Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to politely ask FIL to NOT touch me

510 replies

Bluesky5512 · 30/07/2023 07:38

I’ve known FIL for the last 15ish years. He is 75. He has been a thorough gentleman all through. Inlaws live in the US, we visit them every year. MIL passed away a couple of years ago in a sudden accident. Ever since FIL has been visiting us more often and at times staying for 2-3 months at a time. We stuck a friendship during his recent visits. We talk about politics, astronomy (is was a professor) and yoga (my passion). I see him as a father figure and a friend. DH works in a hospital and I work from home. I take FIL out and about with me - grocery, school runs etc

He has been acting weird lately. Pinching my cheeks, Putting his hands on my shoulder, and yesterday on my waist. WTF !! I was totally taken back and he doesn’t seem to realise. He was never a “creep” IYKWIM. But this touchy behaviour is making me very uncomfortable. I don’t know how to tell him to stop without ruining our friendship.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
Rosscameasdoody · 05/08/2023 18:14

Mummy08m · 05/08/2023 18:11

Because she knows FIL won't want to go. Read the op's posts. FIL doesn't value her opinion enough, and also believes ill health is a sign of weakness etc.

The main reason her cowardly dh won't do it is because he knows FIL won't hear of it.

You're implying that op is disdainfully allowing her FIL to languish in ill health but that doesn't reflect the info she's given us at all.

Not implying anything, just don’t understand the mindset, given the possible consequences.

Mummy08m · 05/08/2023 18:11

DotAndCarryOne2 · 05/08/2023 17:59

Why does the OP need anyone’s permission to take FIL to see her GP ? If he’s willing to do so, she doesn’t need to involve anyone else unless/ until a problem has been identified, at which point she can insist they support her, as it’s she who is at risk.

Because she knows FIL won't want to go. Read the op's posts. FIL doesn't value her opinion enough, and also believes ill health is a sign of weakness etc.

The main reason her cowardly dh won't do it is because he knows FIL won't hear of it.

You're implying that op is disdainfully allowing her FIL to languish in ill health but that doesn't reflect the info she's given us at all.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 05/08/2023 17:59

Mummy08m · 05/08/2023 17:50

Indeed, op's dh doesn't want to lift a finger to assess his father. Op can't easily do it against her dh's wishes.

We are all in agreement that op's dh is useless.

Whether op should leave him or bury him under the patio is a discussion for another thread no doubt

Why does the OP need anyone’s permission to take FIL to see her GP ? If he’s willing to do so, she doesn’t need to involve anyone else unless/ until a problem has been identified, at which point she can insist they support her, as it’s she who is at risk.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 05/08/2023 17:53

Mummy08m · 05/08/2023 17:22

all the posts claiming it doesn't matter if the FIL has dementia

I don't know if you're referring to my posts. I thought I'd been clear that it doesn't make much of a difference to op whether or not it's dementia. Because she can't do anything to get FIL assessed beyond what she has already done - broach it with dh. Either way op needs to take steps to protect herself (either confrontation or avoidance), and she's opted for avoiding his touch where possible.

Obviously it makes a great deal of difference to FIL if he has dementia or not. No one is disputing that, it would be nonsensical to dispute that.

If he continues to spend long periods of time in the OPs home and the behaviour is down to dementia, then sooner or later it will make a difference to her as the disease progresses undiagnosed and unchecked. His behaviour could worsen or become aggressive - she’s the target for his present behaviour so any escalation puts her more at risk. This has been pointed out by several posters.

Mummy08m · 05/08/2023 17:50

pam290358 · 05/08/2023 17:47

Obviously it makes a great deal of difference to FIL if he has dementia or not. No one is disputing that, it would be nonsensical to dispute that.

And yet no one wants to lift a finger to find out. If they really wanted to help, despite the fact that he’s not resident in the UK, they can still take him to see their own GP, who could assess him. If a problem is detected, they could then potentially access secondary care which may or may not incur a fee. So to say there’s nothing they can do isn’t strictly true. It’s just easier. Which is what we’re really talking about here - easier to pack him off back to the USA and leave him to his fate.

Indeed, op's dh doesn't want to lift a finger to assess his father. Op can't easily do it against her dh's wishes.

We are all in agreement that op's dh is useless.

Whether op should leave him or bury him under the patio is a discussion for another thread no doubt

pam290358 · 05/08/2023 17:47

Mummy08m · 05/08/2023 17:22

all the posts claiming it doesn't matter if the FIL has dementia

I don't know if you're referring to my posts. I thought I'd been clear that it doesn't make much of a difference to op whether or not it's dementia. Because she can't do anything to get FIL assessed beyond what she has already done - broach it with dh. Either way op needs to take steps to protect herself (either confrontation or avoidance), and she's opted for avoiding his touch where possible.

