Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand what she’s spending it on

516 replies

Idlovetoknow · 29/07/2023 21:58

It’s my mother. She’s a pensioner and a widow, but she working. She cannot deal with her finances. She’s been on the phone tonight weeping over how much of a dire situation she’s in financially, but I don’t see how.

income from work: £1100 (after tax)
state pension: £800
widows pension: £1600 (think this is after tax too)
private pension: £200/300 (she was wooly on this)
so total income around £3600 a month

No mortgage, no rent, no grounds costs.
council tax £200 a month. Power £150 (let’s say 200 to round up) food and pet food £400, car £450 petrol £100, health insurance £200, phone £50, sky £50, pet insurance £80- that’s £1300 at an absolute max

i don’t understand. She’s not being frauded or taken advantage of, but i don’t understand. I try to talk to her for instance tonight when she rang frantic over money but she gets into such a tizz she can’t tell you anything. I’ve asked for months for all bills and bank statements to go over expenses but she can’t produce them

Anyone any ideas?

OP posts:
LIZS · 30/07/2023 08:56

Maybe the col increases have scared her, utility bills, food shop, insurance premiums etc. Lots of media hype can create anxiety if her income is fixed . She could officially nominate you to be able to make enquiries of bank, suppliers and so on on her behalf.

ThanksItHasPockets · 30/07/2023 08:52

This sounds like a very difficult situation, OP, but I am not sure how helpful the conjecture on this thread can be for you.

I understand your reluctance to do this but unless you are going to cut her off the only course of action is to clear a weekend, leave the children with your DP and go and stay with her to go through absolutely everything. Only then will you know whether there is a genuine issue, or gambling, or fraud, or whether this is manipulation for attention that you can safely ignore with a clearer conscience.

PermanentTemporary · 30/07/2023 08:50

No, you can use POA to do some things but not everything for a person financially, because I've done it. The person giving the power needs to tick the right box on the POA form.

We'd done POA years before and with her permission once she was struggling I started with a debit card and my own Internet login for my mum's bank account so that when she rang me in a panic about her affairs I could have a look at the statement and discuss it with her. I could also do a bit of legwork to pay bills if she wanted me to.

You can also if necessary provide evidence that they have permanently lost mental capacity for all financial decisions, and the bank will stop the person's access to their own bank account. I've never bothered to do that as following my mother's devastating stroke she is no longer capable of contacting her bank at all so there's no risk.

Honestly though in this case I would think very hard before taking that on. I think you'd be tearing your hair out very rapidly.

FANCHEA · 30/07/2023 08:47

Gambling? It's the panic and deseration that makes me think gambling.

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 08:44

How and why does she own another house?
Is it hers or was it in her name and your father's?

If there is another house that is just 'rotting' as you say, that needs sorting out.

Honestly, you need to be firmer. Either she accepts proper help, or you close down those conversations when she gets upset.

From what you have said, she sounds hopeless with money if she went against the advice of her financial advisor.

Is it possible she has another man around? All those 'singles' holidays (on her own) that were luxury holidays. That sounds quite odd to be honest.

Missingmyusername · 30/07/2023 08:39

She doesn’t show you her bank statements, so there are things she doesn’t want you to see. Whether it’s a QVC habit! Or savings or both. If she goes out, goes on holiday she could easily spend a lot on clothes.

In one hand and out the other. £50k should be ample for someone with no rent or mortgage and living in a property with that ctax banding for god sake!

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 08:33

she won’t be able to manage downsizing mentally. She’s got another house she just let rot because it’s too much, she won’t be able to sort out getting a valuation and packing up the house, it’s too much for her.

Have I understood this OP?

She also owns another house that has fallen into disrepair and can't be bothered to sell it?

In all honesty, she sounds very immature and just incapable.

I think what you are getting is attention-seeking drama.

It's not about the money.
It's about 'poor me'- meaning she can't make financial decisions and is looking for some sympathy.

Also, don't underestimate how grief might affect her.

I am not sure from your posts but it appears your Dad died 2 years ago just before retiring. Sorry for that.

You need to be firm with her. Put your foot down.

