Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I've spent nearly 10 years trying to decide whether or not to have a kid

334 replies

ForestGoblin · 31/07/2023 06:29

I think I must be the weirdest person on the planet. Everyone knows, right? But not me. I want to want kids. Been pregnant a couple of times but even then didn't feel any resolution. Mostly panic but uncertainty then relief then sadness.

Don't enjoy the company of kids but then they do say it's different when it's your own.

Husband would make a lovely dad but he says it's my choice and we already have a loving life together.

I want to be a better person and I think children could make me that but what if it made me bitter and cruel instead.

I have terrible social anxiety. Maybe it would make me strong for them. Or maybe I'd mess them up.

Worry about old age but know we're fundamentally all on our own for that.

A glimmer of me wants to meet "my" baby but a huge bit of me knows this is sentimental.

What if the baby has additional needs.

What if I have a birth injury.

What if my husband gets sicker (he has kidney disease).

What if I don't then at 45 something clicks.

What if I get bored. Either way.

Life is just so scary I hate it.

OP posts:
LGBirmingham · 31/07/2023 17:08

TarquinOliverNimrod · 31/07/2023 08:10

Such a great, spot on post 👏🏼

It's such a huge life change having children isn't it. From around 18 months I feel like we've emerged into our new normal and it really helps. Of course the more ds can do the more enjoyable our time together is.

People can tell you all these things about how hard the first year is. Or how it really does get easier, this too will pass etc... But until you've first hand experience of parenthood you just really really don't get it.

Work2live · 31/07/2023 15:59

Came on to say I absolutely relate to your feelings, @ForestGoblin. I’ve reached the point in life where kids ‘should’ be the next step. Happily married, own home, financially sorted etc. I thought that once I turned 30 a switch would flip, but that hasn’t happened for me.

I spent most of my 20s feeling 50/50 about kids, and as I’ve got older if anything, I feel more and more like I don’t want them, but also more and more like I should want them.

It’s confusing as hell and I spend a lot of time wrestling with it in my own head. DH is also on the fence. This thread has been an interesting read.

MotherofGorgons · 31/07/2023 15:48

I have travellled all over the world with mine, including to India. And had a life. I wouldn 't have wanted to put that on hold for 20 years.

Fordian · 31/07/2023 15:45

Love my 2. But honestly, I genuinely don't think I'd've regretted not having them.

I was equivocal, really, and in fact probably wandered into it!

But a thing is, once they're here, despite one's best intentions to travel to India with them, etc, it turns out to be far easier to go with the flow of parenthood, as the routines, hassles, and worries of kids fill up so much of your time, you can almost happily get away without 'having a life' for 2 decades....

It's why so many marriages fail once the kids leave home.

In your position, I think that if you were keener, you would have done it by now.

I think you can have a fun, spontaneous, fulfilled and well-financed life without kids!

MotherofGorgons · 31/07/2023 15:26

If I were you, I would work on my social anxiety first and make some friends first to save you from loneliness. They tend to be more reliable than either husbands or children.

Fifthtimelucky · 31/07/2023 14:27

I dont think anyone should have children unless they really really want to.

You are not in that position.

Sakura7 · 31/07/2023 14:24

There is one other thing I think you should potentially consider, and I'll probably get flamed for saying it but I speak from my own experience.

You say you're considerably older than 33, and if by that you're talking early-mid 40s (and if your DH is the same age or older) then it's getting towards the point where you need to consider whether it's fair on the child.

My parents were 40 and 45 when I was born and there have been times when having older parents has been really tough. The generation gap was huge, and I had to deal with caring responsibilities, hospitals, nursing homes and ultimately their deaths at a much younger age than my peers. My dad's dementia began when I was in my late teens and throughout my 20s I had to watch him slowly fade away (and look after my mum who was completely unable to cope). If you have an only child (which is quite likely if you start late) they'll be dealing with any heath issues on their own and that can be very isolating.

My parents were both dead by the time I got married. I also never really knew my grandparents as they all died when I was a very small child.

I know this sounds very morbid, and some others in my situation will have had a better experience, but age does catch up with us and the risks of ill health shouldn't be ignored. I bet people will respond saying "but you could be hit by a bus tomorrow" and "nobody knows the future" but the fact is that the older you are the greater the risks.

