Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand what she’s spending it on

516 replies

Idlovetoknow · 29/07/2023 21:58

It’s my mother. She’s a pensioner and a widow, but she working. She cannot deal with her finances. She’s been on the phone tonight weeping over how much of a dire situation she’s in financially, but I don’t see how.

income from work: £1100 (after tax)
state pension: £800
widows pension: £1600 (think this is after tax too)
private pension: £200/300 (she was wooly on this)
so total income around £3600 a month

No mortgage, no rent, no grounds costs.
council tax £200 a month. Power £150 (let’s say 200 to round up) food and pet food £400, car £450 petrol £100, health insurance £200, phone £50, sky £50, pet insurance £80- that’s £1300 at an absolute max

i don’t understand. She’s not being frauded or taken advantage of, but i don’t understand. I try to talk to her for instance tonight when she rang frantic over money but she gets into such a tizz she can’t tell you anything. I’ve asked for months for all bills and bank statements to go over expenses but she can’t produce them

Anyone any ideas?

OP posts:
GettingOldB4MyTime · 30/07/2023 14:56

Hi, your original post doesn't mention payment for the holidays.
5 holidays a year, 2 weeks at a time and in I presume expensive hotels can add up. That works out at paying for a holiday roughly every 2 months.
Not to mention the 10 weeks a holiday taken off work....a lot of that would have to be taken unpaid.

CecilyP · 30/07/2023 14:54

She gave me her tax code as it’s a higher rate one it’s a DO code which I looked up and it says higher rate on all income, trouble is she’s just found out and doesn’t know when it started because she doesn’t look at bills or payslips.

She could ask her employer for back payslips. She would also have received a letter from HMRC giving her tax code. She seems to be indulging in a lot of leaned helplessness, yet she can’t be that helpless if she holds down a fairly well paid job.

I do think it’s awful that she moans about you not helping her when you have a job and 2 very young children.

nokidshere · 30/07/2023 14:50

My elderly MIL was similar in her later years. No dementia or other illness but constantly worrying about money. I used to ask her if she wanted the paper when I was out and about and she would say 'can I afford one'. I just used to laugh and say you can afford the whole paper shop shall I buy it for you.

She would stop buying things because they 'were expensive', small things like M&S trifles, it was never anything big. I think for a lot of older people it just becomes something they focus on.

CecilyP · 30/07/2023 14:37

Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 11:14

She seems to think she’d being taxed at 50% on all earnings now, so not being a higher rate tax payer but literally 50% of pay pack taken away

She will be paying a lot of tax on her salary, though I doubt it’s 50% if she is receiving enhanced state pension from leaving it in for a few years, it is probably taxable and instead of getting a bill for the tax it is coming off her work PAYE. I’m in a similar position, though not nearly as wealthy, and 30% comes off my salary. Must say your mum must be on quite a good wage if she still takes home £1000 a month for 20 hours work.

PurelyOrnamental · 30/07/2023 14:26

Drop the rope OP, why on earth are you stressing yourself out over a 68 year old woman that is minted in comparison to most people?
If she is short of £400 let her go short, she needs to learn somehow that once she has spent it, it's gone!
At 68, she should have learned that money isn't an infinite resource for most of us and she might have to go without a holiday or two but I would not be bending over backwards to sort her finances (she didn't listen to a financial advisor, why would she listen to you?)
Honestly, she sounds like a spoiled brat rather than a mature older lady, I would probably laugh down the phone at her next time she rang complaining!!!

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 14:25

I agree with @Trianglesandcircles1 .

Given your mum might live for another 25 or 30 years, it might be worth having some counselling around your relationship.

Because it's the money now, but could well be something else later on.

You've already mentioned how she likes to come and see you at weekends for a change of scene. So she appears lonely.

But if she's draining you dry ( and not your brother) that says a lot.

I'd put money on you always being the 'people pleaser' as home caught in between your mum's abuse towards your Dad and the backwash you received.

And like a lot of men, your brother escaped either because he's a man (and your mum didn't dare involve him) and you were the capable, caring daughter who felt obliged to step into their dodgy marriage and help keep the peace.

It's worth considering all of this with a professional because, as others have said, your Mum is now abusing you because you have taken your Dad's place in the family dynamics.

NettleTea · 30/07/2023 14:24

and yes, as @Trianglesandcircles1 say, the potential of any neurodiversity or personality disorder doesnt make her behaviour acceptable. Understandable perhaps, but it doesnt mean that you have to indulge it.

