Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand what she’s spending it on

516 replies

Idlovetoknow · 29/07/2023 21:58

It’s my mother. She’s a pensioner and a widow, but she working. She cannot deal with her finances. She’s been on the phone tonight weeping over how much of a dire situation she’s in financially, but I don’t see how.

income from work: £1100 (after tax)
state pension: £800
widows pension: £1600 (think this is after tax too)
private pension: £200/300 (she was wooly on this)
so total income around £3600 a month

No mortgage, no rent, no grounds costs.
council tax £200 a month. Power £150 (let’s say 200 to round up) food and pet food £400, car £450 petrol £100, health insurance £200, phone £50, sky £50, pet insurance £80- that’s £1300 at an absolute max

i don’t understand. She’s not being frauded or taken advantage of, but i don’t understand. I try to talk to her for instance tonight when she rang frantic over money but she gets into such a tizz she can’t tell you anything. I’ve asked for months for all bills and bank statements to go over expenses but she can’t produce them

Anyone any ideas?

OP posts:
icelolly99 · 30/07/2023 10:13

My first thought was is she the victim of some sort of romance fraud....

Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 10:13

mrsnoodle55 · 30/07/2023 07:22

This may have already been said, but how is she getting both a widow’s pension and her own state pension?

Pre 2017 I believe you got the widows pension until you reached pensionable age yourself (this happened to my mum; she received my dad’s ‘widow’s pension’ which then stopped when she hit 65, and was replaced by her own state pension). Post 2017 I think you get widow’s pension for 18 months following the death of a spouse, but it’s only for this short duration of time.

Is she definitely still getting both? Apologies if this has already been highlighted.

She’s definitely getting both because she was crying that she only gets half over my dads pension and it’s not enough, she’s only just started claiming state pension. She had a lump sum for that too for deferring it, and I think it’s caused tax problems for her and I think this could be issue, she went against financial advise

OP posts:
marmaladegranny · 30/07/2023 10:12

Is she getting demands from HMRC for income tax? There are odd rules about not being able to take tax due from pensions. My spouse’s pension is taxed at source to the maximum permitted but I still get a massive bill each year from HMRC. It does take a few years to sort out after the spouse’s death and might be enough to panic her.
Also do not be dismissive about the possibility of her drinking - after DF died DM had 4 people regularly buying her bottles of whisky and presumably drinking them all! She was tiny and when she broke her hip the hospital doctor said she was severely malnourished and dependent on alcohol, first we knew about it and it took several years to wean her off it.

Summersunshineplease · 30/07/2023 10:12

LividHot · 29/07/2023 22:02

She’s raking it in!!!

Is she perhaps one of these who frets if her savings go below £300k or something?

That's like my mum
Income after tax around 1500 pounds a month
Then she has 20k in savings and 8k in a current account.
She receives a pension from my dad because he died.
No rent or mortgage to pay. House was worth 295k in 2018.
But she isn't satisfied unless she can save and save and doesn't seem to understand life costs money

Her energy bill is 150 a month
Council tax 150
Sky 69
Other small bills
Phone 10 a month.

She still doesn't think she can afford life

GellerYeller · 30/07/2023 10:05

Sorry I’ve only skim read but:
How has she been getting 5 x 2 week holidays from work annually? That’s 50 days annual leave. Are some unpaid?
5x 5 star first class flight holidays could easily be costing five figures each- surely that’s from savings not monthly salary?
Why doesn’t she have to worry about servicing the car because she only keeps them 3 years? Is she not servicing them or is it included in her lease?
Apologies if I’m being thick or missed something.

LIZS · 30/07/2023 10:04

Might she be caught in a romance scam, but too embarrassed to admit it. Or online gaming/bingo for company.

Mutinyonthecrunchie · 30/07/2023 10:01

Meant to add, I too, was wondering about gambling or something similar on line. She's not going to admit to it if that was the case and would deny it was happening. Bank statements would give answers to a lot of this.
An addict or cheating person will often speak out against something that they are supposedly totally dislike but are using it as a smoke screen for what is really happening.

Mutinyonthecrunchie · 30/07/2023 09:57

I don't understand the lack of bank statements, does she bank online? If she has paper statements they must be in the house somewhere.
Then there's the aspect of 'running the show' at her job, she holds it together there but can't cope with her personal matters.

JbytheSea · 30/07/2023 09:56

Indecisivename · 29/07/2023 22:00

Was also going to suggest gambling or maybe alcohol problem ?

