Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How generous are you with money in friendships

383 replies

Ryvitas · 31/07/2023 05:34

Inspired by another thread.
I will likely get criticised for this, but if I go out for a coffee or bite to eat (on the very odd occasion) I will pay for my own, I won't pay for my friends'. I don't like letting others pay for mine, but if they absolutely insist, I will make sure I buy theirs the next time. Otherwise, I will just pay for my own, and let them pay for their own.
I don't buy rounds. Again if someone's bought me a drink I will buy them one, but I won't otherwise.
I don't tend to buy them gifts unless it's an event like a wedding or a new baby.
I would never lend a friend money unless it's a life or death situation, or an absolutely desperate situation.
Something like 50p ok, but not regularly.
It probably all sounds very transactional and harsh. I believe I'm a supportive friend, but I refuse to mix money with friends.
My partner has a friend who's addicted to drugs and constantly asks them all to borrow money.
I've had several leeches in the past who always forgot their wallet and it's always 'oh I'll pay you back'.
Too many people who like being paid for.

OP posts:
Ryvitas · 01/08/2023 07:18

@msmonstera please tell me she's now an ex friend...

OP posts:
TodaysNameIsZig · 01/08/2023 06:00

Eltonjaunice · 31/07/2023 17:41

Wouldn't be my bag at all, don't think I have ever done it to be honest. The bill comes, we split it, all throw in a tip and that's it.

No calculators.
No going up alone to the till.
No totting up.

I suppose it depends on the friend group.

None of that happens if everyone pays for their own food though. It's usually easy to work out how much you need to pay and if not you can ask the wait staff.

msmonstera · 01/08/2023 00:10

We tend to split, but this is with long term good friends. A round each in a bar or split the bill evenly unless someone's only joined for a cup of tea or is doing the driving everyone home. It probably works out pennies over time.

I don't do this at work (avoid work socialising in general now though) because the times I've had to suck it up, the split bill always involved forking out for say the brand new kid and the alcoholic from accounts who had eight cocktails and had to be sent home, and you end up down a hundred quid for your own plate of pasta and glass of wine.

I would lend to a good friend, but only if I could accept never seeing the money again. If they were in dire straits I would gift it, but probably only once. I did lend a grand to a friend some years ago for a medical emergency. She promised to pay it back in instalments but never did in spite of gently reminding. She has since bought and furnished a house so I learned the hard way there.

I'd treat someone who was temporarily broke but don't persist for those who won't get their act together. Stopped buying drinks for an old constantly 'broke' artist mate who was spending his dole money on tattoos.

I think the above falls under a sensible generous rather than meanie :)

Catsmere · 31/07/2023 23:15

I'm with you, OP, and always have been. Everyone pays for their own food, drinks, whatever.

Oatycookies · 31/07/2023 22:57

TheEmeraldRealm · 31/07/2023 19:38

Out of interest, all of those on this thread who like to calculate and pay for only what you eat/consume - what do you do when a Chinese or Indian takeaway is ordered. Or even Pizza for that matter. Do you all order and pay for your own dishes and not share? Or do you all choose a variety dishes and then share them all, splitting the overall bill.

I am interested to see if there is a correlation between people who refuse to split a bill and people who order their own dish from the takeaway and don't share.

Our family/friends always choose a bunch of stuff and share it out, like a banquet. But I have been at a house where I was quite alarmed to have to eat my entire chicken and black bean sauce alone and not have a spoon of it and then a bit of chow main and and couple of spoons of the crispy beef.

If I order a takeaway for friends who are visiting me at my home I pay for it all. they all, bar the one CF, work the same way as well - they pay for the whole bill when guests are at their house . I usually order what each person wants actually and we prefer to do that rather than sharing dishes.

If we go out to eat something like tapas or order a bunch of sharing dishes we split the bill but tbh we usually order different mains etc so that’s less common. I’m the type to hone in on a main dish on the menu and just want that, rather than want a bunch of little things from various dishes. I think most of my friends are the same.

My friends often cover the entire tables bill on their birthdays or events they are hosting and I do the same. But sometimes we also choose to just pay for what we’ve ordered individually which takes about 30-60 seconds to work out. It’s not difficult and no one should have a problem with it. The only time someone kicked up a fuss about us not paying equally was when a friend of a friend had ordered steak and wine and some of the table had ordered veggie food with no wine said heck no . She’d been hoping everyone would subsidise her I guess even though she didn’t know half the table 😂

MyOtherCarisAFerrari · 31/07/2023 21:47

TheEmeraldRealm · 31/07/2023 19:38

Out of interest, all of those on this thread who like to calculate and pay for only what you eat/consume - what do you do when a Chinese or Indian takeaway is ordered. Or even Pizza for that matter. Do you all order and pay for your own dishes and not share? Or do you all choose a variety dishes and then share them all, splitting the overall bill.

