Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand what she’s spending it on

516 replies

Idlovetoknow · 29/07/2023 21:58

It’s my mother. She’s a pensioner and a widow, but she working. She cannot deal with her finances. She’s been on the phone tonight weeping over how much of a dire situation she’s in financially, but I don’t see how.

income from work: £1100 (after tax)
state pension: £800
widows pension: £1600 (think this is after tax too)
private pension: £200/300 (she was wooly on this)
so total income around £3600 a month

No mortgage, no rent, no grounds costs.
council tax £200 a month. Power £150 (let’s say 200 to round up) food and pet food £400, car £450 petrol £100, health insurance £200, phone £50, sky £50, pet insurance £80- that’s £1300 at an absolute max

i don’t understand. She’s not being frauded or taken advantage of, but i don’t understand. I try to talk to her for instance tonight when she rang frantic over money but she gets into such a tizz she can’t tell you anything. I’ve asked for months for all bills and bank statements to go over expenses but she can’t produce them

Anyone any ideas?

OP posts:
Peridot1 · 31/07/2023 10:55

She sounds utterly impossible.

Idlovetoknow · 31/07/2023 10:52

FiloPasty · 31/07/2023 10:38

Who organised probate on your dads estate when he died? Would that have given a better view of what the overall financial situation was?

There was no probate, she was named on all the assets. There’s just some outstanding investment she won’t move to her name and cash In because it’s ‘too much, so she just collects the dividends each month.

she let her parents estate rot because she ‘can’t’ do it, the house is as they left it 10 years ago but now in dereliction, and is constantly getting letters from council and environmental health about it. She just destroys them. With 20/30k put into it (about half they had in the bank but again no probate or letter of authority as they died without a will, she’s squandered it) the house could sell for 150/170 easy. But she’d rather waste it than do something.

OP posts:
Idlovetoknow · 31/07/2023 10:47

FarmGirl78 · 31/07/2023 10:39

@Idlovetoknow You've previously been advised by @Hungrycaterpillarsmummy to ask for bank statements and for her to get internet, and if she refuses or is evasive to say "ok well since you won't use internet banking and won't show statements I can't help you. Do not talk to me about any money issue."

But you said that wasn't an answer for you. Why not? What's stopping you saying this to her?

I’ve not said that’s not the answer for me, itd the only logical answer, it’s what we’ve (dh and I) said before, I can try and help but only if I have the facts which is payslips, Bank statements, investments and financial advice reports because unless I have it it’s just guessing, that’s what causes her to go off into a spin and say I’m not helping. To which I’ve said I can’t if you won’t meet me half way, so we can’t more forward until you do. We had this conversation yesterday when she said she was worried the power would go out. She’s £600 in credit

my reason for the thread is she’s claiming she’s got such high outgoings and is being crippled (her words) with tax but I cannot understand why or even how it’s possible. whilst she used to go on lavish holidays, she’s ‘only’ been on 2 fairly average ones this year.

OP posts:
FarmGirl78 · 31/07/2023 10:39

@Idlovetoknow You've previously been advised by @Hungrycaterpillarsmummy to ask for bank statements and for her to get internet, and if she refuses or is evasive to say "ok well since you won't use internet banking and won't show statements I can't help you. Do not talk to me about any money issue."

But you said that wasn't an answer for you. Why not? What's stopping you saying this to her?

FiloPasty · 31/07/2023 10:38

Who organised probate on your dads estate when he died? Would that have given a better view of what the overall financial situation was?

FarmGirl78 · 31/07/2023 10:27

I've only got to page 2 of 3 of your own posts and one thing is very clear.

She is consistently phoning you crying and worrying about money. You have made suggestions to resolve this by asking for her bank statements and pension summaries etc. She is not doing anything to help herself and instead just continues to complain it's all impossible.

