Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who have cleaners, nanny's etc

110 replies

W0MENclimb · 30/07/2023 13:52

I am happy for you to tell me iabu. I'm just trying to understand it. Just stayed at a friend's in another country where it's normal for white people to have cleaner, nanny etc and they are all black.
I felt so uncomfortable with it, I'd hate someone doing menial tasks for me, the fact that they are black felt worse for me.

I realise that some people think that they are doing them a favour because they need work but it just feels wrong to me. AIBU?

OP posts:
IHateLegDay · 30/07/2023 16:24

My cleaners charge a small fortune so I don't feel bad about it at all 😂
I'm white and they're all white.

Nevermind31 · 30/07/2023 16:23

My friend, who is from a country where it is quite normal to have domestic help, once explained to me that if you can afford it you are expected to hire domestic help as this will provide a family with an income (no benefits in her country).
i think the main part is to treat domestic help as a human, a service provider, who you talk to, treat and pay fairly. Skin colour shouldn’t come I to it, and I think in the UK it doesn’t matter.
in countries such as South Africa, it would make me feel I comfortable too

Goldenbear · 30/07/2023 16:18

My Dad lived in Ghana for a bit and due to the expectation did employ people to clean and run errands. He did pay well but fundamentally I think it made him a bit lazy and when he returned he didn't have staff it was quite an adjustment. He is lovely and fair-minded but that doesn't change the affect it had on his outlook.

willWillSmithsmith · 30/07/2023 16:14

Flamingmango · 30/07/2023 14:01

I find this noticeable with carers in the UK. I've known a few people who needed carers at home and I've never met a carer who wasn't black and over 90% were specifically from Nigeria. I guess it makes me uncomfortable because of some understanding that it's so badly paid, people born in the UK won't do this job, even though it's such a vital and difficult job.

My mum had what seemed like an army of carers last year when she was in great need of them (nhs) and all of them were white.

Goldenbear · 30/07/2023 16:11

continentallentil · 30/07/2023 15:48

But why is cleaning a house demeaning and sweeping a road isn't?

It's because house cleaning is traditionally 'women's work' so it's lower status.

There is nothing demeaning about cleaning.

It's also irrational to say that people who do have a cleaner are lazy - they are outsourcing work so they can spend their time on something else, and giving someone else a job in the process.

You could employ a male cleaner (I've had one) if you don't want your son to associate domestic labour solely with women, although as above, the fact that mostly women do it doesn't make it 'less'. And presumably he sees his father do housework.

I didn't say it was demeaning. My upbringing is based around being self sufficient, doing lots of your own cleaning and clearing out stuff you don't need- that isn't down to someone else doing it for you. Sweeping the road is not comparable as it is not the mess of one family. You are cleaning the most intimate spaces of someone's home, I just am not comfortable with that.

I think it is good that he sees his Father who is a director in an Architects practice cleaning as it is not below him, which I think having a cleaner insinuates. It is not just the male thing, it is well off male thing.

maybebalancing · 30/07/2023 16:02

There are two separate issues in your post OP.

One is about the structural racism in the country you visited and the other is about employing people to carry out household chores.

The structural racism is a serious issue that needs addressing separately to the domestic chores. If it were addressed you would probably find it was people with low incomes who carried out the domestic chores and that would cover a representative sample of the ethnicities in the country.

The domestic chores is more likely to be impacted by structural high levels of wealth inequality. Live in staff can always be afforded by the very wealthy but only by the middle classes in unequal societies often with little or no safety net.

We lived in a country with live in staff and at first didn't have anyone. Locals took us aside and explained that it was part of our social responsibility to employ people and ensure that they were paid, their dc had access to education and healthcare. So we did. It was an adjustment at first but in reality having staff often makes your life easier and occasionally more difficult.

Scaraben · 30/07/2023 16:02

My take on this is coming from the UK, but my cleaner is white. So am I. We grew up quite near each other. I have the money to be able to employ people to do tasks I am able for but that I'd rather not do myself. I am happy to spend money to gain time.
See also - washing my car, cleaning the gutters, putting up wallpaper etc.

It's a job like any other. I've never had anyone be sniffy about me employing a window cleaner or taking my car to the car wash but I have had people ask if I feel "guilty" for having a cleaner. Guess which of these cleaning jobs are done by men and which is done by a woman...

I think it's because jobs associated with femaleness are inherently seen by society as not worth paying for. I ensure my cleaner is paid well and I hope she would say she is treated like a professional doing an important job, which she is.

Maddy70 · 30/07/2023 16:00

It's a fact that many immigrants do do cleaning jobs. It's a job where bring fluent in the language isn't necessary

continentallentil · 30/07/2023 15:48

Goldenbear · 30/07/2023 15:33

Definitely feel uncomfortable, I'd feel uncomfortable about it living in England. I think cleaning is humbling though. DH wants to employ a cleaner's services as we both work full time have two DC but I don't feel comfortable with potentially someone with less life choices cleaning up after me or my DC. This was my preteen and teen learn to be self sufficient and DH is seen by my son to do his fair share of domestic drudgery i.e no woman cleaning up after you (which is typically the case). I don't get the whole, "we are not good at cleaning" argument, it is not hard to learn how to clean. We have friends who say this and I raise an eyebrow tbh. I am just not comfortable with someone cleaning up my mess I have made and my DC just learn that they don't have to bother either, it is a question of self respect as well. A caveat would be obviously extenuating circumstances but fit, healthy people that just can't be bothered I find that lazy.

