Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I break no contact for my son's benefit

36 replies

whatdoisay1 · 31/07/2023 11:08

I have been No contact with my mum for almost 3 years now. She was an absolute vile woman while I was growing up. Emotionally abusive, neglectful ( eg I'd use socks instead of Tampax because she refused to buy them for me) She has always hated me.. from 7 years old she would regularly tell me she wished she had an abortion. I have no idea why, as far as I know she was brought by parents who spoiled her.
I had my son when I was 20, completely alone with no dad in the picture. Not to blow my own whistle but I have done a good job and have loved everything about being a mother. I've worked my arse of to provide the life for my son that I could only of dreamed of. My mum did seem to have a change of heart when my son was born, she still acted very off with me (eg she'd get extremely jealous of my achievements) and make sly remarks. I let it go so my son could have a grandmother. It meant a lot to me because he hasn't got a dad or dads side of family around.
3 years ago I was contacted by the police. I was raped and beat up as a teenager by a man not related to me. Long story short the police reopened my case. This pissed my mum of no end. I don't think she liked the idea that by reading some of the old paperwork from when the rape happened (over 25 years ago) it would become very apparent to my husband what a shitty mother she'd been. Once she knew my husband had read the notes made by the police when I was a teenager she became very defensive (I don't care if he reads it and thinks bad of me!) she's always been obsessed with my husband not thinking bad of her.
Anyway we got into an argument over the phone and she told me she didn't believe the rape had happened and thought i was making it up. I haven't spoken to her since.
My son is 22 now and when I stopped talking to my mum I explained to him that I didn't expect him to also break contact. He is an adult. In the 3 years that I have broke contact she has sent me a few abusive messages, I haven't responded once. She has sent birthday and Christmas presents and cards to my son. Always by post, we live on the same road!!
My son has contacted her maybe once every 3 months asking if he can go and see her or treat her to a birthday meal, she accepts then cancels last minute. I can see how much this is hurting him. He's literally being ghosted by his own grandmother. It's breaking my heart to witness.
My question is, should I contact her?
And just say if you plan on not seeing your grandson again then to tell me, so I can explain to him to stop trying. And also to stop with all the fake birthday/Christmas cards.
The idea of my son being continuously rejected kills me. I need advice on how to deal with this in a way that will have the least impact on him.
Thank you for reading.

OP posts:
Escapingafter50years · 31/07/2023 11:41

These horrible "mothers" do not change. They are poisonous through and through. Yours is quite happy to use her grandchild to hurt you. How horrible. If she finds out that it's working, do you really think she'll stop? No, she will only double down.

I think to best protect your son, you need to have a reasonably honest conversation with him about your mother's behaviour throughout your life. Obviously there will be some things that you feel are too private, but if my own story is anything to go by, there will be plenty of examples of atrocious parenting on her behalf.

Why do you think your son is trying to have a relationship with his awful grandmother? Is he perhaps stuck in fear, obligation and guilt? Or does he believe at heart she is a nice kind person who for some reason is only horrible to you? Does he think her behaviour is normal/acceptable? One way or another he needs some clarity. Perhaps seeing a professional counsellor might be an idea, or he might Instagram accounts helpful as they are "bite-sized", some I follow are patrickteahantherapy, understandingthenarc, gottmaninstitute, the.holistic.psychologist, scapegoatchildrecovery

Your son may be an adult but this is big stuff. At over 50, I've only realised in the last couple of years how much trauma there is in my past and am dealing with it through therapy, podcasts, books, Instagram and the Stately Homes thread on MN (have a look). At 22 it's a huge thing to try to process, it's very hard to believe there are such horrible people in the world, and that you are related to one of them!

Isheabastard · 31/07/2023 11:31

I had a selfish manipulative mother (though no where as bad as yours) and I know how much this hurts.

I don’t think you should contact your mother, but I think you need to have a heart to heart with your son.