I am interested to see if there is a correlation between people who refuse to split a bill and people who order their own dish from the takeaway and don't share.

Our family/friends always choose a bunch of stuff and share it out, like a banquet. But I have been at a house where I was quite alarmed to have to eat my entire chicken and black bean sauce alone and not have a spoon of it and then a bit of chow main and and couple of spoons of the crispy beef.

Erm depends on what people want surely?
If everyone wants to eat most things we share, otherwise not.
And the former only happens with people who are not fussy!
With things like dim sum meant as a sharing dish we share, but other stuff often gets so bogged down with what people can't/won't eat that it is easier for people to get their own. We split the bill for broadly similar priced food anyway.
Some things like roast duck and spare ribs are almost double the cost of the other stuff, not much with loads of people but noticeable if it's 3-4 of you!

MyOtherCarisAFerrari · 31/07/2023 21:38

Batshit1 · 31/07/2023 21:36

Me and my friends are always buying stuff for each other or paying for coffee etc, next time we get coffee someone else pays. If someone comes out without a bank card I will pay for what they want and I know they will get it back to me. When a friends kids all have bug and she can’t leave the house I will pick up and pay for what they need for the shops and let them settle it later… usually a few days later when my kids all have the same bug and the favour is returned.
I don’t think any of us are counting the exact pennies owed and if it makes a difference none of us are anywhere near being ‘well off’.

See that's the thing though - none of you are 'well off', you are broadly similar. Yet, it only takes one entitled person to ruin the dynamic, or one person ordering loads more than the rest...

MyOtherCarisAFerrari · 31/07/2023 21:37

*ate and drank ofc

Batshit1 · 31/07/2023 21:36

Me and my friends are always buying stuff for each other or paying for coffee etc, next time we get coffee someone else pays. If someone comes out without a bank card I will pay for what they want and I know they will get it back to me. When a friends kids all have bug and she can’t leave the house I will pick up and pay for what they need for the shops and let them settle it later… usually a few days later when my kids all have the same bug and the favour is returned.
I don’t think any of us are counting the exact pennies owed and if it makes a difference none of us are anywhere near being ‘well off’.

MyOtherCarisAFerrari · 31/07/2023 21:36

Also @DontYouThreatenMeWithADeadFish I think a lot of people also don't socialise outside their little groups. A PP, think it was @LolaSmiles mentioned you know your friends' behaviours.
That's true for my 'close' friends, but I'm often invited to group outings by say, friends of a friend where I don't know everyone. I'm using the word 'friend' here to cover all bases instead of pedantically typing 'friends and acquaintances'.

There's always at least a couple of people who take the P ordering more than the rest, or one who eats less. Instead of trying to balance these out it's easier to split.

I also find it hard to fathom how people find it a pain keeping track of what they ate. It's not hard. I have ADHD and terrible working memory if I can do it anyone can. Unless of course you were merrily ordering various things without a care in the world... which is WHY you want to split in the first place! Nobody will admit to being the CF.

MyOtherCarisAFerrari · 31/07/2023 21:30

DontYouThreatenMeWithADeadFish · 31/07/2023 20:04

A lot of anecdotes here describe dining out with established friendship groups where there is a roughly similar disposable income and you see each other regularly so there is a strong chance of costs balancing themselves out over time. I'm sure we have all attended events where there is a mixed group around the table with a few randoms you don't know who get a bit giddy with the drinks and expect other to pick up the tab. Usually I am happy to split the bill but I have stood my ground on a few occasions when people I barely know are clearly taking the piss. I was at one dinner when three people at the table started to ordering successive half bottles of very expensive dessert wines, quaffing them and moving onto the next bottle on the menu. They could not give a shit about the actual wine, they just wanted to get pissed. Those wines added nearly £350 to the bill. Fuck off if they they think I am paying for that.

I think a lot of people on the thread are
a) Lucky enough that paying 'a bit extra' means nothing to them
b) Established friendship groups, like you said
c) Only hanging out with people at their own 'level'.

That's why they are content enough to happily judge other people....

Oceanus · 31/07/2023 21:29

@TheEmeraldRealm With real friends we usually take turns hosting so there's rarely a bill to split. If it's a big event I'll take stuff and they'd do the same.
Takeways are a family thing here. If I invite somebody over I'm unlikely to order in, except if it's very close family and then there's no issue of who pays or who doesn't, because it's as true as a friendship can be so it's give and take forever, there's no resentment. It's a two-way street with most of my family (for everything, not money in particular).