Alcohol too cheap to explain this! You can can wine for £3 a bottle so even 3 bottles a day is only £63 a week so cannot explain the spending.

gambling yes

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 09:54

LIZS · 30/07/2023 09:22

@SouthernLassies I agree but if she is overreacting and hysterical there may be an underlying mh condition or physical illness affecting her ability to rationalise , impulse control and make sensible decisions,

@LIZS Let's hope not because she is still working in a sales environment! EEK!
And driving a posh car which she changes every 3 years.

Honestly, as a woman roughly her age it really annoys me that women of my generation who burned their bras, clamoured for equality, can be so flipping useless (perhaps) when it comes to looking after themselves on £43Kpa!

It's either all emotional blackmail or she's led a charmed life where she's never ever had to budget and is now panicking that she hasn't enough money.

MichelleScarn · 30/07/2023 09:50

YetAnotherSpartacus · 30/07/2023 09:26

Your mother sounds like she's never really been a good mother to you. And her behaviour is that of a reckless child. Spoilt, selfish and manipulative. I'd be telling her straight, either you let us see your statements or you are on your own. You sound very caught up in fear, obligation and guilt. I'd put good money on Walter Mitty brother bleeding her dry, it's quite a common scenario. I have a friend whose sister conned their dad out of £100k. And I've heard of two other instances amongst acquaintances.

This.

Agree, is she used to being the damsel in distress and your dad was her rescuer so she needs a new one? So her expectation is you will come along and take care of the boring things like bills and general cost of living for her and she doesn't have to use her savings and she can go back to enjoying her 1st class, 5 star fun?

theleafandnotthetree · 30/07/2023 09:50

She may be your mother but she sounds a spoilt whiny bellend and I would be giving her very short shrift. In the context of how most people live, I simply couldn't listen to this nonsense. When you think of all the bright talented people across the world who work so hard and who have so little materially in life, that someone this incompetent gets to be this wealthy and entitled just boils my piss.

Wafflesandcrepes · 30/07/2023 09:40

She seems quite typical of someone who’s gone through life without having to look after financial matters. We once nearly called the financial regulator as MIL swore blind her mortgage was GBP 5,000 a month. We thought she and FIL had got conned. When we spoke to FIL, we discovered mortgage was GBP 500 a month. 🙄 I expect MIL will be incapable of managing anything if something were to happen to FIL.

Your mum’s version of poor is different to most people’s. She’s incredibly well off. Again this is quite common. My MIL says SIL (huge house, two luxury cars, kids in private schools) is poor and has no luxuries and often cries about it. 🙄

Nevetheless, I’d go through her accounts with her, and get her checked out for dementia, just in case. I wouldn’t seek POA if I were you (unless she has dementia). I’ve a feeling she’d just accuse you of stealing her money.

GenieGenealogy · 30/07/2023 09:37

i don’t think it’s dementia, she’s never really understood Money and always got frantic over it.

All the speculation about alcoholism and gambling. 🙄OP my mum is just the same. Dad died about 9 months ago, I have been sorting out his estate and they are swimming in money. At almost 80, mum has plenty of money to last the rest of her life. She does not have an expensive lifestyle, does not buy expensive clothes or jewellery, no expensive hobbies, very few holidays, no mortgage/rent. Her public sector pension more than covers her living expenses so she has all these ISAs and Premium Bonds and other things just sitting there.

Yet she worries about spending and "treating" herself to a M&S meal for dinner rather then Lidl or Aldi. You would not speak to her and think she was well off. Dad was the one who always managed the money and organised the savings accounts and mum just went along with it. Although dad was ill for the last few years before his death and she had to deal with it she just left things ticking along, paying bills by direct debit and allowing policies to renew. She has no concept of how much money she has, how much she's spending, where the savings are, how she would access them. She finds it all very scary and has delegated it all to me and my sibling. When brother visits he regularly finds lots of unopened correspondence for him to deal with. Recently she needed a new fridge freezer which is a large but not enormous purchase. Lots of worry about affording it although she could buy every fridge freezer in the showroom and have money spare.

I do hear you OP, it's frustrating and worrying. You won't change her though, it's a confidence thing and if she's not confident on the phone or internet she's not going to get suddenly better. All you can do is keep reiterating that there IS money and that she IS living within her means.