This woman has caused immense pain to you. My first thought is to double check how much this is affecting him. Is it possible at all that there is a bit of projecting going on? Because her rejections of you (and your son) still hurt you so much, it is possible that he isn’t as affected quite as much as you imagine?

wether this is the case or not, it’s still worth having a chat with him. Does he know everything she has done to you? He’s old enough to know the truth, or an edited version of it.

Perhaps reframe the situation, and try to work out why she keeps cancelling. Perhaps she thinks your son wants to hold her accountable, or by cancelling she’s trying to hurt you not him? Try to explain to him that her actions are about her and not him.

Youve gone no contact for a reason, this maybe the only way she knows how to have some control back.

AnSolas · 31/07/2023 11:27

I would say dont contact her.
He is an adult and like you did will make the decision not to continue contact if and when he is ready.

All you can do is listen if he wants to speak to you about it. You were strong enough to give him the choice stick with that.

BoohooWoohoo · 31/07/2023 11:25

It's a trap.
She wants you to contact her and I think you know deep down that she won't change her behaviour on your say so or tell you what she's really thinking.
What would you advise your son if a friend or romantic partner was acting this way? You wouldn't encourage him to continue chasing them when they are happy to shame him. She clearly doesn't want a relationship with him but likes to drip her poisonous reminder that she's around on his significant days. Does he drop off birthday and Christmas cards at her house? Maybe that's all she really wants from him? If she's embarrassed about your h knowing the truth, maybe she feels the same about your son?
We don't pick our families. We can't change their behaviour either. But we can protect ourselves by choosing whether or not to make ourselves available as a target. It is completely understandable why you don't speak to her and well done for protecting your son from her venom. He is an innocent and you ended the cycle of abuse by shielding him from her. while I sympathise with his curiousity, it's heart breaking that he is being treated like this.

YouveGotAFastCar · 31/07/2023 11:22

No. Work with your son, instead.

I let it go so my son could have a grandmother. It meant a lot to me because he hasn't got a dad or dads side of family around.

I feel endlessly guilty that my son doesn't have contact with my in-laws because he doesn't have any relations on my side. Sometimes, the only reason that I haven't given in is that once he knows them and understands who they are and that they are supposed to love him; it'll be much harder to stop contact again, even if they're damaging him. Your son will need help to process who she is, and that her behaviour isn't a reflection of him, or a rejection of him. He might need some therapy sessions. He'll get there, and you tried to do what you thought was right at the time, but he doesn't have all the grown-up understanding and history that you do.

Ignore her; work with him to lessen his need to contact her, and constantly opening himself up to being rejected again. And I'd intercept the cards, at this point, too.

Annaishere · 31/07/2023 11:19

Oh I thought you meant contact her as in restart your own relationship

DismantledKing · 31/07/2023 11:19

No, she’ll attempt to ruin his life too. What a fucking monster she is.

Annaishere · 31/07/2023 11:19

She sounds narcissistic but she might have learned her lesson by now as far as she’s able to

JenWillsiam · 31/07/2023 11:18

I agree with previous poster. That’s what she wants. Do not contact her.

perhaps, now though is the time to be honest with your son. So he knows who and what she is. Then allow him to make his own informed decisions.

CherryMaDeara · 31/07/2023 11:15

Well done for making a good life for yourself despite your horrible mother.

And just say if you plan on not seeing your grandson again then to tell me, so I can explain to him to stop trying.

I agree with pp, don’t contact her, it’s what she wants. Explain to your son she’s toxic and how she abused you, you don’t need her to tell you she doesn’t plan to see him, her actions say that already. And it’s good she doesn’t sink her toxic tentacles into him.

And also to stop with all the fake birthday/Christmas cards.

Return the cards and to sender with ‘not living here’ written on them.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 31/07/2023 11:10

No, don’t contact her. That’s what she wants.

Your son is an adult. Have an adult conversation with him about how nasty she has been to you and tell him that she’s unlikely to ever change. She’s upsetting you by treating him poorly.

Then you have to let him decide how to handle it for himself.