Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who have cleaners, nanny's etc

110 replies

W0MENclimb · 30/07/2023 13:52

I am happy for you to tell me iabu. I'm just trying to understand it. Just stayed at a friend's in another country where it's normal for white people to have cleaner, nanny etc and they are all black.
I felt so uncomfortable with it, I'd hate someone doing menial tasks for me, the fact that they are black felt worse for me.

I realise that some people think that they are doing them a favour because they need work but it just feels wrong to me. AIBU?

OP posts:
Simonjt · 30/07/2023 19:22

We have cleaners, a husband and wife team who are white British. Neither of us are British and I’m not white.

BurntWindowcleaner · 30/07/2023 19:05

Begonne · 30/07/2023 18:38

In the 50s and 60s female Irish immigrants in the US were in high demand as domestic staff because they were white, catholic and therefore seen as trustworthy both with the family silver and husbands.

And a few generations earlier, they were a despised immigrant group considered uncivilised, dirty and shiftless, their Catholicism evidence of their gullibility and depravity.

There is wide-ranging research on the racialised constructions of the ‘Irish Bridget’ alongside the black ‘Mammy’ stereotype in US domestic service in the 19th and early 20thc by April Schulz and others. One of the more uncomfortable threads in US social history is the periods when Irish Americans and African Americans clashed when they were the two most despised ethnic groups, constructed in similar terms as apelike, rebellious and unfit to self-govern (Jacobsen, Knobel, Ignatiev.)

OsirisservesAnubis · 30/07/2023 18:51

My cleaner is a white man. I could clean my own home, but it's saved so many arguments between me and DH about division of labour that that alone is worth the cost. Dreading having to give it up to be honest.

sewerrat · 30/07/2023 18:38

my cleaners are both eastern European. I am British. does that make me a problem?

Begonne · 30/07/2023 18:38

In the 50s and 60s female Irish immigrants in the US were in high demand as domestic staff because they were white, catholic and therefore seen as trustworthy both with the family silver and husbands.

isthismylifenow · 30/07/2023 18:36

sandgrown · 30/07/2023 18:24

A friend had a job that took her to South Africa. She lived in a gated community and was told she would be expected to employ a black cleaner . The cleaner was well paid and they bought lots of books and toys for her children even though she was useless at cleaning.

I am sorry, but this is utter nonsense.

No one is expected to do anything. People hire help if they want/need to. No one is being forced to hire anyone.

And not everyone has domestic help.

Maybe that is what she told you, seeing as it's not the norm in the UK, and there is possibility of friends/family suggesting having help = being lazy. Which has already been said on this thread.

StarchySturgess1 · 30/07/2023 18:34

I am white British and have a white British cleaner - not out of anything other than she was recommended to me by a friend.

You hand wringing about having someone help out around the house is your own business to deal with, not project it on people who are busy and happen to be able to find the money to pay a cleaner.

Tryingandfailingagain · 30/07/2023 18:29

yabu because in some countries, it is much needed, and well sought after, work. I am guessing your friend is an expat in a developing country?

Her cleaner likely has children to feed.

sandgrown · 30/07/2023 18:24

A friend had a job that took her to South Africa. She lived in a gated community and was told she would be expected to employ a black cleaner . The cleaner was well paid and they bought lots of books and toys for her children even though she was useless at cleaning.

Elvis1956 · 30/07/2023 18:17

I'm a white make gardener who's in his 50s I've worked for black, Indian and gay people it didn't bother me I have always joked I'm one of the "staff" and if I wasn't bald I'd tug my forelock. My wife is a cleaner. She also doesn't mind whom she works for...unless as another poster said they do actually treat you as a lower being, which has happened to both of us.
Employing someone means that they can put food on the table. I'm guessing that you were in South Africa and given the high unemployment levels, increased problems with the infrastructure, then employing a black person is a good thing...as long as they are treated with respect.
I was disgusted the last time I was there with a white couple who were visiting a water park...Ushaka, in Durban...They took their employee clearly to look after the kids but rather than say wear your own clothes she was wearing an overall, clearly to keep her in her place.

isthismylifenow · 30/07/2023 18:16

Yellowlegobrick · 30/07/2023 17:21

We were extremely uncomfortable when we went to south africa and the white owners of our accomodation (one local, one who'd grown up in kenya) were terrifically rude to their (primarily black) staff. Especially when they had one white member of staff and they were much more respectful to him.

