Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being too demanding by asking for 1 hour a day to exercise?

165 replies

Dad12344444 · 31/07/2023 11:08

For context, I am a 35 year old guy with 3 kids, 9 7 and 6 weeks old and a golden retriever. I work a fairly high pressure job and earn in excess of 250k a year and I’m very proud of the life this enables my family and I to have.

I do almost all of the school runs for the eldest and all of their club pickup/drop offs (4 days a week). I do the 3am night feed for my youngest, so my wife can get a block of sleep.

In the house, Im almost exclusively responsible for the laundry, make the majority of kids’ dinners & bed times. I probably do 50% of the food shopping however, maybe 20% of my wife & I’s dinner.

In addition to this, we have a cleaner, a sleep nanny 2ce a week, a tutor for eldest & a dog walker which I pay for to try and provide support & free up some time. I am fully aware how privileged we are to be able to fund this help.

My wife is on maternity, however just prior to this she had recently qualified as a therapist and working 2 days a week. She suffered from post natal depression with both of our previous children and i has been something we have been really aware of this time & have tried to take into account ways to give her the best chance and space to mentally recover.

With all of this said, I feel like I need to be ‘on it’ most of the time, I don’t drink anymore as I found this was really contributing to this. It led to my mood being irritable and generally not as sharp.

The other thing that I find enables me to function to a high level is exercise. I recently made the ask of 1 hour a day to do this, I can do this in the middle of the day or night, i don’t mind getting up at 4 am or going during my workday.

However this request was met with: ‘I have carried this child for 10 months and now breast feeding and you are putting your own needs above me’. And ‘give me my time. If there is time for you great, but stop demanding it’.

This is the reason for my post. I feel like I go to the extreme to carve my wife out time, which she wastes, scrolling or lying on the sofa. So when I then try and take an hour that I work really hard to create, her response is ‘well i haven’t had any time’ and it becomes really difficult to swallow for me.

The logical side of me understands that her needs aren’t being met somehow and she has been though a rollercoaster of emotion. But I don’t know how to meet those needs to enable her to feel safe and happy.

I suppose I am asking to hear that I am not alone and that I am doing a good job. And words of wisdom from mothers as to where I am falling short as I’m not meeting my wife’s needs somewhere.

Thanks

OP posts:
ZacharinaQuack · 31/07/2023 14:08

I don't think I'm being that much of a martyr thinking an hour a day for exercise is unrealistic at the moment - it probably won't be later on, but with a newborn in the family (as well as two older DC), it's a lovely aspiration for both parents to get that time alone, but it's pretty unlikely to happen, for both parents, every single day. I used to do endurance events pre-DC and train about 8 hours a week but I wouldn't be planning to do that with a new baby in the family.

TheGoogleMum · 31/07/2023 14:08

When she has time and is just scrolling maybe make it clearer to her - you are managing the kids she can go do what she wants to relax for an hour. Normally with a 6 week old I would say YABU but it does sound like you're doing a lot plus have a lot of extra help

hahahahahahahahahah · 31/07/2023 14:04

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Yamatoosogani · 31/07/2023 13:54

This post looks more like 'broposting' than a request for help

I think your woman is being more than unreasonable, but if i had 250k a year i'd pay someone else to go jogging for 1 hour.

CreeperBoom · 31/07/2023 13:53

And ‘give me my time. If there is time for you great, but stop demanding it’.

This jumped out at me. Sounds like she thinks if she agrees to an hour per day, it will be written in stone, and you will not flex regardless of what is happening on a particular day or week. She probably also realises that it will quickly escalate - to an Ironman, no less.

Where will the "hour" come from? Less time at work? Less time doing other leisure activities? Or less time for her/family?

I don't disagree that an hour per day of exercise is a decent goal, btw. But not with a tiny baby. And an Ironman is not an hour per day.

Luxell934 · 31/07/2023 13:45

Just hire a babysitter/nanny for a few hours in the day and both have your "me time" then.

