Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I've spent nearly 10 years trying to decide whether or not to have a kid

334 replies

ForestGoblin · 31/07/2023 06:29

I think I must be the weirdest person on the planet. Everyone knows, right? But not me. I want to want kids. Been pregnant a couple of times but even then didn't feel any resolution. Mostly panic but uncertainty then relief then sadness.

Don't enjoy the company of kids but then they do say it's different when it's your own.

Husband would make a lovely dad but he says it's my choice and we already have a loving life together.

I want to be a better person and I think children could make me that but what if it made me bitter and cruel instead.

I have terrible social anxiety. Maybe it would make me strong for them. Or maybe I'd mess them up.

Worry about old age but know we're fundamentally all on our own for that.

A glimmer of me wants to meet "my" baby but a huge bit of me knows this is sentimental.

What if the baby has additional needs.

What if I have a birth injury.

What if my husband gets sicker (he has kidney disease).

What if I don't then at 45 something clicks.

What if I get bored. Either way.

Life is just so scary I hate it.

OP posts:
Lottapianos · 02/08/2023 10:35

'You either want children or not'

That's just not true. It's not that black and white for all of us. Plenty of people on here, OP included, feel highly ambivalent and are struggling with the choice

LittleMoReturns · 02/08/2023 10:29

I wouldn’t in your situation. Having a child completely turns your world upside down. If you’ve got to crunch point and you’re still dithering I wouldn’t force the issue.

I might be unpopular for saying this, but I also think that having a baby at 40+ is far from ideal. If you were desperate for a baby then fair enough, you could weigh that up against being an older parent, but if you’re not sold on the idea and so highly anxious about so many aspects of parenting, I definitely wouldn’t.

Evieanne · 02/08/2023 10:27

Yalta · 02/08/2023 10:23

I think you are too self absorbed to have children. You are wasting your life looking for guarantees and thinking of the What Ifs

You either want children or not. But if you decide not and you say your dh does want them then you have missed the What if dh leaves to have a family of his own.

She’s not self absorbed, you’re basically implying she’s selfish. She just has different priorities to you. Equally if she’s child free, she could easily leave him first anyway.

ForestGoblin · 02/08/2023 10:26

Yalta · 02/08/2023 10:23

I think you are too self absorbed to have children. You are wasting your life looking for guarantees and thinking of the What Ifs

You either want children or not. But if you decide not and you say your dh does want them then you have missed the What if dh leaves to have a family of his own.

He could but we've been together nearly twenty years and he definitely doesn't seem sad about our situation. I think since his siblings had kids he's had a better idea of the practical side (I have friends who had kids young so was never in any doubt). I mean, even if we had a kid he could still leave me. Hope not!

The deep love sounds wonderful. I think love is the only reason for human existence. But the work of raising a child seems almost impossible to me. I am in awe of people who do it, tbh. How can it be something that almost everyone does when it's so immense?

OP posts:
Yalta · 02/08/2023 10:23

I think you are too self absorbed to have children. You are wasting your life looking for guarantees and thinking of the What Ifs

You either want children or not. But if you decide not and you say your dh does want them then you have missed the What if dh leaves to have a family of his own.

KimberleyClark · 02/08/2023 10:18

MrsMcisaCt · 02/08/2023 09:40

I think a lot of people on this thread are underestimating the pain of regretting not having a child. I don't mean regretting it for a while, then going on to have one, I mean regretting it when the opportunity is gone forever. That doesn't mean I think the OP should have a child btw. I just think it's easy to say 'oh, it's not as bad as having a child and regretting that'. Well then you really don't understand the pain of being childless when actually children were the only thing you ever wanted in life. And suggesting adoption just makes me want to scream with frustration.

I do understand it. Been there never had kids, but I’m now very happy without children. For the OP it’s clear that children were not the only thing she has ever wanted in life.

DirectionToPerfection · 02/08/2023 10:08

I can't believe there are women on this thread, in 2023, claiming we'd be better off without contraception. Without choices.

After all the sacrifice of the women before us, the hard won rights so that we could have better lives, it's incredible to see the freedom we now have being taken for granted.

I bet if you could be transported for a day into the life of a 1940s housewife with eight kids you'd have a rude awakening.

Sakura7 · 02/08/2023 10:02

MrsMcisaCt · 02/08/2023 09:40

I think a lot of people on this thread are underestimating the pain of regretting not having a child. I don't mean regretting it for a while, then going on to have one, I mean regretting it when the opportunity is gone forever. That doesn't mean I think the OP should have a child btw. I just think it's easy to say 'oh, it's not as bad as having a child and regretting that'. Well then you really don't understand the pain of being childless when actually children were the only thing you ever wanted in life. And suggesting adoption just makes me want to scream with frustration.

