Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset by DB texts?

94 replies

WeeksintheSun · 30/07/2023 09:35

I have a half brother that is 10 years my senior. He is nearly 60 years old.
We have never been really close due to the age gap. He lives 3 hours away and I live close to our Mother. My parents are divorced and my brother doesn’t have a relationship with my Dad although they are civil.
My DB has had a troubled past and is a difficult person to be around. He moved away some years ago and is settled with his wife. He is very opinionated and likes to dictate what others should do. He is loud and feels he is always right. He doesn’t listen. As he has gotten older he is fixated on his health and is always ill and has numerous ailments. zHe has been aggressive in the past.
He visits our Mother sometimes and I use to go to her house to see him but I struggle with his personality and I don’t feel comfortable in his company. He has been very rude and disrespectful in the past. I moved into a new home a few years ago and he came to visit our Mother. He was bringing her to my house and I thought he would come in and pay some interest in our new home but he dropped her off outside and drove off without as much as a ‘hello’. His niece wanted to call him to thank him for his gift and when he answered the phone he shouted “what do you want!” thinking it was me. These are just a few examples and he has had me in tears many times. He contacts me in relation to our Mother and vice versa . I used to send him pictures of his Neice but stopped as he doesn’t seem interested and it just fizzled out.
So onto the issue I need advice on..
He will only use one method of communication called Signal as he doesn’t trust WhatsApp etc. I have a new phone and didn’t download it as I only use Signal for his messages. I did try to download but I couldn’t remember the password. Mother hurt her ankle but it wasn’t serious. I got a text from my brother which read:
Why didn’t you tell me you no longer use signal. If you don’t want to receive anything then I can quite happily accommodate you. We only communicate in the barest sense of the word over our mother anyway, so if it’s all too much of an effort, then I suggest you go the whole hog and don’t bother me again.
I asked if he was okay? He replied:
Don’t attempt to defuse a situation by invoking some form of problem, hormonal, physical or otherwise. Noting wrong whatsoever apart from jumping through hoops to secure the most basic information. You’ve had that phone how long? Being a mother of one child doesnt preclude you from polite social interactions. I ask for the barest of information from you. You just gone beyond the line in the sand for the umpteenth time and sooner or later this was going to be the result. I suggest we communicate through our mother while she is still here.
This was a few weeks ago and I decided not to reply as I was upset and didn’t want to do anything rash. I also don’t want to upset Mum. It was my birthday last week and I didn’t get the usual card and text.
I am thinking of ignoring it and carrying on a normal, sending cards and birthday/Christmas wishes and just communicating about Mum when it’s really necessary.
Any advice please?

OP posts:
Cantuserealname · 30/07/2023 11:48

Dombasle · 30/07/2023 10:06

He's a pompous old git.

What's being old got to do with anything? You can be a pompous git at any age. Less of the ageism please.

WeeksintheSun · 30/07/2023 11:43

I don’t know if he felt like he had a difficult childhood. I wasn’t there and am 10 years younger. I have never treated him any differently to they way I treat anyone else. I don’t treat him badly because he has made some mistakes. We were never close because of the age gap. I tried to get into Signal a few times but wanted to recover the original account. I struggled to do this because I needed the information from my old phone. I am a bit of tech phobe. I didn’t mean to be condescending in my message but yes, I maybe we passive aggressive. I am that way with him as I feel I need to be careful what I say as he can fly off the handle and start shouting and yelling. So yes, I am always trying to tread carefully.

OP posts:
nonevernotever · 30/07/2023 11:40

Not really relevant to this, but just to be aware in relation to your father. You haven't said where you are in the UK (and I don't think you should here because I don't want to derail) but if you're in Scotland and your dad legally adopted your brother, then your brother would be automatically entitled to a share of any money etc on your dad's death, whatever is in the will and whether or not your brother changed his name. (It's called prior rights IIRC)

cansu · 30/07/2023 11:40

Just tell him that you are sorry you didn't let him know about Signal but you are no longer going to use it. Tell him that if he needs to contact you he can text or phone. That would be it. Don't get involved in an argument or get sucked into the drama or unpleasantness.

