Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I've spent nearly 10 years trying to decide whether or not to have a kid

334 replies

ForestGoblin · 31/07/2023 06:29

I think I must be the weirdest person on the planet. Everyone knows, right? But not me. I want to want kids. Been pregnant a couple of times but even then didn't feel any resolution. Mostly panic but uncertainty then relief then sadness.

Don't enjoy the company of kids but then they do say it's different when it's your own.

Husband would make a lovely dad but he says it's my choice and we already have a loving life together.

I want to be a better person and I think children could make me that but what if it made me bitter and cruel instead.

I have terrible social anxiety. Maybe it would make me strong for them. Or maybe I'd mess them up.

Worry about old age but know we're fundamentally all on our own for that.

A glimmer of me wants to meet "my" baby but a huge bit of me knows this is sentimental.

What if the baby has additional needs.

What if I have a birth injury.

What if my husband gets sicker (he has kidney disease).

What if I don't then at 45 something clicks.

What if I get bored. Either way.

Life is just so scary I hate it.

OP posts:
OhcantthInkofaname · 01/08/2023 19:23

Coatimundi · 31/07/2023 06:34

if you are prone to anxiety, I wouldn't.

IF she is prone to anxiety?

Alcemeg · 01/08/2023 19:21

For what it's worth, OP, I didn't have kids and am now in my 60s and I don't regret it at all.

My one big chance was in my mid-30s, when I'd been with DH#1 for 15 years. The pregnancy was an accident (change of pill, protection diminished during transition) and he was furious with me, saying I'd ruined his life etc. He seemed to think I'd done it deliberately for some reason (he always blamed me for everything). I ended up having an abortion rather than have a child with someone who could be so stupid and cruel. A few years later, I left him.

In my late 30s, the question of whether to have kids or not raised its head quite a few times. I nearly did with one guy; thank god I didn't, as things would not have turned out well (he was, in retrospect, a bullying narcissistic cheat!).

Mostly, though, my focus after divorce was on making up for lost time, which meant doing anything that wasn't boring (having been bored stiff for years). Thus life became pretty wild for a time, but never dull, and I learned an enormous amount.

I'd definitely have had children if you could guarantee that things would turn out well: that they would be healthy, that we would love each other, that I could pour wisdom and kindness and humour into them in ways that they would appreciate.

It just seems to me that parent–child relationships are rarely that simple. Most of the families I know, it seems to be more a case of "Ooh, it's so lovely when things are going well, makes up for all the shit you have to put up with" 🤣 ... but maybe I just haven't seen the joyful wonder of it all close at hand, if it all happens behind closed doors.

I am not a particularly lucky person and have poor boundaries, so I tend to think that if I'd had kids, I could pretty much guarantee they'd be the sort to roll their eyes and get stroppy and create endless mess for me to clear up (literally and metaphorically).

You mention sort of an urge to make a mini tribe of people who will know that I exist.
See, I feel as though over all those years when I could have been running the kids round the M25 to tennis classes or whatever, instead I've gradually built up my own mini-tribe of people who truly value me. But they're not family. (In fact, to be honest, my family mostly treat me with contempt!)

Idontcareboutthestateofmyhair · 01/08/2023 19:19

If it helps, I went through this a bit though not quite as intense as you have. It always felt like it was a massive decision for me. I always put it off..I got married at 23 to first husband and it just never felt like the right time and then I decided to leave it up to fate. Stopped using contraception though for one reason or another we didn't really have an active sex life and I couldn't ever see myself trying to get pregnant. Met my soon to be second hubby 7 years ago, early 40s so still young enough. He'd had the snip and it would have meant a reversal etc. We did speak about it because we are the absolute love of each others lives but we didn't. I think we were having too much fun! I always felt a bit left out when I was younger, some mothers say the most bitchiest comments to non-mothers. I was hurt a few times definitely. I have a nephew who I had 2 nights a week after work and at the weekend, took him on hols etc and I adore the bones of him so it's not that I wasn't 'maternal'. He's 19 now, and we hang out at the pub, or go to footy and nice restaurants, etc. But, looking back I am so so glad I don't have my own children. It was the right choice for me absolutely. I'm 50 now and feel free that I don't have the feelings of 'female failure' anymore, I'm actually proud of myself for realising it wasn't for me and sticking to it! I'm stepmother to 2 older girls and I have tons of family.
I also suffered from depression and anxiety and this can factor into decisions about children. I also believe if you really have to make it such a massive decision it's probably not for you. ❤️💐