You are consistently posting moaning and being frustrated at the situation. We have made suggestions to resolve this by you going up there or asking for her details to set up online banking which you could check. You are not doing anything to actually resolve this and just continue to complain it's all impossible.

One of you has to actually DO something if you want this situation to change. You or her. But you need to DO something.

FictionalCharacter · 31/07/2023 10:22

SouthernLassies · 31/07/2023 08:08

TBH all this delving into her possible tax affairs is ridiculous.

It's not the point.

IF- and it's a big 'if' - her mum feels she is being taxed incorrectly, she needs to talk to HMRC.
End of.

It's just stupid any of us here wondering what's going on.

The OP's Mum is clearly manipulative, doesn't appear to know what's going on with her money- or at least pretending she doesn't.

OP has had bucket loads of sensible advice, which in a nutshell is Step back, don't engage, this is all about control/abuse' and refuse to discuss it

Spot on. This is a selfish, manipulative, financially very comfortable woman who has already seen a professional financial advisor and decided to do the opposite of what they advised. Now she's blaming her daughter for her imagined financial difficulties. But she is absolutely not short of money. She has a good income, chooses to be extravagant and has substantial savings and investments - she isn't running out of money.

All the people here talking about incorrect tax, scams, dementia or that she's grieving or lonely are barking up the wrong tree.

OP you have already spent too much time and emotional energy on her, when you have your own life and family that should be your priority. The only sensible thing to do is disengage and ignore the moaning, but you won't do that. So you've set yourself an impossible task. Your mother demands that you help her but won't let you. If you don't stop letting her play you, you'll have all this anxiety permanently.

Kazzyhoward · 31/07/2023 08:11

@CecilyP

Thats about the long and short of it. Even the most expert financial adviser won’t be able to advise without seeing the finances they are advising on!

Fully agree. I'm an accountant and sometimes get people in very similar situations with multiple income sources, lots of money sloshing around, but wanting help with tax etc. Trouble is that like the OP's mother, they come in with half baked stories and very little documentary evidence as to what's actually happening, so it's impossible to help them. Half the meeting is usually "woe is me" about how they've paid tax all their lives and how unfair it is that they have to pay tax on pensions, la-la-la. I just want to drill down to the detail but they seem to think I can solve their problems with just generic whingeing about how hard done by they are (despite usually having incomes more than an average worker with much lower outgoings and of course no NIC to pay!).

Sometimes they come in with, say, a PAYE coding notice, but it's meaningless without knowing their income levels from each source, which they're usually very vague about. It's often like pulling teeth, you think you're getting somewhere and then suddenly they say "Oh, I also get £1k a month from my teacher's pension" and you're back to square one again because they "can't find" any payslips or PAYE codes for that, so I don't know if it's £1k gross or net etc. Or they say "Oh, and there's the carer's allowance". Sometimes I just want to bang my head against the desk as they're painful to deal with.

Then, of course, you know they're going to moan about the bill as we've had to spend a lot more time than necessary just constantly asking them for the documents we asked for from the outset and then finally having to delve through a small mountain of paperwork, often going back decades, because they couldn't be arsed to sort it out themselves and just dumped a box full on my desk (after about the 20th time I asked for a handful of recent documents, such as last month's bank statement, payslip, and latest PAYE coding notices!)

SouthernLassies · 31/07/2023 08:08

TBH all this delving into her possible tax affairs is ridiculous.

It's not the point.

IF- and it's a big 'if' - her mum feels she is being taxed incorrectly, she needs to talk to HMRC.
End of.

It's just stupid any of us here wondering what's going on.

The OP's Mum is clearly manipulative, doesn't appear to know what's going on with her money- or at least pretending she doesn't.

OP has had bucket loads of sensible advice, which in a nutshell is Step back, don't engage, this is all about control/abuse' and refuse to discuss it

Kazzyhoward · 31/07/2023 07:58

whowhatwerewhy · 30/07/2023 18:40

Ok so I'm no mathematician but-
Income from work £1100 = 1320 taxable ( based on 20% tax )
Pension £800
Widows pension £1600= £1920 taxable
Private pension £200/300 = £240/360 taxable

Income 3700 month-or £52100 taxable year
The fact her taxable income could be @ 52000+ would explain the 40% tax code ?