It's not the same situation. You're speaking of someone who desperately wanted children and is feeling the pain of being unable to have them.

It's clear that someone who chooses to stay childfree simply doesn't have that desire for a child, and is far less likely to be unhappy with their situation.

Alcemeg · 02/08/2023 09:45

SnozPoz · 02/08/2023 06:53

I wonder sometimes if there is too much analysis these days of how we should live our lives? I think it's wonderful that we do and can think things through and have choices but has it made things more complicated for us? Not long ago you probably would have just got with having children without questioning it too much.
I really don't like most other children but love my own. She wasn't an easy child but she's my favourite person of all time. Her father was off the scene pretty quickly so I was effectively a single parent but it was fine. You would be fine too. The fact that you ask all these questions says to me that you really care and you would for this reason really care for your child and be a great mother, and you've already said your husband would be a great father. You cannot worry about "what ifs"... they will paralyse you. Equally don't worry about the what ifs if you don't have children. Good luck

I think you're right! My mum (who was a lovely mum) often said to me that she felt sorry for the generations of women that followed hers (she was married in the 1950s) who "enjoyed the freedom" of the Pill. She said no one in their right mind would really decide to have kids, as a rational choice, and it was hard for anyone to be faced with that rather than just letting Nature take its course.

MrsMcisaCt · 02/08/2023 09:40

I think a lot of people on this thread are underestimating the pain of regretting not having a child. I don't mean regretting it for a while, then going on to have one, I mean regretting it when the opportunity is gone forever. That doesn't mean I think the OP should have a child btw. I just think it's easy to say 'oh, it's not as bad as having a child and regretting that'. Well then you really don't understand the pain of being childless when actually children were the only thing you ever wanted in life. And suggesting adoption just makes me want to scream with frustration.

nalabae · 02/08/2023 09:30

.I'm in the same position but I only want one son then I will be okay. You can have one child or if anything adopt

ForestGoblin · 02/08/2023 09:26

BreatheAndFocus · 02/08/2023 07:52

Society would exist without children! 😆 To coin a phrase - they’re our future. Of course, society is set up to value them. Interestingly, all these ‘annoying children’ will be the ones paying your pension and wiping your bum when you’re old. Society needs children and young people - and so do we all.

Well, in this tech era I'm not sure that's true in the way it used to be. As a pp mentioned, a lot of children born today are likely to find it hard to find work. The whole structure of everything is going to have to change.

OP posts:
Lottapianos · 02/08/2023 08:46

'I’m in this weird place at the moment where I can’t imagine my life with or without children. I look at myself now and can’t see how I can ever have a child but I also can’t imagine myself further into the future as a post menopausal woman without them.'

I do feel for you. Ambivalence is a very tough place to be, especially when it's such an all-or-nothing decision. I guess you can only make what you feel in your guts is the best decision for you right now. Theres no insurance against regret whichever path you take in life

polkadotdalmation · 02/08/2023 08:42

I really feel from what you say, you would be better off without kids. I'm sure you would be an adequate mother and the child would be loved, but from your current standpoint, just why have one? It would add nothing to your life. You're happy as you are. Husband is happy with the decision you make. So why add a whole load of work (kids are such hard work as well as rewarding) to your life?

The money you save by staying child free will give you a lovely standard of living. Mumsnet have a child free section you may want to visit?

MotherofGorgons · 02/08/2023 08:25

OP, if I might give you some advice, as an older woman, try building a network of friends and support for your old age. This is good advice for anyone, childfree or not.

Sakura7 · 02/08/2023 08:15

I think it's wonderful that we do and can think things through and have choices but has it made things more complicated for us? Not long ago you probably would have just got with having children without questioning it too much.

Yes, because women having children when they don't really want them and aren't suited to parenthood is a fantastic experience for all concerned, especially the children. 🙄

If you were a woman of childbearing age in the days before contraception, you might feel very differently about choice being an inconvenience. Many women wanted that choice desperately.

SashaPearce · 02/08/2023 08:08

BreatheAndFocus · 02/08/2023 07:52

Society would exist without children! 😆 To coin a phrase - they’re our future. Of course, society is set up to value them. Interestingly, all these ‘annoying children’ will be the ones paying your pension and wiping your bum when you’re old. Society needs children and young people - and so do we all.

I have a childless friend in her early 90s. She wipes her own bum, no-one else is doing that for her. How on earth would children be paying her pension when they are not earning? She earned it by working hard all her life and paying into the system. She also until covid was doing volunteer reading help with children with reading disabilities, so I’d say children were benefiting quite a bit more from her than vice versa. Guess you were laughing so hard you forgot to think.