greenbeansnspinach · 01/08/2023 19:12

Or you could look at it as, she is not so self centred as to produce children that she’s not sure she really wants or needs. There doesn’t have to be a value judgement around this huge decision that the OP is grappling with.

greenbeansnspinach · 01/08/2023 19:09

There’s no cooling off period unfortunately

Christie70 · 01/08/2023 19:07

I was like you. I had children after 12 years of not wanting them. I didn’t look forward to motherhood even when I was pregnant. But I’ve never known love like I experienced for my children. I would give my life for them. It’s indescribable. Yes there are problems, there can be disability or illness, rows, exhaustion - every family has its problems. I would have lived a happy life without children but they have made my life far, far richer than I could ever have imagined. It’s an adventure, a rollercoaster. Either go with the flow or stay in the security of what you know. Whatever you choose to do, you won’t know what you’re missing!

lollylimejuice · 01/08/2023 18:56

Don't have them, you love your life and you are to self centered to shower a child with the love, care and attention they need and deserve to grow into well rounded human beings. This isn't a game dear, as an older lady I can tell you it's a lifetime commitment. The joy and happiness, the love and care I get from my darling children is wonderful. My grandchildren are a blessing. Yes, years of hard work which I thoroughly enjoyed. You see, it was my idea of heaven and never a trial. But, not for you, you have different needs and interests. Don't do it.

BreatheAndFocus · 01/08/2023 18:56

ForestGoblin · 01/08/2023 13:16

It's comforting to read this. I've had a hard weekend and have been wondering what I should be doing with myself.

I envy people who have total clarity.

Maybe that’s part of the problem - your expectations? Wanting total clarity and certainty when life’s not like that? Every decision we make comes with a risk? If we sat here, thinking about all the little things that might go wrong or not go the way we want, we’d never do anything. Never get married/have a partner, never accept a job offer, never make a new friend, never go on holiday. Nothing is certain.

For all the ‘negative’ points you made about having a child, there are equally positive ones. But, truthfully, I don’t think you really want a child. I think you thought you should but your heart wasn’t in it. That’s fine. Some people don’t want children and they absolutely shouldn’t feel any ‘obligation’ to have them. All the posts here you’ve made are you trying to convince yourself and justify your decision (you’re messy?? You should see me 😂). But you don’t have to justify your decision - not to yourself and not to anyone else.

If you still have pangs of doubt, then look at the other side. Look for positives of having children, look at people who don’t have children and are old. Would you be ok in that situation?

HarrietJet · 01/08/2023 18:53

It sounds far more as though you're worried about regretting some time in the future than actually, actively wanting children.
I really wouldn't in your case. Too lukewarm.

MotherofGorgons · 01/08/2023 18:49

greenbeansnspinach · 01/08/2023 18:42

If you’re not that keen anyway, imagine this. You have a successful pregnancy and a healthy baby. You manage financially, although obviously you’re going to be poorer and not be able to do all the things or go the places you currently do for the next fifteen years or so. The child is averagely academic, but like many young adults unable to obtain worthwhile, satisfying employment even if we discount the impact of AI on jobs.
In twenty, thirty, forty years time you will have another adult (say it’s male) that you’re quite fond of, but lives in a room in your house, contributes little financially, spends his life (which is mainly nocturnal by now) doing things on whatever the internet has become by then and drinking cans of beer.
it’s a bit of a risk to take.
I have children and grand children I love, and none of them fit the description I’ve given above although friends do have such children - but my own children and grandchildren have had difficulties from time to time in their fairly average lives which have caused them, and me, enormous grief and pain through the years - as well as times of great happiness.
Unless you have an absolutely overwhelming desire for a child, (rather than a cute baby which is a fleeting stage), then think long and hard, and then think long and hard again.

