Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is sexual discrimination?

133 replies

Blondie6123 · 31/07/2023 21:03

I Went out this evening for food at a large national pub chain.

I feel slightly embarrassed to publish this, as I have been made to feel like an irresponsible parent, whereas on the contrary I am a very responsible and conscientious person.

I am currently breastfeeding and I know some people choose not to drink but I have done my research and I am happy to have the occasional drink and still feed on the rare occasion. I strongly feel this is personal choice.

I had two glasses of wine over the space of over 2 hours and then ordered a meal with a further glass of wine, which to be honest I would not usually do but this my first time out since my son was born and I was enjoying having time with my partner out of the house.

We sat discretely in the corner and I breastfed my son on our arrival, I had a bottle of pre made formula with me which my partner gave to our son during the evening. It was during this time I consumed two glasses of wine without any issue and without being intoxicated due to the time elapsed.

We then ordered food and a subsequent drink. My son then required a further feed and I started to breastfeed which I felt was fine due to having two alcoholic drinks over a number of hours and feeling sober. Soon after this the manager came over and said I could have no more to drink as we were in charge of a child and mumbled something about pregnant women and a two drink policy if there are children present.

I would understand but there were people in there with children running riot and drinking what they wanted without any intervention or enforcement of the two drink policy. I understand if it’s company policy but surely it becomes discriminatory when not applied universally to the pub clientele and only targeted and the only breastfeeder in the pub? I explained we had been there for a number of hours and I was hardly downing sambucca’s!

I am without doubt that the reason for this intervention was because I had started to breastfeed and this was confirmed by the comment about pregnant woman (as I am not pregnant and clearly the issue was some concern around alcohol transmission through breastfeeding).

I have come away feeling so ashamed and upset. I was at no point drunk or intoxicated and had spaced out drinks adequately to feel I was safe enough to feed my child.

AIBU to think this treatment was discriminatory and unfair? Or should I not be breastfeeding and having alcohol in public again?

OP posts:
gogomoto · 01/08/2023 12:39

It's not uncommon for pubs to have a limit for parents to stop them having drunk parents. I've seen signs up recently saying 2 drinks max and must order food

greenteaandmarshmallows · 01/08/2023 12:37

Lemonfanta4 · 31/07/2023 21:11

If it’s a two drink policy if you’re with a child and it applies to both parents where is the discrimination?

Was this the policy? I'm unclear

MisschiefMaker · 01/08/2023 12:34

I am confused. How much was your DH drinking and was he prevented from drinking too?

FOJN · 01/08/2023 11:48

The discussion is not about whether OP should be drinking if she is breast feeding, Wetherspoons have neither the expertise or authority to express an opinion on that.

I think it's perfectly reasonable for them to impose a drink limit on parents in charge of children. I doubt the pub wants the responsibility of maintaining a child's safety because the parents are pissed.

Whether this is discriminatory is a legal question but I think it's one worth asking if your husband was served more than two drinks without reference to the policy.

SilkyMint · 01/08/2023 11:39

Honestly can't imagine ever drinking while taking care of my toddler, let alone when they were a newborn. I know this is MN so there'll be lots of people saying it's totally normal and fine to drink and get drunk while caring for small children but in the real world, I don't know anyone that would be like oh, I'm caring for my toddler/baby, let me drink a bottle of wine. How could your judgment not be impaired? What if there was a medical issue and you needed to get to hospital?

10HailMarys · 01/08/2023 11:37

It isn’t discriminatory if the rule applies to parents in general, not just mothers.

It is your choice to breastfeed after three glasses of wine, but that doesn’t mean any establishment has to bend their usual rules for you.

You don’t say what size glasses they were, but a large glass is 250ml so three glasses is a full bottle. A medium glass is 175ml so about three-quarters of a bottle. Up to you to decide whether you think that’s OK. I personally wouldn’t drink that much if I had a small baby in tow, regardless of whether I was breastfeeding.

drpet49 · 01/08/2023 11:37

SilkyMint · 01/08/2023 11:15

Honestly, good for them. Your right to decide how much you drink and bf, but the pub don't have to let you do it on their premises. I think child safety is everyone's business, and too many people just look the other way. Three glasses of wine in the span of a few hours while breastfeeding is a massive amount. Not just in terms of the alcohol passing to the baby but only a hardened alcohol drinker would feel sober enough to care for a child after that amount.

