Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to politely ask FIL to NOT touch me

510 replies

Bluesky5512 · 30/07/2023 07:38

I’ve known FIL for the last 15ish years. He is 75. He has been a thorough gentleman all through. Inlaws live in the US, we visit them every year. MIL passed away a couple of years ago in a sudden accident. Ever since FIL has been visiting us more often and at times staying for 2-3 months at a time. We stuck a friendship during his recent visits. We talk about politics, astronomy (is was a professor) and yoga (my passion). I see him as a father figure and a friend. DH works in a hospital and I work from home. I take FIL out and about with me - grocery, school runs etc

He has been acting weird lately. Pinching my cheeks, Putting his hands on my shoulder, and yesterday on my waist. WTF !! I was totally taken back and he doesn’t seem to realise. He was never a “creep” IYKWIM. But this touchy behaviour is making me very uncomfortable. I don’t know how to tell him to stop without ruining our friendship.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Bluesky5512 · 01/08/2023 11:43

There was another pat on the back yesterday. I was showing FIL and DH something from a website. A specific type of light we were looking for. It was out of stock for months everywhere. The minute DH stepped out of the room, I got a multi pat applaud on my back. What I noticed is it’s NEVER in front of DH. Which kind of throws the dementia thing out of the window.

i don’t know what I’m dealing with TBH. I told DH yesterday. He was semi pissed off with ME - his default reaction always when I expect him to deal with any unreasonableness from his family.
I don’t care. I will continue to back off. After another touching yesterday, I’ve now decided not to involve FIL in any discussions. I will start taking away bits of “friendship” until he realises.

I also had a word with DD today. She doesn’t mind hugs etc. so no problem. I told her she doesn’t HAVE TO put up with it at all. At ANY point if she is feeling uncomfortable, there are ways to stop it without offending anyone.

OP posts:
Bluesky5512 · 01/08/2023 10:45

SusieWicks · 01/08/2023 10:20

i hear you. I think it’s ok to name the elephant in the room and state your boundaries about this. It doesn’t have to ruin a friendship - but if he reacts badly to your boundaries and basic human rights to physical autonomy thats on him and not you. There is a kind way of doing this- simply explaining that it makes you feel uncomfortable when he touches your body without asking first. He probably will respond with a degree of shame or embarrassment and that’s his emotion to process and not yours, so don’t feel obligated to take it on. This doesn’t have to concern your DH directly beyond him being supportive in your own empowered communication here. You have gone above and beyond in showing your love and support here already and you are not obligated to run circles around either DH or FIL. The only reason why you stating your boundaries could compromise the friendship is when either man takes issue with your autonomy, self respect or needs and if that the case it’s his problem and not yours.

Also I’ll respond to the suggestions women made that FIL has dementia- just no. I think oftentimes men start to push boundaries and it’s not to do with decline- it’s a bid for dominance. Let’s not delude ourselves- as a species we are still affected by a degree of male narcissism (which is conditioned and established by patriarchal power structures and not women) and it’s a fools errand to make excuses for boys behaving badly.

We need to dismantle power structures gently and support our sisters in getting free and clear on our rights. Love to all ❤️

thank you very much for this.

OP posts:
Mummy08m · 01/08/2023 10:42

SusieWicks · 01/08/2023 10:20

i hear you. I think it’s ok to name the elephant in the room and state your boundaries about this. It doesn’t have to ruin a friendship - but if he reacts badly to your boundaries and basic human rights to physical autonomy thats on him and not you. There is a kind way of doing this- simply explaining that it makes you feel uncomfortable when he touches your body without asking first. He probably will respond with a degree of shame or embarrassment and that’s his emotion to process and not yours, so don’t feel obligated to take it on. This doesn’t have to concern your DH directly beyond him being supportive in your own empowered communication here. You have gone above and beyond in showing your love and support here already and you are not obligated to run circles around either DH or FIL. The only reason why you stating your boundaries could compromise the friendship is when either man takes issue with your autonomy, self respect or needs and if that the case it’s his problem and not yours.

Also I’ll respond to the suggestions women made that FIL has dementia- just no. I think oftentimes men start to push boundaries and it’s not to do with decline- it’s a bid for dominance. Let’s not delude ourselves- as a species we are still affected by a degree of male narcissism (which is conditioned and established by patriarchal power structures and not women) and it’s a fools errand to make excuses for boys behaving badly.

We need to dismantle power structures gently and support our sisters in getting free and clear on our rights. Love to all ❤️

This is an interesting viewpoint and tbh I think I buy it.

I've admitted already I know very little about dementia - (my grandad had it after a stroke but it wasn't gradual onset, he went from his usual self to very disabled and not recognising anyone overnight, due to the severe stroke). I've tried to read more about it from the links and suggestions on this thread.

