Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU with BF about finances?

108 replies

notagolddigger · 30/07/2023 09:04

Boyfriend & I do not live together and have no shared expenses. Both BF and I are on salary and paid bimonthly on the opposite weeks, I earn slightly more than BF per annum (£2,000 potentially rising to £4,000 in September). Both BF and I have no fixed expenses individually and are very lucky financially.

As a student (graduated last May), I was really poor and frugal with my money. Last September I landed my “big girl” job and decided I would have a year of guilt free spending without saving (besides a rainy day/emergency fund) and have enjoyed every minute of it.

BF and I went abroad earlier this year and he was very frugal with his money while I was buying things I wanted. He complained about the cost of alcohol (EU city) while I didn’t look at the price with much concern - we were on holiday and budgeted appropriately! Throughout the holiday, he kept checking in and asking how my finances were - we both showed our bank accounts to each other as well as setting up a shared fault on Revolut - and we were honestly more than fine.

So, we are also going on a sun holiday next month and BF is financially stressed. I was very surprised to hear he felt this way, and when I asked why he said he feels he will be okay but is nervous about me!

He once again asked how my finances were and I reassured him they were fine because they are. I asked why he felt nervous and he said I’ve made a lot of big purchases lately - I explained they were budgeted for - and not included in my current finances. To clarify, I don’t make any silly purchases and I don’t go all out on 5 star resorts when I go abroad, but I like to make sure I eat good and dress nice. My recent big purchases were Coldplay tickets as a present for my mum and money towards obtaining drivers license.

BF is from a wealthy family and has more money than I despite me having a higher salary (inherited wealth) but I have never asked BF for money and since we became a couple and we always split things 50/50 or rotate who pays.

BF & I aren’t together a full year yet and the whole talk about money and finances is really starting to suck the fun out of things. I hate having to prove I have money also just because I like to spend money here and there. I’ve spoke about this with my BF and he just disregards it.

AIBU to feel annoyed? I don’t know what to do.

OP posts:
notagolddigger · 30/07/2023 12:54

ChesterAndRaoul · 30/07/2023 12:36

I don't know about all these financially controlling, get rid comments.

If the man is wealthy and 30 years old, it's highly likely that he's been in a relationship in the past where it has fallen apart because he was oblivious to the partners financial status.
Maybe he is just going a bit OTT trying to make sure you are not spending beyond your means just to 'keep up', especially in the current climate.

Only you can know what his motives are, but from what you've explained, and as you are still planning things together that are not necessary spends and the one thing he's actually said no to was something he wanted to do rather than you, he just sounds concerned rather than controlling.

To clarify his family are wealthy, he’s not wealthy - but they do support him financially and allow him to live bill free. He inherited the house from his grandfather but the parents land is actually being split between the two eldest brothers rather my BF. He will inherit some money along with his sister but that’s all that’s been discussed.

His previous relationship was with someone in their early twenties and they lived together but never went abroad or travelled. I think he paid more than she did because he tends to tell people I’m great for paying my own way “unlike the other one”…

I don’t know what his motives are honestly, it makes no sense for him to be this pressed as I am completely transparent with him about everything! I just hate being asked about my own finances as I do feel it’s a personal topic but also my own business.

OP posts:
notagolddigger · 30/07/2023 12:48

Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 12:21

Yes. I see it as a sign he is seriously considering the future, which is good.

OP you may need to have gentle discussions with him to work out what income and expenditure levels he plans for himself in the future.

Ooh - a horrible thought. Maybe he wants you secure so you can provide him with the security net his parents are currently offering?

There’s times where we split the bill and he looks to actually divide what we had instead of splitting it down the middle which I always found odd. Even with friends, we all agree to split down the middle rather divide what everyone had unless someone’s been on the wine a bit more! BF & I typically don’t drink while out for meals as he drives and I would fall asleep at the table if I mixed a meal with alcohol so our bills are never really an issue. Again, not completely abnormal, but just a little odd. If we’re in the shop and picking up little things say gum or water (things under £2), I usually always pay for my own because he doesn’t offer, so I’ve stopped offering to pay for his little things in shops too!

