I’d be saying ‘I know you had a hard time. I’m here for any questions or concerns you have, or just to share what I had- I’d you ever need that’. You could just have talked through the positives and offered ideas for anything she may find difficult

Sazza26xx · 01/08/2023 08:41

I can see why you're concerned, however it doesn't mean she will continue the cycle or be a bad parent, many people break the cycle of neglect and abuse

ShiteRider · 01/08/2023 08:35

You’re really out of order. The headline isn’t actually what you’re saying. From the body of the text it sounds like she wants to give a child a positive start in life not heal herself.

I see the intergenerational impact of poor parenting every day and it’s far more complex than if you’ve never experienced positive parenting you shouldn’t have kids.

You’re coming across as incredibly judgey and it sounds like you’ve never actually tried to help her, just looked down on her for having a different life from you

Ngmi · 01/08/2023 08:32

I think you are being very judgmental.

Saoirse82 · 01/08/2023 08:31

ncrelative · 01/08/2023 08:01

I see what everyone is saying and will try to apologise (though she's not speaking to me at the moment!)

I think personally I would view it from the perspective of being heartbreaking and unfair, but if I were in that position I would accept that it's not right to have children in my circumstances, like a career athlete having to give up a sport if they get injured due to no fault of their own. But I completely agree that it's a personal choice and there's no right or wrong and there may be therapy and parenting groups she can access. I will see if I can look a few of these up for her.

The nail polish and chicken were just random examples so probably shouldn't have included them. I just worry having a child is another fad like the latest supplement she is trying or illness in the news she's convinced she's got and now needs to treat to fix everything.

You're making yourself sound worse as you go along. How dare you say from your privileged position that if you were her that you wouldn't have children!

I wouldn't bother looking up parenting classes for her, I can't imagine that going down too well after what you've already said.

I honestly think she's better off without someone like you in her life, you sound smug and judgemental and quite frankly awful!

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 01/08/2023 08:29

ncrelative · 01/08/2023 08:01

I see what everyone is saying and will try to apologise (though she's not speaking to me at the moment!)

I think personally I would view it from the perspective of being heartbreaking and unfair, but if I were in that position I would accept that it's not right to have children in my circumstances, like a career athlete having to give up a sport if they get injured due to no fault of their own. But I completely agree that it's a personal choice and there's no right or wrong and there may be therapy and parenting groups she can access. I will see if I can look a few of these up for her.

The nail polish and chicken were just random examples so probably shouldn't have included them. I just worry having a child is another fad like the latest supplement she is trying or illness in the news she's convinced she's got and now needs to treat to fix everything.

Get over yourself. You have no idea how you would feel in her position and you have no right to dictate who should and should have children.

unless of course you haven’t mentioned a drug or alcohol problem, or that her relationship is violent and not safe for kids to be brought into, or she’s homeless or something. Is there an issue like that? If not butt out.

AverseNotAdverse · 01/08/2023 08:25

ncrelative · 01/08/2023 08:01

I see what everyone is saying and will try to apologise (though she's not speaking to me at the moment!)

I think personally I would view it from the perspective of being heartbreaking and unfair, but if I were in that position I would accept that it's not right to have children in my circumstances, like a career athlete having to give up a sport if they get injured due to no fault of their own. But I completely agree that it's a personal choice and there's no right or wrong and there may be therapy and parenting groups she can access. I will see if I can look a few of these up for her.

The nail polish and chicken were just random examples so probably shouldn't have included them. I just worry having a child is another fad like the latest supplement she is trying or illness in the news she's convinced she's got and now needs to treat to fix everything.

You sound really sanctimonious. The chicken and nail polish and childcare comments actually undermine your argument. If that’s all you can come up with, she sounds pretty sorted.

Yes people shouldn’t have kids as therapy. But many people with bad childhoods are great parents. Some make better parents for doing the opposite of what their own mum and dad did.

Believe it or not, she could end up a better parent than you.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 01/08/2023 08:19

I think this is none of your business OP and you should keep your beaky nose out of it.

you cannot police who can and can’t have children. Some people who have terrible upbringings make wonderful parents who are determined not to let history repeat. Loads of people with no experience of children have babies. Get over yourself and you superior attitude. No wonder she’s upset with you.

please apologise to her for being so judgemental. If you want to help then support her to be the best parent she can be.