WeeksintheSun · 30/07/2023 11:34

He is a massive bully and always has been. He dictates to you rather than discussing anything. He doesn’t want to be bothered with my life and tells me so. It’s just ‘white noise’ to him. I agree that whatever I say in retaliation will fall on deaf ears and will just end up being my fault. I just feel that, after all these years of unacceptable behaviour, he needs to know what an unpleasant person he is. I realise why my DH told me not to react. I just want to hurt him for all the times he has hurt me but that’s not going to help is it.

OP posts:
Sparkletastic · 30/07/2023 11:30

Sounds like he might have a personality disorder but that's not your problem.

I'd text:

'I no longer use Signal. You can contact me via text in the event of an emergency.'

Then ignore him.

Aprilx · 30/07/2023 11:29

Your brother does sound difficult, but maybe he had a difficult childhood and felt pushed out when you came along, I don't know, but there could be a relevant his side of the story here.

You stopped using the messaging system that you used with him without telling him and are making stupid excused about passwords when we all know passwords are very easy to reset. Your response when he mentioned it "Are you ok?" was passive aggressive and condescending and I don't think you really were concerned to know if he was ok, I am not surprised it annoyed him, sounds like that is exactly what you wanted.

Anyway the two of you don't seem to get on, so why not cut out or reduce your contact.

AsMyGranWouldSay · 30/07/2023 11:24

The only way to deal with conflictual people like him is to have firm, consistent boundaries and to refuse to engage in combat.

He's not self-aware enough, it's pointless trying to get through to him or explain things, he'll just turn it around on you.

Be factual and polite (but not to excess) in every interaction and keep your feelings safely out of his reach.

You don't owe him anything, it's not your fault he had a troubled life. And no-one is doing him any favours by playing by his rules.

Purplecatshopaholic · 30/07/2023 11:20

If it was me, I wouldn’t officially ‘cut him off’ as such I just wouldn’t contact him. He can text you if he wants to - this Signal app is just something controlling, and to moan about by the sound of it. He sounds unpleasant and life’s too short to put up with that shit, brother or not. Just disengage.

itsmylife7 · 30/07/2023 11:20

OP your awful brother is a bully, a massive BULLY to you and your Mum.

You don't need to download anything on YOUR phone that you're not comfortable with.

So you're 50ish then and still being bullied.
This horrible person brings nothing to your life, does he. ?

I've not read any replies on here but will assume people are making excuses for his behaviour ?
If so ignore them OP.

WeeksintheSun · 30/07/2023 11:19

My Mum doesn’t have anything to leave in a Will. She has no money and doesn’t own property. She has requested no funeral and her ashes are to be returned to me. However, my DF does have money and he wasn’t going to leave my DB anything. He did adopt him but my DB changed his name legally to my DM maiden name. He asked my my advice and I told him to think about it and do what he felt was right. He decided to leave him something in his Will. He also elected for no funeral so the likelihood that I will ever see him again is slim.

OP posts:
WeeksintheSun · 30/07/2023 11:12

He has had a difficult childhood but most of us have. He didn’t know his Dad in an era that wasn’t forgiving of this. He live with DM and DG and he was loved. DM met my DD and he adopted him but they were at loggerheads mainly because my DB got into a lot of trouble. He made bad decisions and never owned them. His GF left him with their child because of his behaviour and moved out of town so he went through a lengthy battle for custody. He eventually got this but ended up having a fight in front of his DD with his GFs new partner. He decided to stop seeing her. He has never worked apart from 1 job but he got into trouble with another member of staff me he ended up leaving. He worked for a family member once but said he ripped him off and so our families don’t speak now. Mum has always made excuses for him. I know he has some issues. That’s obvious but how long can you keep making excuses for him. He has never acknowledged his difficulties or tried to help himself. I am nearly 50 now and it’s time to think about me and the people I want in my life.

OP posts:
Jifmicroliquid · 30/07/2023 11:09

I would reply -
“Use text messages like everyone else and stop making a mountain out of a mole hill. I couldn’t download Signal, and I apologise for not letting you know, but why didn’t you just text me? I haven’t got the energy for constant drama over nothing so I think it’s best we have a break from communicating with each other for a while.”

Then cut him out of your life, he sounds like an idiot.

Hawkins0001 · 30/07/2023 11:04

DontLetMeKeepYou · 30/07/2023 10:08

Yes, if he’s texting you, why is Signal vs WhatsApp an issue?