Obviously it makes a great deal of difference to FIL if he has dementia or not. No one is disputing that, it would be nonsensical to dispute that.

Obviously it makes a great deal of difference to FIL if he has dementia or not. No one is disputing that, it would be nonsensical to dispute that.

And yet no one wants to lift a finger to find out. If they really wanted to help, despite the fact that he’s not resident in the UK, they can still take him to see their own GP, who could assess him. If a problem is detected, they could then potentially access secondary care which may or may not incur a fee. So to say there’s nothing they can do isn’t strictly true. It’s just easier. Which is what we’re really talking about here - easier to pack him off back to the USA and leave him to his fate.

ZairWazAnOldLady · 05/08/2023 17:34

Nah it’s just a bunch of people not listening to each other. NOBODY has said the man doesn’t have dementia NOBODY has said he does, literally everyone has said that OP should start by telling him to stop and go from there. Some people think he “most likely has the has dementia they’ve seen it, and some say it’s not the most likely reason. Then lots of people have got offended because they stated they have first hand experience of dementia and feel their expertise is being ignored.

Mummy08m · 05/08/2023 17:22

SquirrelMadness · 05/08/2023 15:17

The reason I keep posting is in response to all the posts claiming it doesn't matter if the FIL has dementia. I do think it's important on a thread like this to explain why it does matter.

The attitudes towards elderly relatives on this thread is absolutely disgusting. As someone with a close elderly relative who has dementia, I find it really quite upsetting. I can only think that people don't understand what a tragic disease ut is.

all the posts claiming it doesn't matter if the FIL has dementia

I don't know if you're referring to my posts. I thought I'd been clear that it doesn't make much of a difference to op whether or not it's dementia. Because she can't do anything to get FIL assessed beyond what she has already done - broach it with dh. Either way op needs to take steps to protect herself (either confrontation or avoidance), and she's opted for avoiding his touch where possible.

Obviously it makes a great deal of difference to FIL if he has dementia or not. No one is disputing that, it would be nonsensical to dispute that.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 05/08/2023 16:41

Skinthin · 05/08/2023 16:08

The problem is that people are only capable of very black and white thinking.
Touching without consent = bad, OP= female victim, FIL=bad man, anyone who brings up something like dementia is “excusing” / justifying violence again women and placing onus on the victim and siding with the “perpetrator”.

That’s the chain of reasoning and people get angry if you try to bring in any discussion of potential context/ nuance or suggest that FIL might also be a vulnerable human.

This whole thread in a nutshell. Somewhere upthread a poster actually gloated that they were glad another poster had left the thread. That poster, who had put forward reasoned posts with the insight and compassion of experience of caring for a dementia sufferer, gave up after being treated with scorn, and her valid opinions dismissed with no reasoned argument other than OP victim, FIL perpetrator. That’s nothing to be proud of and it’s happening more and more on MN. I don’t think this thread is helping anyone now.

Skinthin · 05/08/2023 16:08

The problem is that people are only capable of very black and white thinking.
Touching without consent = bad, OP= female victim, FIL=bad man, anyone who brings up something like dementia is “excusing” / justifying violence again women and placing onus on the victim and siding with the “perpetrator”.

That’s the chain of reasoning and people get angry if you try to bring in any discussion of potential context/ nuance or suggest that FIL might also be a vulnerable human.

Seeingadistance · 05/08/2023 15:47

I am with those who are disturbed and depressed about attitudes about dementia on this thread. Yes, it is appreciated that there is only so much the OP can do, but the more recent posts on this thread are intended less for the OP and more for those who seem to be luxuriating in their ignorance of the realities of dementia and are being really quite offensive now to those who are aware of those realities and can see how this might be affecting the OP, her FIL and the family as a whole.

I wonder if it would be easier to comprehend if the OP had posted about an elderly relative who kept bumping into thing in her house and damaging them? Would it be considered enough to tell him to be more careful - and suggestions that he might perhaps be losing his eyesight be scorned and dismissed?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 05/08/2023 15:31

SquirrelMadness · 05/08/2023 15:17

The reason I keep posting is in response to all the posts claiming it doesn't matter if the FIL has dementia. I do think it's important on a thread like this to explain why it does matter.

The attitudes towards elderly relatives on this thread is absolutely disgusting. As someone with a close elderly relative who has dementia, I find it really quite upsetting. I can only think that people don't understand what a tragic disease ut is.