Saoirse82 · 01/08/2023 08:18

Further, if you have never been raised with any idea of successful parenting it isn't right to bring a helpless child into the world to potentially repeat the cycle.

No wonder she isn't speaking to you. I'd cut you dead after the way you've behaved.

Are you saying that people who have experienced abuse or trauma in childhood aren't fit to be parents?

I have a friend who had a terrible childhood, absolutely awful in every way and she's a wonderful loving mother.

You're beyond rude and judgemental. I'm angry on behalf of your relative. You need to apologise but don't be surprised if she doesn't accept your apology.

itsmyp4rty · 01/08/2023 08:14

I was pretty lost when I had DS, I was educated but really struggled with work and finding a job (probably ND) - didn't know what to do with myself and so decided having a child was the answer. Then I had DS and it was hell! He was a really, really difficult baby and I thought he'd ruined my life. Then he got to 3 and everything got better and he's been the best thing ever for the last 14 years. He gave my life a focus and purpose and I worked so hard at being a really good mum as it was so important to me. He's off to uni soon and I'm so proud of him (he's ND too).

It could be the making of her or it could be the breaking of her - or perhaps a combination of both! but no one can predict that. I don't think anyone ever has any idea how much having a baby will change their life! Much better for you to be there to help and support her, tell her your experiences and suggest some things that really worked for you.

I would buy her a really good baby book and send it to her her with an apology card saying how sorry you are and that you were just worried that she might not realise how hard having a baby can be because you found it very difficult yourself (or relate it to your own experience in some way).

LiloP · 01/08/2023 08:11

What are her circumstances exactly? You have not said anything that made me think she can’t have children unless this is a massive drip feed and she is homeless or a drug addict.

i can’t get over how judgmental you are. A lot of us have not had perfect childhoods or even far from and can still parent well with the right support and help. Nobody is destined “to fail” at parenting. Maybe she is better off cutting you out as you clearly can’t be supportive.

IAmAnIdiot123 · 01/08/2023 08:11

ncrelative · 01/08/2023 08:01

I see what everyone is saying and will try to apologise (though she's not speaking to me at the moment!)

I think personally I would view it from the perspective of being heartbreaking and unfair, but if I were in that position I would accept that it's not right to have children in my circumstances, like a career athlete having to give up a sport if they get injured due to no fault of their own. But I completely agree that it's a personal choice and there's no right or wrong and there may be therapy and parenting groups she can access. I will see if I can look a few of these up for her.

The nail polish and chicken were just random examples so probably shouldn't have included them. I just worry having a child is another fad like the latest supplement she is trying or illness in the news she's convinced she's got and now needs to treat to fix everything.

What a load of rubbish, you have no idea what you would do in her position because you are in the privileged position to not have had an awful family background and now have a loving family of your own.

I don't know why nail varnish and chicken are proof that she is following a fad, still can't quite wrap my head around that.

Everyone has children for one selfish reason or another, including you.

ncrelative · 01/08/2023 08:01

I see what everyone is saying and will try to apologise (though she's not speaking to me at the moment!)

I think personally I would view it from the perspective of being heartbreaking and unfair, but if I were in that position I would accept that it's not right to have children in my circumstances, like a career athlete having to give up a sport if they get injured due to no fault of their own. But I completely agree that it's a personal choice and there's no right or wrong and there may be therapy and parenting groups she can access. I will see if I can look a few of these up for her.

The nail polish and chicken were just random examples so probably shouldn't have included them. I just worry having a child is another fad like the latest supplement she is trying or illness in the news she's convinced she's got and now needs to treat to fix everything.

OP posts:
Pippa12 · 01/08/2023 07:58

You should apologise. But to be honest you sound quite young yourself and I remember having very black and white views in my early 20’s.

The examples you gave really are not reasons to not have children.

Perhaps you should consider that she’s had a crash course in how not to parent, and might be bloody brilliant at it!