If your DH wasn't drinking then it's a bit different as at least one adult would be safe to be in charge of the baby, but still you have the issue of essentially giving your baby alcohol.

This.

ichundich · 01/08/2023 11:24

I think it's understandable how you felt, but I do think 3 glasses of wine in a couple of hours is generally a bit too much, even when not breastfeeding.

Mummy08m · 01/08/2023 11:22

Mummy08m · 01/08/2023 11:21

[Moving away from how much alcohol is OK when breastfeeding because its clearly complicated and I myself have got mycalculations wrong above... oops!] ...

I think op it wasn't sex discrimination on balance. I think there are lots of situations where wetherspoons might refuse to serve and it probably affects men actually more often than women if anything (rightfully so).

If someone is drinking too much and staff are worried about their behaviour

If parents are drinking too much and staff are worried about the kids' behaviour

If someone is drinking and staff reasonably suspect they're planning to drive home.

It becomes too difficult for staff to judge on a case by case basis so they just have blanket rules. Parents with kids (of any age)? Two drinks max.

Fwiw I also think I'd be sympathetic if staff refused to serve strong alcohol to a woman who was visibly pregnant. It's illegal to drink when pg of course (and I do have the odd half glass of wine once in a while) but I can see why they'd refuse to serve me with my massive bump. We are all a society looking after each other.

In my mum's country, traditional medicine rules say certain foods like coconut eaten to excess can cause premature birth (might well be BS) and my mum told me once that a market stall owner (older woman) refused to sell her coconut when she was pregnant with me and gave her a little lecture. She wasn't offended but kind of touched cos it came from a caring place.

So even if the staff took it upon themselves to decide not to serve you as you were BF, i wouldn't see that as a judgy thing, more just everyone looking out for each other

That should say iys NOT illegal to drink when pg!

wutheringkites · 01/08/2023 11:21

I think breastfeeding is a bit of a straw man argument here. The staff member didn't say that breastfeeding mothers are refused service, they said there is a 2 drink limit for people with kids.

Unless she was counting the drinks of everyone around her, I'm not sure how she can say that they only imposed this on her.

Op was also unclear about whether her partner was also drinking and if the limit applied to him as well.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 01/08/2023 11:21

Is it Wetherspoons ? I believe they have a 2 drink per person policy to anyone who has small kids with them. The policy I believe applies to males and females. So not discrimination. Even if it was indirect discrimination ie more likely to impact females I reckon they could try and justify it on the basis that people looking after kids shouldn’t be intoxicated. It’s nothing to do with pregnancy or BFing.

Mummy08m · 01/08/2023 11:21

[Moving away from how much alcohol is OK when breastfeeding because its clearly complicated and I myself have got mycalculations wrong above... oops!] ...

I think op it wasn't sex discrimination on balance. I think there are lots of situations where wetherspoons might refuse to serve and it probably affects men actually more often than women if anything (rightfully so).

If someone is drinking too much and staff are worried about their behaviour

If parents are drinking too much and staff are worried about the kids' behaviour

If someone is drinking and staff reasonably suspect they're planning to drive home.

It becomes too difficult for staff to judge on a case by case basis so they just have blanket rules. Parents with kids (of any age)? Two drinks max.

Fwiw I also think I'd be sympathetic if staff refused to serve strong alcohol to a woman who was visibly pregnant. It's illegal to drink when pg of course (and I do have the odd half glass of wine once in a while) but I can see why they'd refuse to serve me with my massive bump. We are all a society looking after each other.

In my mum's country, traditional medicine rules say certain foods like coconut eaten to excess can cause premature birth (might well be BS) and my mum told me once that a market stall owner (older woman) refused to sell her coconut when she was pregnant with me and gave her a little lecture. She wasn't offended but kind of touched cos it came from a caring place.

So even if the staff took it upon themselves to decide not to serve you as you were BF, i wouldn't see that as a judgy thing, more just everyone looking out for each other

FloweryName · 01/08/2023 11:17

It’s ridiculous to try and claim sexual discrimination over this. Clearly, your judgment on various things isn’t great OP.