Say- Look, Mum, I am happy to help with your finances but we need to work on this together. I will come over at (x time) at the weekend and you need to get all your bank statements out or set up the internet so I can see your online banking. If you aren't willing to do that, then I can't help and I am asking you to stop complaining about how you can't manage.'

DivineLillith · 30/07/2023 08:27

You need to just get the statements and sit and look through everything. Wondering and fretting will solve nothing.

We did this with MIL at Christmas, we managed to cut her budget, she could have cut it further but she won’t. Real issue is in the past from childhood till she stopped working she was really very well off. I do wonder is she has lost sense of money as well. I have known her for 30 years and she always give me 25 quid for my birthday, she is on a fixed income now, I don’t even need her 25 quid but in her head it’s probably still a decent amount.

My MIL version of poor is also not really poor but it’s all relative to what you are used to.

littleblackcat27 · 30/07/2023 08:27

MutantTurtles · 29/07/2023 22:25

My DP have an income of £4000 a month and spend it ok
mid 80s- not extravagant spending

Yeah sure - spending £4k a month between 2 people is not extravagant? Gulp.

I know I'm just a pleb - but that seems quite a massive amount of money to me for 2 people with very little outgoings. Perhaps you live in St Johns Wood though.

Intercrapper · 30/07/2023 08:25

Subscriptions…..

Anothernamethesamegame · 30/07/2023 08:23

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 08:22

The only other option is to get her to give you power of attorney and access to her financial setup without her having to be involved at every step

POA only works if the person is unable to make decisions themselves (no capacity) OR has given express permission for their attorneys to take over their decisions.

And if the other person is willing to take on that huge task.

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 08:22

The only other option is to get her to give you power of attorney and access to her financial setup without her having to be involved at every step

POA only works if the person is unable to make decisions themselves (no capacity) OR has given express permission for their attorneys to take over their decisions.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 30/07/2023 08:21

Magenta65 · 30/07/2023 07:59

You see her every week? Then you sit her down and log into her baking, or take her to the bank for statements. And simply say until you see the statements and can figure out where the problem lies you won’t discuss finances anymore. She’s spending somewhere, I’m inclined to think she’s living outside her means. £50 here and there added onto t@he shopping for a new top etc soon adds up. She’s likely not skint as her income suggests she can manage this but you need the proof. Put your foot down and don’t engage with it until she provides it. We have a similar family member, she’s minted just most of its in savings (easily accessed) but she frets

I think this is a good idea. You cannot ultimately give her any real help unless she's willing to show you her finances. At most it would be advice that may be irrelevant and that she won't take anyway. Then once you know what's happening, if you still want to be involved with resolving the problem, if there actually is one, that's up to you.

PermanentTemporary · 30/07/2023 08:20

I think given your relationship and her personality, trying to sort this yourself is a non-starter. I'd practice saying 'oh dear, that sounds very hard, poor you' and suggest she goes into a bank branch to get advice, or possibly Step Change.

The only other option is to get her to give you power of attorney and access to her financial setup without her having to be involved at every step. That sounds like it would be painfully difficult, plus if your brother kicked off and asked for equal access there might be a risk he'd start helping himself from the account?

Blondeshavemorefun · 30/07/2023 08:16

You need to go and see her. Look at her accounts online /take her to a bank and get statements for past 6mrhs

Till you look you don't know

Her poor doesn't sound like my poor

Iyswim

Look to see if any cash is take out and find out what it's for

She's prob spending money and not releising it

Holidays are costly

Flights are double what we paid before covid now

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 08:10

income from work: £1100 (after tax)
state pension: £800
widows pension: £1600 (think this is after tax too)
private pension: £200/300 (she was wooly on this)
so total income around £3600 a month

This is £43K pa.

She can't be struggling.

Something else is going on.

Where does she work?

I assume her own private pension is from another job and she was able to access her pension at 60, but it still working in another type of job now?

Peridot1 · 30/07/2023 08:10

It sounds incredibly frustrating but I think the only way you will get to the bottom of it all is to go to her and physically get all the paperwork, statements etc. Maybe then bring it back to yours so you can have time to go through it all. Then get her over to talk about it and put in place any cancellations or internet banking etc that will make it easier.

She sounds quite spoilt and selfish and if your father did everything about money she is probably feeling overwhelmed and panicky. My mother would have been the same. Never did anything financial. Dad did it all.

Pringleface · 30/07/2023 08:08

Are you the poster who keeps posting about your Walter Mitty brother asking for money for random stuff like handwriting tests?

What relationship does he have with your mother? Is she giving him money? It strikes me that you seem quite enmeshed in the financial affairs of family members.

DarkWingDuck · 30/07/2023 08:06

I would sit down and do a budget with her when she’s not in a tizz. No one can think straight when they are stressed and all over the place. You won’t get any straight answers then.

Yes, objectively she is had a lot income (from my perspective) but try not to bring that up or shame her. Anytime can get in a tizz with money regardless of income. None of us are taught it, it’s hard to figure out and quite stressful.

It’s great that you both have a relationship where you can talk about these things though. I try and empower her rather than do it for her, though- you don’t want to find yourself responsible for her budgeting. That’s a stress on you.
Good luck

BendingSpoons · 30/07/2023 08:06

When you said you fixed her energy bills, the fixed rate is the unit amount and the direct debit. It doesn't generally mean she can use what she likes. We have a 4 bed detached and were building up a large debt with the energy company over winter, as our bills were more like £600 a month and the direct debit was £120ish. Obviously we made the decision to have our heating on, but your mum may have done the same and had to pay some large chunks for that. I appreciate that doesn't fully explain it though. But just generally if you are used to not thinking about what you are spending, you are likely to pay more for everything.

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 08:06

Without seeing her bank statements, you simply don't know.

I'm querying the £450 a month for a car- is this a credit payment or for fuel?

I'd be asking to see her bank statements and investments, but I'd also look at this another way.

Is she crying for help and using the money as a red herring?

Is she depressed?
Is she mentally unstable?

What work does she do?
If she is getting her state pension she must be at least 67.

She has a LOT of money close to £40K a year.
Yes, she will be paying tax on this, so there is its net value to consider.

Can't you go and visit and ask to see the paperwork?

grannycake · 30/07/2023 08:05

I took on power of attorney for my MIL when she was increasingly anxious about money - she was confused (mainly due to untreated UTIs.

Her state pension was paid into a PO account and she hadn't ised it for at least 10 years - £48000.00 sitting there paying no interest. She also had multiple direct debits to the same charities - four for cancer research and six for Dogs Trust. I think she would see an ad on TV and donate forgetting she had already set up DDs. She had mobile phone contracts for phones she no longer had and her house insurance which was auto renewed was absolutely extortionate. Her widows pension from my FIL had been stopped as she hadn't replied to letters asking if she was still alive.

It could be something like this

Hallmark1234 · 30/07/2023 08:04

Is saying she's broke a ploy to get you to give her money?

My mother was poor, but hardly had any outgoings as everything was paid for (rent, coucil tax), but was still feckless with money. She would spend all her money in one week, despite knowing a phone or gas bill would be due every 3 months and would never budget to cover those bills, but would get upset and look to the family to help her out!

Fancylike · 30/07/2023 08:01

It does sounds like she’s attention-seeking a bit - she doesn’t actually want/need help as evidenced by not providing her statements. But she does want the soothing noises and sympathetic for her supposed predicament.

There could be a shopping addiction in there too. My Nan had a great pension and monthly income, but when she died it turned out she was in debt and her cupboards were full of bags and bags of expensive bags and clothes, all with tags and some moths setting up shop. The shed had KitchenAids in every colour, rusted to hell! Such a waste of money and we had no idea.

Magenta65 · 30/07/2023 07:59

You see her every week? Then you sit her down and log into her baking, or take her to the bank for statements. And simply say until you see the statements and can figure out where the problem lies you won’t discuss finances anymore. She’s spending somewhere, I’m inclined to think she’s living outside her means. £50 here and there added onto t@he shopping for a new top etc soon adds up. She’s likely not skint as her income suggests she can manage this but you need the proof. Put your foot down and don’t engage with it until she provides it. We have a similar family member, she’s minted just most of its in savings (easily accessed) but she frets

Swipe left for the next trending thread