Titicacacandle · 31/07/2023 21:08

My friendships are decades old. We don't bother with presents but I have no idea who has spent more on who. We buy rounds, treat one to dinner if they're a bit broke that month and others in our circle aren't, turn up with alcohol and food to each others houses, invite each other round and host which costs more than the obligatory bottle of wine they bring. I have leant a friend small amounts of money and years ago borrowed the odd 50 quid.

I don't know how I'd be with new friends as I'll be honest I don't make new friends. Every few years I make a friend who sticks around but it takes a few years of being an acquaintance to be a friend.

ButterCrackers · 31/07/2023 21:01

TheEmeraldRealm · 31/07/2023 19:38

Out of interest, all of those on this thread who like to calculate and pay for only what you eat/consume - what do you do when a Chinese or Indian takeaway is ordered. Or even Pizza for that matter. Do you all order and pay for your own dishes and not share? Or do you all choose a variety dishes and then share them all, splitting the overall bill.

I am interested to see if there is a correlation between people who refuse to split a bill and people who order their own dish from the takeaway and don't share.

Our family/friends always choose a bunch of stuff and share it out, like a banquet. But I have been at a house where I was quite alarmed to have to eat my entire chicken and black bean sauce alone and not have a spoon of it and then a bit of chow main and and couple of spoons of the crispy beef.

I simply pay for my share of what I can have if it’s a shared dish takeaway or tapas. It’s that easy. I’m interested to know if you think that people with dietary restrictions or vegan /veggie should pay out for what they can’t eat when with friends? If you had gluten intolerance would you split the shared pizzas bill and pay for what you couldn’t eat? Would you split the bill for the meat dishes you couldn’t have if you are vegan/veggie in the shared dish Indian takeaway? If your friends are real friends they wouldn’t let you pay for what you can’t have from shared food. If the are cf then you would be their best friend paying out for them.

EllaPaella · 31/07/2023 20:38

In my friendship groups we tend to split the bill unless someone has not been drinking as much alcohol or clearly had a lot less than everyone else. I would always offer to buy a friend coffee; in my experience if someone buys one time the other person offers the next. If I have a friend who I know doesn't have much spare income then I would certainly pay, especially if it had been my suggestion to go out. I think I'm a pretty generous friend - if I want someone's company i'm not going to be clocking up a bill in my head as we go along.

JST88 · 31/07/2023 20:29

I wouldn’t think twice about paying for a friends coffee. Ffs I find people who are this tight mortifying, I get that paying for meals regularly or larger things is taking the piss but I’d honestly rather pay the bill than sit and itemise it, especially if it’s just two people, the awkwardness over saying, ‘you had a starter and I had a Pepsi’ 🫣😐🥴😳

DontYouThreatenMeWithADeadFish · 31/07/2023 20:04

Eltonjaunice · 31/07/2023 17:41

Wouldn't be my bag at all, don't think I have ever done it to be honest. The bill comes, we split it, all throw in a tip and that's it.

No calculators.
No going up alone to the till.
No totting up.

I suppose it depends on the friend group.

A lot of anecdotes here describe dining out with established friendship groups where there is a roughly similar disposable income and you see each other regularly so there is a strong chance of costs balancing themselves out over time. I'm sure we have all attended events where there is a mixed group around the table with a few randoms you don't know who get a bit giddy with the drinks and expect other to pick up the tab. Usually I am happy to split the bill but I have stood my ground on a few occasions when people I barely know are clearly taking the piss. I was at one dinner when three people at the table started to ordering successive half bottles of very expensive dessert wines, quaffing them and moving onto the next bottle on the menu. They could not give a shit about the actual wine, they just wanted to get pissed. Those wines added nearly £350 to the bill. Fuck off if they they think I am paying for that.

Oceanus · 31/07/2023 19:42

Ideally the bill would split and I wouldn't bother "about 50p" but when I have to cough up over twice what I had (because of fancy booze and desserts etc etc) then I need to be careful not to find myself in the same situation every time with the same people. Next time I'll think of me because clearly nobody thought of me before.
It's fine to treat a friend but when they go "if you're paying I'll order something nice" and then proceed to pick the most expensive thing on the menu and posh booze. I'll be a bit more careful next time. Next time I'll think of me because clearly nobody thought of me before.
If I tell my friend I'm buying them a drink (when they're drinking pints) and they bloody ask for an expensive whisky then I'll be careful not to find myself in the same position. Next time I'll think of me because clearly nobody thought of me before.
When this sort of thing happens to me more than once, then I have to consider the fact there's something about me that makes people think I'm loaded and take the piss. I also need to be realistic in that I can't pick friends all that well, so it's just easier not to put myself in such situations.
The other day I saw a train for kids at the shopping centre. It had several seats. My kid wanted to go for a ride but another kid was sat and both him and the parents were expecting me, a stranger, to put a coin in so they could both go for a ride. Yes, all complete strangers and didn't make a move to get the kid out or anything. You should have seen the this kid staring at me waiting. Could I have put a coin in? I didn't really want to but the stares really made up my mind for me.