This. We’re constantly told to look out for exactly the kind of behaviour in elderly relatives that FIL is displaying. It’s disturbing and depressing to read some of the callous and frankly ignorant comments. Sadly we’re wasting our breath.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 05/08/2023 15:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

No, she’s not. Like others posting here, she just has first hand experience of dementia and recognises the red flags. And I have never advocated the OP put up with the behaviour, regardless of the cause, but given that FIL is spending a lot of time in her home, not addressing dementia as a possible cause puts her in harms’ way if things deteriorate. His family need to stop pretending it’s not a problem and support her.

SquirrelMadness · 05/08/2023 15:17

Mummy08m · 05/08/2023 14:20

Op has already raised the issue of dementia with her dh, who was dismissive. Dh is fil's next of kin and who might be in a position to get him assessed.

I'm not sure what all this repetition about dementia is in aid of.

Op knows dementia is a possibility. There is literally nothing more she can do about it.

People continuing to point out that it's a possibility (which, I think, no one is denying) is a waste of op's time, if she's even still here

The reason I keep posting is in response to all the posts claiming it doesn't matter if the FIL has dementia. I do think it's important on a thread like this to explain why it does matter.

The attitudes towards elderly relatives on this thread is absolutely disgusting. As someone with a close elderly relative who has dementia, I find it really quite upsetting. I can only think that people don't understand what a tragic disease ut is.

tootallfortheshelf · 05/08/2023 14:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Mummy08m · 05/08/2023 14:20

SquirrelMadness · 05/08/2023 07:40

@Mummy08m
This exactly. Dementia doesn't just make life difficult for the sufferer, it makes life more difficult for everyone around them.

I can't really see the benefits of ignoring the dementia possibility. People seem to be suggesting that she can't possibly say "no" to FIL, tell him she doesn't like to be touched etc etc. And on the same day or in the same week, also have a serious conversation with her DH about what they would do if it is dementia.

Raising the issue of dementia does not stop her from enforcing her boundaries and I'm really irritated that people keep misrepresenting the posts about dementia in this way.

Op has already raised the issue of dementia with her dh, who was dismissive. Dh is fil's next of kin and who might be in a position to get him assessed.

I'm not sure what all this repetition about dementia is in aid of.

Op knows dementia is a possibility. There is literally nothing more she can do about it.

People continuing to point out that it's a possibility (which, I think, no one is denying) is a waste of op's time, if she's even still here

ZairWazAnOldLady · 05/08/2023 14:14

@DotAndCarryOne2 I’m not going to apologise for prioritising the OPs need to be safe from anyone’s unwanted touching. She is married to the man’s son not a slave to endure whatever his male relatives needs are. It speaks volumes that you are unable to prioritise the woman’s safety and well-being. Wake up.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 05/08/2023 09:07

ZairWazAnOldLady · 05/08/2023 08:17

and she’s held off tackling him for quite some time, so she obviously cares about him, that’s really not why women who’s boundaries are pushed in this way don’t respond or report, though can be used against them.

The recent NHS statistics state "1 in 11 people over the age of 65 have dementia in the UK." If you'd like to take this up with the NHS, be my guest.why would I need to “take that up with the nhs”. When a simple google search will allow you to understand that fact more clearly. What I read was that those patients were predominantly female and in their eighties. The statistic was being used to increase the concern that the man has dementia because it was much more common than everyone thought. But 1 in 11 wasn’t the incidence for a man in his late 60s, but instead for everyone over 65.

The OP is not in charge of her visiting FILs health. She is responsible for keeping herself and her children safe. She would like this not to be happening and would love to be able to politely stop the behaviour. I think that’s utterly understandable and feel so sorry for her because it must be terribly upsetting.

My advice is to confront him and ask him directly not to touch you. You don’t need to apologise, sound angry, or give a reason. If he continues I don’t think you can host him anymore. I would explain that to dh and stand by it. If FIL has a medical condition that causes disinhibition then how to manage that if he makes it your problem could be addressed once it’s diagnosed. I know there are several posters that are concerned about dementia but some medication can be problematic too.

So your sympathies are entirely with the OP regardless of what’s driving the behaviour ? No regard for a 75 year old man who may be about to fall victim to a horrible, tragic disease ? Just confront him and then if the behaviour continues, simply cut him loose and leave him to his fate. Wow.

ZairWazAnOldLady · 05/08/2023 08:17

and she’s held off tackling him for quite some time, so she obviously cares about him, that’s really not why women who’s boundaries are pushed in this way don’t respond or report, though can be used against them.

The recent NHS statistics state "1 in 11 people over the age of 65 have dementia in the UK." If you'd like to take this up with the NHS, be my guest.why would I need to “take that up with the nhs”. When a simple google search will allow you to understand that fact more clearly. What I read was that those patients were predominantly female and in their eighties. The statistic was being used to increase the concern that the man has dementia because it was much more common than everyone thought. But 1 in 11 wasn’t the incidence for a man in his late 60s, but instead for everyone over 65.