Without her being transparent and showing you statements you can't help her .
All you can do is tell her sorry you can't help until she shows you bank statements/ pay slips .

Not really. It'd only be 40% higher rate tax on the income over £50k, ie on £2k, not on the full £52k.

SouthernLassies · 31/07/2023 07:50

CecilyP · 30/07/2023 23:34

There is no lump sum for women aged 68 who take their pension later than when they are eligible. I know. I am one of those women (close to your mum's age.)

Southernlassies, just want to check as I got it wrong earlier, but can a woman born after 5 March 1953, who delays claiming still backdate her claim for a year? That would give her £9600 paid at once which, given her other income might push her into higher rate tax.

The quote I included was from an online site on pensions. It's pretty clear. No lump sum is available for women taking a state pension after 2016.

I don't know why the OP is getting bogged down in the detail of this small taxation / pension issue.

It's clear her mum has issues that are not about the money itself, but about seeking attention and abusing her as she did her late husband.

Read some of the insightful posts on this and the family back-story.

thedevilinablackdress · 31/07/2023 07:47

I don't know if it's been mentioned already, but could the recent inflationary rises on the cost of everything be fuelling her panic?

CecilyP · 30/07/2023 23:34

There is no lump sum for women aged 68 who take their pension later than when they are eligible. I know. I am one of those women (close to your mum's age.)

Southernlassies, just want to check as I got it wrong earlier, but can a woman born after 5 March 1953, who delays claiming still backdate her claim for a year? That would give her £9600 paid at once which, given her other income might push her into higher rate tax.

SequentialAnalyst · 30/07/2023 23:34

May I recommend you have a look at the following active thread, where you will find people who understand the toxic family dynamic from which you seem to be suffering:
April 2023 -"Well we took you to Stately Homes" | Mumsnet

I get it about the driving, sorry you've had such a hard time over this.

Brew Brew

MuggleMe · 30/07/2023 23:04

Can you ask her to take a photo of her next statement and send it to you?

Leftbutcameback · 30/07/2023 23:03

The last four posts are spot on. She clearly has a very decent income, doesn’t want to sort out her money problems (even if those problems are just not understanding any of it), and won’t accept practical help. She isn’t going to run out of money and is working and driving a nice car.

You on the other hand OP sounds very busy, and stressed, and need to prioritise yourself in this situation. I like the advice above to nod, and be sympathetic, and then don’t get involved. There’s nothing you can do that you haven’t tried already.

justasking111 · 30/07/2023 22:20

@Idlovetoknow I wish she'd peck your brothers head as she is yours. Next time and every time she calls say

"I'm not discussing your finances any more mum and if you do start I shall end the call"

And mean it. I had to do this. My mum would of course call back again even during the night. She did stop when she realised I just wasn't having it any more

You have a Very busy life she doesn't so has more drama llama energy

Suspific · 30/07/2023 22:13

The more I read the more it sounds like an elderly relative of mine who was cash and time rich but seemed to think me who was cash poor and time poor had to run round helping her or I was a terrible person refusing to help a helpless old lady.

When the reality was I would waste my time finding a new car insurance policy for her and she'd ignore me and ask the man who owns the local garage who had so little information to go on he just recommended she stick with her current insurer. Which literally ended up costing her thousands. So I understand how infuriating it is for someone to go against the advice you take the time to work out for them. Ignoring the financial advisor must have been a huge mistake for her and it does sound like she wants you to do it all so she can blame you. My elderly relative wasted thousands on solicitors advice and just said she wouldn't use them again rather than me try and work out what was useful. She just moved to another solicitor and the previous advice was wasted. Although I at least got to speak to the new solicitor so the advice was more useful.