If I were a waiter in this restaurant I wouldn’t want to be responsible for serving so much alcohol to someone who was breastfeeding just because I’d feel uncomfortable with it. The manager did the right thing by protecting his staff from being in that position. You can make your own choices about how much alcohol you drink while breastfeeding but if you want someone else to facilitate that choice for you by drinking in a restaurant, then other people’s opinions matter. Protecting vulnerable children is everyone’s business.

SilkyMint · 01/08/2023 11:15

Honestly, good for them. Your right to decide how much you drink and bf, but the pub don't have to let you do it on their premises. I think child safety is everyone's business, and too many people just look the other way. Three glasses of wine in the span of a few hours while breastfeeding is a massive amount. Not just in terms of the alcohol passing to the baby but only a hardened alcohol drinker would feel sober enough to care for a child after that amount.

If your DH wasn't drinking then it's a bit different as at least one adult would be safe to be in charge of the baby, but still you have the issue of essentially giving your baby alcohol.

MutantTurtles · 01/08/2023 11:11

Refrosty · 31/07/2023 23:47

You need research to tell you that 3 glasses of wine might not be a good idea when responsible for kids?

The comment I responded was specifically about drinking and breastfeeding

MutantTurtles · 01/08/2023 11:10

temosmail · 31/07/2023 23:40

@MutantTurtles based on the fact that there is alcohol in her blood and therefore going to go in the breast milk.

It's absolutely reckless and selfish to breast feed straight after drinking five glasses of wine.

Alcohol - poison.

Baby - takes the alcohol.

Don't risk it, bottle feed. Ffs.

If a man was to do this you would be up in arms.

And OP you were pushed.

And can you provide the evidence that the stated amount of alcohol is harmful?

temosmail · 01/08/2023 10:38

CheeseNPickle3 · 01/08/2023 00:10

I read the OP again - I think it was only 2 glasses in the space of 2 hours, both before the meal and that was it. The one ordered with the meal wasn't served because of the 2 drink limit. Not sure where people are getting 5 from?

"I had two glasses of wine over the space of over 2 hours and then ordered a meal with a further glass of wine,"

So three glasses/a bottle of wine she was having whilst breast feeding.....

Baby was fed on arrival and got hungry two hours later.

All OP needed to do was bring enough formula so she didn't have to breast feed whilst drinking.

CheeseNPickle3 · 01/08/2023 00:10

I read the OP again - I think it was only 2 glasses in the space of 2 hours, both before the meal and that was it. The one ordered with the meal wasn't served because of the 2 drink limit. Not sure where people are getting 5 from?

Deathbyfluffy · 01/08/2023 00:07

pambeeslyhalpert2 · 31/07/2023 22:00

It's absolutely fine to drink and breastfeed. That waitress knows nothing and isn't her place to mum shame you

But it is her place to follow company policy, which she was doing.

Refrosty · 31/07/2023 23:47

MutantTurtles · 31/07/2023 23:38

Based on which research?

You need research to tell you that 3 glasses of wine might not be a good idea when responsible for kids?

temosmail · 31/07/2023 23:41

Pissed*. Five glasses of wine = Standard glass of red/white/rosé wine (175ml, ABV 12%)
2.1 units

10.5 units.

You shouldn't have breast feed for 10 hours after your last drink.

temosmail · 31/07/2023 23:40

@MutantTurtles based on the fact that there is alcohol in her blood and therefore going to go in the breast milk.

It's absolutely reckless and selfish to breast feed straight after drinking five glasses of wine.

Alcohol - poison.

Baby - takes the alcohol.

Don't risk it, bottle feed. Ffs.

If a man was to do this you would be up in arms.

And OP you were pushed.

temosmail · 31/07/2023 23:38

Emmamoo89 · 31/07/2023 22:53

You've done nothing wrong. I drank 3 glasses of wine and continued to breastfeed my son and didn't pump and dump.

I'd like to add you'd literly have to have alcohol poisoning for it to reach baba through the milk.

Because pumping and dumping doesn't work....

MutantTurtles · 31/07/2023 23:38

temosmail · 31/07/2023 23:37

You had five glasses of wine and breastfeed. Idiot.

Based on which research?

temosmail · 31/07/2023 23:37

You had five glasses of wine and breastfeed. Idiot.