Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How generous are you with money in friendships

383 replies

Ryvitas · 31/07/2023 05:34

Inspired by another thread.
I will likely get criticised for this, but if I go out for a coffee or bite to eat (on the very odd occasion) I will pay for my own, I won't pay for my friends'. I don't like letting others pay for mine, but if they absolutely insist, I will make sure I buy theirs the next time. Otherwise, I will just pay for my own, and let them pay for their own.
I don't buy rounds. Again if someone's bought me a drink I will buy them one, but I won't otherwise.
I don't tend to buy them gifts unless it's an event like a wedding or a new baby.
I would never lend a friend money unless it's a life or death situation, or an absolutely desperate situation.
Something like 50p ok, but not regularly.
It probably all sounds very transactional and harsh. I believe I'm a supportive friend, but I refuse to mix money with friends.
My partner has a friend who's addicted to drugs and constantly asks them all to borrow money.
I've had several leeches in the past who always forgot their wallet and it's always 'oh I'll pay you back'.
Too many people who like being paid for.

OP posts:
ButterCrackers · 31/07/2023 13:09

Usernamen · 31/07/2023 12:22

I would hate the faff of trying to split a bill based on exactly what everyone ordered, or each person going up to buy their drink in a bar instead of doing rounds.

Yes, I may technically lose out as I’m not a big eater or drinker, but surely that’s the price of socialising with friends? Not everything in life is about scoring on the spreadsheet.

I check the prices before I order and know how much I’ve spent. I then put that money in with a contribution to the service charge and a tip. I don’t need to see the bill to have to check the amount I owe. I don’t do rounds so that doesn’t concern me

AngelinaFibres · 31/07/2023 12:50

Never do rounds ( we are in a walking group and if we go to the pub everyone pays for themselves. Everyone simply expects that. Some people come every week, some only every six weeks or so so it would be very messy to work out who owed who a drink)
Pay for myself everytime, unless it's a friends birthday treat ( they are always friends who return the gift)
Mum pays for what she has I pay for what I have.
Have never, ever been asked to lend money to anyone. Never would. I was a skint single parent of 2 for years. I wouldn't have dreamt if asking anyone for a penny.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 31/07/2023 12:46

Mamai90 · 31/07/2023 06:10

You sound like a miser OP.

In my opinion it's not a nice trait. I'm a generous person and I treat my friends who have less money than me and I'd always lend money if someone needed it. I've always been paid back. You can't take it with you!

All my friends are generous except one and it really stands out. He tries to dodge paying rounds and it's annoying he's a good friend in other ways but I really think being so tight let's him down.

Well, I'm sure you love showing your largesse to your non-paying friend, don't you? I mean, you must, mustn't you, after calling the OP a miser?

OP's friendships are very different to what you've stated as your own experience so, where do you get off on calling her names?

==

OP... I understand, it's a barometer and most people get it and behave accordingly. It doesn't need talking about, it's just there and friends instinctively know where it currently lies. Takers don't/won't - feel free not to pay for them and ignore clueless people who call you a 'miser' based on their own non-comparable situations..

M4J4 · 31/07/2023 12:42

Zanatdy · 31/07/2023 12:39

It’s not buying their food and drink, swings and roundabouts whether someone spends £2 more this time than last. Fair enough if someone is struggling for money but generally I find it petty to sit there working it out and would rather meet friends for something else than sit there working out how much mine came to.

But I don't think anyone is talking about £2 more.

If OP buys 1 course, why would she fund people buy 3 courses?

I think it can be mainly be avoided by eating with like minded people but there are times when you can't avoid it.

Oceanus · 31/07/2023 12:42

I have a close circle of friends. There are 6 of us.
gay couple, lesbian couple, and another couple in me and my partner.
Sorry what are you implying here? If one is gay or a lesbian it impacts how they handle money or split the bill? Do they eat more or just have expensive tastes? Or you're cool because you're straight but have gay friends? Sorry, feel free to enlighten me!

Branleuse · 31/07/2023 12:40

I think im pretty generous with friends. I think friends are generous with me too, but we are realistic when skint.
I think we are all just a bit shit with money really 😄

Virginsexonthebeachplease · 31/07/2023 12:39

This is an interesting question OP!

I actually feel like I have become more tight in recent years as I am naturally generous but have ended up feeling a bit silly or taken advantage of at times. If it's a coffee I'd get one for my friend if it's a good friend and I'm there first. For lunch and dinners I'm happy to split the bill unless some people are drinking and I'm not. I've done this before when pregnant and out with friends who were drinking a lot and one of them said "shall we split the bill?" I said no I'm not paying for all your drinks (which cost more than the food!).

I do but gifts but I'm a lot more money conscious than I was and I do it less. I think I need to go back the other way a bit though as a few times I've regretted not giving more!

Haven't really loaned money but I do have a friend who always forgets her purse or asks for stuff and I just refuse now.