OMG, can I return my children? This is a terrifying picture!

greenbeansnspinach · 01/08/2023 18:42

If you’re not that keen anyway, imagine this. You have a successful pregnancy and a healthy baby. You manage financially, although obviously you’re going to be poorer and not be able to do all the things or go the places you currently do for the next fifteen years or so. The child is averagely academic, but like many young adults unable to obtain worthwhile, satisfying employment even if we discount the impact of AI on jobs.
In twenty, thirty, forty years time you will have another adult (say it’s male) that you’re quite fond of, but lives in a room in your house, contributes little financially, spends his life (which is mainly nocturnal by now) doing things on whatever the internet has become by then and drinking cans of beer.
it’s a bit of a risk to take.
I have children and grand children I love, and none of them fit the description I’ve given above although friends do have such children - but my own children and grandchildren have had difficulties from time to time in their fairly average lives which have caused them, and me, enormous grief and pain through the years - as well as times of great happiness.
Unless you have an absolutely overwhelming desire for a child, (rather than a cute baby which is a fleeting stage), then think long and hard, and then think long and hard again.

AnxiousAcademic · 01/08/2023 18:39

I think this is classic anxiety (which I know all too well, hence my username). All the ‘what ifs’ you list is your anxiety and no-one can think clearly (or rationally) when anxious. Maybe looking to heal your anxiety will bring clarity about motherhood?

Cucucucu · 01/08/2023 18:37

What if you go out and have a car crash , someone runs you over or a satélite falls on your head ? Life is full of what ifs

There is no perfect timing , there is no magic formula .
I can’t tell you if you should or not to have a child , the only thing everyone else who never has children is missing out is on the unconditional love , I can tell you that the love you will feel for your child is not comparable to any other love , it’s so big and so … just amazing , that there is no way you will ever feel it without having a child . But again you won’t miss what you never had . You don’t say how old you are or your partner . Maybe you still have time to decide ?

mandlerparr · 01/08/2023 18:24

Whenever it is a decision this big, err on the side of caution. Regret for not having a child feels a lot better than regretting having one.

MotherofGorgons · 01/08/2023 13:25

Have you considered a pet? I am not saying they are the same as DC, but they do love you and are very helpful for anxiety.

ForestGoblin · 01/08/2023 13:16

It's comforting to read this. I've had a hard weekend and have been wondering what I should be doing with myself.

I envy people who have total clarity.

OP posts:
Lozois99 · 01/08/2023 12:14

Raising kids is the hardest thing. Endless stress, anxiety, work. If you aren't sure then definitely don't. Its actually the easiest bit of advice ive ever been able to give anyone

VestaTilley · 31/07/2023 22:21

It doesn’t sound like you want them. And with crippling social anxiety you’d be bound to pass that on.

Stick with the life you have.

Usernamenotavailabletryanother · 31/07/2023 21:53

I still don’t know if I want children and mine are now 14 and 11 😂

Lottapianos · 31/07/2023 21:30

'But I always think your posts are very thoughtful and valuable, @Lottapianos,'

Thank you ❤️

BewareBends · 31/07/2023 20:18

Lottapianos · 31/07/2023 18:25

'I've spent about 5 years driving myself insane trying to decide whether or not to TTC, and I'm now approaching 40 and still childfree, so I think I'm pretty much decided.'

Driving myself insane - oh how I can relate! It was probably more like 15 years in my case. Part of me really did want children very much, which made it all very painful, but I knew that the actual reality of parenthood was not for me. It was a huge loss that I had to grieve, but I'm 43 now, no kids and that's that. I highly recommend it by the way. Despite the off wistful moment, I'm often deeply grateful that I don't have children, and feel so relieved that I stuck to what I knew was right deep down

Come join us on the MN Childfree board!

