Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to politely ask FIL to NOT touch me

510 replies

Bluesky5512 · 30/07/2023 07:38

I’ve known FIL for the last 15ish years. He is 75. He has been a thorough gentleman all through. Inlaws live in the US, we visit them every year. MIL passed away a couple of years ago in a sudden accident. Ever since FIL has been visiting us more often and at times staying for 2-3 months at a time. We stuck a friendship during his recent visits. We talk about politics, astronomy (is was a professor) and yoga (my passion). I see him as a father figure and a friend. DH works in a hospital and I work from home. I take FIL out and about with me - grocery, school runs etc

He has been acting weird lately. Pinching my cheeks, Putting his hands on my shoulder, and yesterday on my waist. WTF !! I was totally taken back and he doesn’t seem to realise. He was never a “creep” IYKWIM. But this touchy behaviour is making me very uncomfortable. I don’t know how to tell him to stop without ruining our friendship.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Catsmere · 31/07/2023 05:36

SouthLondonMum22 · 30/07/2023 11:43

Except he isn't touching his own son more, he's touching you. Just you. More.

Losing his wife doesn't give him the right to touch you as he pleases.

Also makes me wonder why his own daughter doesn't care much ...

Catsmere · 31/07/2023 05:34

@Dibbydoos

Do you know why you don't like to be touched? If you do share that with him.

Why the hell does OP have to share anything with him? Why does she have to supply a justification?

mangochops · 31/07/2023 05:12

housingplanningquestion · 31/07/2023 00:10

@PuzzledObserver @mangochops The reason I suggested that approach was twofold:

  1. OP has already said she is finding it very hard to broach it, feels guilty / worried / that she will be blamed or punished. If she could be direct and clear, that would be better, but that's not available to her currently.
  2. Asking FIL 'if he's ok with that' is an exploratory tactic, and strategic. Any direct challenge is likely to trigger his misogynist and chauvinism and entrench his position further. Appearing to give him a choice allows him the feeling of not being pushed around by a woman. God knows he sounds awful, but OP seems to want to keto the peace. And what's he going to say? 'No I want to keep touching you even tho you've asked me not to'? He must know he'd sound like an arsehole. And if he does say that, OP knows better what she's dealing with, and how to manage her next response (avoidance, sanctions etc).

Fair enough, those are good points! But I do think he'll try to wriggle out of it by brushing it off if he's given a choice to be ok with it or not, especially if he has very strong views that men are the head of the household and women are subserviant, you know? I also think the more women firm up their boundaries, the more comfortable we'll feel doing it, we dont need to ask if men are ok with boundaries because boundaries are chosen by us and others can equally choose their own.

housingplanningquestion · 31/07/2023 00:10

@PuzzledObserver @mangochops The reason I suggested that approach was twofold:

  1. OP has already said she is finding it very hard to broach it, feels guilty / worried / that she will be blamed or punished. If she could be direct and clear, that would be better, but that's not available to her currently.
  2. Asking FIL 'if he's ok with that' is an exploratory tactic, and strategic. Any direct challenge is likely to trigger his misogynist and chauvinism and entrench his position further. Appearing to give him a choice allows him the feeling of not being pushed around by a woman. God knows he sounds awful, but OP seems to want to keto the peace. And what's he going to say? 'No I want to keep touching you even tho you've asked me not to'? He must know he'd sound like an arsehole. And if he does say that, OP knows better what she's dealing with, and how to manage her next response (avoidance, sanctions etc).
Mummy08m · 30/07/2023 22:25

SeamsLegit · 30/07/2023 22:19

Is it really that hard to understand that these situations gradually build up, and that people push feelings away and try to 'get on with things'?? The drip feed can happen when talking things over with others (like on mumsnet!) finally makes pennies start dropping and puzzle pieces slot together. Talking is the catalyst to realizing the full scenario - nobody is trying to pull the wool over YOUR eyes! This entire website is to HELP people, especially in situations where they don't feel able to talk about the issue in regular life. Be helpful or bugger off!

Yes. Especially as op seems to be outnumbered by men around her (dh and fil) who had convinced her that they're lovely while she is oversensitive.

These days lots of women, myself included, don't have enough of a support network of women around them, esp older and wiser women, who can reassure/advise/warn about this kind of thing. So women get swept along into situations that they aren't comfortable about and get slowly cooked like frogs before it gets too much to ignore and they reach out online.

SeamsLegit · 30/07/2023 22:19

Blossomtoes · 30/07/2023 10:22

I do. It always happens when everyone doesn’t unanimously agree with the OP.

Is it really that hard to understand that these situations gradually build up, and that people push feelings away and try to 'get on with things'?? The drip feed can happen when talking things over with others (like on mumsnet!) finally makes pennies start dropping and puzzle pieces slot together. Talking is the catalyst to realizing the full scenario - nobody is trying to pull the wool over YOUR eyes! This entire website is to HELP people, especially in situations where they don't feel able to talk about the issue in regular life. Be helpful or bugger off!

