Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being too demanding by asking for 1 hour a day to exercise?

165 replies

Dad12344444 · 31/07/2023 11:08

For context, I am a 35 year old guy with 3 kids, 9 7 and 6 weeks old and a golden retriever. I work a fairly high pressure job and earn in excess of 250k a year and I’m very proud of the life this enables my family and I to have.

I do almost all of the school runs for the eldest and all of their club pickup/drop offs (4 days a week). I do the 3am night feed for my youngest, so my wife can get a block of sleep.

In the house, Im almost exclusively responsible for the laundry, make the majority of kids’ dinners & bed times. I probably do 50% of the food shopping however, maybe 20% of my wife & I’s dinner.

In addition to this, we have a cleaner, a sleep nanny 2ce a week, a tutor for eldest & a dog walker which I pay for to try and provide support & free up some time. I am fully aware how privileged we are to be able to fund this help.

My wife is on maternity, however just prior to this she had recently qualified as a therapist and working 2 days a week. She suffered from post natal depression with both of our previous children and i has been something we have been really aware of this time & have tried to take into account ways to give her the best chance and space to mentally recover.

With all of this said, I feel like I need to be ‘on it’ most of the time, I don’t drink anymore as I found this was really contributing to this. It led to my mood being irritable and generally not as sharp.

The other thing that I find enables me to function to a high level is exercise. I recently made the ask of 1 hour a day to do this, I can do this in the middle of the day or night, i don’t mind getting up at 4 am or going during my workday.

However this request was met with: ‘I have carried this child for 10 months and now breast feeding and you are putting your own needs above me’. And ‘give me my time. If there is time for you great, but stop demanding it’.

This is the reason for my post. I feel like I go to the extreme to carve my wife out time, which she wastes, scrolling or lying on the sofa. So when I then try and take an hour that I work really hard to create, her response is ‘well i haven’t had any time’ and it becomes really difficult to swallow for me.

The logical side of me understands that her needs aren’t being met somehow and she has been though a rollercoaster of emotion. But I don’t know how to meet those needs to enable her to feel safe and happy.

I suppose I am asking to hear that I am not alone and that I am doing a good job. And words of wisdom from mothers as to where I am falling short as I’m not meeting my wife’s needs somewhere.

Thanks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RedPony1 · 02/08/2023 22:34

Tandora · 02/08/2023 21:22

Gyms in the house and morning and evening stables 😳😂😅. Sorry I forgot where I was temporarily and was talking about the majority of people who don’t live with such facilities in their own home.

Nome of my friends have a gym at home or their horses at home. They have to go to where they are kept. Twice a day, everyday. Its just part of their life that doesnt change with having a family.

Bonfire23 · 02/08/2023 21:25

@Tandora I don't think that means stable at home
Taking the baby TO the stables/livery yard/field most people say morning/evening stables

I have a "gym" at home. It's my spare room with some weights and a bike etc. not expensive

Tandora · 02/08/2023 21:22

RedPony1 · 01/08/2023 16:34

Why ever not?!
All my friends can still do their horses twice a day, they take baby for morning stables, and OH might have them for evening stables, or go along with them. i don't get this tied down mentality. Surely planning is key? Which he is trying to do.

Gyms in the house and morning and evening stables 😳😂😅. Sorry I forgot where I was temporarily and was talking about the majority of people who don’t live with such facilities in their own home.

RedPony1 · 01/08/2023 20:34

Cracklecrack · 01/08/2023 16:45

If your wife will also get an hour a day to exercise or scroll or relax- uninterrupted- to use how she wants etc etc then yanbu. You describe an awful lot of things that you do but you don’t seem to recognise all the things that she does? and whether she gets genuine downtime?

yup you do laundry and the 3am wake up. So presumably she’s doing the other wake ups and all the rest of the daytime stuff. Are you doin the entirety of the laundry? Ironing? Putting away etc?

if your wife gets an hour uninterrupted- equal leisure/ exercise/ downtime to you and you are 50/50 when you are home etc then no I do t think you’re being unreasonable. however if the situation is otherwise then yup you’re being unreasonable. I’m

There is paid help going in.
and he works full time! If she’s a SAHM then her job is to do the lionshare - he’s doing plenty on top of a full time job imo (if this is all true….)

