Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who have cleaners, nanny's etc

110 replies

W0MENclimb · 30/07/2023 13:52

I am happy for you to tell me iabu. I'm just trying to understand it. Just stayed at a friend's in another country where it's normal for white people to have cleaner, nanny etc and they are all black.
I felt so uncomfortable with it, I'd hate someone doing menial tasks for me, the fact that they are black felt worse for me.

I realise that some people think that they are doing them a favour because they need work but it just feels wrong to me. AIBU?

OP posts:
CeciNestPasUnPipi · 30/07/2023 14:53

*principle

AndyMcFlurry · 30/07/2023 14:53

If you feel uncomfortable staying at your friends, then next time pay to stay at a hotel. Simple .

CeciNestPasUnPipi · 30/07/2023 14:53

I used to live in South Africa, where most cleaners/gardeners were either black or coloured (in a South African context, "coloured" is not pejorative, but denotes a heterogeneous ethnic group).

Yes, it is an obvious vestige of the apartheid regime and continued inequality; but it also gives employment to people - many women, who are otherwise often socially and economically disenfranchised - who would not be able to support their families otherwise. To not employ non-white staff as a matter of principal would, ironically, damage a damaged society even further.

Goldbar · 30/07/2023 14:52

Surely the issue isn't employing people in these roles per se, it's the structural and racial inequality, lack of employment legislation and lack of a social security net in many of these countries. All of these mean that many people have no choice but to work in low paid roles where they are open to exploitation if they don't want to starve.

wutheringkites · 30/07/2023 14:49

I have a white British cleaner. The job suits her lifestyle and I certainly don't feel like I'm doing her a favour. It's a job like any other. She can choose her hours and her clients.

I'm often at home when she's here, we chat, I make tea, and then we both get on with our jobs.

Babdoc · 30/07/2023 14:47

I have in the past employed two nannies, a cleaner and a gardener, though never all at the same time! I’m English, living in Scotland, and they were all white - three Scots and one Australian.
I don’t regard any of their work as “menial”. Caring for my young children in particular was something I rated as highly important. I had a good relationship with all of them, and was grateful that they enabled me to continue to work as a hospital doctor after being widowed, and to maintain my garden for a year while I was retired and incapacitated with long Covid.
The cleaner was forty years ago, when I was working 100 hours a week as a junior doc, and she was a hoot. She used to rock up on the doorstep steaming drunk on random nights and we’d discuss her complicated love life. DH and I called her mad Mrs Mac! But boy, she could clean, the place was pristine while we had her.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 30/07/2023 14:45

I have a cleaner. I hate cleaning and I'm bad at it, so I pay to have it done by someone who is good at it. I respect her as a person and for her skills.

Similarly I am a tutor. The families that pay me respect me as a person and for my skills.

I think it can be uncomfortable with cleaning (like waitressing or retail) that some people (dickheads) see those jobs as lesser and therefore don't treat the workers appropriately. But that's something wrong with the individual dickhead who looks down on others, not the fact that the job exists.

Wrongsideofpennines · 30/07/2023 14:44

Flamingmango · 30/07/2023 14:01

I find this noticeable with carers in the UK. I've known a few people who needed carers at home and I've never met a carer who wasn't black and over 90% were specifically from Nigeria. I guess it makes me uncomfortable because of some understanding that it's so badly paid, people born in the UK won't do this job, even though it's such a vital and difficult job.

I imagine this varies across the UK. I come across carers on an almost daily basis through my work and very rarely meet black carers. Most are white British, some Asian British. Where I was previously they were almost all white Eastern European.

FlipFlops4Me · 30/07/2023 14:43

Ah - didn't realise the thread was about racial differences. My cleaner, dog walker, respite carer and I are all white. Sorry for posting out of context.

MerinoCashmere · 30/07/2023 14:43

It is people who are poorer and less qualified here who do the cleaning jobs. Here in my bit of London, we have always had Eastern European cleaners and more recently Filipino. I am not white.

I can see when there is an obvious race difference it’s uncomfortable. The main question to ask is why people of those backgrounds cannot get ‘higher level’ jobs, if that is what they want.

JockTamsonsBairns · 30/07/2023 14:43

Flamingmango · 30/07/2023 14:01

I find this noticeable with carers in the UK. I've known a few people who needed carers at home and I've never met a carer who wasn't black and over 90% were specifically from Nigeria. I guess it makes me uncomfortable because of some understanding that it's so badly paid, people born in the UK won't do this job, even though it's such a vital and difficult job.

Not sure this is UK wide. I'm a careworker and, of a staff total of around 150, the overwhelming majority are white UK born women. 3 are black women and 2 are white men.

This is Yorkshire though.

FlipFlops4Me · 30/07/2023 14:41

I have a cleaner once a week, a dog walker three mornings a week and respite care one afternoon a fortnight.

I have them because my husband is physically disabled and brain damaged following a stroke and he has now developed vascular dementia. I am in the same room as him almost 24/7. Some early mornings I can get out and walk the dogs before I get him up, and most afternoons we can take them out together but the runs they get from the walker are wonderful for them.