Zanatdy · 31/07/2023 12:39

Ryvitas · 31/07/2023 12:14

Honestly if people want to give me a wide berth because I won't buy their food and drink, that's quite ok with me!

It’s not buying their food and drink, swings and roundabouts whether someone spends £2 more this time than last. Fair enough if someone is struggling for money but generally I find it petty to sit there working it out and would rather meet friends for something else than sit there working out how much mine came to.

Rooroo42 · 31/07/2023 12:32

i am very generous and my friends all seem to have a similar outlook, if we argue over who is going to pay it’s because one of us is insisting I’ll get these it’s my turn. If we were to go out for a bigger meal/drinks then the bill would be split down the middle with most friends, but have some good old friends who we will pay for then they pick up the next one. In terms of lending money, then yes absolutely, I have a small circle of good friends who would only ask if they really needed it and would always pay me back. Many years ago I used to have a real penny pinching friend, she was incredibly tight, as was her husband (they wouldn’t even buy each other a drink in the pub let alone anyone else), It was miserable and embarrassing going to eat out with her, at the end of the night the calculator would come out, she’d pay to the penny for what she had (which was usually only £1 or £2 difference to others on the table) and would then refuse to leave a tip. I always leave 10-20% so would end up adding extra on to cover her as well. We didn’t socialise together for very long her behaviour was just mortifying to me and no she wasn’t skint just incredibly tight, she was always happy for someone else to pay though! I lent her my horse box once (hers was in for repair and she had an event booked), it’s not an uncommon thing for horsey friends to do but it’s kind of the unwritten rule that you return in the state you got it in and if you collected it with half a tank then you would top it up to more than cover what you had used. She returned mine having worked out the average mpg and put that exact figure into it, something like £19.06 any normal person would of shoved £20 in the tank, of course she had calculated it wrong based no doubt on motorway miles rather than country lanes and steep hills, so even my favour to her cost me money, with anyone else I wouldn’t of cared less but the fact that she took me through her sums to work out how much she had used as if to highlight her good deed really grated on me.

M4J4 · 31/07/2023 12:31

Arou · 31/07/2023 12:27

I used to be the friend who would always offer to buy our coffees - never got it back but didn’t mind. I also treated us to takeaways and they never offered to pay (which again fine). Went out for lunch the other week and they paid for it - I treated us a coffee after. I was then sent the bill later that night lol not sans drinks I’d bought either! I’m happy to go half’s of course but I think after that I’m going to be just as miserly and ask for my half and not bother treating as it’s not a two way street. My friend is lovely and I’m sure they have no idea that it rubbed me wrong mind so I say this with only the most love for her

You’re going to keep treating someone who asked for your half?

I think you’re so bent on not being miserly that you’ve become a mug.

M4J4 · 31/07/2023 12:28

Zanatdy · 31/07/2023 12:25

No, we never get out a calculator and work out who owes what. 9/10 we split the bill, if we have drinkers pay more they pay £10 more each for example. If anyone had any objection they could pay for what they had, but we never have anyone want to just pay exact amount. As I say far easier to split the bill

So if all your friends regularly had 3 courses and you just had the 1 course, you would be happy to keep splitting the bill?

Arou · 31/07/2023 12:27

I used to be the friend who would always offer to buy our coffees - never got it back but didn’t mind. I also treated us to takeaways and they never offered to pay (which again fine). Went out for lunch the other week and they paid for it - I treated us a coffee after. I was then sent the bill later that night lol not sans drinks I’d bought either! I’m happy to go half’s of course but I think after that I’m going to be just as miserly and ask for my half and not bother treating as it’s not a two way street. My friend is lovely and I’m sure they have no idea that it rubbed me wrong mind so I say this with only the most love for her

Zanatdy · 31/07/2023 12:25

M4J4 · 31/07/2023 12:05

I’d hate to eat out with you. I always split the bill with friends. Everyone I go out with is happy to split the bill, and I eat out with friends a lot. If I ate 3 courses (never do) and they had 1 I’d obviously offer to pay more or pay for own items, and if we eat out in a group and some people are drinking and others not then those drinking alcohol pay more.

So you would do what OP does - people paying for what they eat and drink.

So no different to the OP!

No, we never get out a calculator and work out who owes what. 9/10 we split the bill, if we have drinkers pay more they pay £10 more each for example. If anyone had any objection they could pay for what they had, but we never have anyone want to just pay exact amount. As I say far easier to split the bill

Verv · 31/07/2023 12:24

I have a close circle of friends. There are 6 of us.
gay couple, lesbian couple, and another couple in me and my partner.

If we meet for dinner we bill split, as we all consume pretty much the same and I dont really care about the cost difference between a coke and a g&t.

If we meet up not as a 6, eg if I meet my best mate to go to the cinema then one of us will get tickets and the other will get snacks. If we go for coffee then one of us will get the bill and the other next time etc etc.

