Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In-laws and my new sister-in-law

395 replies

RozDoylessister · 30/07/2023 22:34

My in-laws are late 70s 80s old enough to be my parents’ parents. They are bloody lovely!

They are Catholic and are not English, kind, generous and very family oriented.

When my brother and sister-in-law announced that kids weren’t invited to their wedding I knew my parents weren’t going to be impressed but I was dreading my in-laws finding out as they would be so upset. In the end my kids were invited.

Anyway didn’t my in-laws (along with husband’s niece who is 10) turn up at the church for my brother’s wedding yesterday. They absolutely wouldn’t have thought that they were doing anything wrong. They would very genuinely have thought that they were showing respect to my family. My Father-in-law handed over a card to my brother with £50
My sister-in-law was just not impressed. She was thunderous. She came snarling at me asking what they thought they were doing. I had no idea that’s what they planned.

When we went down for breakfast today sister-in-law’s mother asked if they had been trying to wangle an invitation.

Husband is mortified. What would you say to Sister-in-law? DH thinks there’s going to be a rift. Went back to my parents’ this afternoon and they were laughing but my mum said sister-in-law’s family was going on about my in-laws.
Mum has just phoned and said brother has mentioned it as well and sister-in-law is still annoyed.
My in-laws meant nothing by it. Niece behaved impeccably and they all left immediately bride and groom got in car.

OP posts:
SparkyBlue · 31/07/2023 08:00

Sister in law sounds like a horrible person. Totally normal for people to turn up to see the happy couple. I had young cousins as flower girls and all their cousins on the opposite side of the family all turned up outside the church to see them. So did other random people and everyone admired me and wished us well. I would be 100% defending your in laws on this one I wouldn't entertain any nonsense from your sil.

SertralineAndTherapy · 31/07/2023 07:59

I had said quite widely to colleagues and not-very-close-friends etc, "Of course everyone is welcome at the church service," and to my pleasant surprise a handful of them turned up. Also an old school classmate, I still have no idea quite how they found out, but I thought it was lovely.

Enfys1982 · 31/07/2023 07:57

I can’t see what they did wrong. I’ve been and waited outside the church at a few weddings I wasn’t invited to but knew the couple getting married. Years ago when you could only get married in a church or registry office it happened all the time, I’ve got memories going back to early childhood of doing this. Your sister in law is a twat.

Aquaphant · 31/07/2023 07:57

Your SIL sounds awful, good luck to you because I doubt this is the last time she causes drama!

I'm surprised she even noticed your in-laws at the church. I was in a daze at my wedding with people pulling my attention left and right and definitely would not have noticed three extra people at the back of the church, or given a crap if I did.

Ellie1015 · 31/07/2023 07:54

A few people i knew came to church, friends parents i knew as a teen, mum's neighbours etc. It is lovely that they showed an interest. Very generous to give a gift.

Your SIL, brother, her parents and your parents are being ridiculous. Your inlaws were not trying to get an invite and did nothing wrong.

I would say to any of them "it is really common for more distant friends to attend service and lovely of them to spare the time. There is no way they wanted or expected an invite."

LivingDeadGirlUK · 31/07/2023 07:54

So your brother and sister in law have pocketed the ÂŁ50 but are now bitching about them coming to a public church ceremony? Incredibly petty and crass, I don't know if pointing this out will help because they sound Incredibly self centered.

CapEBarra · 31/07/2023 07:50

I have a chorister friend who got married on a Saturday in the church where she normally sings on a Sunday. Practically the whole congregation turned up to wish them well and they invited everyone to the attached church hall for tea, homemade sausage rolls, and tray bakes before heading off to her wedding reception. Church weddings are very much public (and often popular) events!

Dombasle · 31/07/2023 07:50

They only turned up for the church service and they gave a generous gift.

What a lovely thing to do.

Your sister in law and her family are uncouth and ill mannered to resent this.

Cakeandcardio · 31/07/2023 07:50

Bananazebra · 30/07/2023 22:40

Did they just come and drop a card off or stay for the ceremony?
If it's the later I can see why someone would be a bit annoyed as essentially they've turned up to a wedding uninvited and with a child in tow when the couple didn't really want children at there wedding.
If they didn't cause any disturbance then it's not enough to cause a family rift but I could see why it was cause irritation.

But the thing with church weddings is that anyone CAN just come and stay for the whole ceremony. It's not like a wedding in a hotel. OP - your in-laws did nothing wrong. Your sis in law maybe just doesn't understand how church weddings work. It was lovely of your in-laws to come along.

Epidote · 31/07/2023 07:50

Churches are public and free to go aren't they?
I thought they were and if is that case they have done nothing wrong.

You don't rent the church, if fact the marriage ceremony should be free of charge, although there always a generous contribution towards the church.

In some places people that is not invited at the feast go to church to pay respect, see the family and they are given a token gift or a card to remember the day. Some un invited people even give the bride and groom an envelope with some money in.
I'm Catholic and I ve seen that all my life. I see complete normal what your in laws have done.

They can't banned a kid to go to church, is the house of God, not their private venue. They are no one to banned the niece. Nor your in laws.

Bride and groom are not particularly into religion and they think they can apply their own rules/ secular rules in a temple.

They are the ones over reacting because their lack of knowledge.

They should have done a civil marriage in the rented venue.

Good for your in laws to go show respect.

Riverlee · 31/07/2023 07:50

Not an ancient law. Churches are open to all. Back in the day when you only had churches or registers offices to get married in, it was quite usual for neighbours etc to pop in and go to the wedding. I remember going to one in my lunch hour of a school friends older sister who I knew once.

CoffeeRevelsForever · 31/07/2023 07:49

I think a lot of people who get married in a church have no idea what a church is beyond a nice quaint photo op! You can't exclude children, or anyone else, from a church ceremony or dictate every aspect because its your special day - a church is a community institution. The in-laws clearly came with generous intentions, and I know from Irish Catholic family that they would feel so rude not attending or not giving a gift. It won't have occurred to them that the bride and her family are so ignorant that they would view this the opposite way and see their behaviour as rude.

I wish people would take the time to understand what they're doing when they choose a church wedding! Not just the letter of the rules, but the spirit of the community it serves. It's so graceless to trample all over that in pursuit of your social-media perfect day. Book a private venue if that's what you want!

LadyBird1973 · 31/07/2023 07:45

It's also pretty rude to want to exclude grooms nieces/nephews. I get why people want child free weddings but family children are different surely?

Blinkinbloodyhayfever · 31/07/2023 07:44

Your sounds awful. She isn't a church goer, but has appropriated one for the purpose of nice wedding photographs, then bitched because she didn't know the rules about churches being open to everyone. Classic.

Mortgageportgage · 31/07/2023 07:44

Your SIL sounds like an absolute prick!

My grandparents used to take me to the church to see the bride all the time when I was little, I loved it! Infact it was encouraged, thr father of the bride would have a pocket full of change and throw it in the air and all the kods would find some coins, we'd go most Saturdays in the summer!

HelloDaisy · 31/07/2023 07:37

FlamingoQueen · 31/07/2023 07:33

It sounds like they were being respectful by showing up at church. What a shame the brides family have blown it all out of proportion. I would just say to the bride that they meant it as a respectful gesture and it’s sad that it’s being seen as a grabby thing. If your in-laws had gone to see the bride and groom but just stood outside the church, that would have been wrong too.
I genuinely don’t think you will ever win this argument, but you know they were being respectful so leave it at that. You are lucky to have such lovely in-laws. Your brother does obviously not have the same fortune!

perfectly said!

BorsetshireBanality · 31/07/2023 07:35

Maybe your SIL should have bogged off to the Maldives and had an “insta” wedding.

FlamingoQueen · 31/07/2023 07:33

It sounds like they were being respectful by showing up at church. What a shame the brides family have blown it all out of proportion. I would just say to the bride that they meant it as a respectful gesture and it’s sad that it’s being seen as a grabby thing. If your in-laws had gone to see the bride and groom but just stood outside the church, that would have been wrong too.
I genuinely don’t think you will ever win this argument, but you know they were being respectful so leave it at that. You are lucky to have such lovely in-laws. Your brother does obviously not have the same fortune!

ManxRhyme · 31/07/2023 07:33

SIL is being really graceless about this and anyone egging her on is shit stirring. This is so disrespectful to the church, you and your in laws.

Iamtheonwandlonely · 31/07/2023 07:30

They still took the card with money in it.
That's says it all about them really.

LadyBird1973 · 31/07/2023 07:30

Stop feeling embarrassed by your lovely in-laws and maybe start feeling embarrassed by your arsehole brother and sister in law, who are making your nice dh feel bad, for no good reason!
Time to have a civil but firm word with your brother to a) remind him that anyone has a right to turn up at a church and if he didn't want this he should have booked a different venue, b) it's a good thing when people wish you well and c) it's totally normal behaviour in many cultures.

Don't let your brother and sil give you any grief - shut them down firmly.
Your sil has basically marred her own weddings, having a face like thunder over a total non-event!

Thosepeskyseagulls · 31/07/2023 07:29

It’s a public worship service: anyone can attend! And actually that’s important because of the last chance to declare the couple can’t legally be married which is built into the service. Hence, techno someone could show up to announce the groom is already married (a la Jane Eyre) although in reality it never happens. There could also be kid choristers in the church choir or teenage bell ringers. SIL is being precious and misunderstanding what it means to have a church wedding. She’s just thinking of it the same as having a service in a hotel or private venue.

PolliFlinders · 31/07/2023 07:27

Scottish Highlands here, perfectly normal for neighbours, friends,ect, to sit at the back of the church to pay respects to the couple. Your in-laws did nothing wrong.

SweetyMcSweeterson · 31/07/2023 07:26

I guess it's a clash of cultures. I'm from originally from India and it would be considered extremely offensive to not invite the in-laws of the groom's sister (along with their kids and grand kids). I know it's different in the UK but if your in laws were friendly and gave a generous gift it's obvious that they had good intentions.

I also don't understand why they are still fuming about it. Was there nothing more exciting to get upset about at the wedding? Weddings are breeding grounds for resentment and drama (in my opinion) and I think it's often the couple's family who create the drama once the wedding is over because maybe they feel deflated that there is nothing interesting going on anymore. If that is the case though your sil and especially your brother are silly to rise to it.

I'd just explain to your sil (or have your brother explain) that your in-laws just followed their own tradition and didn't realise anyone could think that it was disrespectful.

Good luck. Don't write off your sil yet. Weddings are hugely stressful. Hopefully she'll see sense soon (but do explain the whole thing to her).

Azaeleasinbloom · 31/07/2023 07:21

Your new SIl is an ungrateful brat. Some nice people turn up to see her at her shiny best , with a generous gift, and she gets upset at the cheek of it. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Your in-laws sound lovely.