The cleaner is because I simply don't get time to do much except husband-care and the cooking. I cook nearly everything from scratch with fresh ingredients because it's so much better for him. He comes out to the kitchen and "helps" which can make it take longer but he enjoys it.

The respite care is so that I remain able to do the husband-care without losing my marbles.

Dreamingofthathouse · 30/07/2023 14:39

I am not white, living in the UK. I employ a white European nanny to look after my children, so that I can work.
She is well paid and has a contract that sets hours and protects her like any other employment contract. On an hourly basis she is getting more than twice the minimum wage and all in all significantly more than most graduate programmes pay these days.
No exploitation happening here.

Your context sounds different and more racially tinged. On an individual basis I’m guessing the local employees are happy to have work because their country doesn’t offer many better opportunities sadly. if the government provided the same kind of unemployment benefits you can get in the UK, likely many would rather not work vs have the long hours you describe at a low wage.

BurntWindowcleaner · 30/07/2023 14:39

et12 · 30/07/2023 14:02

I don't know what the question is here. Is it ok to employ a cleaner? Yes, of course it is. Is there something wrong in a society where all the cleaners come from one racial group and all their employers from another? Yes, probably.

This.

You’re conflating structural racial inequality with the act of employing someone for domestic childcare work. For what it’s worth, I spent 20 years as an immigrant in the UK, and the nannies and cleaners I employed were all white English.

Louloulouenna · 30/07/2023 14:38

Nothing to do with race or skin colour but I loathe having staff around while I’m at home and now I no longer work I do my own cleaning and gardening etc. I have no idea how the super rich can stand having a house full of cleaners and cooks etc.

Merryoldgoat · 30/07/2023 14:36

Are you talking about a country where black people are generally only able to work in roles like this? Then ‘yes’ - I can see how that would feel wrong.

Because that’s different from having a black cleaner or nanny here.

Mari9999 · 30/07/2023 14:33

@W0MENclimb
The only wrong happening in those situations would be under paying those employees because of their race or ethnicity. If your friend is paying a fair salary then this is no difference from any other transaction between employer and employee.

Hoppinggreen · 30/07/2023 14:12

I am white and so is my cleaner.
I treat her with the same respect and courtesy as I would anyone else providing me with a service I am paying for, everyone in our house is expected to do the same. She gets money we get a clean house, everyone is happy

Gilmorehill · 30/07/2023 14:08

Aah I’ve just read you are specifically talking about a racial element. Sorry for not reading the original post properly. Yes, I did notice this where I lived. The refugee community provided a lot of domestic staff where I lived (Sudanese, somali etc). They lived in such terrible conditions and were definitely exploited by the rich families who hired them (long hours). Yet the families thought they were doing them a favour.

SlippySarah · 30/07/2023 14:08

The fact that you would not want anyone doing "menial" jobs for you is your problem and fairly short sighted tbh. You are talking about people's livelihoods and many take pride in it and charge a decent amount of money from those who don't have the time/capacity/inclination to do it themselves. Many people choose to be cleaners/nannies/home helpers because they are good at it and it fits with their other commitments. You also might change your mind when you are 95 and just getting your own breakfast is a struggle.

The race element in some countries is another matter and will be different from place to place and from one home to the next. It's impossible to generalise.

smilesup · 30/07/2023 14:06

I would find it hard. I have been a cleaner for a few years though mainly to rich Asians.
My friend who moved to Kenya is white and they stopped the housekeeper and cook immediately as they felt so uncomfortable. The next day the staff came back in tears begging to be re-employed. Which they did. It's complicated because of history. But if you pay well, treat your staff well, make sure they have holidays and sick pay then it's OK. If you can't afford to pay well and give holidays then you don't get staff.

electriclight · 30/07/2023 14:05

Why would you feel uncomfortable with someone doing 'menial tasks' for you?

I employ cleaners and a gardener. They advertise their businesses and are, I assume, pleased to take on new customers.

It is common to pay someone to do a task that you can't do yourself, because you lack the skills or time. I also pay someone to do decorating, for example.

I can see how race might feel like an issue in the country you were visiting but don't think that's the case in the Uk really. My cleaners are white, and one of them seems to be significantly wealthier than me (owns the company, big team).

et12 · 30/07/2023 14:02

I don't know what the question is here. Is it ok to employ a cleaner? Yes, of course it is. Is there something wrong in a society where all the cleaners come from one racial group and all their employers from another? Yes, probably.

Gilmorehill · 30/07/2023 14:02

I used to live in a country where it was the norm to have a maid, nanny etc. I hated having to deal with ‘staff’ and the responsibility of it. I also hated seeing women coming from really poor countries, often leaving their own children, to earn a few hundred dollars a month to run after spoiled children.

Flamingmango · 30/07/2023 14:01

I find this noticeable with carers in the UK. I've known a few people who needed carers at home and I've never met a carer who wasn't black and over 90% were specifically from Nigeria. I guess it makes me uncomfortable because of some understanding that it's so badly paid, people born in the UK won't do this job, even though it's such a vital and difficult job.