The OP is not in charge of her visiting FILs health. She is responsible for keeping herself and her children safe. She would like this not to be happening and would love to be able to politely stop the behaviour. I think that’s utterly understandable and feel so sorry for her because it must be terribly upsetting.

My advice is to confront him and ask him directly not to touch you. You don’t need to apologise, sound angry, or give a reason. If he continues I don’t think you can host him anymore. I would explain that to dh and stand by it. If FIL has a medical condition that causes disinhibition then how to manage that if he makes it your problem could be addressed once it’s diagnosed. I know there are several posters that are concerned about dementia but some medication can be problematic too.

SquirrelMadness · 05/08/2023 07:40

DotAndCarryOne2 · 05/08/2023 05:44

Given that she’s the target of FIL’s behaviour she should insist on family support for a start. They are ignoring the fact that if the behaviour is due to dementia, it will worsen and possibly become aggressive, which is putting the OP in harms’ ways as he spends long periods of time in the her home. That’s unacceptable.

@Mummy08m
This exactly. Dementia doesn't just make life difficult for the sufferer, it makes life more difficult for everyone around them.

I can't really see the benefits of ignoring the dementia possibility. People seem to be suggesting that she can't possibly say "no" to FIL, tell him she doesn't like to be touched etc etc. And on the same day or in the same week, also have a serious conversation with her DH about what they would do if it is dementia.

Raising the issue of dementia does not stop her from enforcing her boundaries and I'm really irritated that people keep misrepresenting the posts about dementia in this way.

SquirrelMadness · 05/08/2023 07:16

ZairWazAnOldLady · 05/08/2023 01:09

@SquirrelMadness It might not even be dementia. But 1 in 14 people aged 65 or over in the UK have dementia. It's very common.

this suggests it’s more like 2% of adults between 65 and 69 and the majority are women.

https://aspe.hhs.gov/reports/profile-older-adults-dementia-their-caregivers-issue-brief-0#:~:text=KEY%20FINDINGS,adults%20aged%2090%20and%20older.

The recent NHS statistics state "1 in 11 people over the age of 65 have dementia in the UK." If you'd like to take this up with the NHS, be my guest.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/dementia/about/

I was quoting out of date statistics from Alzheimers UK previously.

nhs.uk

About dementia

Find out about dementia, including the symptoms, how to get a diagnosis, and how common dementia is.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/dementia/about

DotAndCarryOne2 · 05/08/2023 05:44

Mummy08m · 05/08/2023 00:35

What do you suggest op does? Specifically

Given that she’s the target of FIL’s behaviour she should insist on family support for a start. They are ignoring the fact that if the behaviour is due to dementia, it will worsen and possibly become aggressive, which is putting the OP in harms’ ways as he spends long periods of time in the her home. That’s unacceptable.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 05/08/2023 05:20

ZairWazAnOldLady · 04/08/2023 23:12

All I’m saying is that if the family care so little that they won’t at least try to help, then they can’t moan if there are unexpected consequences. what on earth do you mean

As several posters have pointed out he’s living in the same house as OP for long periods of time. If the change in behaviour is due to some form of dementia, then symptoms are already showing. So how long do you think it will be before things get worse ? It makes no sense to just assume that he’s suddenly become ‘handsy’ when it’s never been a problem before, and the change in behaviour could suggest illness. Other changes in behaviour could be on the way, including aggression. OP will be in the firing line and the rest of the family are burying their heads in the sand.

The OP posted for advice on how to handle this without ruining the friendship, and she’s held off tackling him for quite some time, so she obviously cares about him, and most of the advice as far as I can see, has been to confront him, tell him to back off, and set boundaries. Which is fine as far as it goes, and no-one is suggesting that she should have to put up with this, regardless of whether or not he is ill. But as has been pointed out over and over again, if he has dementia, no amount of confrontation or boundaries will make any difference because he isn’t in control of his behaviour. If the friendship means so much, why such reluctance to get to the root cause ?

It’s all very well digging up statistics on dementia to try to support the argument against it being the cause, but the fact is, his age and recent bereavement, and the fact that this is a sudden onset of new and out of character disinhibited behaviour, all fit. So why are his family not stepping up, given that if he is ill, the consequences of simply ignoring that possibility could become much more serious as things progress undiagnosed and untreated.

Squeaky2023 · 05/08/2023 00:41

Grab his wrist and remove his hand from you and just say, "No thank you."
If he wants to take the conversation further, he can, but I hope that he would be embarrassed and it would put him in his place?