Willmafrockfit · 30/07/2023 09:30

you see her every week?
ask for her statements
or just listen to her
is she buying other things off the tv channels, you said she bought jewelry
perhaps her heating bills are higher than £150
water bills
green garden bill

YetAnotherSpartacus · 30/07/2023 09:26

Your mother sounds like she's never really been a good mother to you. And her behaviour is that of a reckless child. Spoilt, selfish and manipulative. I'd be telling her straight, either you let us see your statements or you are on your own. You sound very caught up in fear, obligation and guilt. I'd put good money on Walter Mitty brother bleeding her dry, it's quite a common scenario. I have a friend whose sister conned their dad out of £100k. And I've heard of two other instances amongst acquaintances.

This.

LIZS · 30/07/2023 09:22

@SouthernLassies I agree but if she is overreacting and hysterical there may be an underlying mh condition or physical illness affecting her ability to rationalise , impulse control and make sensible decisions,

PinkCherryBlossoms · 30/07/2023 09:19

BarbaraofSeville · 30/07/2023 09:13

If she still owns the other property, could you help her sell it as a do-er upper so it's one less thing that's causing her anxiety and she sees a boost to her finances (I know she may fritter the money, but it doesn't sound like she's at risk of actually needing it for essentials any time soon).

Should be doable without too much effort from either of you, just tell an estate agent that it needs selling for whatever it will sell for - put it up for auction if needs be and all she will need to do is sign a few things.

Yeah I'd do that.

BarbaraofSeville · 30/07/2023 09:13

If she still owns the other property, could you help her sell it as a do-er upper so it's one less thing that's causing her anxiety and she sees a boost to her finances (I know she may fritter the money, but it doesn't sound like she's at risk of actually needing it for essentials any time soon).

Should be doable without too much effort from either of you, just tell an estate agent that it needs selling for whatever it will sell for - put it up for auction if needs be and all she will need to do is sign a few things.

lionsleepstonight · 30/07/2023 09:11

I could, and do, easily rattle through that each month with little 'to show'.

If she's got a pcp, regular holidays, likes to dress at the shops you mention and does not have to account to anyone what she spends, then I can see how she can end the month on a minus. It's ridiculous, but pretty easy.

All you can do is have convo where you draw up a budget and ask her to aim for this each month.

Tracker1234 · 30/07/2023 09:05

This is easy to solve for your own mental health. As others said you NEED to look at bank statements before you start trying to piece it together. There is no other way to do it. Been there - done it before!

Don’t stand any hand wringing. A sizeable amount of people have tons in savings but that isn’t counted overall. That is put aside for a rainy day and it’s hailing outside!

Otherwise it will be a big attention seeking drama for her and she also sounds overwhelmed by home ownership and day to day living.

Say you will help but not without seeing bank statements. Don’t waste anymore time on this.

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 09:04

LIZS · 30/07/2023 08:56

Maybe the col increases have scared her, utility bills, food shop, insurance premiums etc. Lots of media hype can create anxiety if her income is fixed . She could officially nominate you to be able to make enquiries of bank, suppliers and so on on her behalf.

she's 68 not 98!

I am nearly her mum's age and do all of what you suggest for my Mum who is close to 100!

Her mum needs to get her act together.

Epidote · 30/07/2023 09:03

YANBU.
Could be that she wants your attention? She is just complaining and doing nothing about it when you offer her advice. Be serious if she wants your advice she has to show you bank statement for the last 6 months. No criticism there just to see if there is something that she is not aware off, like you did with the electric. Together you can see where the money goes and if that is correct and she is skint or if is just her freaking out because although in a good income position is less income than before.

I would think she will refuse to show them to you and she will carry on complaining because I'm inclined to think that she doesn't really have a money problem, unless there something shady there that she is hiding, and is more a loneliness attention, wrong expectations problem.

A decent amount of money goes every month in her account, you cant help her if she doesn't tells you for real when that money goes.

LookItsMeAgain · 30/07/2023 09:03

I agree with the suggestion by @Anothernamethesamegame. If that doesn't work, tell her that the only alternative arrangement is that you get Lasting Power of Attorney over her financial matters. Would she be willing to hand over her financial affairs to you and you give her an allowance?

You mentioned that your Dad has passed away. I'm sorry for your loss. Can I ask if he was the financial responsible one in their relationship? If he was, then it really could be anxiety that she's not doing it right or something and she might simply need a "You're doing fine mum". Just a thought, because when my own dad died, it was the first time my mum had an ATM card, cheque book and full responsibility for all of the bills.

Hunkydory99 · 30/07/2023 09:02

Honestly from what you’ve said, I’d refuse to discuss it with your mum when she brings it up, if she’s not prepared to accept some help/advice and to do that she needs to show you her statements if she wants help