BF is ahead of me career wise due to age difference and once he secures a job in his field will be on double my salary. I will return to uni to complete my masters and enter the career I initially wanted to, but I really need some time to just live and be in my 20s instead of grinding 25/8 first! BF knows & understands this, and agrees I’ve all the time in the world to go back to uni - probably because his 20s have been spent in and out of courses.

BF’s aware his salary will always be higher than my own but said he prefers this as he wants to be the main breadwinner. We have had general conversations on joint bank accounts and agreed they’re necessary for shared expenses i.e. mortgage (the he doesn’t want), bills etc., but to still have individual accounts and separate savings unless kids were in the equation. Financially, we are really on the same wavelength about our expectations or at least I think!

However, he knows I am a saver as I encouraged him to start saving. He knows about how I put myself through university and how I did it, it’s not exactly news to him! While we weren’t together during my uni years, we did get together when we both lived in the same city and were completely independent and had no parental involvement whatsoever. As for his parents, personally, I really love them! They’ve been so welcoming and warm towards me and I really get on with all his siblings too. I don’t think he’s necessarily babied but his mother holds a lot of guilt for how she was as a mother when they were kids so is now over compensating.

BF & I discussed travelling together to Asia which is why I will be saving like a storm come September. BF’s brother lives in Dubai and lives a high life on six figures, his wife is a SAHM & I think BF gets a bit envious of it at times. I’ve made BF aware that travelling won’t be cheap & unless we have remote jobs, we more than likely won’t have any steady income if any income at all and won’t be able to freely splash the cash. He seems to understand and is convinced he’ll have a remote job whereas I’m not 100% sure but will be budgeting for that worse case scenario.

BF is adament he doesn’t want to settle here and wants to live abroad. Again, he’s also the same man who speaks about living in a van travelling the world, raising kids in the van, & then spends time talking about how he wishes he was a hunter gatherer. At this point of our relationship, I don’t take any conversations about the future too seriously & wouldn’t bring up moving in together etc., because it is too soon.

Of course, I see him in my future, but I’m not sure where we will be in 5 years as I can’t even tell you where I hope to be individually!

OP posts:
ntmdino · 30/07/2023 12:37

Ooh - a horrible thought. Maybe he wants you secure so you can provide him with the security net his parents are currently offering?

That's a hell of a stretch, particularly given that the assets are being transferred into the sons' names - given the sums already mentioned, and the fact that he already owns the house, it's fairly likely he'll never have to work again if he's careful. And, if he does work, he already has the safety net.

ChesterAndRaoul · 30/07/2023 12:36

I don't know about all these financially controlling, get rid comments.

If the man is wealthy and 30 years old, it's highly likely that he's been in a relationship in the past where it has fallen apart because he was oblivious to the partners financial status.
Maybe he is just going a bit OTT trying to make sure you are not spending beyond your means just to 'keep up', especially in the current climate.

Only you can know what his motives are, but from what you've explained, and as you are still planning things together that are not necessary spends and the one thing he's actually said no to was something he wanted to do rather than you, he just sounds concerned rather than controlling.

Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 12:21

Luckydip1 · 30/07/2023 11:06

If he's thinking of your future relationship he may be concerned you are more of a spender than a saver and if this is the case you may not be compatible.

Yes. I see it as a sign he is seriously considering the future, which is good.

OP you may need to have gentle discussions with him to work out what income and expenditure levels he plans for himself in the future.

Ooh - a horrible thought. Maybe he wants you secure so you can provide him with the security net his parents are currently offering?

Luckydip1 · 30/07/2023 11:06

If he's thinking of your future relationship he may be concerned you are more of a spender than a saver and if this is the case you may not be compatible.

Newyearnewmeow · 30/07/2023 11:06

Firstly OP I think you are bloody amazing.

You worked hard, really hard before Uni and during and you totally deserve to have your splurge year.

BF on the other hand hasn’t had to really work for anything. He’s had everything handed to him on a plate and is very lucky with that.
He’s got a cheek monitoring your spends and lecturing you on what your buying and how much the things cost that you spend your money on.
That would really piss me off.
I think you are financially incompatible and add that to the stifling relationship he has with his parents I don’t think this relationship is ever going to work.

Hereforsummer · 30/07/2023 11:02

I'm very jealous of your year of spending OP. I'm not so convinced by the boyfriend though. I think you need to consider carefully whether you are going to be compatible long term.

