Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My partner’s family booked a holiday without me

314 replies

Isthisrea · 30/07/2023 22:32

Hi, looking for opinions on this situation:

I’m from another country, my partner is from England. We used to live in London, but shortly before our children were born we moved out of London so we could buy a house. We settled near to his family; after our children were born the relationship between me and my partner’s family deteriorated. I found MIL very overbearing and after a few intense situations, I have limited contact with her. MIL and FIL see children weekly.

I used up all my holiday for visiting my home country with my partner and children and have no holiday left for this year, I work part time (3 days during the week and every Saturday).

My partner’s family ( his parents, sister and her partner) have booked a caravan holiday next weekend and my partner and children are expected to attend. There has been no mention of me attending (I’m working on Saturday and can’t book any time off).
My partner is more than capable of looking after the children. However I feel sad and don’t think it’s appropriate to book a holiday for my children(both under 5) without me being there…Am I over reacting or you think this is ok?

OP posts:
PeloMom · 31/07/2023 14:04

@Isthisrea i totally get it and I think you’re completely right. However I don’t think the issue is your MIL. I think the issue is your DH- he should have consulted you, he should stand up for you when you’re threaten in such a disrespectful manner and he should make sure his family includes you.

electriclight · 31/07/2023 13:26

"Be honest, if a family member organised something and just didn't invite you, would you not be a little hurt?"

Not if I'd gone low contact with them and they asked dh about it first.

TonTonMacoute · 31/07/2023 12:25

Sorry, but I think you are overreacting. Frankly it sounds great, enjoy having the weekend all to yourself!

DinoRoar14 · 31/07/2023 12:16

Why would they ruin their lovely family holiday by inviting you?
You're a family unit but not joined at the hip. You can individually enjoy things.

rainbowstardrops · 31/07/2023 11:55

I think this depends entirely on how the conversation with your MIL and your DH went.
If she mentioned the weekend away and said , 'Will you all come and join us' and your DH said, 'I can bring the kids but @Isthisrea is working. I'll check with her' then fair enough. But if it was more along the lines of, 'We want you and the kids to come along but not Isthisrea' then that's rude. Or she might have suggested that just the kids come and DH said he'd need to be there?
Only you guys know how the conversation went!
Oh and I don't know where in the country they are but crammed into a caravan in the pissing rain with people you don't much like would be bloody miserable!!!

LAMPS1 · 31/07/2023 11:10

OP, in your initial post, you didn’t say that your MIL and SIL didn’t like you.
You indicated that YOU didn’t like them and that YOU were the one limiting their time with you because your MIL was ‘overbearing’.

Do you think they might feel the hurt/injustice of that measure you put in, even though, without question they have just had to accept not seeing as much of you as they would have liked.

Is it possible you could have misinterpreted their enthusiasm and delight at your family unit as ‘overbearing’ because of cultural differences.
We can only go on what you tell us.

But it still seems to me that you can’t curtail them on the one hand, whilst on the other, expecting them to keep up their enthusiasm with your company by issuing a specific invitation to you.
You can’t have it both ways.
They probably thought you wouldn’t want to come. Maybe they thought inviting you would cause more drama which they were trying to avoid. Only you know.

Ordinarily, of course you come as a family unit and an invitation specifically excluding you would need more communication to figure out if there was any misunderstanding (such as they knew you couldn’t get time off so knew not include you in the head count) But you didn’t paint this as an ordinary situation …you told us that you have already deliberately limited contact with them. (Rightly or wrongly…not for anybody else to judge) So to my mind, your ‘low contact’ could have well produced this consequence of not including you.

VictoriaVenkman · 31/07/2023 10:44

I think you are projecting onto this decision feelings you have in general about being accepted both within the family and in the local community.

If you look at it logically, you do not like them and they do not like you. You have no annual leave left. The idea of holidaying with them in close quarters cannot be one that you would look forward to. This isn't a week or two, just a weekend so I'd let it go.

Also, you have not said what exactly was said to your DH, or what he said, in the initial discussion.

saraclara · 31/07/2023 10:39

villamariavintrapp · 31/07/2023 10:33

You say the 4 of you come as a unit, but that you have limited contact whereas the children (?and your partner) see your inlaws weekly. So I don't think you can blame them for thinking that you don't in fact come as a unit, but that your partner leads on family time that involves them, and that you do your thing. I think your partner could have checked/discussed this with you, but I wouldn't expect your MIL to contact you separately.

Also a good point.

I honestly think that the most likely scenario is that MIL was offered the use of this caravan for the weekend (and only this particular weekend) at very short notice. She invited her kids and their families if they were free, DH said that he and the kids were but OP was working and wouldn't be able to get leave.