Especially given that you seem to be the scapegoat in the triangle of narcissism/golden child/scapegoat

Its really hard. You cannot change how she behaves and she reacts. Whether she is willing to try, or whether she is unable to, due to whatever reasons, it is actually quite unlikely. She has found a way that serves her well - be that due to awful parenting / early life experiences or undiagnosed neurodiversity, or a toxic mix of all theree - her ways of getting her needs met are that of a young child, and they seem to have been so extreme that they have endured into adulthood. Im sure that she can be pleasant, funny, charming and attentive. But its when things go wrong or needs arent being met that either the panic or the fury set in, and the histrionics come out. In the past that has set everyone running around trying to solve and pacify. Ultimately her needs are met.

Golden boy probably carries his own baggage, but like your mum - thats not your problem to solve. I assume he probably uses the same techniques as is a bit of a mini me for your mum. But his approval will only come while he is agreement with her, and does what she approves of. they both probably feed each others neediness and adoration.

You are the saver. But also the role of saver means that responsibility is passed over, and as you say it is your fault when it goes wrong, even when she goes against the advice that you gave. And no praise when it doesnt because 'she did it'

You cannot win here. Ultimately you need to learn how to step out of her game.

Back to the start - you cannot change her behaviour. The ONLY thing you can change is how you react to it. At the moment you are still trying to fix it.

You need boundaries.
You need to to discuss with your own family what you can and cannot achieve.
To be honest Id be twempted to take the wrath (and I KNOW that has awful feelings for you, due to her conditioning of you, but honestly the light off your shoulders in the long run would be worth it) and tell her that you cannot help her. Thats she doesnt have the paperwork and you cannot do anything. Direct her elsewhere. and then refuse to discuss it again. I think someopne suggested it upthread. She is far far from destitute. So wont starve. She wont be made homeless. She may run up debts, but sounds as if she is on the ball enough to not do that. But what she is wanting is actually impossible.

I expect there will be another disaster. But you are allowed to step back. You are allowed to not help - to pass her to agencies much better placed and local to her. You are allowed to not be drawn into her dramas

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 14:19

If I was your Mum OP and had that kind of income, savings and a 2nd home standing empty and going to rot, I'd give you an early inheritance so you didn't have to take a 2nd job to make ends meet.

Honestly, she's your Mum, but she doesn't deserve your angst over all of this.

Trianglesandcircles1 · 30/07/2023 14:06

As others have said, this is not really about the money at all.
She has loads of money and assets, it is really not a problem.

It is not even a problem if she is being scammed, giving money to your brother, gambling, drinking, giving it all to charities, getting dementia, etc, etc. - that is to say it is not YOUR problem.
If when she dies there is nothing left but a pile of debts, well, so what? Are you counting on getting an inheritance? (No-one should ever count on an inheritance, as you never know if care homes will take the lot, even if your parent has been a financial wizard all their life.)

You do however have a major problem - your reactions to her.

She is utterly spoilt, childish, selfish, and in your own words 'abusive' (to your late father). You have suffered your whole life from this abusive mother and don't seem able to see it. Even if she has a 'condition' like ADHD, PDA, or whatever, it doesn't change the fact that you have suffered, and are still suffering, because of her.

You seem unable to detach emotionally from her. Your problem is that you are unable to shut her up and refuse to listen to her tantrumming and hysterics.

I suggest that (when you can afford it) you might get some counselling about the highly dysfunctional relationships between your mother, brother and you.

You must also recognise that you are grieving over your father - perhaps look for some free grief counselling for yourself.

NettleTea · 30/07/2023 14:05

she sounds a bit like my daughter. But she has PDA / autism.
I do too, and could see myself spiralling if I started to panic / was pressed too much for info that I couldnt solve immediately

SmileyClare · 30/07/2023 14:05

If nothing else, it’s spectacularly self absorbed of your mum to complain about money (and in the next breath buys a new car and books a holiday) when you and your dh are juggling four jobs just to stay afloat and can’t afford a holiday. Confused

Maybe suggest your mum gets a second job? Let’s out or sells her second house?
My parents are in their 70s and both work full time.

Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 14:04

GellerYeller · 30/07/2023 14:02

apologies I’ve conflated @justasking111 s elderly hubby and your own situation. Hard to keep up x

Ah cross post x

OP posts:
Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 14:03

GellerYeller · 30/07/2023 13:55

Any minute now someone will be along to tell us the elderly hubby with a second job and the young kids is a drip feed.
Another quick answer: get your mobile in your own name pronto. There’s your utility bill. And get access to the online utility accounts.

I dont quite understand this

OP posts:
GellerYeller · 30/07/2023 14:02

apologies I’ve conflated @justasking111 s elderly hubby and your own situation. Hard to keep up x

Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 14:00

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 13:40

it never happens it’s wildly frustrating

For the last hour, myself and other posters have given an hour of our lives trying to help you.

Not once (yet) have you said that any of us are right in advising you to walk away.

You need to change your behaviour, and it's only that which will change your mum's.