SequentialAnalyst · 30/07/2023 19:41

Julian Clary came to mind as a role model "Don't touch me!" if any of the contestants on one of his shows tried to do it just as a natural part of the conversation, in any way.

tootallfortheshelf · 30/07/2023 19:24

she needs to go 'Grant Mitchel'
'OI BACK OFF GRANDAAAD'

mangochops · 30/07/2023 19:19

housingplanningquestion · 30/07/2023 16:23

'FIL, you've been more affectionate recently. I'm glad you are feeling welcome and comfortable with us. Can I ask you to stop touching me? I know you don't mean anything by it, but I'm not a person who is comfortable with casual touching. My personal space is very important to me. Is that OK? Do you think you will be able to change that behaviour?'

If he continues, 'FIL I've asked you to stop touching me. This is important. Are you forgetting that I've said that? What is going on here?'

If he still continues, medical assessment / stop seeing him. Would that work?

The problem with this approach is that its literally asking him if he's ok to stop. What if he says "oh dont be so silly, I'm not doing anything wrong!" what then?

A firm NO is far better as it doesnt allow or invite negotiation on his part.

SequentialAnalyst · 30/07/2023 17:37

It's a hand on the shoulder that I hate. From anyone.

I was once just about to leave a meeting with someone in their office, when his boss came in. I had half-stood up to leave, I was going anyway. The boss, while still standing, said "you don't have to go just because I've come in" and with his hand, pressed firmly down on my shoulder so I had to sit back down. I protested that I was leaving anyway...

I think he thought he was doing a good thing - but didn't seem to realise physically preventing me from getting up was not appropriate.

I know this is not strictly relevant to your plight, OP, but it came welling up out of my memory, and I thought I would post it anyway.

PuzzledObserver · 30/07/2023 16:33

housingplanningquestion · 30/07/2023 16:23

'FIL, you've been more affectionate recently. I'm glad you are feeling welcome and comfortable with us. Can I ask you to stop touching me? I know you don't mean anything by it, but I'm not a person who is comfortable with casual touching. My personal space is very important to me. Is that OK? Do you think you will be able to change that behaviour?'

If he continues, 'FIL I've asked you to stop touching me. This is important. Are you forgetting that I've said that? What is going on here?'

If he still continues, medical assessment / stop seeing him. Would that work?

It’s a no from me to that approach. She doesn’t need his permission to ask him to stop touching her, or to ask if it’s OK, or ask if he can change his behaviour. What does she do if he says no?

A bit of a shrug/swerve to avoid or end the contact, combined with “Please don’t touch me like that, I don’t like it.”

If he argues, or “forgets”, then it’s avoidance tactics - limit contact, make sure there’s a table between them etc.

I have had to do the furniture between tactic twice with men who for work-related reasons I could not completely avoid but who hadn’t done anything which was overt enough to have counted as assault, although they totally gave me the ick. It worked. They didn’t like it, but it worked in that they couldn’t get near me.

Actually - full disclosure - in neither case had I said anything to them first. But I was young, they were a lot older, and the power politics meant I might have been seen to have been being unreasonable had I told them not to touch me. Cos, you know - they hadn’t actually groped me. So I did what I needed to do to make sure they couldn’t get even the little bit of thrill they were presumably getting from what they were doing.

BasiliskStare · 30/07/2023 16:28

I agree with a couple of posters here - there is no answer needed except - please don't do that I don't like it. & say it every time and if he carries on - I have told you I do not like this - please stop. Whatever his reasons don't matter - the point is you don't like it so just tell him to stop.

PuzzledObserver · 30/07/2023 16:23

@stallonesbicep I agree 100% - you don’t have to have any reason other than you don’t like it.

You don’t owe men (or anyone, actually) access to your body. Nor do you owe them an explanation as to why you don’t want their touch.

housingplanningquestion · 30/07/2023 16:23

'FIL, you've been more affectionate recently. I'm glad you are feeling welcome and comfortable with us. Can I ask you to stop touching me? I know you don't mean anything by it, but I'm not a person who is comfortable with casual touching. My personal space is very important to me. Is that OK? Do you think you will be able to change that behaviour?'

If he continues, 'FIL I've asked you to stop touching me. This is important. Are you forgetting that I've said that? What is going on here?'

If he still continues, medical assessment / stop seeing him. Would that work?

Mummy08m · 30/07/2023 16:21

Bluesky5512 · 30/07/2023 15:33

I haven’t told DH yet. I feel he’ll say I’m being overly sensitive. His mom was a bit of a narcissist, so he struggles to see the shit his parents do and even if it’s obvious, it’s just easier for him to blame me rather than stand up to them.

I'm really sorry to hear this update. I would feel pretty devastated if dh didn't back me up in something like this.

If it was me I'd go back to my proposed plan A, which is meet FIL far less, keep a table physically between you when you have to see him, be vigilant and avoid him as much as you can.