Cracklecrack · 01/08/2023 16:45

If your wife will also get an hour a day to exercise or scroll or relax- uninterrupted- to use how she wants etc etc then yanbu. You describe an awful lot of things that you do but you don’t seem to recognise all the things that she does? and whether she gets genuine downtime?

yup you do laundry and the 3am wake up. So presumably she’s doing the other wake ups and all the rest of the daytime stuff. Are you doin the entirety of the laundry? Ironing? Putting away etc?

if your wife gets an hour uninterrupted- equal leisure/ exercise/ downtime to you and you are 50/50 when you are home etc then no I do t think you’re being unreasonable. however if the situation is otherwise then yup you’re being unreasonable. I’m

RedPony1 · 01/08/2023 16:34

Tandora · 31/07/2023 13:34

I think you are out of your mind to think you can exercise everyday for an hour with a six week old baby.
Im betting there is a verrry different alternative side to this story.

Why ever not?!
All my friends can still do their horses twice a day, they take baby for morning stables, and OH might have them for evening stables, or go along with them. i don't get this tied down mentality. Surely planning is key? Which he is trying to do.

Jazzybean · 31/07/2023 17:10

Delatron · 31/07/2023 16:37

Ha just read that you are training for an iron man. Just be aware of the huge commitment that is and that will probably be more than an hour a day. Not sure how well that will go done with 3 young kids.

DH has done several (at a good standard) since ours were born and they are 2 and 4. I did my first 70.3 when DS was just turned 1 which I know is slightly less in terms of training but if I was the breastfeeding parent (and went back to work when he was 8 months) and managed to find 10-15 hours per week to train.

But yes, realistically an hour a day is not going to be anything like enough during a training plan. You’re looking at some 7 hour days in the last month or so, not weeks. You really do need to be on the same page as DW if it’s not going to ruin your marriage.

Delatron · 31/07/2023 16:37

Ha just read that you are training for an iron man. Just be aware of the huge commitment that is and that will probably be more than an hour a day. Not sure how well that will go done with 3 young kids.

B72 · 31/07/2023 16:36

Of course you're not being unreasonable. It's not as though you're not pulling your weight around the house.
Go for it.

ZacharinaQuack · 31/07/2023 16:35

Hankunamatata · 31/07/2023 16:22

Take baby out in a running pram?

The baby will need to be at least 6 months old for that.

Delatron · 31/07/2023 16:33

You do loads. If you can fit in an hour and still do all that then great. As long as she gets her hour. Not sure why she wouldn’t want you to look after your health. I mean if you were doing naff all to help her then disappearing off to train for a triathlon a la Motherland then it would be different.

Just make sure she has equal down time.

Hankunamatata · 31/07/2023 16:22

Take baby out in a running pram?

electriclight · 31/07/2023 16:19

I don't think an hour a day is too much to ask tbh, as long as your dw gets the same (to do what she wants, even mindless scrolling).

The fact that you are willing to take it at 4am or during your working day makes the proposal even more reasonable imo - not taking it at bedtime every day.

This should be possible in a house with the reserves to pay for cleaners and nannies.

ZacharinaQuack · 31/07/2023 15:58

@Catskidsandme sure - I get that. I can make time to lie on the sofa or read a newspaper or something. In the OP, it sounds like the wife is getting time to do that too (scrolling on her phone), but would value some time either with her husband or completely on her own, which she's not currently getting. OP also wants time completely on his own to do exercise for an hour every day. What I find unrealistic based on my own experience is the idea that they can both have that hour every single day. I'm totally not being a martyr here either - I get plenty of downtime, DC don't need constant attention, they're lovely to spend time with, and this is what I signed up for. I do miss being fitter and running marathons though - hopefully will get back to it later.

Remmy123 · 31/07/2023 15:55

I actually think you do an awful lot / I had x3 kids similar ages I didn't expect my husband to get up to do feeds if he was working. I also took my kids to school and collected them.

i think an hour in the gym is reasonable seeing as you are pretty hands on. Your wife gets a full night sleep so unlikely to be tired in the day.

Catskidsandme · 31/07/2023 15:49

@takealettermsjones and @ZacharinaQuack of course not all dc are alike and some require more input. My eldest was born with an illness that requires treatment and her first year was spent in and out of hospitals, she couldn't be left after a feed as her little tummy was damaged.
My youngest has adhd and sat up at 3 months, walked at 9. Eldest spoke first words at 8 months and never shuts up to this day, she has asd.
I just worked with it to keep my sanity. I used safety gates and made the garden secure so youngest could run and climb, i used to take her to a field early to run and run. Eldest i let her ring my sister to talk to her for an hour even as a toddler. Youngest never slept more than 20 mins but would be ok for a bit in the swing or sling. I used to make the room secure and dooze while she rolled about. My supervison was sometimes while I laid on the sofa. Im not saying it was all prefect or easy but I didnt feel like I couldn't take an hour. No family help but I just prioritised some time for me as I too have adhd and would have gone crazy.