But I always think your posts are very thoughtful and valuable, @Lottapianos, precisely because you refute the idea that people ‘should’ automatically know, about the fact that the decision for you was long and difficult, and that you grieved it, even while recognising it was the right one. It strikes a chord with me, while I made the opposite decision, and I grieved my childfree life when DS was new.

I simply don’t think that anyone who finds the decision difficult or comes from a place of ambivalence should take it as a message from the universe they’re not suited to parenthood.

Lottapianos · 31/07/2023 18:26

ODD wistful moment, not off!

Lottapianos · 31/07/2023 18:25

'I've spent about 5 years driving myself insane trying to decide whether or not to TTC, and I'm now approaching 40 and still childfree, so I think I'm pretty much decided.'

Driving myself insane - oh how I can relate! It was probably more like 15 years in my case. Part of me really did want children very much, which made it all very painful, but I knew that the actual reality of parenthood was not for me. It was a huge loss that I had to grieve, but I'm 43 now, no kids and that's that. I highly recommend it by the way. Despite the off wistful moment, I'm often deeply grateful that I don't have children, and feel so relieved that I stuck to what I knew was right deep down

Come join us on the MN Childfree board!

Zolf · 31/07/2023 18:19

Op, you sound exactly like me. It's been very cathartic reading this thread. I've spent about 5 years driving myself insane trying to decide whether or not to TTC, and I'm now approaching 40 and still childfree, so I think I'm pretty much decided.

I also have social anxiety as well as low self esteem and one of the many fears I have is that any child I had would take after me - as well as the dread of the school gates, parties etc.

I know deep down that I don't want kids, but it's hard to go against the grain and wonder whether it might have actually been the best decision ever. Your point about forging your own path then in hindsight realising why people generally stick with the traditional path really resonated with me.

Good luck with whatever you decide - but as others have said, it sounds like you have decided already really.

ForestGoblin · 31/07/2023 17:15

Sakura7 · 31/07/2023 14:24

There is one other thing I think you should potentially consider, and I'll probably get flamed for saying it but I speak from my own experience.

You say you're considerably older than 33, and if by that you're talking early-mid 40s (and if your DH is the same age or older) then it's getting towards the point where you need to consider whether it's fair on the child.

My parents were 40 and 45 when I was born and there have been times when having older parents has been really tough. The generation gap was huge, and I had to deal with caring responsibilities, hospitals, nursing homes and ultimately their deaths at a much younger age than my peers. My dad's dementia began when I was in my late teens and throughout my 20s I had to watch him slowly fade away (and look after my mum who was completely unable to cope). If you have an only child (which is quite likely if you start late) they'll be dealing with any heath issues on their own and that can be very isolating.

My parents were both dead by the time I got married. I also never really knew my grandparents as they all died when I was a very small child.

I know this sounds very morbid, and some others in my situation will have had a better experience, but age does catch up with us and the risks of ill health shouldn't be ignored. I bet people will respond saying "but you could be hit by a bus tomorrow" and "nobody knows the future" but the fact is that the older you are the greater the risks.

There have been a few threads on this topic over the years and among the children of older parents it tends to be about two thirds saying it was difficult and one third saying it was good. It depends on so many factors such as your families' general health, the network you have around you, financial security, the plans you make for the worst case scenario, etc, but it's something else to think about.

I totally get this. Lots (and lots) of friends and family are having babies 40+ at the moment so I don't think it's unusual in the way it once was but that doesn't change the fact that a kid with parents my age at birth have a greater risk of being orphaned at a young age.

And my husband's health is a consideration (plus the fact that his condition makes him vulnerable to infections and small children get sick a lot).

I hated being a child because child stuff stressed me out. The way you were treated and the chaos some other kids brought into the room.

I should probably spend more time thinking about how I can build relationships in my (adult) comfort zone.

OP posts: