Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand what she’s spending it on

516 replies

Idlovetoknow · 29/07/2023 21:58

It’s my mother. She’s a pensioner and a widow, but she working. She cannot deal with her finances. She’s been on the phone tonight weeping over how much of a dire situation she’s in financially, but I don’t see how.

income from work: £1100 (after tax)
state pension: £800
widows pension: £1600 (think this is after tax too)
private pension: £200/300 (she was wooly on this)
so total income around £3600 a month

No mortgage, no rent, no grounds costs.
council tax £200 a month. Power £150 (let’s say 200 to round up) food and pet food £400, car £450 petrol £100, health insurance £200, phone £50, sky £50, pet insurance £80- that’s £1300 at an absolute max

i don’t understand. She’s not being frauded or taken advantage of, but i don’t understand. I try to talk to her for instance tonight when she rang frantic over money but she gets into such a tizz she can’t tell you anything. I’ve asked for months for all bills and bank statements to go over expenses but she can’t produce them

Anyone any ideas?

OP posts:
RosesAndHellebores · 30/07/2023 06:40

MIL was widowed at 70. She has ferretted money her whole life and it would be nice to see her spend it. She lives very poor. However, despite being a former HT she does not and will not deal with her finances. FIL did all that. She will not and has not opened the post since he died (except cards and stuff). DH visits monthly to keep her organised and has PoA.

iloveeverykindofcat · 30/07/2023 06:18

If you're positive there's no gambling/compulsive shopping/alcohol addiction, this sounds more like a mental health thing than real financial problems.

MRex · 30/07/2023 06:17

Debt is possible, she might not be calling it credit card debt. It's also possible she's still paying into savings accounts and thinks she's needs to do that. It's also possible she's giving your brother money, but doesn't count that as he isn't just "someone". It's also possible she's spending money on handbags and then panicking. It has dementia. We can't solve this for you without more info, any more than you can solve it for her. You'll need to spend a weekend with her and sort out what the problem is.

Hollyhobbi · 30/07/2023 03:53

OP if your mother is really short of money or in debt, she has another house she can sell or let out!

Twillow · 30/07/2023 03:51

With the best will in the world, because you sound like an extremely tolerant and rational person, have you considered absolutely losing your shit with her? Nothing else has had any impact so far and while you risk her wrath and self-pity, there is a - albeit slight - chance that she may reflect on how fortunate she actually is and how it might be necessary to curtail her frivolous spending somewhat - you know, like normal people do...Flowers

OssieShowman · 30/07/2023 03:01

Sit her down. Make a spreadsheet showing outgoings and incoming.

maybe find a budget app to help her.
or banks offer financial counselling.

sheworemellowyellow · 30/07/2023 02:56

I don’t know what’s going on with your DM, OP, but honestly you have the patience of a saint putting up with her. She’s sounds totally insufferable. How have you not either washed your hands of her, or told her to grow up and deal with her problems herself??! You deserve a medal, truly.

KickAssAngel · 30/07/2023 02:52

Honestly, it sounds like she's struggling to adjust to being alone and making financial decisions. she also sounds like she's trying to manipulate you. I think you need to start cutting off those conversations. Just say that unless she's willing to let you see bank statements there's no point in even talking about it.

user1492757084 · 30/07/2023 02:26

You need to go with her for a financial discussion with her bank or financial advisor. She should know how her statement looks and how everything is managed.
You need to know as well so you are of assistance and reassurance. Your mother could be missing out on superannuation top ups or other tax reducing payments.
Make the appointment, with her blessing, and go with her.

It also could be that she is being taken advantage of.
Does she pay a finaincial advisor?
Do donations come automatically out of her account for charities that she can no longer afford?

rivercobbler · 30/07/2023 01:58

I wonder if she expects you to give her money. It sounds like the wailing and moaning it is a tactic she is deploying to get money even though there is no hope of it working, just because she doesn't have any other weapons in her arsenal.

I would stop worrying about her, tbh. She's loaded, and being histrionic for no reason. If she wanted to change, she would, but she wants a solution where she doesn't have to think or take responsibility.

SmileyClare · 30/07/2023 01:52

Trying2understand · 30/07/2023 01:37

Both I and my mum have a friend each like this. They are loaded. It's crying over what they expected to have/the privilege they are used to, vs. their still very privileged reality.

If there's no other issue at hand, I'd say that's likely it.

It’s rather grating in the current climate to hear op’s mum crying about money whilst also enjoying two holidays abroad, shopping in boutiques, dripping in jewellery and treating herself to a new car every year to park outside her enormous house. No wonder she’s fallen out with some of her friends!

And Since when is a 60 year old classed as “elderly” ?

No doubt the loss of her husband is contributing to her current meltdowns/anxiety. I very much doubt this is early onset dementia which is incredibly rare.
More likely she’s never had to consider the cost of anything (as 99% of the population do) and doesn’t like it.

