Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why it's so tricky to find a good family tent?

59 replies

OhwhyOY · 30/07/2023 14:15

Looking at reviews for best family tents and every site has a completely different list, whereas for lots of products the best list usually has at least a bit of overlap.

Every one I've thought sounds good based on 'best' lists, even on reliable sites, throws up problems when you look up that specific tent e.g. one brand of very expensive tents apparently doesn't provide spare parts in the event that anything breaks. So you could spend £700-2000 on a tent that becomes unusable because e.g. a pole gets damaged. Anyone got any suggestions on a robust family tent that they really like? 4 person family but would like a good bit of space as planning some lengthy camping holidays.

OP posts:
FlameGrilledSquirrel · 30/07/2023 15:46

kirinm · 30/07/2023 15:42

I'd avoid an air tent - no experience of them but I just think if you get a puncture it would be a nightmare to fix.

We have a Vango Farnham which we love but we are a family of 3 and it might not be big enough for a 4th.

I'd go with a Berghaus.

The Scout Group I volunteer with went to air tents last year and they've been absolutely brilliant so far. A hell of a lot easier to drop than poled tents on a sleep deprived Sunday morning. They did spend a fair bit on them though for that reason.

JenniferAllisonPhillipaSue · 30/07/2023 15:46

Getting a puncture in an airbeam is very rare, about as rare as a pole breaking; and you can then repair or replace, same as a pole. They are actually more forgiving in high winds, and easier to put up single-handed. But as somebody else said, they're bulky and heavy. So OP you need to work out what you want from a tent before shopping around.

There are a few really good groups on Facebook (Family Camping UK being one) as well as manufacturer/owner groups, so it would be worth joining and getting some real life opinions rather than reading (often sponsored) review blogs.

GreyStampIcon · 30/07/2023 15:44

We love the decathlon fresh and black air range of tents ⛺️ we all sleep better with blackout bedrooms and they pitch really easily with nifty little features.

kirinm · 30/07/2023 15:42

I'd avoid an air tent - no experience of them but I just think if you get a puncture it would be a nightmare to fix.

We have a Vango Farnham which we love but we are a family of 3 and it might not be big enough for a 4th.

I'd go with a Berghaus.

BiliousOhGod · 30/07/2023 15:38

The reason there's so much difference in the "best", as that there's such a large variety options to meet needs /wants. First question is do you want poled or air? Then, do you want nylon or cotton / canvas? And what's your budget? I have a Berghaus air 4, and it's perfect for me / my needs. My friends have a Zempire which we all the Village Hall - it's enormous, but is perfect for them / their family. For a good all-rounder, I'd look at the Berghaus 6xl - good, solid structure, decent sized bedrooms, huge living space and if you want even more living room, there's an additional porch. But, as with all airbeam tents, it's v heavy and takes up a lot of room when packed. For any tent, consider how you will dry it if you have to pack up in the rain - it's a lot easier to dry a poled tunnel tent in sections if you have a small back garden than a bell tent, which has to be pegged "properly".....

PermanentTemporary · 30/07/2023 14:30

I agree with the Outwell Montana. They've been popular for a while so should be possible to get spares. In theory at least they are reasonably simple to put up and solid once up with plenty of space.

Camping really should be about good enough, not perfect.

SingingFaLaLa · 30/07/2023 14:27

I think you're over thinking op. We spent a fair amount on our last tent and the possibility of needing to buy spare poles etc never even crossed my mind. We've camped for 20 years with a variety of tents that have been put up and down dozens of times and have never had a serious breakage.

I would just make a list of your essentials. Mine would be 8 berth (for 5 of us), two seperate bedrooms, bedrooms at the back not the sides, built in groundsheet etc. Then narrow down to those with excellent reviews in your budget and pick the one you like the look of most.

WickedUsername · 30/07/2023 14:26

We've got an Outwell Montana 6p and it's a fabulous tent for a family of 4. Ours is 10 years old and still going strong.

It's steel framed and really practical in terms of space. It was considered huge when we got it, but now is an average size.

If I was buying a new one again I would look at Outwell in heart beat, and see what tge updated version of ours is.

Ohmylovejune · 30/07/2023 14:19

Our, now very old, Khyam tourer 6 is fab. Don't know if they still.make them. Ours must bt 25 years old.now. we've not used it much in past 10 years but put it up in the garden last year and it was as good as new. The poles used to be available as spares although maybe not now, after so long