NoSquirrels · 30/07/2023 10:57

You sound very sorted with finances, as you’ve budgeted and scrimped to get through uni and work hard. You’ve given yourself this year of spending.

Your BF sounds like he’s never had to scrimp because he comes from money, done loads of courses that have led nowhere and at 30 has a bit of a ‘let’s be fancy free and not tied down’ van-life free spirit type personality, which he’s lucky enough to have been able to indulge because he comes from money.

He’s only known you in spending mode, though. Not scrimping mode. So I can see why he might be concerned. I’m not sure quite why it’s getting your hackles up so much? You said yourself that in September it’ll all change, so for now just say you can definitely afford both the holiday and the activity, and don’t worry about it.

Ultimately I think you’re going to be financially incompatible. It’ll be interesting to see how it shakes out when you’re not having a year of free spending.

Callisto1 · 30/07/2023 10:39

I think he might genuinely be concerned about your finances (even if he has no reason or right to!) because he comes from such a wealthy background. There might also be all sorts of pressures on him from his parents since they are bankrolling him at the ripe age of 30.
I think this should be your main concern. How much would his parents be involved in your life should you stay together. The large amount of money in the family could be nice, it could also be a complete nightmare if they use the to control their son and make him, you and any future kids dance to their tune. Look at the family dynamics before you move in with him or make it more serious.

Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 10:27

Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 10:24

The way to keep generational wealth is to be paranoid about spending it. Frugality will be a core belief for him.

Hard to shift even if you are factually right, and no reflection on you.

Possibly he will feel poor until he has deposit, school fees or even entire house price sitting in the bank.

If you shift it, you may be downgrading his expectations of future life.

Oops - missed that he has a house already!

Maybe he is replaying to you what he hears at home about his own finances?

notagolddigger · 30/07/2023 10:26

PinkFrogss · 30/07/2023 10:15

We’re your tuition fees the usual £9k? If so it’s very impressive you’ve managed to save over £27,000 plus living costs to nearly pay off your student loans by 24.

Yes!

I took a year out and saved almost everything I earned and tried to only live on my tips. I had about £18,000-19,000 saved from a full year of work (but I really worked hard and picked up every extra shift going).

I lived off my tips in my first year of Uni & my actual wages covered my rent. £9000 of my savings covered fees.

For second year, my rent was capped by more than half by the landlord because of the pandemic & he often let us live rent free some months as we did the place up (painted it etc..,) & as my course was fully online and recorded, I got a job working in a local shop and picked up a lot of shifts and then did uni work in the evenings. The remainder of my savings covered fees.

Final year was the toughest year because I was probably the most strapped and decided to take out an £8000 loan to cover the cost of fees as I had maybe £4000 in savings. As I had some savings that I knew I would get by ok for rent but would have to frugal and say no to most things & I decided to leave the shop job in December for the factory shop that paid more but was definitely a depressing job.

I never went abroad on friend holidays in uni, never bought new clothes, I might have ate out maybe every six weeks but always brought a lunch & made my own coffee, never bought new clothes and actually spent time repairing old things instead of buying new ones, and if I went out I would make sure I drank before & limit myself to 2/3 drinks out (all hail student deals)

OP posts:
Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 10:24

notagolddigger · 30/07/2023 09:04

Boyfriend & I do not live together and have no shared expenses. Both BF and I are on salary and paid bimonthly on the opposite weeks, I earn slightly more than BF per annum (£2,000 potentially rising to £4,000 in September). Both BF and I have no fixed expenses individually and are very lucky financially.

As a student (graduated last May), I was really poor and frugal with my money. Last September I landed my “big girl” job and decided I would have a year of guilt free spending without saving (besides a rainy day/emergency fund) and have enjoyed every minute of it.

BF and I went abroad earlier this year and he was very frugal with his money while I was buying things I wanted. He complained about the cost of alcohol (EU city) while I didn’t look at the price with much concern - we were on holiday and budgeted appropriately! Throughout the holiday, he kept checking in and asking how my finances were - we both showed our bank accounts to each other as well as setting up a shared fault on Revolut - and we were honestly more than fine.

So, we are also going on a sun holiday next month and BF is financially stressed. I was very surprised to hear he felt this way, and when I asked why he said he feels he will be okay but is nervous about me!