But why is cleaning a house demeaning and sweeping a road isn't?

It's because house cleaning is traditionally 'women's work' so it's lower status.

There is nothing demeaning about cleaning.

It's also irrational to say that people who do have a cleaner are lazy - they are outsourcing work so they can spend their time on something else, and giving someone else a job in the process.

You could employ a male cleaner (I've had one) if you don't want your son to associate domestic labour solely with women, although as above, the fact that mostly women do it doesn't make it 'less'. And presumably he sees his father do housework.

MNetcurtains · 30/07/2023 15:47

I'm assuming your friend lives in Africa and employs locals. This is completely normal there. They're paid employees and some of them will be with the family until they retire. I understand it can be uncomfortable as a European.

continentallentil · 30/07/2023 15:42

I think you are confusing two things.

There's nothing wrong with employing cleaners, nannies, housekeepers - it's a job like any other. Doing someone a favour doesn't come into it.

Of course it's wrong that some people have a wider range of opportunities than others, but that's a wider problem with society. It needs fixing but pretending the problem doesn't exist is the worse way to do that - which you would be if you don't hire people for the jobs that need doing, or only hired them to do more invisible jobs like overnight office cleaning.

vivaespanaole · 30/07/2023 15:38

I am white and a FT working mum. I have a white working mum as my cleaner. She advertised her services and i need that service. At the time obviously i knew nothing about her l.

I don't think its menial. Shes a self employed business woman in my book. She makes my life much easier. Her rates are high and i pay them willingly.

Bonfire23 · 30/07/2023 15:37

Flamingmango · 30/07/2023 14:01

I find this noticeable with carers in the UK. I've known a few people who needed carers at home and I've never met a carer who wasn't black and over 90% were specifically from Nigeria. I guess it makes me uncomfortable because of some understanding that it's so badly paid, people born in the UK won't do this job, even though it's such a vital and difficult job.

That surprises me. I worked as a carer and would say 95% of the staff were white

hev126 · 30/07/2023 15:36

londonmummy1966 · 30/07/2023 15:33

I have a housekeeper and a gardener and used to employ a nanny. My housekeepers have been Philippina, Irish and the current one is Romanian - all are brilliant as was my English nanny. My gardner is actually a school mum friend who has a gardening business. My previous gardner was incredibly posh (much more so than me) and charged in guineas. I don't see it as any different to getting a mechanic to service the car or a decorator to paper a room. I suppose it seems worse to some people as the housekeeper/cleaner/nanny is doing tradionally wimmins work whilst the mechanic and decorator do "dad jobs" and there's probably a feeling that men's work is intrinsically more important/valuable than women's.

That's an interesting view - never thought of it that way but there may be something in the male/female divide.

Men are such hard workers and so busy then tired out by the weekend so it's justified to employ someone to help with "mens work" - us women should be able to clean daily and look after our dc full time....while working too of course

Mingomang · 30/07/2023 15:35

Obviously here in the UK people of all colours and backgrounds will employ others of all colours and background to help them domestically. Those roles aren’t really racialised as they are in some other countries, where the majority of employers are wealthy ex pats (or in times past, colonialists) employing local people cheaply and there definitely IS a sense of what is menial work fit for black/brown people and what is important work fit for white (men). That structural equality makes me uncomfortable too but I’m not sure what an individual can do about it without making a load of people lose their jobs?

Interesting to note about the domination of certain sectors by people from specific ethnicities in the UK. All the cleaners - and I mean every one - who works my hospital department is Ghanaian. There’s obviously some other factor at play here that I’m not party to - I don’t think hospital domestic work is really badly paid, Ghanaians are generally known to be high achievers anyway so I don’t think would generally be content with this job if it were badly paid so I’m not sure the “poor Africans coming here doing jobs we white people refuse to do” reallY holds water here? I’m assuming it’s a social thing where people are gathering friends and family around them as a route to employment, same as my ancestors came here and en masse became tailors or cloth traders in East London.

Anyway all very interesting!