It's infuriating but I ended up saying not my circus not my monkeys and she ended up using other random people in her life for advice (like the butcher I kid you not) and I gave up worrying about it as it was her money to waste. It was also a case of her veering from crying about all these problems heaped on her and burying her head in the sand (which resulted in the problems of course) And repeat.

You have my sympathy. Would nodding along and saying that does sound tough, that does sound hard, well if you feel you must cancel them then you should help you manage this situation for your wellbeing? Remember her circumstances are not your fault and not your problem.

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 22:04

But I think you’re right, I think that’s what she’s done, she deferred her pension and then took a lump sum, she was very specific in that it’s state pension.

Given that your mum hardly knows what day of the week it is( regarding her money) I'm sure she is wrong.

There is no lump sum for women aged 68 who take their pension later than when they are eligible. I know. I am one of those women (close to your mum's age.)

She could have deferred her occupational pension, from her job she still has. Occupational pensions pay out a lump sum (whether you take them early , on time, or late.)

Anyway OP it's not your role to sort this out.
Your Mum is an adult. There is no way I'd burden any of my children with this or behave as she is.

You need to let go of it.

CecilyP · 30/07/2023 20:45

Sorry for the confusion OP. Southernlassies will correct me if I’m wrong, but I think point 2 is still valid in that you can backdate your claim for up to a year from the date of your claim. This would lead to a less substantial lump sum being paid. However as your mum has so much other income, the sum could put her in the higher rate tax bracket in the year that it is paid.

The reality is your mum has a high income and no mortgage or rent to pay. She really should have no financial worries. And she definitely shouldn’t be burdening you when you’ve a young family to look after.

Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 20:32

CecilyP · 30/07/2023 20:12

Sorry cross post, Southernlassies, I didn’t realise that the lump sum had been done away with for younger pensioners. So, the enhanced pension for deferring would bring her state pension up to over £800 per month. This is another source of income that OP doesn’t know about. The 2 payments would be shown separately on the bank statements OP has not been able see.

OP, please ignore point 3 on my previous post.

But I think you’re right, I think that’s what she’s done, she deferred her pension and then took a lump sum, she was very specific in that it’s state pension.

I’m confused

OP posts:
CecilyP · 30/07/2023 20:12

Sorry cross post, Southernlassies, I didn’t realise that the lump sum had been done away with for younger pensioners. So, the enhanced pension for deferring would bring her state pension up to over £800 per month. This is another source of income that OP doesn’t know about. The 2 payments would be shown separately on the bank statements OP has not been able see.

OP, please ignore point 3 on my previous post.

CecilyP · 30/07/2023 20:03

Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 18:45

I think this is it, I don’t quite understand how tax all works to have a grasp on it but she’s blaming me because i couldn’t tell her what to do, and said she needed a FA, she saw an FA and did the opposite of what he said

i think she’s paying 40% on her paye salary but I think she drew the lump sum last tax year

In a way, there’s not really any right or wrong answer when claiming delayed state pension. Not without a crystal ball to know your life expectancy.

There’s 3 choices

1 Take from the date of your claim, then your pension will be more than £800 per month
2 Backdate for a year; again you’ll get more than £800 but not so much more
3 Take the backdated pension as a lump sum, which given other income is likely to put you in the higher rate tax bracket

However, that would only apply to last year in that was when she claimed.

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 19:58

@CecilyP Her mum would not be eligible for a lump sum if she deferred her pension.

A lump sum is only available if you reached state pension age before 6 April 2016.

so, 7 years ago she'd be 61.

She could have an enhanced pension but the £800 a month suggests she doesn't.

It's all a bit irrelevant anyway isn't it as the OP isn't an FA and she has never seen her mum's paperwork.

PeloMom · 30/07/2023 19:58

when I my mother was like that eventually came out she was putting money in MLMs and pyramid schemes