LuckySantangelo35 · 31/07/2023 13:41

Tandora · 31/07/2023 13:34

I think you are out of your mind to think you can exercise everyday for an hour with a six week old baby.
Im betting there is a verrry different alternative side to this story.

@Tandora

its an hour that’s all

Tandora · 31/07/2023 13:37

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I’ve never met a mother with a six week old baby who had time to go to the gym everyday for a hour 😂. I’m presuming this is what OP is talking about, not just moving his body around.

Tandora · 31/07/2023 13:34

I think you are out of your mind to think you can exercise everyday for an hour with a six week old baby.
Im betting there is a verrry different alternative side to this story.

JenniferBarkley · 31/07/2023 13:28

SweetyMcSweeterson · 31/07/2023 13:25

I think, it's very simple. Does your wife have an hour a day to do something for herself and are all the joint tasks (eg household chores, anything related to kids) done satisfactorily with both of you taking about 7h a week out for yourself? If yes, then go ahead. If not, then you need to come up with a new plan so that everything that has to be done is done and so that both of you get an equal amount of time to yourself.

When I was on maternity leave I absolutely did not have an hour a day to myself by the way. I still Don't.

Exactly.

SweetyMcSweeterson · 31/07/2023 13:25

I think, it's very simple. Does your wife have an hour a day to do something for herself and are all the joint tasks (eg household chores, anything related to kids) done satisfactorily with both of you taking about 7h a week out for yourself? If yes, then go ahead. If not, then you need to come up with a new plan so that everything that has to be done is done and so that both of you get an equal amount of time to yourself.

When I was on maternity leave I absolutely did not have an hour a day to myself by the way. I still Don't.

ManateeFair · 31/07/2023 13:20

You earn a quarter of a million quid, mate. Pretty sure you can pay [another] nanny to keep an eye on the kids for an hour a day while you go for a run.

notahappybunny7 · 31/07/2023 13:11

TealSapphire · 31/07/2023 12:07

Would you really exercise at 4am? If you do the 3am feed, exercise at 4am, then presumably you wouldn't go back to bed so effectively you'd be up at 3am every day. You'd have to go to bed pretty early or make up that sleep somewhere.

My ex used to be up early to exercise on the weekend and then sleep half the day when he got home. Annoying.

I regularly get up at 3am! Not out of choice but I am an early riser and usually up by 5, exhausted and ready for bed by 9 each night though!

DismantledKing · 31/07/2023 13:07

jellyfrizz · 31/07/2023 12:59

An addition to the family must be a great motivator! The number of men I know that decide to enter events that take on Iron Man events or marathons when the children are at 0-4 is huge. See also 'having' to go back into the office.

Or cycling of course…

jellyfrizz · 31/07/2023 12:59

An addition to the family must be a great motivator! The number of men I know that decide to enter events that take on Iron Man events or marathons when the children are at 0-4 is huge. See also 'having' to go back into the office.

Thepeopleversuswork · 31/07/2023 12:56

DismantledKing · 31/07/2023 12:55

Thais ain’t a dating site, mate.

LOL. Harsh but I like it.

DismantledKing · 31/07/2023 12:55

Thais ain’t a dating site, mate.

QueenCamilla · 31/07/2023 12:47

What is this magical job which pays £250k, can be done on broken sleep, gives you time to do all the things you have listed AND fit in an hour of exercise a day?

AND gives time to read the relationships page in Cosmo to realise that he's not meeting Her primal need to feel safe and secure and that his love language is not delivering to satisfaction.

... Meanwhile, in the parlour, She's all TikTok and PND.

Thepeopleversuswork · 31/07/2023 12:43

On the face of it YANBU: exercise is important, you do do a lot and an hour isn't excessive.

But this bit of your post:

I feel like I go to the extreme to carve my wife out time, which she wastes, scrolling or lying on the sofa.