Goldenbear · 30/07/2023 15:33

Definitely feel uncomfortable, I'd feel uncomfortable about it living in England. I think cleaning is humbling though. DH wants to employ a cleaner's services as we both work full time have two DC but I don't feel comfortable with potentially someone with less life choices cleaning up after me or my DC. This was my preteen and teen learn to be self sufficient and DH is seen by my son to do his fair share of domestic drudgery i.e no woman cleaning up after you (which is typically the case). I don't get the whole, "we are not good at cleaning" argument, it is not hard to learn how to clean. We have friends who say this and I raise an eyebrow tbh. I am just not comfortable with someone cleaning up my mess I have made and my DC just learn that they don't have to bother either, it is a question of self respect as well. A caveat would be obviously extenuating circumstances but fit, healthy people that just can't be bothered I find that lazy.

londonmummy1966 · 30/07/2023 15:33

I have a housekeeper and a gardener and used to employ a nanny. My housekeepers have been Philippina, Irish and the current one is Romanian - all are brilliant as was my English nanny. My gardner is actually a school mum friend who has a gardening business. My previous gardner was incredibly posh (much more so than me) and charged in guineas. I don't see it as any different to getting a mechanic to service the car or a decorator to paper a room. I suppose it seems worse to some people as the housekeeper/cleaner/nanny is doing tradionally wimmins work whilst the mechanic and decorator do "dad jobs" and there's probably a feeling that men's work is intrinsically more important/valuable than women's.

WonderingWanda · 30/07/2023 15:09

Flamingmango · 30/07/2023 14:01

I find this noticeable with carers in the UK. I've known a few people who needed carers at home and I've never met a carer who wasn't black and over 90% were specifically from Nigeria. I guess it makes me uncomfortable because of some understanding that it's so badly paid, people born in the UK won't do this job, even though it's such a vital and difficult job.

I think this very much depends on where you live in the UK.

Pogpog21 · 30/07/2023 15:08

All the people we have who help us are Caucasian - I’ve never thought about it. We pay them a very good rate to do things wed have no issue doing but just don’t have time to because we both work 12 hours each day, full time in the week and have a toddler. So I don’t see their work as menial. It’s simply what we can’t get to and they all understand that’s why we need them

Middlelanehogger · 30/07/2023 15:06

I've lived in a country like this, mostly black population and live-in domestic help would essentially always be black rather than white (although many employers were also black).

I do feel uncomfortable and some families definitely do encourage a "boss of the house / servant" dynamic which is physically palpable. Although not all or even most.

In context though, this is a country where you see people walking along the streets filling in potholes on the road with mud/stones from the side, in the hope that they might get a $1 tip from someone and that's their income for the day. So a secure live-in situation (which often is provided for the whole family, e.g. mum is the maid/cook, dad is the gardener, children's school fees are paid by the employer) is actually something really valuable, even if it seems demeaning and uncomfortable to you.

hev126 · 30/07/2023 15:03

I think it depends what you mean by "employs" a cleaner?
Im white and technically "employ" a white cleaner (different nationality) for 3 hours per week.
She's will paid, self-employed, works flexibly to suit her lifestyle. She's been cleaning my house weekly for 8 years but I've been wfh since covid and have gotten to know her quite well recently and we're now friends on social media so I see quite a bit about her lifestyle and she's certainly not hard done by....eats/drinks out in nice places, just back from a 2 week all inclusive holiday, lives in a nice area. I can also see from when she parks at mine that she drives a very nice car.

Good on her. She works hard and deserves it - I do suspect her DH earns well but she earns a decent living herself too.

I don't have any qualms about the situation at all. I appreciate what she does for me, she's well paid and seems happy with the arrangement. I definitely don't see her as inferior, we're completely equal but I struggle for time to do house work, she does it better and I can afford it.

However, I don't think this is the situation you have in mind given your hints at the racial element. I suspect your op isn't getting your point across well. Are you thinking of situations with live-in cleaners and nanny's on a very low wage?

YaraRocks · 30/07/2023 15:02

I grew up in a country where having household staff was common. We’re not white and many of the staff were from the same ethnic background as us. My family provided good, stable and well paid employment for people who were less fortunate than us. My dad paid the school fees of many of the staffs children. What’s wrong with that?

My cousins think the way we live in the west , where we do everything ourselves is bonkers. Sometimes, when I’m juggling work, kids, life et all, I see their point. We have cleaner, they’re from Colombia i think, not that it matters. She provides a much needed service that I’m more than happy to pay for. We used nurseries and childminders when the children were little and after school school and holiday clubs for childcare now. Staff were of various ethnicities but the most important thing was that they were human.

I’d happily have an army of staff if I could afford it.

Inequality exists, whether we like it or not. There is nothing wrong with doing ‘menial’ work and if that’s what was required to feed my family, you bet I’d do it.

Abuse of anyone though, whether domestic staff or not is not ok. For obvious reasons.

isthismylifenow · 30/07/2023 15:02

If it is indeed the same country we are referring to, then I should just mention that just as many black families have household help too. It is not white people who employ cleaners. So let's not insinuate that it is a privilege for only white people, as this is what your post suggests.

TheGoogleMum · 30/07/2023 14:57

I have a white cleaner. We aren't well off we couldn't afford a nanny but we really struggle with and hate cleaning so would rather spend the money getting someone else to do it. Costs us £30 a time and we have her every other week. I do sometimes feel a little awkward having someone else do it but it's her job and I'm sure she is glad there are people who would rather pay others to do it otherwise she would need a different job

isthismylifenow · 30/07/2023 14:56

What do you need help with understanding?

I think I live in the country you are referring to.

You felt uncomfortable because the helper was black, or because it seemed a menial job to you and someone shouldn't be employed to do it?