I wouldn't read any more into it than that. If you're going to go LC you have to realise that practically, you're not going to be part of conversations. And that reading as much negativity as you can into something that's probably entirely innocent, is not going to be good for your mental health.

villamariavintrapp · 31/07/2023 10:33

You say the 4 of you come as a unit, but that you have limited contact whereas the children (?and your partner) see your inlaws weekly. So I don't think you can blame them for thinking that you don't in fact come as a unit, but that your partner leads on family time that involves them, and that you do your thing. I think your partner could have checked/discussed this with you, but I wouldn't expect your MIL to contact you separately.

AnSolas · 31/07/2023 10:26

saraclara · 31/07/2023 10:09

MIL's child should be communicating better with the OP and MIL.

I'm not convinced is on him to do so, to be honest. OP hhaschosen to go low contact. MIL is respecting that. None of this is by DH's choice as far as I can tell. Why should he have to pick up the pieces?

My assumption is that MIL did not say "OP can not come" if she did it is his choice with how he deals with this. My assumption is that as OP is not reporting MIL stopped OP it did not happen that way. DH needs to say WE have been invited .....
If OP's family agreement is "100% family unit holidays only" he should have said that to MIL at the start of the "FIL and I are booking a caravan" conversation.

He picked the OP, piggie-in-the-middle comes with their marrige

LakieLady · 31/07/2023 10:18

Without knowing how the conversation between the IL's and the OP's DH went, it's hard to know if OP is BU.

There's a million miles between

"We've managed to book a few days in a caravan at the last minute, how would you all like to join us?", followed by DH saying "fine but OP can't get the time off work". (Clearly NBU in the slightest)

and

"We've booked a caravan for a few days and thought you and the kids would like to join us. We know @Isthisrea hasn't got any leave left, so it'll just be us." (Possibly BU)

or even

"Tell us when @Isthisrea will be working, and we'll book a caravan for then so you can come on your own with the kids". (Defninitely BU and sneaky with it)

saraclara · 31/07/2023 10:09

MIL's child should be communicating better with the OP and MIL.

I'm not convinced is on him to do so, to be honest. OP hhaschosen to go low contact. MIL is respecting that. None of this is by DH's choice as far as I can tell. Why should he have to pick up the pieces?

AnSolas · 31/07/2023 10:04

Seaside3 · 31/07/2023 08:59

I'm genuinely shocked by the amount of people who think it's OK to not invite a partner on holiday.

Low contact to keep things civil doesn't mean "we hate each other and can never be in the same place". It is a hostile act from the in-laws who clearly didn't ask, or make any attempt to accommodate op. She only works a few days a week, I'm sure something could have been organised.

I'm grateful I'm not related to any of the people posting that the family are right to exclude her, what a spiteful way to live. I'd also hazard a guess that most posting that they wouldn't care actually would be hurt if they were in the ops shoes, and that they would judge harshly if op just didn't invite her mil to a family gathering.

Its a caravan holiday weekend

Keeping things civil and not crossing into hate each other takes work. From the MIL point of view OP has set out her stall and the OP has control of (all) the children so if it not broken dont fix it.

The OP is doing the work on her side by insuring the children and MIL's child visits on a regular schedule.

MIL is doing the work on her side by not sticking her nose (directly) into OP's business anymore and communication is via MIL's child.

MIL's child should be communicating better with the OP and MIL.

Plus OP laid out how PIL had not ever demanded a chunk of Op's annual hoilday then had not bothered to directly invite their DS or await DP's reply before booking along why she would not go and only wanted the invitation not the oppertunity to spend time with MIL. OP is not saying MIL instructed her child not to bring OP

Starting a fight with DH over an invitation OP's was going to refuse anyway......

readbooksdrinktea · 31/07/2023 09:56

electriclight · 31/07/2023 09:30

If you'd been invited you'd be on here complaining that you were trapped in a caravan with your despised mil. Or that they expected you to use some precious annual leave. Or that they had no consideration for the fact that you work Saturdays.

Exactly!

Crikeyisthatthetime · 31/07/2023 09:53

Isn't it your partner you should be talking to about this? Did he just announce that he was going on this family holiday without you, but taking the kids?
Or did he say they've been invited, is that ok with you? Because if he just told you it was happening, he's the one I'd be angry at. He's living close to his family, seeing them all the time, going on holiday to see your family while you are living in a foreign country, being excluded. Does he have your back, OP?

Mummyoflittledragon · 31/07/2023 09:41

My dh is foreign and I have lived abroad relatively near to dh’s family so I can understand what you’re saying to a degree.

What isn’t clear to me are the circumstances under which you’ve been left out. As it was a last minute booking, it’s likely that there were few if any options for booking at a time, when everyone is free, especially if school aged children are involved (do your in laws have kids and are they older?