We spent the holiday going out of our way to be polite to all the staff and tipping them extra.

You get rude people all over the world.

That one person isn't an indication of how the whole country treats other people though.

watersprites · 30/07/2023 18:15

I pay them more than I get paid @Ladyoftheknight how can you afford it then?

BurntWindowcleaner · 30/07/2023 18:13

Fancylike · 30/07/2023 17:59

I’m assuming you donated your salary from your time spent in that much-abused, corrupt system then?

Do you really think that’s some kind of ‘gotcha’?

I was working as a freelance journalist. Or I was until I realised the press is heavily self-censoring and The National was never going to publish unaltered a mild little interview with a Lebanese spoken word poet who described her work as ‘critical of social and religious authorities”, far less an investigation into what happened to former child camel jockeys after the introduction of robots. I made virtually no money from UAE sources during my time there. DH quit his job and we moved back to London. Of all the places I’ve ever lived, it’s the only one of which I have nothing good to say.

Ladyoftheknight · 30/07/2023 18:04

Our cleaner is black(English), nanny is white (not English). Their skin colour doesn't affect or dictate their career choices. The social view of these jobs being like servant roles is outdated, I pay them more than I get paid and they both have multple benefits alongside their salaries. I also think their careers are more meaningful than mine. They're not slaves and it's not demeaning

Fancylike · 30/07/2023 17:59

BurntWindowcleaner · 30/07/2023 17:20

I used to live there too, in Abu Dhabi and Dubai. The UAE deserves the vast majority of the criticism it gets. And while obviously it’s good that you treat your domestic help with respect and pay them above the (low) market rate, you’re still participating in a much-abused, corrupt system, whose supposed reforms are tokenistic and largely unenforced. That you also regard yourself as in the same system, just at a higher market value, doesn’t make it ok.

I’m assuming you donated your salary from your time spent in that much-abused, corrupt system then?

watersprites · 30/07/2023 17:22

The UK doesn’t feel like this at all, even if certain jobs are dominated by immigrants.

I would argue a lot of cleaners in the UK are immigrants

Yellowlegobrick · 30/07/2023 17:21

We were extremely uncomfortable when we went to south africa and the white owners of our accomodation (one local, one who'd grown up in kenya) were terrifically rude to their (primarily black) staff. Especially when they had one white member of staff and they were much more respectful to him.

We spent the holiday going out of our way to be polite to all the staff and tipping them extra.

BurntWindowcleaner · 30/07/2023 17:20

Borracha · 30/07/2023 17:05

I live in the much maligned UAE. I have a Filipina nanny, a Filipina cleaner, an Indian guy who does our ironing, a Nepalese pool guy and a Pakistani gardener.

I pay them all above the market rate. They receive all the benefits they are entitled to, and more. (For example, I ‘upgraded’ the standard health insurance usually offered to domestic worker, so they don’t have to pay extra for things like dental care) When I receive my annual bonus from work, they get a slice of it as well - my feeling being that without their hard work, I wouldn’t be able to spend as much time at work.

They are all treated with respect in our home (eg I ask them to call me by my name and not ‘mam’ or ‘miss’, my children absolutely know they deserve respect and are immediately told off if they forgot a ‘please’ or ‘thank you.’

I am immensely grateful for their work and my home would not run smoothly without them.

Ultimately, we all came here for the same thing - to earn better money than we would in our home countries. Just as I work and get paid for it, so do they.