Trying2understand · 30/07/2023 01:37

Both I and my mum have a friend each like this. They are loaded. It's crying over what they expected to have/the privilege they are used to, vs. their still very privileged reality.

If there's no other issue at hand, I'd say that's likely it.

Sugarfree23 · 30/07/2023 01:22

You can't be sure she isn't being defrauded unless you check her statements - all bank and credit cards (which might be set up to automatically pay).

Credit card fraud can happen to anyone. And if they get away with it they'll keep doing it.

Elderly women especially are pray for your roofs got damaged £500 from me to fix it, type fraud too.

PrincessFiorimonde · 30/07/2023 01:03

Idlovetoknow · 29/07/2023 23:12

It’s the effort, she just doesn’t want to shop around she’d rather bury her head in the sand and it’s the same with money.

she’s better now but she’s always been like this, you got her the wrong thing for x mas and she’d flip out and not talk to you or get very nasty. You had to buy all her x mas list etc

she might be lonely she fell out with a friend last week because a family friend (of the friend) died so said friend had to rearrange their plans. Without divulging too much, I was the ‘evil’ child growing up, the golden one is Walter Mitty and will only talk to you if you’ve got something to offer him, so he doesn’t engage with her unless he wants something. I do try my best but it’s actually very difficult with her, it always ends up my fault somehow

I'm sorry, OP, but please re-read what you have written here and think about what you would say if you had a good friend who said this to you.

Please also re-read what @BusMumsHoliday wrote above: On the other hand, you could just... Let her get on with it. You sound like you find your mum difficult, and you're not obliged to help her sort this out. She's not in danger of being homeless and it sounds like bills are being paid. What happens if you stop trying to sort it and just say, "hmm sounds tough," and change the subject? (My guess is she might find something else to fret about so this isn't about money at all.)

The bottom line is that your mother seems in no danger of being skint. She just seems to be trying to claim your attention.

Sittingonasale · 30/07/2023 00:43

ilyana · 30/07/2023 00:40

Not necessarily.

Someone who has been spoiled and cosseted their entire life might genuinely feel poor if they suddenly have to ever actually think about money at all.

My friend's mother lives in a mortgage-free, four-bed detached house, retired at 57, having only started working at 40ish after kids, and genuinely thinks she's poor because she can't just book holidays to Florida without even thinking about it anymore.

My friend is a millennial who graduated into the recession, works 60 hours a week, her husband does the same, they're barely scraping by in a two-bed flat, their tiny baby is always at nursery because they work so much, and her mother genuinely believes she's worse off than they are. It was my friend's birthday the other week, her mother took her out for dinner and spent the entire meal commenting on how expensive it was until my friend lost her temper and just ended up paying the entire bill. Lots of them are like this. It's not dementia, it's self absorption, entitlement, stinginess, and cruelty.

Exactly and many have histrionic personality disorder! 😅
OP already said her mum was abusive towards her dad. What comes around, goes around. I wouldn't want tk visit either!

EmmrT · 30/07/2023 00:42

This is so similar to my MIL!

Turned out she was spending a fortune buying jewellery off TV channels.

She said she only bought the odd necklace or earrings, but in reality it was loads. One ring cost £450!

She spends a ridiculous amount on plants too.

Bonfire23 · 30/07/2023 00:42

ThereIbledit · 29/07/2023 23:48

At risk of stating the bloody obvious, if she wants your help she can jolly well find those bank statements and gather everything up for you to be able to look at. She might be acting like a teenager but she isn't, and she can get onto the banks to order replacements if she chooses to.

If she won't send them to you, you can't help.

That ^^
My mum used to ring me crying about pain she was in. Wouldn't take painkillers though or ring the doctor
I ended up saying unless she had seen the doctor and taken painkillers, I didn't want to hear anything about it

ilyana · 30/07/2023 00:40

jgjgjgjgjg · 30/07/2023 00:01

I echo the concerns about potential early dementia. She may have seen or read something about the cost of living crisis and become obsessed with the idea.

Not necessarily.

Someone who has been spoiled and cosseted their entire life might genuinely feel poor if they suddenly have to ever actually think about money at all.

My friend's mother lives in a mortgage-free, four-bed detached house, retired at 57, having only started working at 40ish after kids, and genuinely thinks she's poor because she can't just book holidays to Florida without even thinking about it anymore.

My friend is a millennial who graduated into the recession, works 60 hours a week, her husband does the same, they're barely scraping by in a two-bed flat, their tiny baby is always at nursery because they work so much, and her mother genuinely believes she's worse off than they are. It was my friend's birthday the other week, her mother took her out for dinner and spent the entire meal commenting on how expensive it was until my friend lost her temper and just ended up paying the entire bill. Lots of them are like this. It's not dementia, it's self absorption, entitlement, stinginess, and cruelty.