Perhaps the date was a fait accompli and your in laws asked ‘can you come with the kids’ to which your dp may have said ‘I am around but rea is not’.

And lastly, this isn’t really a holiday. It’s a weekend break away. If you aren’t ready or are nervous of being separated from your kids, I think it’s one thing but I would try to reframe this from the family’s perspective that they may well not have done anything wrong and may not have actually intentionally excluded you.

If you want to build better relations in the future, it’s going to take time and effort on your part. You are living in their country and people, who haven’t benefited from living abroad, especially if they’ve not moved much within their own country, will likely struggle to ‘get’ what it is to feel like an outsider.

Seaside3 · 31/07/2023 09:40

Thanks @WannaBeRecluse . I'm at how few people are seeing it as a lost opportunity from the in-laws.

Even if they had said something like 'we know you're stuck for holiday time, so we would love to take the gcs away for a few days. Would you like to join us/ mind ?' Then a lot if this could have been avoided.

Seems few people understand communication and diplomacy.

saraclara · 31/07/2023 09:40

@Seaside3 She probably was invited. But as she didn't visit them with her DH, the invitation was given verbally to him. I doubt MIL said "you and the children are welcome to come, but we're not inviting isthisrea"

MNers are constantly advocating going LC, but this is the downside. An invitation was made to OP's family, but she wasn't there to hear it or to involve herself in the conversation.
Given that she avoids them, they're not obliged to jump through hoops to speak to her about it separately.

Medsy · 31/07/2023 09:37

Aside from the are they close, would she want to go, does she have annual leave, etc: it's just plain rude really isn't it?

OP I would be using this as an opportunity to start a conversation about moving.

  1. It's not your country or area
  2. You describe it as a small town that's not particularly welcoming to foreigners
  3. Literally your only reason for living there is your ILs, and they've made it clear they like to cut you out

Why don't you move back to London, a different part of the country, or your own country for a bit?

Yonderway · 31/07/2023 09:35

Now if you can’t/ don’t want to go or don’t want your kids to go- should be your decision.

And what about the children's father 's opinion?
I don't see the issue. The children and their father regularly see OPs in-laws without OP as she doesn't like them and has limited contact. OP wouldn't want to go on holiday with them and can't anyway. Why would in-laws invite her. They know she doesn't like spending time with them. The father does want to go on holiday and presumably so do the children. Why should OP veto her husband and children spending time with close members of their family?

WannaBeRecluse · 31/07/2023 09:34

Seaside3 · 31/07/2023 09:32

If I were the in laws I'd try to make things better by at least inviting the mother of my grandchildren.

I'd hope I would have empathy to realise she's left her family in adufferent country and perhaps she would like to be asked to participate in his family holidays.

I don't think there should be 'punished ' for trying to keep things civil.

Be honest, if a family member organised something and just didn't invite you, would you not be a little hurt?

Exactly, unless there is the likelihood of violence or something, inviting is one way to show you respect the family unit. In OP's place, barring something completely unforgivable having happened in the past, I'd make the effort to go. Being together might help us make inroads into relationship building.

Seaside3 · 31/07/2023 09:32

electriclight · 31/07/2023 09:09

She's made it clear she doesn't like them and gone low contact despite originally moving to be near them.

You can't expect there to be no consequences to that.

They're expected to suck that up for the sake of family unity when she hasn't felt able to do the same - pretend, get along,

And they asked her dh first before booking anything so no I don't think all the anger is being directed to the right place at all.

If I were the in laws I'd try to make things better by at least inviting the mother of my grandchildren.

I'd hope I would have empathy to realise she's left her family in adufferent country and perhaps she would like to be asked to participate in his family holidays.

I don't think there should be 'punished ' for trying to keep things civil.

Be honest, if a family member organised something and just didn't invite you, would you not be a little hurt?

electriclight · 31/07/2023 09:30

If you'd been invited you'd be on here complaining that you were trapped in a caravan with your despised mil. Or that they expected you to use some precious annual leave. Or that they had no consideration for the fact that you work Saturdays.

saraclara · 31/07/2023 09:30

I would be mildly annoyed that they hadn’t spoken to me about it

This is what happens when people go low contact though.
OP has chosen not to visit her in-laws with her husband and children, so consequently she's not present when conversations are had. It seems they spoke to their son about this last minute opportunity, he said OP wouldn't be able to go because of work. Why would they then call her? Are men not to be trusted with information?

Given how late notice this is, it doesn't seem like something that could be rescheduled for OP. Statics are booked up way, way in advance for August. Sounds more like a last minute offer from someone they know who owns one and isn't using it this weekend.

Dombasle · 31/07/2023 09:26

Despite the friction between you and them they have a relationship with your husband and children.

Why deny them family time together?

You are working and when you're at home you're having a nice break from swing to the children etc.