My no1 question is, do women tend to show this frisky behaviour during the onset of dementia? If not, is the dementia just removing the inhibition that the man had preventing him from doing what he'd like to do anyway? For example, my dh genuinely has no interest in younger women (he's not got a particularly strong sex drive at all and he really doesn't like touch/hugs etc except with trusted people). So if he were to get dementia, would it be unlikely for him to show this behaviour...? (I'm not actually asking anyone here, just thinking aloud! I will read more about it.)

In any case, if it is dementia and so not fil's "fault", that further reinforces that op's current strategy of not rocking the boat is probably the best one. And hopefully makes it more likely that it is just a phase and some other behaviour might emerge.

SusieWicks · 01/08/2023 10:20

i hear you. I think it’s ok to name the elephant in the room and state your boundaries about this. It doesn’t have to ruin a friendship - but if he reacts badly to your boundaries and basic human rights to physical autonomy thats on him and not you. There is a kind way of doing this- simply explaining that it makes you feel uncomfortable when he touches your body without asking first. He probably will respond with a degree of shame or embarrassment and that’s his emotion to process and not yours, so don’t feel obligated to take it on. This doesn’t have to concern your DH directly beyond him being supportive in your own empowered communication here. You have gone above and beyond in showing your love and support here already and you are not obligated to run circles around either DH or FIL. The only reason why you stating your boundaries could compromise the friendship is when either man takes issue with your autonomy, self respect or needs and if that the case it’s his problem and not yours.

Also I’ll respond to the suggestions women made that FIL has dementia- just no. I think oftentimes men start to push boundaries and it’s not to do with decline- it’s a bid for dominance. Let’s not delude ourselves- as a species we are still affected by a degree of male narcissism (which is conditioned and established by patriarchal power structures and not women) and it’s a fools errand to make excuses for boys behaving badly.

We need to dismantle power structures gently and support our sisters in getting free and clear on our rights. Love to all ❤️

Elfblossom · 01/08/2023 10:12

OP - are you touch avoidant with everyone in your life? Or just FIL?

I am a sensory seeker, my mother (wasn't great one in general) was a sensory avoider - she didn't do hugging or physical comfort, even for her children (though she was more physically affectionate with my brothers who she openly said were her favourite above my sister & me) ...

Not suggesting that anyone should allow being touched in any way that they don't approve of. I totally appreciate that sometime an outwardly 'innocent' word or action doesn't 'feel' innocent ... gut instinct is real.

bemusedmoose · 01/08/2023 08:31

I dont like people touching me either so i get it. Honestly i think he is probably just missing his wife, older couples often have a sort of language with small gestures like touching my granddad would put his hand on my nans shoulder and give her a little squeeze, her face would light up and she would pat his hand and smile. It was their little 'i love you'. You fil probably would reach out and just touch her while chatting and being around her and he might not even realise he is doing it, it becomes a habit. That doesnt mean you have to be ok with it. I would just say to him that you really love him and your time together but you arent the sort of person that likes to be touched so could he not do that. Also make your husband spend some quality time with him and give him a hug - some people cant be without human touch and it makes them feel so alone (not me - i more than happy with zero contact!)

willWillSmithsmith · 01/08/2023 08:04

ShiteRider · 30/07/2023 08:05

I have a family member who nursed a spouse through MND. They said that one of the hardest things was not having someone to hug them. Nothing remotely sexual.

I’m someone who really values human touch, I can’t imagine life without it.

We’re all different. I don’t really like being hugged so it’s not something I’d ever miss. I’m not cold or unfriendly or anything like that but hugs aren’t something I ever crave.

Marmitecrumpetswithalittlecheese · 01/08/2023 02:43

Agree with the infatuation thing, as your friendship has only developed recently. Maybe he feels like you have a 'connection'

WandaWonder · 01/08/2023 02:19

Ask him nicely to stop touching you, you are a grown up you don't need your husband to do anything just keep on asking him to stop

user1492757084 · 01/08/2023 02:09

Would a simple - Oh please don't touch me - at the time, every time, do the trick. If he asks for an explanation say that you are a person who likes their own space.

If that won't fix it than ask your husband to politely ask him to stop touching you as you are not a touchy feely type of person.

Catsmere · 01/08/2023 01:23

ImNotReallySpartacus · 01/08/2023 01:07

Seriously? What medications are known to have 'inability to keep hands off other people' as a side effect?

Or worse, "inability to keep hands off one particular woman" since he's not doing it to anyone else!

ZairWazAnOldLady · 01/08/2023 01:15

If he does it again step on his toes hard.