He once again asked how my finances were and I reassured him they were fine because they are. I asked why he felt nervous and he said I’ve made a lot of big purchases lately - I explained they were budgeted for - and not included in my current finances. To clarify, I don’t make any silly purchases and I don’t go all out on 5 star resorts when I go abroad, but I like to make sure I eat good and dress nice. My recent big purchases were Coldplay tickets as a present for my mum and money towards obtaining drivers license.

BF is from a wealthy family and has more money than I despite me having a higher salary (inherited wealth) but I have never asked BF for money and since we became a couple and we always split things 50/50 or rotate who pays.

BF & I aren’t together a full year yet and the whole talk about money and finances is really starting to suck the fun out of things. I hate having to prove I have money also just because I like to spend money here and there. I’ve spoke about this with my BF and he just disregards it.

AIBU to feel annoyed? I don’t know what to do.

The way to keep generational wealth is to be paranoid about spending it. Frugality will be a core belief for him.

Hard to shift even if you are factually right, and no reflection on you.

Possibly he will feel poor until he has deposit, school fees or even entire house price sitting in the bank.

If you shift it, you may be downgrading his expectations of future life.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 30/07/2023 10:23

Autumntimeagain · 30/07/2023 09:19

Agree with PP who said it doesn't sound like he's a respectful partner due to his controlling nature.

I mean, who TF does he think he is to feel entitled to question your finances ?? And to ask you to produce 'proof' that you 'have money' ??

Have you ever demanded to see HIS bank statements ?

He also sounds extremely stingy and penny pinching too !

Can you not see the potential 'future' with this man ? Him demanding you account for every single penny you spend ? Of your OWN bloody money ?

How hellish would he be if you were on maternity leave ? Expecting YOU to produce 'proof' that you actually DID need to spend £20 on bloody nappies ?

He'd have you on a bloody pittance, and refuse to spend a damn penny more that 'strictly necessary', wouldn't he ? I'd bet that he'd also 'expect' YOU to then go back to work part time (to reduce any 'childcare' costs), yet he'd still be 'insisting' that you HAD to keep paying YOUR 50% of all bills etc !

Fuck no ! Get yourself a new BF, and dump this controlling miser !

This. It's highly unlikely to change for the better.

Gateappreciation · 30/07/2023 10:23

i’m sorry but you need to tread very carefully here. He’s 30 and his mum cooks for him on a daily basis. He doesn’t have to pay rent/mortgage and bills. He’s done a million college courses and is currently upskilling.

it doesn’t actually sound like he has grown up. He’s not living in the real world. Out of interest, who does his washing and cleaning?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 30/07/2023 10:21

MoveOnTheCards · 30/07/2023 09:11

With no shared financial commitments I would tell him to butt out of my finances. Stop showing him your statements!

You’re a grown up who can manage their own money and it’s up to you how you budget and what you prioritise with your own money.

Brutally though, at less than a year in, if this continued I’d be walking away. It suggests a stingy, financially-controlling future partner. Not good IMO.

This.

Why on earth at this early stage would you be divulging salary and bank account status to him? Stop oversharing, and tell him once and for all to butt out of your finances.

I would reconsider a relationship with someone so patronizing and inappropriate.

TiaraBoo · 30/07/2023 10:20

I think you sound really sensible. Yes you’re spending lots but also saving and got your student loan down. You budget for your holidays, you’re not just randomly spending. Definitely good to make the most of your time while you have no responsibilities.

But your boyfriend- what does he spend his money on? He’s 30 years old and his parents pay for his bills, doing up the house and insurance. He doesn’t need to buy a car. Why does he not have thousands saved? Why is he worrying about you spending? And wanting to look at your bank accounts.
Definitely not one for the long haul, you’d have to justify every penny. And imagine his ‘stress’ when he has to organise and pay his own bills.

notagolddigger · 30/07/2023 10:17

ntmdino · 30/07/2023 10:09

Fair play - that's a great way to create generational wealth!

So...could it be that he's getting unwelcome pressure from his family because they're all about the money, so he's trying to minimise the appearance of spending in order to shut them up?

It's not really the right way to go about it, but it would qualify as a reason - and one that could easily be solved.

As I said, I'm just hypothesising.