Everything you say about both FIL and your DH tell me that it'd be explosive if you say anything to FIL. FIL would bad mouth you to your DH and cause drama, I hate drama.

I hope you're wrong about your DH though because this update makes him sound like a very bad partner

PimpMyFridge · 30/07/2023 16:12

lemmein · 30/07/2023 16:10

'Oi, Mr Handsy - rap it in or I'll chop it off!'

Or....you could do a dramatic scream every time, like that Catherine Tate character who is startled by everything! Grin

Seriously though, I would really hate this, a hand around the waist is really quite intimate. It sounds like he's escalating too, pinching cheeks to touching your shoulder and now your waist - it's not ok and you're more than reasonable to tell him bluntly to keep his fucking hands to himself.

🤣🤣🤣🤣

lemmein · 30/07/2023 16:10

'Oi, Mr Handsy - rap it in or I'll chop it off!'

Or....you could do a dramatic scream every time, like that Catherine Tate character who is startled by everything! Grin

Seriously though, I would really hate this, a hand around the waist is really quite intimate. It sounds like he's escalating too, pinching cheeks to touching your shoulder and now your waist - it's not ok and you're more than reasonable to tell him bluntly to keep his fucking hands to himself.

Mirabai · 30/07/2023 16:10

Bluesky5512 · 30/07/2023 15:33

I haven’t told DH yet. I feel he’ll say I’m being overly sensitive. His mom was a bit of a narcissist, so he struggles to see the shit his parents do and even if it’s obvious, it’s just easier for him to blame me rather than stand up to them.

Explain that age related brain changes can affect behaviour of elderly people, that this behaviour is new and you need help dealing with it.

If he’s intelligent surely he will understand that?

PimpMyFridge · 30/07/2023 16:09

It's a pity you know your DH won't be a help in this scenario, but that's what toxic family dynamics do to people, they f* them up.
Doesn't mean you can't break the pattern of bending to the will or not daring to exert boundaries. All our to you op.
What he's doing is a cheek and ick-worthy and why he is doing it is nothing you need to worry about. Its perfectly ok to put a firm stop to it without concerning yourself with his feelings.

blahblahblah1654 · 30/07/2023 16:07

Bluesky5512 · 30/07/2023 15:33

I haven’t told DH yet. I feel he’ll say I’m being overly sensitive. His mom was a bit of a narcissist, so he struggles to see the shit his parents do and even if it’s obvious, it’s just easier for him to blame me rather than stand up to them.

It's pretty shitty if your DH blames you! I wouldn't keep it secret anyway in case the behaviour escalates as he's testing his boundaries. Next time please tell him to stop and/or move away.

PimpMyFridge · 30/07/2023 16:05

When you remove his hand or dodge him and say No Thank You (or whatever, just keep it short and sweet). Be prepared for the 'What's the matter can't I hug my Dil?' or 'only being friendly' or whatever retort which is designed to make you doubt your reaction, or make you feel unreasonable.
Just ignore the discomfort, stick to your guns and say, 'it's no thanks and that's that'.
Don't explain
Don't apologise
If he doubles down - repeat
If he goes moody - ignore
If he maintains an uncomfortable silence - let him
If he demands an explanation/What's up with you - repeat.
Calm, solid, clear.

Bluesky5512 · 30/07/2023 15:38

Dealing with this is 100% on me

OP posts:
Bluesky5512 · 30/07/2023 15:33

I haven’t told DH yet. I feel he’ll say I’m being overly sensitive. His mom was a bit of a narcissist, so he struggles to see the shit his parents do and even if it’s obvious, it’s just easier for him to blame me rather than stand up to them.

OP posts:
stallonesbicep · 30/07/2023 15:29

PuzzledObserver · 30/07/2023 14:19

Do you know why you dont like to be touched? If you do share that with him.

Why should she have to???

I know why I don’t like being touched - because I was sexually assaulted when I was six. But that’s my information and I decide with whom I share it, and when.

Plus - think of the implication of what you’re saying: there are valid reasons for not wanting to be touched, and if you’ve got one, you should tell people….. but if you haven’t got a valid reason, you should grow up and accept the touch. That’s the message you are conveying.

Sod that. No-one has to accept any touch from anybody that they don’t want to. And they don’t have to explain why.

Agree. Its an awful attitude. I was not sexually abused as a child, does that mean I have to let men put their hands on me whenever they feel like it because I dont therefore have a valid "reason" to say no? Fck right off with that. Noone needs to provide a reason to not want to be touched by men. Men have no right to go around touching women's bodies without their express consent. End of.

SequentialAnalyst · 30/07/2023 15:02

Just say sharply "please don't touch me" immediately he tries to. Every time.

You may hestitate to do this the first time, for fear of embarrassing yourself. Overcome the hesitation, it will be easier the next time (if there is one). And don't get into an argument about what you've done, or try to explain or justify yourself.

He's the one that should be embarrassed.