We're laid back about it but its long standing close friendships and nobody has ever taken the piss.

I would lend any of them money and them me, but we're all working or financially independent so the only loans have been things like if someone leaves their wallet at home or if something is cash only and they only have card. All paid back by PayPal FF same day so a total non issue.

Usernamen · 31/07/2023 12:22

I would hate the faff of trying to split a bill based on exactly what everyone ordered, or each person going up to buy their drink in a bar instead of doing rounds.

Yes, I may technically lose out as I’m not a big eater or drinker, but surely that’s the price of socialising with friends? Not everything in life is about scoring on the spreadsheet.

ButterCrackers · 31/07/2023 12:17

I pay for what I have. The bill can then be split by the others if they want to split the bill. I don’t drink alcohol and this adds a big cost to the bill if drinks are ordered. In cafes I pay for myself.

LolaSmiles · 31/07/2023 12:15

MyOtherCarisAFerrari
I think you get to know your friends.

One of my friends will often have one course and a couple of glasses of wine. I don't drink alcohol but like to have a starter or a side dish. Over time it probably all comes out in the wash.

Same with siblings. Some days we might have DC with us, some are adult only, sometimes one of us will have a savory snack because we're meeting on their lunch break, others we both have tea and cake. It comes out in the wash.

Other friends,like you mentioned, have very different eating and drinking habits so if probably pay for our own with those friends. They're not CF though so never suggest splitting the bill

MyOtherCarisAFerrari · 31/07/2023 12:15

Ryvitas · 31/07/2023 12:14

Honestly if people want to give me a wide berth because I won't buy their food and drink, that's quite ok with me!

@FunGamesStuff exactly.

I'm too old to bother with other people's entitlement these days. If they want to select themselves out of my friendship group find with me. Life's too short to put up with people on different wavelengths.

MyOtherCarisAFerrari · 31/07/2023 12:14

JMSA · 31/07/2023 12:10

As others have said, I match the generosity level of the friend. Only then does resentment not kick in.

I couldn't be as regimented or as miserly as the OP, though (sorry). It just seems a bit joyless to me. I can understand you've been burnt before and want to protect yourself, but there is definite Scrooge undertones here!

My two closest friends get a birthday or Christmas present, sometimes both.

I think some people are magnet for chancers, and that makes you more cautious.
I certainly was.
I've been told that I have a nice listening face and I can be quite patient. Being ND myself I always feel sorry for people who don't have many friends so I tried to give them a chance.
It also didn't help that I earned a lot for my age! Of course I didn't go around telling people my salary but people assumed from my profession and they wer correct.

These days I'm very selective and so can loosen up a bit

Ryvitas · 31/07/2023 12:14

Honestly if people want to give me a wide berth because I won't buy their food and drink, that's quite ok with me!

OP posts:
FunGamesStuff · 31/07/2023 12:12

Also, why would it annoy posters if someone in their group only wanted to pay for their own food and drinks. It's no bother to them and doesn't effect what they are doing.

JMSA · 31/07/2023 12:10

As others have said, I match the generosity level of the friend. Only then does resentment not kick in.

I couldn't be as regimented or as miserly as the OP, though (sorry). It just seems a bit joyless to me. I can understand you've been burnt before and want to protect yourself, but there is definite Scrooge undertones here!

My two closest friends get a birthday or Christmas present, sometimes both.

FunGamesStuff · 31/07/2023 12:09

Why do so many posters think you can't be a generous person but still not want to split bills. The two things aren't mutually exclusive.

M4J4 · 31/07/2023 12:05

Zanatdy · 31/07/2023 11:55

I’d hate to eat out with you. I always split the bill with friends. Everyone I go out with is happy to split the bill, and I eat out with friends a lot. If I ate 3 courses (never do) and they had 1 I’d obviously offer to pay more or pay for own items, and if we eat out in a group and some people are drinking and others not then those drinking alcohol pay more. But more often than not, we go 50/50. I lent a friend 12k last year, for her to buy a camper van a year earlier, as her pension was due and she wanted to travel around. She paid me back, with interest. I’d only borrow money to friends I know will pay me back but generally I don’t loan money to friends but would if asked to good friends

I’d hate to eat out with you. I always split the bill with friends. Everyone I go out with is happy to split the bill, and I eat out with friends a lot. If I ate 3 courses (never do) and they had 1 I’d obviously offer to pay more or pay for own items, and if we eat out in a group and some people are drinking and others not then those drinking alcohol pay more.

So you would do what OP does - people paying for what they eat and drink.

So no different to the OP!

NaNaNasAndAirGuitars · 31/07/2023 12:01

We split the bill when out, take turns having our group of friends over for meals, buy each other nice things if we see something one of us would like so I’d say we’re all generous. It’s easy though as we’re all financially comfortable and responsible and were a close group.

I did lose a ‘friend’ years ago who took the piss borrowing money from me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread