Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How generous are you with money in friendships

383 replies

Ryvitas · 31/07/2023 05:34

Inspired by another thread.
I will likely get criticised for this, but if I go out for a coffee or bite to eat (on the very odd occasion) I will pay for my own, I won't pay for my friends'. I don't like letting others pay for mine, but if they absolutely insist, I will make sure I buy theirs the next time. Otherwise, I will just pay for my own, and let them pay for their own.
I don't buy rounds. Again if someone's bought me a drink I will buy them one, but I won't otherwise.
I don't tend to buy them gifts unless it's an event like a wedding or a new baby.
I would never lend a friend money unless it's a life or death situation, or an absolutely desperate situation.
Something like 50p ok, but not regularly.
It probably all sounds very transactional and harsh. I believe I'm a supportive friend, but I refuse to mix money with friends.
My partner has a friend who's addicted to drugs and constantly asks them all to borrow money.
I've had several leeches in the past who always forgot their wallet and it's always 'oh I'll pay you back'.
Too many people who like being paid for.

OP posts:
imnotthatkindofmum · 02/08/2023 21:36

I bought my friend some furniture when she moved. It was second hand but I spent around £150. She needed it and I could afford it at the time. The following year she paid for a weekend away with our kids. We always do this and don't keep a tally.

I wouldn't do this with any other friend. I like to just pay for what I've bought when I go out with friends. I just feel so on edge about "repayment" otherwise. I'm also rubbish with rounds, I hate asking people and getting involved in lists and discussions about splitting the bill.

daisychain01 · 02/08/2023 21:31

Ryvitas · 02/08/2023 08:40

Exactly. "If you can't afford to subsidise my choices stay at home." No I'm good thanks. Learn to pay your own way.

But that wasnt the position you were taking upthread. You were saying that people are so privileged because they don't need to worry about the odd fiver or tenner here and there. No mention about subsidising anyone else.

Of course people shouldn't have to blow their budget to subsidise other people's menu and drinks choices, that would be ridiculous. You were calling people "privileged" just because they weren't having to worry about counting the pennies.

thehighwaysfree · 02/08/2023 21:24

An OP who said about "money mirroring" upthread has it spot on. With friends who I know and trust, I tend to be more relaxed as I know it either all evens itself out, or they'll be very hot on paying me back if I buy something eg: tickets or petrol to somewhere. However I have had my fingers burnt in the past with a total piss taker and won't be offering my flexibility to them again, as it just got taken advantage of. It really tarnished my view of them as they pleaded poverty but my view is if you can't afford to do it then don't, as it's not fair to other people to fork out for you.

MyOtherCarisAFerrari · 02/08/2023 21:18

DrManhattan · 02/08/2023 21:08

@Ryvitas this thread is nuts. I can't believe all these generous and kind people are so quick to fire out the insults when someone has a different perspective. One comment actually said they felt alarmed lol

Yes, and it seems not so much generosity, but a need to keep up appearances.

DrManhattan · 02/08/2023 21:08

@Ryvitas this thread is nuts. I can't believe all these generous and kind people are so quick to fire out the insults when someone has a different perspective. One comment actually said they felt alarmed lol

Ryvitas · 02/08/2023 20:49

It's just very sad how people can't share an alternative opinion without having to resort to insults and digs.

OP posts:
MyOtherCarisAFerrari · 02/08/2023 19:03

Tapasgoofy · 02/08/2023 18:57

Hit a nerve did I…. You are clearly in the tighter then a ducks ass crew who don’t tip.

Well I don't want to derail this thread by turning it into a 'tip vs not tip' thread. But as a former waitress and general restaurant staff I'm strongly against tipping.
It's a business' job to pay us. The moment people start tipping that gives them an excuse and incentive to pay less. We deserve our wages for showing up ready to work and working, regardless of whether a shift is busy or not. It shouldn't be up to the generosity of customers.

This is the United Kingdom, there is a national minimum wage, no need for tips. It should be in the price of the stuff you consume.

Tapasgoofy · 02/08/2023 18:57

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 02/08/2023 18:02

How dare you suggest that people who can afford to pay for what they have, shouldn't go out.

Tipping is voluntary too, we have a standard wage in this country and it makes me so angry to see big mouths posture that waiting staff must have a tip, even if the customer is also on standard wage. Just stop it.

I wish I believed in karma when I see posters like you post to cause hurt.

Hit a nerve did I…. You are clearly in the tighter then a ducks ass crew who don’t tip.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 02/08/2023 18:02

Tapasgoofy · 02/08/2023 07:53

If you can’t afford a meal that’s a few quid more then don’t go.

I bet you are the type that doesn’t tip either.

How dare you suggest that people who can afford to pay for what they have, shouldn't go out.

Tipping is voluntary too, we have a standard wage in this country and it makes me so angry to see big mouths posture that waiting staff must have a tip, even if the customer is also on standard wage. Just stop it.

I wish I believed in karma when I see posters like you post to cause hurt.

QueefQueen80s · 02/08/2023 17:00

LolaSmiles · 02/08/2023 13:14

Point being you're penny counting actual pennies and have a very tit for tat outlook that's quite tight, which is fine, but it's not going to be surprising if that's noticed.

Most people (including almost everyone who would rightly have an issue with 3 course fancy eaters being cf wanting to bill split with someone who had a risotto) don't penny pinch to that level.

"Most" yeah maybe in your world
Meanwhile in my world, in any group situation with work, friends, family, everyone has paid just their bit. All close relationships unaffected by this "tightness". Just because they is the norm in your world doesn't mean it's the norm everywhere.
People saying it's tight obviously don't have to worry about money.

Shoutinglagerlagerlager · 02/08/2023 16:22

Totalwasteofpaper · 31/07/2023 06:01

My DH and i are generous people and have had both friends and family take the piss to be frank.

Now i "money mirror"
We are very generous with our friends who we can be reciprocal with. Which is nice because i like to give.
With users /oblivious people i pay for my own and/or do free things that dont require cash.
With my inlaws who expect us to pay for everything i went on strike. I planned nothing, i booked nothing, we went for walks and sat about for months. It took 18m but in march they took us to brunch and may a meal in a local restaurant and paid for us both.

So you give only when you can expect to receive. Doesn’t sound very generous…

WasJuliaRight · 02/08/2023 15:12

One way I look at it is if three of us have gone out and we’ve all had a main, a drink and shared starters if when the bill comes it’s £55/57 we’ll all pay £20. Our mindset is a meal out for £20, We’re happy with that.

coodawoodashooda · 02/08/2023 14:25

LolaSmiles · 02/08/2023 13:20

browneyes77
Agree with you about some people taking a lend and being cf.

I think I think there's a difference between being more stringent (eg it's the norm when I'm out with some friends who drink alcohol that they split the alcohol between them and then non drinkers just split the food element because all dishes are around the same / only doing turn taking coffee orders when you're with someone who you know you see regularly and do their share) and the nit picky tight and transactional outlook that seems to underpin some of these friendships.

Personally I couldn't care less that my scone on one meeting was £1 less than a friend's price of cake or a sibling's syrup shot was 30p, and they're not the sort of people who are going to meet up in a week's time and say "actually Lola we should pay for our own this time because my americano is less than your latte and pennies matter". I guess I'm grateful that I don't have tight friends and nobody is a cf.

But why is it tight? I'm a single parent with very little financial contribution from xh. I can't afford to not be fussed, or tight, about money.

ButterCrackers · 02/08/2023 14:11

Ryvitas · 02/08/2023 13:17

In high school I was bullied by a friend who used to take 50p from my lunch money nearly every day. I was too nervous to stand up to her, she'd just take it and tell me 'you don't need that do you'

So there are a lot of people on here screaming "It's only 50p!!! You're soooo mean, soo right, you're a skinflint!!" These things add up. Call me whatever name you like, that says way more about you. I don't give a toss what you think.

That’s sad you were bullied.
I wouldn’t lend cash. Ive never been asked for a loan or for cash. I’ve never borrowed because I stay within my limits. I tell my kids that you have some money but you only spend half of it. You keep the rest. If you want something you save up until the cost is half of your savings to spend. Never spend more than you have. It’s tough with the prices going up and the bills. I check the prices of everything. I know people in poverty because of the prices and there is no solution.

ButterCrackers · 02/08/2023 14:04

Tapasgoofy · 02/08/2023 12:05

I have….

They must be cf if they don't mind you paying for them. It might be a money issue though because they must be hard up and couldn’t drink if you didn’t pay and being cf they don’t mind taking from you. I hope that they a my your paying for them. I stay within my limits and wouldn’t even think of a someone paying for what I couldn’t afford or what I could afford.

LolaSmiles · 02/08/2023 13:20

browneyes77
Agree with you about some people taking a lend and being cf.

I think I think there's a difference between being more stringent (eg it's the norm when I'm out with some friends who drink alcohol that they split the alcohol between them and then non drinkers just split the food element because all dishes are around the same / only doing turn taking coffee orders when you're with someone who you know you see regularly and do their share) and the nit picky tight and transactional outlook that seems to underpin some of these friendships.

Personally I couldn't care less that my scone on one meeting was £1 less than a friend's price of cake or a sibling's syrup shot was 30p, and they're not the sort of people who are going to meet up in a week's time and say "actually Lola we should pay for our own this time because my americano is less than your latte and pennies matter". I guess I'm grateful that I don't have tight friends and nobody is a cf.

Ryvitas · 02/08/2023 13:17

In high school I was bullied by a friend who used to take 50p from my lunch money nearly every day. I was too nervous to stand up to her, she'd just take it and tell me 'you don't need that do you'

So there are a lot of people on here screaming "It's only 50p!!! You're soooo mean, soo right, you're a skinflint!!" These things add up. Call me whatever name you like, that says way more about you. I don't give a toss what you think.

OP posts:
Ryvitas · 02/08/2023 13:15

Exactly, it's the pressure, shaming and name calling. Who wants friends like that ?

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 02/08/2023 13:14

Point being you're penny counting actual pennies and have a very tit for tat outlook that's quite tight, which is fine, but it's not going to be surprising if that's noticed.

Most people (including almost everyone who would rightly have an issue with 3 course fancy eaters being cf wanting to bill split with someone who had a risotto) don't penny pinch to that level.

browneyes77 · 02/08/2023 13:14

LolaSmiles · 02/08/2023 12:57

browneyes77
But to some people 50p is a problem. They'll lend it but nothing more.And coffees are strictly monitored tit for tat too.

I'm in total agreement on the big disparities though. That is cheeky fucker territory.

But I couldn't imagine taking the attitude of some people always keeping tabs on pennies. One of my siblings likes a syrup in their coffee and I can take or leave it. If I took the outlook of some people on here I should never buy her a coffee unless she has previously bought me a coffee of equal value and in the event we go out together we should both buy our own coffees because her syrup makes her coffee 30p more expensive. If we did reciprocal coffee orders each time we went out I might be out of pocket less than £1 over a month. But of course there's now quibbling here, no penny pinching, no being tight.

Yeah if we’re talking a very minor amount like a quid or two, then I personally don’t have an issue splitting the bill.

But some people do not like splitting the bill even if it is only 50p difference and that’s perfectly fine too. Nobody should be pushed/ forced or shamed into paying more than they need to, however small the amount.

Everyone has different boundaries and principles, that work for them.

Also I think that maybe what’s being missed here (and a few PP’s have given examples of their experiences), is that often people end up being more stringent in their spending around friends, because they’ve been taken advantage of previously.

Ryvitas · 02/08/2023 13:12

It doesn't matter whether it's 1p or 50p tbh. Never said I wouldn't lend it on the odd occasion, I said not regularly as it soon adds up. Work on reading comprehension.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 02/08/2023 12:57

browneyes77
But to some people 50p is a problem. They'll lend it but nothing more.And coffees are strictly monitored tit for tat too.

I'm in total agreement on the big disparities though. That is cheeky fucker territory.

But I couldn't imagine taking the attitude of some people always keeping tabs on pennies. One of my siblings likes a syrup in their coffee and I can take or leave it. If I took the outlook of some people on here I should never buy her a coffee unless she has previously bought me a coffee of equal value and in the event we go out together we should both buy our own coffees because her syrup makes her coffee 30p more expensive. If we did reciprocal coffee orders each time we went out I might be out of pocket less than £1 over a month. But of course there's now quibbling here, no penny pinching, no being tight.

coodawoodashooda · 02/08/2023 12:39

browneyes77 · 02/08/2023 12:36

An extra 50pm is not a problem.

The problems with bill splitting arise when someone orders a shit ton of cocktails/wine/sides etc costing a lot more and when the bill comes they expect their friends to subsidise all that extra stuff they threw down their neck.

Hardly fair if the bill comes to £100, with one persons food costing £60 and other persons food comes to £40, to then expect the person who spent less, to pay an extra £10+ to pay for stuff they didn’t even have. Regardless of whether they can afford it or not, it’s a pisstake.

Yeah. I've been caught like this before. It's very annoying.

coodawoodashooda · 02/08/2023 12:38

Tapasgoofy · 02/08/2023 11:54

I hate the thought that people are so mean fisted they wouldn’t lend a friend 50p! Oh well.

You can only lend it if you have it!

browneyes77 · 02/08/2023 12:36

Tapasgoofy · 02/08/2023 11:54

I hate the thought that people are so mean fisted they wouldn’t lend a friend 50p! Oh well.

An extra 50pm is not a problem.

The problems with bill splitting arise when someone orders a shit ton of cocktails/wine/sides etc costing a lot more and when the bill comes they expect their friends to subsidise all that extra stuff they threw down their neck.

Hardly fair if the bill comes to £100, with one persons food costing £60 and other persons food comes to £40, to then expect the person who spent less, to pay an extra £10+ to pay for stuff they didn’t even have. Regardless of whether they can afford it or not, it’s a pisstake.