Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who have cleaners, nanny's etc

110 replies

W0MENclimb · 30/07/2023 13:52

I am happy for you to tell me iabu. I'm just trying to understand it. Just stayed at a friend's in another country where it's normal for white people to have cleaner, nanny etc and they are all black.
I felt so uncomfortable with it, I'd hate someone doing menial tasks for me, the fact that they are black felt worse for me.

I realise that some people think that they are doing them a favour because they need work but it just feels wrong to me. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
YaraRocks · 31/07/2023 19:14

Goldenbear · 31/07/2023 09:28

Tube Drivers are paid on average £55,000 a year and it is not comparable to cleaning a person or families mess up. It is disingenuous to say that it is. Given the chance, would a cleaner rather be a tube driver on £55,000 or clean a families toilet, I would say that many would prefer the former! It is nothing to do with men's and women"s work, driving a train is infinitely more interesting, not as laborious and is necessary for the infrastructure of the economy, unlike a cleaner for one house where ultimately anyone can clean, Surgeon, Stock Broker, Banker - who does it or doesn't do it has no impact on the economy in any way whatsoever. Arguably, it is good for people to be humbled by cleaning their own crap up, reminding them of their equal status to fellow human beings in society!

In the scenario the OP describes on particular, there is a power balance going on in a large number of house cleaner/employer scenarios that is not so weighted in one person's favour when someone works for a cafe for example or an organisation.

Not the point of your post but FYI, tube drivers earn closer to £65K now than £55k 🙂

Goldenbear · 31/07/2023 09:28

AuntieJune · 30/07/2023 19:35

Get over yourself. Inequality doesn't stop existing just because you don't bring people into your house to do domestic work.

You still live in a world where factory workers, cleaners, bus drivers, etc etc are working class and disproportionately from ethnic minorities. If you're middle class, you have the privilege of benefitting from their work. Even if they're not in your house.

Next time you get a tube in London to your office and have a takeaway coffee on the way - there's a whole chain of people whose labour makes that possible.

If people do cleaning, childcare etc and are treated well and paid well - why is that a problem?

Tube Drivers are paid on average £55,000 a year and it is not comparable to cleaning a person or families mess up. It is disingenuous to say that it is. Given the chance, would a cleaner rather be a tube driver on £55,000 or clean a families toilet, I would say that many would prefer the former! It is nothing to do with men's and women"s work, driving a train is infinitely more interesting, not as laborious and is necessary for the infrastructure of the economy, unlike a cleaner for one house where ultimately anyone can clean, Surgeon, Stock Broker, Banker - who does it or doesn't do it has no impact on the economy in any way whatsoever. Arguably, it is good for people to be humbled by cleaning their own crap up, reminding them of their equal status to fellow human beings in society!

In the scenario the OP describes on particular, there is a power balance going on in a large number of house cleaner/employer scenarios that is not so weighted in one person's favour when someone works for a cafe for example or an organisation.

PeloMom · 30/07/2023 23:32

@ladyvivienne yes! She has a key to the house and does some deep clean etc that doesn’t get done during normal cleaning (we travel quite a bit so it’s not a matter of giving her a 3-4 weeks off).
during normal holiday such as Xmas etc she gets paid but doesn’t work and gets a bonus (bonus is at Xmas only though and some rare life events such as her kids graduating etc)

Flandango · 30/07/2023 22:05

ladyvivienne · 30/07/2023 20:17

When you go on holiday, do you all still pay your cleaner?

Yes, I pay my cleaner PAYE and have an employment contract that covers holiday, sickness, etc.

astarsheis · 30/07/2023 20:54

I have lived in four different countries where we had cleaners, nannies and drivers. We were not allowed to drive in two of them (company directive) and always had cleaners/nannies. Again...the company insisted on us employing them as it was part of job creation (their salaries were part of our expat package). All this countries had plenty of local people that also employed multiple staff. In Asian, African and ME countries it is very much the norm.

It enabled me to have maximum time for all the visitors, like you, when did come to visit and also to work full-time when I went back to work. My DC and us have always become quite close to our 'helpers' and we are still in touch with some of then now.

Back in the UK now and employ a cleaner. Why wouldn't I? I can afford it.
She is quite happy to get paid to do the 'menial' tasks that we can't be bothered or don't have the time to do.

No exploitation at any time!

Get your head out of you arse!

user1471453601 · 30/07/2023 20:30

I have a cleaner. I think of her as no different to me, when I was working. We both swapped our Labour for money, that's the capitalist way, for good or for bad.

her Labour is no more "demeaning" than mine was. It's a transaction .

Yes, I'd feel uncomfortable in a country where all the domestic carers were one colour, and all "other" workers were another. If "domestic" care was seen as less valuable than other work.

isthismylifenow · 30/07/2023 20:24

ladyvivienne · 30/07/2023 20:17

When you go on holiday, do you all still pay your cleaner?

Yes of course. And she has annual leave as well for which she gets paid fully, plus double pay for December.

Lira715 · 30/07/2023 20:21

I used to live in Dubai and it’s very common to have a live in nanny.. our villa had an en suite “ maids room” designed for that purpose. I couldn’t stand the thought of having someone live there and wanted to raise my child myself .. the room had no windows and was at the back with the garage and laundry I’d have felt guilty to expect her to spend her time off in there, the rates of pay are very low too and they are expected to clean cook and look after the children in most cases.. villa also had 2 kitchens so staff cook in one and the other is for show when entertaining .. l loved that idea, although It was me cooking and being able to leave the mess until later. I did have a cleaner though and have continued with that since moving back to the uk.