Sittingonasale · 30/07/2023 00:38

Clementin50 · 29/07/2023 23:01

Op I mean this kindly but I think you are getting drawn into her craziness here. You might find a reason in her bank statements if you get a chance to look at the hard facts and figures, but I suspect this is more a combination of:

Never managing her money as an adult, ever.
Your father's income drop.
Her wildly unrealistic understanding of how much is "skint".
Some sort of mental disorder, whether that's in built or new, who knows.

I'm not joking about the mental disorder comment - if she can't understand how to shop around for better deals on stuff like insurance, fair play if she struggles with the internet, but come on - my 85 year old gran understands enough to ring up a call center to get an insurance quote! And the first class tickets and many,many holidays and demands for you to fix her financial situation.. despite having a post-tax income many working people would dream of!

Honestly it sounds like a mix of a deep seated mental health issue which has been exacerbated by your father's passing, and now she's turning to you to indulge her craziness, without actually having a genuine problem or any information supplied that you could use to help her.

Is she possibly also lonely on top?

What's REALLY going on here?
Why is she putting you in this position when your job, your children should be your focus?
Why is she demanding more than a rational Share of your energy?

It sounds exhausting.

I agree with this.
I have a similar mother who never worked but lived very well off my father's income, then pension when he died. She's recently downsized from 4 bed to 3 bed (only for her) but it's already proved too small so she had a massive orangery put on, ripped out the brand new kitchen to put on another extension and brand new kitchen. New roof, new windows etc....

..... Then she claimed for a free boiler on the boiler scheme. She waited 6 months to do this until the building works had finished and she'd paid them before claiming she was skint.

My skint and her skint are very different things and Frankly I get fed up of hearing how bad off she is.

PilsAwfulDilemna · 30/07/2023 00:36

@Ihateslugs

My parent didn't have dementia but also couldn't keep one top of affairs, too old, too tired and ill.

I believe as a moral duty all big companies trim gas to banks to sky need special older people teams to give proper assistance.

I've found out parent also was nt receiving money they should have been due to silly errors by pension people.

Unfortunately they thought they weret doing OK and didn't ask for help.

PilsAwfulDilemna · 30/07/2023 00:32

Op at some point you will have to go and look at her actual papers.

She wants to moan but doesn't want solutions.
Tell her this and you want to help but can't without seeing actual evidence and figures.

changeforthebetternottheworse · 30/07/2023 00:26

Your mother sounds like she's never really been a good mother to you. And her behaviour is that of a reckless child. Spoilt, selfish and manipulative. I'd be telling her straight, either you let us see your statements or you are on your own. You sound very caught up in fear, obligation and guilt. I'd put good money on Walter Mitty brother bleeding her dry, it's quite a common scenario. I have a friend whose sister conned their dad out of £100k. And I've heard of two other instances amongst acquaintances.

SmileyClare · 30/07/2023 00:25

jgjgjgjgjg · 30/07/2023 00:01

I echo the concerns about potential early dementia. She may have seen or read something about the cost of living crisis and become obsessed with the idea.

Worth consideration but let’s bear in mind that early onset dementia is incredibly rare. It affects less than 0.5% of people under 65years.

justasking111 · 30/07/2023 00:14

Well if you're a single parent you're a bit stuck re visiting which is what you need to do really.

Our neighbours are like this now, husband who did everything has had a stroke so now all the online stuff he did is a mystery to his wife. Between them his daughter who lives away and my OH have managed to sort everything out . The shock of a sick husband was the first priority but then it was all the income and outgoings.

Some women get into a pickle because their husbands did everything. My friend had never even put fuel in her car. Then her husband had a breakdown. Was in a private clinic for months. She grew up fast that year

Ihateslugs · 30/07/2023 00:08

My mum got in a right mess with her finances when she was in the early stages of dementia and my siblings and I tried to help her sort out the different accounts and direct debits etc but it was difficult. In the end, I went round when she was out ( my brother took her out for lunch) and rooted through her drawers, cupboards and filing cabinets to find details of all her accounts and investments - far more that I expected! I took photos of all the latest statements to go through at home and took away some old statements that went back years as they were mixed up with current ones and adding to mums confusion.

I found she had a number of unnecessary direct debits such as extended warranties for appliances she no longer had, along with three policies for Sky box insurance when she did not have Sky! I used my Power of Attorney with her bank to cancel them all and also closed some old accounts that she no longer used.

my issues were different to yours in that she did have plenty of money even though she thought she didn’t but she could no longer manage the paperwork due to her increasing confusion and memory loss. But the only was for us to help was to resort to subterfuge and ferreting around when she was out. She never knew and as her dementia advanced, the worry over bank statements became forgotten and replaced by other obsessions but I am so glad that I made copies of all important paperwork as by the time she went into a care home, most of it had disappeared from the house!