BF is the baby. All his siblings are in really high paying jobs bar sister who married wealthy. Parents have funded them all through life & as said tried to buy their love with money. None of them have ever faced any financial pressure and BF dad even makes a joke about how easy they have it being fed with a “gold spoon not silver” - which, they all agree, are thankful for!!

BF has done a million college courses and done nothing with them & that’s not his own fault but purely because they were really niche courses with industries hard to break in to, you can’t just be good but you really have to be the best kind of thing - or you could just know someone (which he doesn’t).

He’s currently upskilling & if he gets a job in his field he will be on twice my salary from Day 1 so he has a lot of potential

OP posts:
PinkFrogss · 30/07/2023 10:15

We’re your tuition fees the usual £9k? If so it’s very impressive you’ve managed to save over £27,000 plus living costs to nearly pay off your student loans by 24.

notagolddigger · 30/07/2023 10:12

PinkFrogss · 30/07/2023 10:06

It sounds like you must have saved a lot prior to uni as well, for your student loan to be under £3,000 now.

And then you say he’s never really had savings before?

It sounds like you both have very different attitudes to money - you’re used to saving, and are now enjoying spending. He’s used to spending and has only just discovered saving.

Maybe he’s expecting you both to love in together and you to contribute sooner than you realise?

Yes! I took a year out between school & uni to work full time so I could save,,and always worked throughout uni. I got a factory job in my last semester that was paid even better than what I’m on now & was able to pick up evening shifts after uni on top of my weekend work and saved saved saved.

He did ask if I wanted to move in & I said no, it was too soon & we could revisit it next year when we have been together a 1 year +++

OP posts:
ntmdino · 30/07/2023 10:09

notagolddigger · 30/07/2023 10:06

No joke. His grandfather brought potato farming to our hometown from Ireland - and employed a lot of the locals in the village. BF’s dad then went onto to inherit it but none of the sons (BF included) wanted to farm so he decided to rent out the land to other local farmers. He buys land every year and rents it out. They turned all profits into more equity and it’s always worked out for them. They had all the land and houses evaluated recently as they’re now transferring some into the sons names & it was in the millions £0,000,000!!!!!!!!!

Fair play - that's a great way to create generational wealth!

So...could it be that he's getting unwelcome pressure from his family because they're all about the money, so he's trying to minimise the appearance of spending in order to shut them up?

It's not really the right way to go about it, but it would qualify as a reason - and one that could easily be solved.

As I said, I'm just hypothesising.

notagolddigger · 30/07/2023 10:06

ntmdino · 30/07/2023 10:02

What's his family history with money?

Speaking personally, we were poor all the way up to my teenage years - my siblings never really knew it, so it never affected them, but it's made me absolutely paranoid about ever being in that situation again. If you looked at my family, though, you'd never know we were ever in that situation.

I'm not saying this is where he's come from, more just illustrating the point that there has to be a reason he's being like this, and getting to the bottom of that reason may well solve the problem.

No joke. His grandfather brought potato farming to our hometown from Ireland - and employed a lot of the locals in the village. BF’s dad then went onto to inherit it but none of the sons (BF included) wanted to farm so he decided to rent out the land to other local farmers. He buys land every year and rents it out. They turned all profits into more equity and it’s always worked out for them. They had all the land and houses evaluated recently as they’re now transferring some into the sons names & it was in the millions £0,000,000!!!!!!!!!

OP posts:
Ohyousillydivvy · 30/07/2023 10:06

Get rid of him as he sounds financially controlling and you're not compatible. Don't show your bank account to anyone you're not married to, it's a massive fraud risk. Change your pins and tighten up your online security details.

PinkFrogss · 30/07/2023 10:06

It sounds like you must have saved a lot prior to uni as well, for your student loan to be under £3,000 now.

And then you say he’s never really had savings before?

It sounds like you both have very different attitudes to money - you’re used to saving, and are now enjoying spending. He’s used to spending and has only just discovered saving.

Maybe he’s expecting you both to love in together and you to contribute sooner than you realise?

TheNineNine · 30/07/2023 10:04

I agree that you need to be financially compatible with someone to have a long term relationship with them but this year is not a standard one for you so it's very hard to tell.

Perhaps he disagrees with you having this year 'off' and doesn't understand it.

It's got nothing to do with him of course, the year of free spending, but maybe he's worried you aren't financially compatible with him.