Raised a bit of a red flag. "Scrolling or lying on the sofa" is usually just about as much as most six weeks post-partum women can manage. It's really very very hard for a man to understand how utterly draining this period of your life is. If she doesn't have PND (and it sounds like she may) she is certainly completely knackered and finding her whole life to be like wading through treacle. I can't help wondering if you have conveyed to her, whether implicitly or explicitly, some contempt for her "scrolling or lying on the sofa".

She presumably isn't in a fit condition to exercise at all yet and wouldn't have time even if she were and she may feel vaguely resentful of you blithely going off for an hour-long run when she's desperately trying to move from a feed to a bit of desperately needed sleep.

This isn't exactly your fault, but it does sound as if your self-professed need to exercise has been delivered with a bit of a lack of sensitivity. I would also be very careful about conveying to her that you are doing a lot to "help" her.

This is the worst time for a couple so you may just be rubbing one another up the wrong way. Keep doing what you're doing, be as tolerant as you can: try to get some exercise in by all means but don't be really hardline about having to have an hour a day. She can't do that. And don't make her feel guilty about scrolling and lying on the sofa.

Justashley · 31/07/2023 12:43

You will get told on here that you should never take even a second to yourself and you should never rest as your wife has had a baby. You should work and pay for a cleaner and nanny and then come home and do 100% of all house and childcare while wife rests. Its a ridiculous MN trend. Its not a reflection of the real world.

I've never seen posts like this at all, most if not all are women rightly wanting their men to do their share around the home and with their children.

Yellowlegobrick · 31/07/2023 12:41

With a very young baby AND two more kids often neither parent gets much leisure time. I have two youngish kids, DH & i each earn £150k+ and we struggle badly to fit in exercise for ourselves. An hour every single day is quite a lot - can you compromise on 3-4 days a week?

Amidlifecrisis · 31/07/2023 12:37

Ok so with update I think you need to postpone your Ironman dreams. Sounds like you’ve got enough time to get some exercise in, which is important for mental and physical health, but at this point with a newborn it’s ambitious and unnecessary to decide to do the Ironman with all the training that goes with that.

As many pps have said, and as you must know from your other kids, stuff gets easier and easier as the baby grows and can be away from your wife for longer (assuming she is bf). Even this time next year it will be doable.

Wakeywake · 31/07/2023 12:36

What's the problem with exercising when the older kids are in bed? What are you supposed to do then, be on call just in case the baby needs a nappy change?

CrazyHedgehogLover · 31/07/2023 12:36

Oh ffs if this was reversed and the woman posting about wanting an hour to herself everyone would be saying the man needs to get off his arse and help.

you near enough do everything, the least she can do is give you an hour a day! To do some exercise.

the sexism on mumsnet is just unreal! Just because she’s suffering with post natal depression etc doesn’t excuse her to give you no life, it takes two to make a child! She should be at least trying to do something by the sounds of it to me she’s putting all the responsibility on to you..

an hour a day really isn’t much to ask for, she should be able to cope for one hour🤷‍♀️

id say she’s being extremely unreasonable tbh, myself and my husband get an hour each a day, I go for a soak in the bath as that’s what relaxes me, he goes for an hour in the evening on the PlayStation.. she’s being unreasonable.

LuckySantangelo35 · 31/07/2023 12:32

Catskidsandme · 31/07/2023 12:23

@ZacharinaQuack im sure she did these things when we were younger. They didn't just start as we got older.
Even when my own dc were breasted newborns me and dh did things for ourselves. Exercise is essential not a luxury but even if we didn't we still did other things we wanted like meeting friends. I was back out having a meal with friends 3 weeks pp I just fed before and after.

People love to be martyrs on here.

I know right

cant believe some people here saying that having an hour per day for yourself is a thing of the past when you become a parent and that kind of thing is only for your pre-parent life! So Martyr

Swipe left for the next trending thread