Some people perceive signal as more privacy than whatsapp. Personally I believe no communication system is secure vs intelligence services,
That said some do think there is a difference.

determinedtomakethiswork · 30/07/2023 11:03

Can you make sure that you are down as your mother is power-of-attorney and executor? This guy is going to cause mayhem at that point. As far as cards are concerned, I would send them to any children he has or his wife but I wouldn't send them to him.

InSpainTheRain · 30/07/2023 11:03

I'd have blocked him years ago on text, calls and anything else. He sounds awful. If you see him at a family gathering I'd do a quick hi if necessary and ignore him whenever possible. You don't need to keep in communication with him so get rid.

DontLetMeKeepYou · 30/07/2023 11:01

CherryMaDeara · 30/07/2023 10:58

But he doesn’t just contact via Signal, it’s clear he does text people because he texted you.

I bet this is another form of control - making you contact him by his approved means.

I bet he texts other people like his wife and has telephone banking.

Take back control and tell him you no longer have Signal but he can text you, as he has done so.

Yes, my point up the thread was that if he texts you and your mother, he’s clearly able to use other forms of comms other than Signal. I also have a friend who uses Signal and won’t use WhatsApp — I tell him I’m not downloading an app just for him, so he texts or actually phones if he wants to get in touch.

Also, he sounds awful. I wouldn’t be putting myself out to communicate with him. Just let him bluster on to himself via whatever form of communication he prefers. You don’t have to engage.

CherryMaDeara · 30/07/2023 11:01

If he stops sending you birthday and xmas cards, will you keep sending thrm to him? I think that’s madness.

WeeksintheSun · 30/07/2023 10:59

I am very grateful for your advice and replies.
I am nervous about cutting ties. My Mum always told me not to do anything I may regret later in life. My husband knows how difficult my DB is. He said that he would ignore the messages and he would just carry on as normal, sending birthday cards etc. to be honest, our relationship is not any more than this anyway. I guess it was inevitable once he moved away.
I think differently to my DH and feel like I can’t rest until I have acknowledged him and got my feelings off my chest. Nothing rude, just that I appreciate his frustration but that I have a boundary and that he has crossed it. Or do you think it’s all just a waste of time. I am so confused as I don’t want a relationship with him as he is and he won’t change as he sees nothing wrong. I just don’t want to get older and regret things. My DM doesn’t speak to her sister and I know this plays on her mind.

OP posts:
TaigaSno · 30/07/2023 10:58

He sounds rude and annoying, but I also suspect there is a lot more to his story than the side you've given here.

He's obviously had a very difficult childhood, I wonder whether he was rejected by a parent or/and step-parent and then you, ten years younger, was the golden child. He probably had other struggles in life that you don't know about. Anyway, that doesn't excuse his rudeness, but may give an insight into his anger.

You only communicated through one method, you stopped using that method without telling him. You struggled with a password but you could have reset that, or sent a message through your mum. Because of this, when your mother hurt herself he didn't hear about it presumably until afterwards, which must have upset him.

Do you want to have a relationship with him? If you don't, then he's set things in place for you to not need to contact him again. Being related to someone doesn't put you under any obligation to be in touch with them. You have the opportunity now to drop him completely.

You say you will still send him cards and messages though so perhaps you do want some level of relationship? In which case, you should send out what you want to, but must expect nothing in return, otherwise I suspect you will be disappointed. Only communicate when you want to, never out of obligation.

I think it may be a good idea to let him communicate directly with your mother if that's possible, never through you. It can be difficult for a sibling when another sibling becomes the "gatekeeper" of an elderly parent's communication.

CherryMaDeara · 30/07/2023 10:58

But he doesn’t just contact via Signal, it’s clear he does text people because he texted you.

I bet this is another form of control - making you contact him by his approved means.

I bet he texts other people like his wife and has telephone banking.

Take back control and tell him you no longer have Signal but he can text you, as he has done so.

mbosnz · 30/07/2023 10:58

I'd ignore him.

For one thing, it will really do his head in.

zingally · 30/07/2023 10:54

Just ignore his diatribe. People like him thrive on drama and want an emotional tug-o-war with everyone. Just... drop your end of the rope, and leave him to steam and bubble over, like the over-emotional little teapot he is.

As he's text you, he's clearly able to use the medium, so continue to text him about mum-related issues as required.

If he asks "why don't you have Signal?" Just reply with "I prefer not to." No need to engage.

kweeble · 30/07/2023 10:52

I would stop trying to have a relationship with him.