ImNotReallySpartacus · 01/08/2023 01:07

Chowtime · 30/07/2023 09:22

Dementia, another type of illness, or a side effect of a medication he's on.

Seriously? What medications are known to have 'inability to keep hands off other people' as a side effect?

SequentialAnalyst · 31/07/2023 23:53

@AcrossthePond55 could there be a cultural issue at play here at all? Seeing as you're across the Pond...

Mirabai · 31/07/2023 23:51

Creep or not, he doesn’t do this to others - so why me? and I think my response was enough to tell him I don’t like it.

Of course it wasn’t. He hasn’t even the remotest idea.

AcrossthePond55 · 31/07/2023 23:42

Bluesky5512 · 31/07/2023 22:04

Was he touchy with everyone or just you?

in my case, it’s just me.

You know, I can't really say. I really wasn't around him in large groups of people and he died 3 years after DH and I married. There was only one other DiL and she insisted they spend all holidays with her family so she and BiL weren't really around a lot.

It never 'felt' creepy to me and there was never any touching anywhere near, shall we say, a 'personal area'. It was sort of the same as your FiL, hand on arm/shoulder, back (but not lower), or a round the shoulders quick 'squeeze'. No rubbing or lingering or handsiness. It just felt an intrusion of my personal space. I probably would have felt the same if MiL had done it. I didn't mind a hug or a kiss on the check at arriving or parting, that was within my comfort zone.

OnlineDream · 31/07/2023 23:39

I think we all been taught the good touch and the bad touch. She can sense if it’s a daughter like touch or something different.

Speak with your husband if you have any concerns..

Charley2023 · 31/07/2023 23:28

Touching your waist seems inappropriate to me. Anything apart from a friendly hug given the context is inappropriate when it's coming from FIL. If something feels off it probably is. Unfortunately, the awkwardness cannot be avoided no matter who delivers the message, but tough love is sometimes necessary.

NattyNatashia · 31/07/2023 23:18

If related to dementia as some have suggested then I'd be more forgiving but needs checking out and if you're not comfortable it still needs addressing. If not then I'd be straightforward and say it clearly.

Seeingadistance · 31/07/2023 23:14

Appleofmyeye2023 · 31/07/2023 22:41

🤔or just tell the truth
” I don’t like it when you touch me”

Yes, just telling the truth would be the most straightforward approach, but the OP has stated that this won't work for her, so she is looking to get the message across in another way.

BlueStarfish · 31/07/2023 23:02

I know several people whose eating patterns became completely off. Some stopped cooking and they would buy crisps, pastries, candy and chocolate instead.
One person was always conscious about what she ate and then she started ordering pizza. One week she ate pizza every single day. By itself this isn't weird, a lot of people do it but these people changed the way they ate completely. Food was always important and then it was like their healthy eating principles went out the window. The change was subtle yet noticeable.

timegoingtooquickly · 31/07/2023 22:50

Bluesky5512 · 31/07/2023 21:53

I’m beginning to doubt if this is dementia or depression or both.

There are no other obvious signs of dementia. Although now I remember, the other day he did something quite strange with a routine thing he did for years. (I won’t mention what it is, as it is really outing. Something to do with a hobby). I’ll keep an eye on him and start logging things in a book if I see anything weird again.

My grandad went frisky with his dementia. I know people are saying it's not a sign but it definitely was for him.

I hope you find an answer as whatever it is it's not ok!

Londisc · 31/07/2023 22:44

You don't need 'other signs of dementia' for a change in behaviour to be a sign of dementia. You have known him a long time. He has never made you feel uncomfortable before and now he is out of the blue making you freeze and think wtf? What other signs do you need?

Appleofmyeye2023 · 31/07/2023 22:41

Seeingadistance · 31/07/2023 22:05

Are you a tactile person with others, OP? If you're not (or even if you are), then one way into a conversation about this might be a few comments about how the pandemic restrictions meant that physical contact wasn't allowed and you actually liked that - because you don't like being touched, or you grew to like it, and now prefer not being touched. Then you could refer directly to the recent touching by your FIL and say how you realise you really don't like being touched.

🤔or just tell the truth
” I don’t like it when you touch me”

Appleofmyeye2023 · 31/07/2023 22:40

Bluesky5512 · 31/07/2023 21:29

With infatuation, I’m not some random female - am I ? Im his son’s wife, the mother of his grandchildren. It’s hard to cross that boundary. Isn’t it ?

He was never the creepy kind before.

A lot of folks get stupidly infatuated by unsuitable or ineligible people.
it’s like a sort of addiction.
not saying it’s right

but there again it’s a lot worse to resolve if it’s dementia 🫤