TheEmeraldRealm · 31/07/2023 19:38

Out of interest, all of those on this thread who like to calculate and pay for only what you eat/consume - what do you do when a Chinese or Indian takeaway is ordered. Or even Pizza for that matter. Do you all order and pay for your own dishes and not share? Or do you all choose a variety dishes and then share them all, splitting the overall bill.

I am interested to see if there is a correlation between people who refuse to split a bill and people who order their own dish from the takeaway and don't share.

Our family/friends always choose a bunch of stuff and share it out, like a banquet. But I have been at a house where I was quite alarmed to have to eat my entire chicken and black bean sauce alone and not have a spoon of it and then a bit of chow main and and couple of spoons of the crispy beef.

Oatycookies · 31/07/2023 19:36

I went out for coffee with a friend once in my 20s, I barely had any money in the bank until the next day. I bought something like a coffee and cake for £6.00 she bought something like coffee and sandwich £10.00 The bill came and she suggest we split £8 each. I should know I wanted to pay just my £6 and you could see she was pissed off but I just didn’t get it. If you know you’ve spent more than someone else than you don’t see frequently, it’s not for you to suggest you just “split the bill” no matter how small the difference is. It’s different if you are people who are meet up regularly and have a tradition of doing this but I didn’t see her a lot.

This girl also had a lot of parental support as she lived at home while I was paying London flatshare rents. There are too many people out there willing to take the piss.

Oatycookies · 31/07/2023 19:27

Ryvitas · 31/07/2023 19:13

No, it's really not odd that some people don't drink and some do. And guess what, they can be friends and go out together, nothing to do with 'sharing values'.

Exactly, that’s absolute nonsense. I rarely drink and some of my friends do. If we go out to dinner we’ll split the food bill and they sort their drinks out . Problem solved. I don’t need to go home early just because I’m not drinking 😂

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 31/07/2023 19:24

That does sound useful, WasJuliaRight. Probably why it's been scrapped now then...

Oatycookies · 31/07/2023 19:23

ripplingwater · 31/07/2023 05:54

The problem with paying for people I have found is that it then becomes an established pattern and they expect it. I also used to be a people pleaser and I realised that my generosity was just being taken for granted to the point they just expected me to pay. No more. Sometimes people get angry when you break out of the role they have placed you in (eg the generous one) and its really shown me who my real friends are. I wont pay for anyone any more as I've been burnt too many times.

This! I’m naturally a generous person mixed with being a people pleaser - and some people who knew from childhood are aware of this. One friend has had hundreds from me over the years, she used to ask for money here and there and I don’t feel comfortable asking for it back as she has 3 kids and a partner who spends a lot of his money on weed so I just left it. But then I’d feel obliged to pay for dinner, coffee etc then.I also used to buy presents /send money fr her 3 kids birthdays.

A couple of years ago I thought I’ll hold back from paying for these coffees and she is she does. She didn’t, she looked at me as if waiting for me to pay and when I didn’t she just paid for herself. The same thing happened on other occasions. I get a text from her on birthdays or once I got a half hearted present. I decided last year she’ll never get another penny from me. Lol.

But other friends I’m fine to split the bill with or buy presents for because they have a similar attitude to me in that they will reciprocate.

I know you don’t give to receive but when someone just takes takes takes when they have the means to give back and choose not to, it’s time to reevaluate the dynamics of your relationship

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 31/07/2023 19:21

JbytheSea, well, I took the lead from you. You've made some very unnecessary judgements and assumptions in your post and made no apology for it.

I too don't care what other people eat or drink and I have no issues with any of my friends; that's how it is with everybody, I imagine.

These threads go 'bad' because posters made judgements and pronouncements about what other people are and aren't, based on their own small experience and without any knowledge of the other person. Why do that? Is it not possible for you to simply say what it is that you do in your circle of friends without extolling the pointlessness/wrong-ness of anybody who does different?

WasJuliaRight · 31/07/2023 19:20

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 31/07/2023 19:17

I have never heard of 'pingit' or some of these apps Shock

It’s been scrapped but we used it all the time and would say ‘I’ll pingit to you’

Swipe left for the next trending thread