There have been a few threads on this topic over the years and among the children of older parents it tends to be about two thirds saying it was difficult and one third saying it was good. It depends on so many factors such as your families' general health, the network you have around you, financial security, the plans you make for the worst case scenario, etc, but it's something else to think about.

KingTriton · 31/07/2023 14:22

We made the decision to have a child based on not wanting to regret not doing it in later life.

Not the strongest argument for having a kid but there you go! We were both incredibly naive too and did not understand just how all consuming it is. We just figured that they would slot into our lives which would carry on relatively as normal - WRONG!

I think the best way to summarise it, is that it's fucking relentless. You never really get an off day. If you're sick or tired, tough, you just have to get on with it. Your life isn't your own any more, you don't get to be selfish or indulge yourself. Everything revolves around your child.

On balance I'm glad we did it and I know I would have always wondered if we hadn't and it would have eaten me up inside.

Ours is almost 9 and is wonderful to be around most of the time. The baby and pre school years were the hardest time of my life though.

My anxiety was sky high for many years (I'm much better now), our marriage suffered due to the stress of it all.

It's the biggest commitment you will ever make. The highs make it worth it and you have to learn how to overcome the lows and adjust to a massive lifestyle change.

Knowing what I do now, I would have been perfectly happy if we had stayed child free, but having said that, I cannot imagine my life without our child.

So yeah, some pros, lots of cons. You just have to work out what is really important to you and whether you want to continue living a fabulous child free life or whether you want to have a completely different life experience.

Lottapianos · 31/07/2023 13:41

'Read a book earlier this year called Motherhood: is it for me? Cannot recommend it enough. I reached the decision not to have kids at last and haven't had so much as a hint of doubt since'

Sounds amazing! Wish I'd had it ten years ago when I was in a right state of indecision

Evaka · 31/07/2023 13:38

Hi OP. I wrangled with the same question for many years. Read a book earlier this year called Motherhood: is it for me? Cannot recommend it enough. I reached the decision not to have kids at last and haven't had so much as a hint of doubt since. It helps separate your true desire from social expectations which are fucking intense! I'm 41 and excited about all the things I can do without a second thought as a childfree woman, and also can be a really supportive aunt as my nieces and nephews grow up. Good luck on your journey!

ForestGoblin · 31/07/2023 13:31

I think my nieces and nephew have cemented the cons side for me for sure (their parents seem to have pretty equal and respectful arrangements but they are exhausted and resentful that they can't do all the things I do). But they are under three and I know this won't last forever. One day they will have free time AND hopefully young people they feel proud of.

Talking to older relatives I wonder what it will be like when I am the old one.

OP posts:
Miajk · 31/07/2023 13:26

It's better to regret not having a child than regretting having one.

Benihana · 31/07/2023 13:24

I think we can all agree the human experience is bonkers! I think a certain amount of regret is inevitable no matter what you choose. I think if I had more family nearby- mine are scattered- I might not have had DC.

ForestGoblin · 31/07/2023 13:22

I suppose the thing is - it's easy to be confident with my choice when I could still change my mind. Harder when the door is locked. BUT agree definitely better to come to terms with no kids than to have a child and feel regret.

The human experience is bonkers, huh.

OP posts:
Benihana · 31/07/2023 13:20

Ugh, I meant both my DC are NT, not ND. Always confuse the two.

Benihana · 31/07/2023 13:19

I don't regret my DC, but they have put immense pressure on my marriage. This is with the following advantages:
both ND
had them young
am physically and mentally fit with zero anxieties
have sufficient money
had loving and relatively decent parents

And still it is the hardest thing I have ever done, and I am still helping them through life, even as young adults, because these days parenting does not stop at 18.

Rathouse · 31/07/2023 13:18

@DirectionToPerfection I wasn't I was just giving my opinion...

meatbaseddessert · 31/07/2023 13:16

Greatest joy imaginable

Hmm not what my 'really honest' friends have told me. They've been quite clear about the drudgery, boredom, sometimes hatred, then the logistical nightmares, the reasoning with little dictators etc etc and you've only got to toddlerhood.

They've been quite clear that they would never have done it if they knew what they did now. Both were desperate for children from an early age. Of course no one can own up to not actually wanting them now they are here so they say 'of course I wouldn't be without them now' which is double speak for 'I'm stuck with the fuckers.'

If you are wavering why do it?

Your brain has an evolutionary element of survival that is one of the strongest forces you will experience. To procreate and do it as many times over. But its incredibly base. Thankfully humans have an outer cortex of intelligence that can override the monkey, drug addicted brain within.
If you have any doubts. Any. Don't go there.

FreeRider · 31/07/2023 13:14

I should also add that neither myself nor my brothers were planned - we were all 'accidents'....something my mother neither tired of telling us as children. My father finally got around to having a vasectomy after my younger brother was born.

Jo190 · 31/07/2023 13:11

Oh and I can confirm that they literally cost thousands, without even thinking about what else they cost us in a metaphorical sense. Like I said, I’ve only got a young child but we’ve spent enough on their supplies as a baby even - just the very tip of the iceberg before education etc comes into the equation. Something else to consider.

FreeRider · 31/07/2023 13:09

I'm 55 soon and I haven't had children - and neither have my two brothers.

I knew from an early age, pre 10, that I didn't want children. I'm the child of a man who didn't want children, and the only reason myself and my two brothers even exist is because my mother is Catholic.

My parents really shouldn't have had children - both were extremely self absorbed/selfish and never put us first. We were fed, clothed and housed...but that was it. There was no emotional bond between my parents and zero towards us. I've never been hugged or kissed by either parent. My mother had children because her religion told her she 'should' - but she made it pretty obvious she disliked parenthood.

I've been pregnant twice and terminated both without a moments hesitation or regret. When I think of the terminations now, all I feel is what I've always felt - incredible relief that that option was available to me.

My mother bothered me for literal decades about having children, she only really stopped when I was in my mid 40s. I have never felt a moment's guilt for not giving her grandchildren...I know I have disappointed her with most of the choices I have a made as an adult, but that's fine...she has disappointed me my whole life. Like me, she will just have to live with that disappointment.

DirectionToPerfection · 31/07/2023 13:09

Rathouse · 31/07/2023 13:03

@DirectionToPerfection well if she's pondering 10 bloody years it doesn't sound like she needs to add a baby to the mix. You or I can't make that choice for her she's had lots of feedback. To be honest it is life changing but it does sound extreme that OP has been toying with idea for 10 years! There are no guarantees with motherhood lots of twists and twists and turns along your own individual motherhood journey. Your experience and mine won't be the same.

I'm really not sure where you got the idea that I'm trying to push the OP towards motherhood, if you actually read my posts I've said something very different.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 31/07/2023 13:08

KimberleyClark · 31/07/2023 06:32

If you really wanted a kid you would have done something about it by now.

Fearing regretting not having a kid is not the same as really wanting one.

This.

You don’t want a child.

PrrrplePineapple · 31/07/2023 13:06

I'm almost 40 and have known for years that I didn't want kids. I thought carefully about it for a long time but ultimately I knew because every time I imagined how life would be with kids, I actively felt displeasure at the thought of it. I did worry for a while that my biological clock would kick in and make me desperate for a child, but it hasn't so far and I'm pretty sure it never will. I have never once regretted not wanting kids. I prefer my life without kids and I definitely feared feeling resentful if I'd chosen to have kids because that would have led to so much unhappiness and guilt and that's just not something I want for myself or my potential kids. Some of my friends love having kids, some of them feel resentful because they think their lives were so much better before kids, some are really struggling and are deeply unhappy and some seem to really relish parenthood.

Parenthood is not for everyone, and that's just fine. There's no need for guilt or anguish about it, do what feels right for you and figure out how to enjoy your life the most you can whatever your choice is.

Rathouse · 31/07/2023 13:03

@DirectionToPerfection well if she's pondering 10 bloody years it doesn't sound like she needs to add a baby to the mix. You or I can't make that choice for her she's had lots of feedback. To be honest it is life changing but it does sound extreme that OP has been toying with idea for 10 years! There are no guarantees with motherhood lots of twists and twists and turns along your own individual motherhood journey. Your experience and mine won't be the same.