Good luck, but I'm not wasting more of my day repeating the same thing . (Because you- maybe like your mum- don't appear to be listening.)

i was missing a lot of the posts because there’s a few. But I do appreciate your support on the matter! And objectively you’re right, of course! It’s objectively thr right thing to do, I do feel bad at the thought however.

OP posts:
GellerYeller · 30/07/2023 13:56

Also the estate agent if audited will fail compliance. This isn’t stacking up either.

Coffeelotsofcoffee · 30/07/2023 13:55

Sounds exactly like my mum.
Does my head in.
A lot of women of that generation aren't practical with money at all

GellerYeller · 30/07/2023 13:55

Any minute now someone will be along to tell us the elderly hubby with a second job and the young kids is a drip feed.
Another quick answer: get your mobile in your own name pronto. There’s your utility bill. And get access to the online utility accounts.

GellerYeller · 30/07/2023 13:52

I agree you’re getting a hard time here. As you can see when posters have drilled into your answers they don’t hold up to scrutiny. Not your fault as this is what your mum has told you.

However, it highlights this: your mum is-whether deliberately or not-withholding material information.
Without it you can’t help.
She didn’t like the financial advisor’s advice. There’s a clue. Probably because it didn’t meet her unrealistic expectations.
If she knows you’re struggling for time, sleep and money yourself and still expects you to step in, that’s a side, but nonetheless important, issue. 💐

Crimeismymiddlename · 30/07/2023 13:51

This sounds like she is seeking attention rather than having actual money worries and that’s why she won’t show you statements. Could it be since your father passed on she is feeling like she needs more from you but won’t ask outright.

drpet49 · 30/07/2023 13:48

theleafandnotthetree · 30/07/2023 09:50

She may be your mother but she sounds a spoilt whiny bellend and I would be giving her very short shrift. In the context of how most people live, I simply couldn't listen to this nonsense. When you think of all the bright talented people across the world who work so hard and who have so little materially in life, that someone this incompetent gets to be this wealthy and entitled just boils my piss.

Amen to this. I would disengage from the crazy woman.

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 13:45

justasking111 · 30/07/2023 13:41

What scares me is online energy bills OH handles those if he starts with dementia I cannot access to change suppliers if their rates go daft. It's all online in his name not a scrap of paper exists.

I do worry because under gdpr no-one will speak to me. He is older than me could be struck down health-wise. We own a house we did let. At the estate agents I could produce a passport, driving license but not one utility bill. Luckily the estate agent was a family friend so let it slide

I think you need to start your own thread on this one @justasking111 !

But as a quick reply, do you not have Power of Attorney set up?
That would allow you to access all accounts in your H' s name if he lost capacity.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 30/07/2023 13:44

OP there is nothing you can do - genuinely there isn’t. What she wants is fir your to replace your DF emotionally & financially. You can never do that. By refusing to allow you to help her by blocking every suggestion you make Abd then literally having a tantrum when you push, shows that it’s not about the money, it’s about the attention.

she isn’t skint, she isn’t going to cancel things, she’s just spoiled, selfish & also, sadly, lonely & a missing your DF

you have to stop engaging. You cannot change her behaviour, you can only change yours. What’s the worst that can happen? She shouts & screams? She does that anyway so you may just as well let her shout & scream at the truth. The more attention you give her, the more she’ll see her way of engaging is working so she’ll keep doing it.

changeforthebetternottheworse · 30/07/2023 13:42

Coming back to this thread after commenting earlier, and reading subsequent comments, I'm actually disgusted by your mother. She's not much older than me and if my husband dies I'll have a lot less than her to live on. But guess what? I'll manage because I live within my means and I will live quite comfortably like that, and certainly have never whined to my daughter about being poor, in fact I've helped her out in times of financial hardship and intend to help her with a deposit when she comes to buy a house (money from savings built up over years).
Your mother's behaviour is utterly distasteful. There are people really struggling and this pitiful woman moans about not being able to take five holiday year.
And I still think you need to investigate Walter Mitty brother, especially given his "golden child" status. Your status in a situation like this is that of scapegoat and I think you need to wise up to the fact that nothing you do will be right in spoilt princessy mother's eyes. You've got a lot more to untangle here than just your mother's finances. I'd be looking for a good counsellor to be honest. How I wish someone could wave a magic wand and have people like your mother live off universal credit for a year!

justasking111 · 30/07/2023 13:41

What scares me is online energy bills OH handles those if he starts with dementia I cannot access to change suppliers if their rates go daft. It's all online in his name not a scrap of paper exists.

I do worry because under gdpr no-one will speak to me. He is older than me could be struck down health-wise. We own a house we did let. At the estate agents I could produce a passport, driving license but not one utility bill. Luckily the estate agent was a family friend so let it slide