Fancylike · 30/07/2023 20:20

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

Yellowflower47 · 30/07/2023 20:20

ladyvivienne · 30/07/2023 20:17

When you go on holiday, do you all still pay your cleaner?

I just give mine a key and she lets herself in, so cleans when I’m on holiday (usually 4-5 times a year). It’s nice to come back to a clean house and fresh bedding!

ladyvivienne · 30/07/2023 20:17

When you go on holiday, do you all still pay your cleaner?

gogomoto · 30/07/2023 20:15

In the countries you talk about it's normal to employ household staff whatever your nationality. I have Pakistani friends who have a staff of 10 to run their home in Pakistan, she's a dr he's a professor

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 30/07/2023 20:13

I think the Uk should relax their live in domestic help visa laws, if they could give short term one year contracts in the same way they do to seasonal contracts for fruit pickers etc, and people could have a live in nanny or cleaner that wouldn't stay so long that they could potentially be a cost to Uk resources and would have a home living in so wouldn't put more pressure on housing, they could earn a lot in a year and take money back home, and we could have more affordable au pair style childcare to help women back into work. Would be a great system.

SlippySarah · 30/07/2023 20:12

Chocolate23 · 30/07/2023 19:26

No time, she's on the dole 🤣🤣

The majority of benefit claimants in the UK also work, often full time. Lazy stereotype.

PeloMom · 30/07/2023 20:10

My cleaner now is Hispanic but I’ve had white in the past too. For me it is about who’d do the best job (eg recommended by friends etc) and who is reliable/ trustworthy. Whether they have certain skin, hair, eye colour- it’s not part of the decision whether I’d hire them or not.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 30/07/2023 20:08

Is the country you visited majority black eg and African or Caribbean country? In that case the majority of all workers would be black.

My friends used to live in an African country and paid a cleaner that came every day £150 a month. I was appalled by how low that is, but they said it's such a high wage in that country people were saying they over paid her and the cleaner employed her own cleaner and also help for her daughter's baby on this wage- she would have much rather worked for my friends family (one white one not) than for a local family. I felt a lot more concern for the cleaners cleaner than the cleaner if that makes sense!

I don't know what point you can be making other than 'you should clean up your own stuff' - not everyone wants to do this. Just like not everyone wants to cook for themselves so they go to restaurants/get take away, or wax their own legs so they go to a salon. It's a free world. As long as people aren't being exploited and they are paid a wage where they can have a decent standard of living and they have opportunities to get jobs other than cleaning via studying or training, if they want to.

Newmum110 · 30/07/2023 20:00

My cleaner earns a higher hourly wage than me.
Am I happy to pay this & do I think she deserves it? Yes
Is she a different race & nationality to me? Yes
Is she exploited? Definitely not

sadaboutmycat · 30/07/2023 19:57

Totally off thread, but just wanted to use a 'teachable' moment (as an Ofsted Inspector once said to me!)
You put an s on the end of cleaners as you referred to the plural cleaners. All correct.
When you wanted to pluralise the word nanny, you put an inappropriate apostrophe in before the s. Plurals do not need an apostrophe. Commonly the plural of a word ending in y is to use ies as in family, families. But that's not my point!
No apostrophe in a plural.
(I'm not having a go, genuinely, just using a teachable moment!)
I'll get my coat... 😏😊

Flandango · 30/07/2023 19:51

I live in SE London. My cleaner is from SE London. She is also the same ethnicity as me. Is that acceptable to @W0MENclimb ?

poorlyarm · 30/07/2023 19:47

Sorry posted early. We went to Barbados on Holliday and it was a really clear divide between the wealthy white people and the local people who did all the cooking / cleaning etc. I did find that weird.

poorlyarm · 30/07/2023 19:46

I have a white cleaner. She's paid pretty well so don't see the problem.

We went

MarySmit · 30/07/2023 19:38

What a strange thread. I have a cleaner. She is well paid, and works flexibly around her children. She is Eastern European (white). I don't see why skin colour matters.

AuntieJune · 30/07/2023 19:35

Get over yourself. Inequality doesn't stop existing just because you don't bring people into your house to do domestic work.

You still live in a world where factory workers, cleaners, bus drivers, etc etc are working class and disproportionately from ethnic minorities. If you're middle class, you have the privilege of benefitting from their work. Even if they're not in your house.

Next time you get a tube in London to your office and have a takeaway coffee on the way - there's a whole chain of people whose labour makes that possible.

If people do cleaning, childcare etc and are treated well and paid well - why is that a problem?

Chocolate23 · 30/07/2023 19:26

NewName122 · 30/07/2023 13:57

My black friend who is on benefits has a white cleaner. Single parent with kids and said she would rather give someone £30 a week then do it herself when she has no time.

No time, she's on the dole 🤣🤣

MsNorris · 30/07/2023 19:24

I expect I live in the country you refer to. I employ a nanny, she is brilliant and my kids love her to bits. She has a contract, at least 6/7 weeks holiday, gets paid over double min wage, interest free loans and is very happy working for us, She’s been here for 10 years and although my kids are older now, we’ll keep employing her until she is ready to retire as she is unlikely to get another job at her age - mid 50s. When she had Covid we paid for her to get tested and meds for her whole family. During lockdown we paid her full salary for over 5 months when she didn’t work (most people paid nothing).

If she quit tomorrow and got a nice office job on triple her salary I’d be so happy for her, but in a country with 40% unemployment I think that’s highly unlikely.