I’m sure I’ll get slaughtered for this post though. Because I live in Dubai, I must be a racist, spoiled, nouveau riche chav who hates human rights and gender equality

I used to live there too, in Abu Dhabi and Dubai. The UAE deserves the vast majority of the criticism it gets. And while obviously it’s good that you treat your domestic help with respect and pay them above the (low) market rate, you’re still participating in a much-abused, corrupt system, whose supposed reforms are tokenistic and largely unenforced. That you also regard yourself as in the same system, just at a higher market value, doesn’t make it ok.

Borracha · 30/07/2023 17:05

I live in the much maligned UAE. I have a Filipina nanny, a Filipina cleaner, an Indian guy who does our ironing, a Nepalese pool guy and a Pakistani gardener.

I pay them all above the market rate. They receive all the benefits they are entitled to, and more. (For example, I ‘upgraded’ the standard health insurance usually offered to domestic worker, so they don’t have to pay extra for things like dental care) When I receive my annual bonus from work, they get a slice of it as well - my feeling being that without their hard work, I wouldn’t be able to spend as much time at work.

They are all treated with respect in our home (eg I ask them to call me by my name and not ‘mam’ or ‘miss’, my children absolutely know they deserve respect and are immediately told off if they forgot a ‘please’ or ‘thank you.’

I am immensely grateful for their work and my home would not run smoothly without them.

Ultimately, we all came here for the same thing - to earn better money than we would in our home countries. Just as I work and get paid for it, so do they.

I’m sure I’ll get slaughtered for this post though. Because I live in Dubai, I must be a racist, spoiled, nouveau riche chav who hates human rights and gender equality

Middlelanehogger · 30/07/2023 16:59

In regards to carers from Africa, this is due to the government adding a special visa scheme for skilled care workers during the pandemic which is still in place today.

People in places like Zimbabwe see it as a route into the UK which requires fairly attainable skills (you can train through the Red Cross, etc, it doesn't take years of advanced qualifications, and you don't need expensive equipment that isn't available in poor countries).

Example https://www.thezimbabwenewslive.com/boon-for-zimbabweans-as-uk-relaxes-visa-rules-for-foreign-care-workers/

Boon for Zimbabweans as UK relaxes visa rules for foreign care workers - theZimbabweNewsLive

LONDON – Care staff will be added to the Government’s official shortages list in order to allow foreign workers easier access to the UK. There has been a

https://www.thezimbabwenewslive.com/boon-for-zimbabweans-as-uk-relaxes-visa-rules-for-foreign-care-workers

Okaaaay · 30/07/2023 16:42

I have a Hispanic cleaner (previous two cleaners were white). I pay her £16 per hour and she is wonderful. I try to be respectful of her in every way (tidy before she comes, chat to her, buy small gifts I know she’ll like - she does the latter for me too) - she wants a better life (and will get there) but needs to earn money whilst she works to it. I employ her service as I work FT, have two small children, a big house and a lazy husband. I can’t do it all. Somethings I feel awkward but ultimately get over it.

Roselilly36 · 30/07/2023 16:41

South Arica?

cuckyplunt · 30/07/2023 16:39

I do a professional job, my cleaner does a professional job, what’s the issue?

imnotthatkindofmum · 30/07/2023 16:37

My sister is my cleaner. It's just her job. It fits round her kids and it suits me. I don't think if it as her being "beneath" me or menial. Obviously there's no race issue either.

She also means for others and has a great time chatting and drinking coffee (and cleaning obviously). I don't think any of her clients treat her like the hired help tbh.

Namechange828492 · 30/07/2023 16:28

My nanny is white British, I pay £250 per day so she's not bring paid menial wages! Being a nanny is a proper profession.

My cleaners have all been white British, I live in London. One was with me for 15 years and was a personal recommendation and the last 2 came from an agency.