LaMaG · 02/08/2023 08:02

Re the ageing point above, I had exactly that conversation with a friend recently who has chosen not to have children. She said she will always worry who will look after her when she is old. She is afraid of regret. I have 3 children and I get her point, but who is to say I will ever have grandchildren or have children who are available to look after me. Plus I wouldn't want a child in 50s or whatever feeling obliged to look after me but I'd hope they'd visit a lot of course. My point was if you have children you cannot expect a payback, it's not a reason to have them. It's terrifying to think of yourself as an old childless person but it's pretty terrifying to think of yourself old and vulnerable either way.

BewareBends · 02/08/2023 07:56

ForestGoblin · 01/08/2023 22:29

I just can't imagine what that's like. Children seem like a trial to me. One that it's good to pass but I guess I wish our society wasnt set up around them.

I can assure you it’s not, or it certainly doesn’t feel that way. When I had DS at 39, I thought it would feel as if I were joining the mainstream in some sense, but actually it was an isolating experience, and I felt very invisible holding my CS scar together and struggling with a pushchair on buses.

BreatheAndFocus · 02/08/2023 07:53

wouldnt exist, that is. I was laughing so much I mistyped 😄

BreatheAndFocus · 02/08/2023 07:52

ForestGoblin · 01/08/2023 22:29

I just can't imagine what that's like. Children seem like a trial to me. One that it's good to pass but I guess I wish our society wasnt set up around them.

Society would exist without children! 😆 To coin a phrase - they’re our future. Of course, society is set up to value them. Interestingly, all these ‘annoying children’ will be the ones paying your pension and wiping your bum when you’re old. Society needs children and young people - and so do we all.

BreatheAndFocus · 02/08/2023 07:48

ForestGoblin · 01/08/2023 20:12

Having children doesn't make being old ok!

What an interesting quote to pick out of my post @ForestGoblin …..
I wasn’t implying having children made being old, ok - but I think you know that. What I was saying was asking you to imagine how you’d feel being childless in old age. I asked that because when I was young, I met an old lady who was a real dear. She fussed over me, got me drinks and snacks. She told me she was a widow and had never been able to have children. I sympathised but she clearly read my mind (I was thinking that that was sad but was all in the past). She told me it wasn’t just not having children, people forgot that it was also not having grandchildren. She said how lonely she felt because although she had friends, they had grandchildren and their children and grandchildren were a big part of their lives. I could tell how much it hurt her.

Now you’ll say you’re different because you’re choosing not to have children, and that’s true, but my initial post suggested that as part of your decision-making you imagined being old and without children and grandchildren. Your flippant response was very defensive. If you’re genuinely unsure about having children, I suggest you consider a few counselling sessions to work through your thoughts and issues before making the final decision.

But - I think you know that you don’t want them, so just don’t. It would probably be for the best.

Jo190 · 02/08/2023 07:17

Cucucucu · 01/08/2023 18:37

What if you go out and have a car crash , someone runs you over or a satélite falls on your head ? Life is full of what ifs

There is no perfect timing , there is no magic formula .
I can’t tell you if you should or not to have a child , the only thing everyone else who never has children is missing out is on the unconditional love , I can tell you that the love you will feel for your child is not comparable to any other love , it’s so big and so … just amazing , that there is no way you will ever feel it without having a child . But again you won’t miss what you never had . You don’t say how old you are or your partner . Maybe you still have time to decide ?

I can tell you that the love you will feel for your child is not comparable to any other love , it’s so big and so … just amazing , that there is no way you will ever feel it without having a child

This is so true but isn’t entirely a positive thing for me. It’s also terrifying how much you love your child, in my experience. From pregnancy, I have found myself having several worries. I wished this special time away thinking I’d feel less anxious when they arrived, but my worries were then tenfold. Like I said in an earlier post, there are so many conflicted emotions and feelings at play. And difficult to articulate/understand fully until you have one. I’m really wish people were brutally honest with me during pregnancy and certainly in the newborn stage about just how hard it is. I remember just one friend went against the grain of “You must be so in love in your bubble” and said something real which spoke to my heart at the time.

SnozPoz · 02/08/2023 06:53

I wonder sometimes if there is too much analysis these days of how we should live our lives? I think it's wonderful that we do and can think things through and have choices but has it made things more complicated for us? Not long ago you probably would have just got with having children without questioning it too much.
I really don't like most other children but love my own. She wasn't an easy child but she's my favourite person of all time. Her father was off the scene pretty quickly so I was effectively a single parent but it was fine. You would be fine too. The fact that you ask all these questions says to me that you really care and you would for this reason really care for your child and be a great mother, and you've already said your husband would be a great father. You cannot worry about "what ifs"... they will paralyse you. Equally don't worry about the what ifs if you don't have children. Good luck

Juleslovesmaths · 02/08/2023 06:43

No totally serious - being a mother is a privilege and the best thing in the world