headcheffer · 31/07/2023 15:44

Normally I think with 3 kids and a 6 week old you have to prioritise family life for a bit, and your wife scrolling in her free time is up to her and resting is a valid choice. With the amount of paid help you have access to though, I don't see how you're not getting an hour to exercise as your wife and kids can be supported for that hour if needed by nanny etc. Why can't you leave an hour early for work on the days the night nanny is there? Or go at lunchtime at work. In my household we struggle with this but we have less help than you. However I've just put in place additional childcare to get me one morning a week where I can exercise because we need to prioritise my health.

PartingGift · 31/07/2023 15:33

Buy a Peleton. Use it at 4am. Job done.

That or pay for more childcare.

Lalalalala555 · 31/07/2023 15:31

To be a support you need to be able to function yourself.
Honestly, nothing is wiser than exercise, good diet and sleep.

Plus it sounds like you are paying to free up time already.
Just go for it.

takealettermsjones · 31/07/2023 15:25

Catskidsandme · 31/07/2023 15:02

Those of you who dont have an hour a day to yourself what are you doing all day? Im genuinely asking because I dont have that experience.
I work in a stressful job but I still manage to have time to myself whrn dc are in bed or when they are occupied in the evening. On weekends or days off what is taking so much time? I have played outside with dc and taken them and the dog for a walk. I have put a load in the washer, tidied their rooms and done the dishwasher. I have watched dc do a 'show' for 20 mins and we have cooked lunch together. I have still had two hours laid on the sofa. Obviously if we are doing a day out thats different but I cant understand what everyone is so busy doing all day every day.
When dc were tiny they fed and then either slept or sat in the baby chair or my arms while i watched netflix. I played with them but not at 6 weeks snd not 24/7. You can get loads done with thrm in the sling then once dh gets home you can have an hour alone as can he.
People are busy busy busy these days. You must all hace show homes and play with the dc 12 hours a day.

I've got a fussy newborn who is very much in a cycle of doze-feed-puke at the moment, and won't sleep reliably unless either in completely dark bedroom or in moving pram (hates bouncer, sling, etc). So while I do have time to scroll aimlessly online or play sudoku etc while I'm feeding, I don't get time to myself otherwise. I can't go to the gym or just take myself off and do something on my own. I also have a preschooler who is constantly on the go. I don't mind, at all, but yeah, that's what I'm doing all day!

ZacharinaQuack · 31/07/2023 15:21

@Catskidsandme I've been thinking about this. I think the main difference between me & DP and normal people is that we get tired and go to bed quite early. But also our DC are toddler age so they can't be carried around in a sling, but also need a bit more supervision and company than older DC might. We do end up with an hour or so to flop on the sofa before bed, but that's not time we'd be spending exercising - too knackered, and too soon after dinner. So it's not that we don't have an hour a day, but not the same quality of hour as we'd have had pre-DC! At weekends we can take turns with childcare to free up time for each other, but if we want a family day out it's often one of our exercise that will fall by the wayside.

Catskidsandme · 31/07/2023 15:02

Those of you who dont have an hour a day to yourself what are you doing all day? Im genuinely asking because I dont have that experience.
I work in a stressful job but I still manage to have time to myself whrn dc are in bed or when they are occupied in the evening. On weekends or days off what is taking so much time? I have played outside with dc and taken them and the dog for a walk. I have put a load in the washer, tidied their rooms and done the dishwasher. I have watched dc do a 'show' for 20 mins and we have cooked lunch together. I have still had two hours laid on the sofa. Obviously if we are doing a day out thats different but I cant understand what everyone is so busy doing all day every day.
When dc were tiny they fed and then either slept or sat in the baby chair or my arms while i watched netflix. I played with them but not at 6 weeks snd not 24/7. You can get loads done with thrm in the sling then once dh gets home you can have an hour alone as can he.
People are busy busy busy these days. You must all hace show homes and play with the dc 12 hours a day.

DrSbaitso · 31/07/2023 15:02

Some odd ones thinking I would lie on an anonymous post 🤣

Yes, what a weird thing to do on the internet!

Tandora · 31/07/2023 15:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ok granted that’s feasible if the gym is in your house 🙈🙈.
otherwise, no.

PeloMom · 31/07/2023 14:11

YNBU. It’s for your mental health and you need that to be able to support her and look after the kids/ work. Also sounds like you’re willing to be flexible, it’s not like you want to do that when it’s the most hectic time for the family.