LovingLivingLife · 01/08/2023 07:54

idea to have a child to heal yourself, so many things can go wrong with that.

But your examples and reasoning as to why she would be a bad mum are terrible. Anyone who motivated to be a good parent can be, especially with the love and support of their family.

IAmAnIdiot123 · 01/08/2023 07:53

DisquietintheRanks · 01/08/2023 07:44

Yes, that was a terrible thing to say @ncrelative and you owe her a huge apology. It's also rubbish.

Jesus! I was so wrapped up with the nail varnish comment, I missed this bit!

OP that is a truly awful thing to say, yoi owe her a huge apology! Who needs enemies eh?

DisquietintheRanks · 01/08/2023 07:44

Ikeatears · 01/08/2023 07:40

"Further, if you have never been raised with any idea of successful parenting it isn't right to bring a helpless child into the world to potentially repeat the cycle"

What? So every neglected, abused or abandoned child must never grow up to have children. This makes no sense, is extremely judgemental and offensive.

Yes, that was a terrible thing to say @ncrelative and you owe her a huge apology. It's also rubbish.

Yoyoban · 01/08/2023 07:43

By your criteria, you should have your children removed from you since you clearly don't know that you CAN cook chicken in the microwave 🤔

Ikeatears · 01/08/2023 07:40

"Further, if you have never been raised with any idea of successful parenting it isn't right to bring a helpless child into the world to potentially repeat the cycle"

What? So every neglected, abused or abandoned child must never grow up to have children. This makes no sense, is extremely judgemental and offensive.

MRex · 01/08/2023 07:40

You were hugely unreasonable. Helpful comments might be talking about the need for counselling alongside as it might raise childhood issues they need to deal with, advising her to get lots of help and input from health visitors, and looking up useful parenting courses to recommend. Useful actions would be buying them "how to talk" books and buying a cookery course for Christmas. You have no right to suggest that someone who had a bad background doesn't deserve to have a family, and I'm shocked you still can't see that.

Random789 · 01/08/2023 07:40

riotlady · 01/08/2023 07:35

Further, if you have never been raised with any idea of successful parenting it isn't right to bring a helpless child into the world to potentially repeat the cycle.

You overstepped and I think this in particular was a really shitty thing to say. Congratulations on having a wonderful upbringing but lots of people are not so fortunate and are able to overcome their circumstances and become excellent parents. Your friend sounds like she is approaching it thoughtfully, none of the examples you’ve given are terrible (what’s wrong with nail varnish? And lots of people are shit cooks at 22!) and you have unfairly insulted her future ability to parent based on her past.

Yes, agree. In fact, if you actually said that to her that is one of the most shockingly unpleasant things Ive ever heard anyone confessing to on MN.

Aparecium · 01/08/2023 07:39

Popetthetreehugger · 01/08/2023 07:27

How about apologise , and give your support to help her learn ? Sign her up to any group that she would find supportive after baby born . Teach her to cook ? She wants to experience a loving family by building one , she may be the best mother by doing the opposite of her life so far . And , nail varnish ? Give me a break ! Get of your smug , I’m better than you box and give this very human human a hand .

Yes, this.

Cycles can be broken. People can parent differently because they actively choose to do things differently. My mother and her siblings were latchkey kids and beaten as discipline, my siblings and I were smacked but mum was always at home when we arrived from school, I have never hit any of my dc. My mum and I actively chose to parent differently to our parents, and the cycle was broken.

As for having a child to heal yourself, I have done this. I had severe PND after dc1, and was advised not to try for dc2 until I was fully recovered. But I realised that life was on hold while I waited to recover, yet I needed to move on with life in order yo get better. So we took the plunge and had dc2. And, yes, having dc2 completed my recovery. I did not have PND again, not after any of my other dc.

LiloP · 01/08/2023 07:37

“Further, if you have never been raised with any idea of successful parenting it isn't right to bring a helpless child into the world to potentially repeat the cycle.”

this is also an awful sentence. Lots of us had bad parents and childhoods and don’t repeat the cycle.
you sound toxic and unsupportive. All I read is a person with a bad childhood wanting to have a normal family life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread