Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand what she’s spending it on

516 replies

Idlovetoknow · 29/07/2023 21:58

It’s my mother. She’s a pensioner and a widow, but she working. She cannot deal with her finances. She’s been on the phone tonight weeping over how much of a dire situation she’s in financially, but I don’t see how.

income from work: £1100 (after tax)
state pension: £800
widows pension: £1600 (think this is after tax too)
private pension: £200/300 (she was wooly on this)
so total income around £3600 a month

No mortgage, no rent, no grounds costs.
council tax £200 a month. Power £150 (let’s say 200 to round up) food and pet food £400, car £450 petrol £100, health insurance £200, phone £50, sky £50, pet insurance £80- that’s £1300 at an absolute max

i don’t understand. She’s not being frauded or taken advantage of, but i don’t understand. I try to talk to her for instance tonight when she rang frantic over money but she gets into such a tizz she can’t tell you anything. I’ve asked for months for all bills and bank statements to go over expenses but she can’t produce them

Anyone any ideas?

OP posts:
Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 12:43

Anotherdayanothernamechanged · 30/07/2023 12:38

2hrs there and back i would easily do in a day (and have done) to visit a relative or friend. For the sake of the peace of mind it will bring you by visiting for a full Saturday/Sunday it's more than worth it.

youd do it with a baby? Who I’d have to take?

OP posts:
SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 12:43

she did it yesterday when I pressed her on her expenses, said I was pushing her to suicide and to drop it even though she has said to me she was going to have to cancel her phone as she can’t afford it anymore

What a ridiculous way to behave.

Look, just walk away from this.
Don't talk about it and if she brings it up, just leave the house.

She will soon get the message. She's just wanting attention.

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 12:41

Is she a bit dim?

I know she works, but from what you say she's not exactly on the ball, is she?

I'd leave her to it.

She won't be helped, so it's not your problem.

Either she shows you the paperwork (not her tax code- she needs to query that) or she shuts up about it.

Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 12:41

Ohmylovejune · 30/07/2023 12:35

I honestly think you have to visit her and arrange it when she is complaining to you. There is a while bunch of reasons this could be from one end of the scale where she doesn't have a money problem at all just a misunderstanding to the other end of the scale where she's being scammed, even without knowing.

It's not easy as our parents get older. I was myself close to tears this week when Dad called me confused about a change in his TV (bloody technology!) And he was struggling to undertake the investigations I needed him to do in order to try and diagnose the problem. But we do need to try and keep the safe and independent - isn't that what we would want for ourselves?

Do try and get to the bottom of this with her and then you can perhaps put safeguards in place to stop her from worrying. My Dad for example checks his banking a few times every day triggered in part by his age but also by the fact he came close to being scammed once. I've asked him to speak to me if the balance goes below £1000 or anything going out looks strange and if not then he can close his banking and does not need to worry. This seems to have settled him.

Going to the property will make 0 difference because I have before and she doesn’t know where anytbing is and then gets in a state and starts screaming.

she did it yesterday when I pressed her on her expenses, said I was pushing her to suicide and to drop it even though she has said to me she was going to have to cancel her phone as she can’t afford it anymore

i don’t believe she’s suicidal I think she’s quite prone to drama, she did this sort of thing growing up to and to her parents

OP posts:
Pringleface · 30/07/2023 12:38

So is she giving money to your brother?

Anotherdayanothernamechanged · 30/07/2023 12:38

Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 12:33

Long is relative it’s about a 2hr drive, so it’s not one you can say pop by after work or really up and down In one day.

she comes up sometimes every week sometimes every other week and stays for a long weekend

she was a solo traveller but no she wasn’t single in the true sense when she was going on those hols

2hrs there and back i would easily do in a day (and have done) to visit a relative or friend. For the sake of the peace of mind it will bring you by visiting for a full Saturday/Sunday it's more than worth it.

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 12:38

Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 12:33

Long is relative it’s about a 2hr drive, so it’s not one you can say pop by after work or really up and down In one day.

she comes up sometimes every week sometimes every other week and stays for a long weekend

she was a solo traveller but no she wasn’t single in the true sense when she was going on those hols

You can easily do a 2 hr drive and back in one day.
I've friends who are your mum's age , who drive for 5-6 hours in a day to see a parent.

Her behaviour when you ask to see her bank statements is just deflecting. She knows exactly what she's doing and you should be firmer.

Or you ignore her behaviour and say you won't discuss it.

Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 12:37

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 12:16

@Idlovetoknow Taxation

Your mum will pay the lowest rate of tax as her combined income is less than £50K pa.

She will pay 20% on her income above £12570.

The tax on your dad's pension is deducted at source (I know this as my Mum is receiving my dad's occupational pension on top of her own state pension.)

Your mum should be getting a letter annually from your dad's pension provider with the figures - what she will receive monthly and what is deducted at source.

ALL her income - state pension, her own occupational pension, her current income and your dad's pension will be combined and taxed. So whatever comes into her bank account each month is net.

Her tax code will reflect the fact she is still working and receiving the state pension.

I don't want to come over as harsh! BUT you seem a bit passive in all of this.

For example if she says she doesn't have online banking, she will be receiving paper statements. So if she says she can't show you any statements, you need to query this and ask her how she knows what is in her accounts. Because otherwise she is lying.

I don't really believe she is struggling. I do believe she is possibly grieving and this is attention-seeking behaviour, especially as she seems quite ignorant about finances - or is determined to be that way and not learn.

You have two options

either butt out altogether and don't listen to her
or insist you see the bank statements

She gave me her tax code as it’s a higher rate one it’s a DO code which I looked up and it says higher rate on all income, trouble is she’s just found out and doesn’t know when it started because she doesn’t look at bills or payslips.

im not sure how I can be more active? I can’t call hmrc for her, I don’t really know the depths or the ins and outs of her income and expenditure. She’s saying I don’t help her enough but I don’t really understand what she’s talking about because she doesn’t use the correct terms for anything and it ends up garbled.

OP posts:
Ohmylovejune · 30/07/2023 12:35

I honestly think you have to visit her and arrange it when she is complaining to you. There is a while bunch of reasons this could be from one end of the scale where she doesn't have a money problem at all just a misunderstanding to the other end of the scale where she's being scammed, even without knowing.

It's not easy as our parents get older. I was myself close to tears this week when Dad called me confused about a change in his TV (bloody technology!) And he was struggling to undertake the investigations I needed him to do in order to try and diagnose the problem. But we do need to try and keep the safe and independent - isn't that what we would want for ourselves?

Do try and get to the bottom of this with her and then you can perhaps put safeguards in place to stop her from worrying. My Dad for example checks his banking a few times every day triggered in part by his age but also by the fact he came close to being scammed once. I've asked him to speak to me if the balance goes below £1000 or anything going out looks strange and if not then he can close his banking and does not need to worry. This seems to have settled him.

Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 12:33

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 12:27

I doubt it's dementia.

If you read all the OP's posts, she is describing a woman who is feckless with money.

-Lost £1000s as she didn't want to tackle probate for her parents
-Has 'singles' holidays flying 1st class ( was she really 'single'?)
-won't do online banking
-doesn't seem to understand the tax system
-splurges hundreds a month on a lease car yet only drives 3K miles a year
-buys expensive jewellery
-has a 2nd home that is falling apart as she can't be bothered to sell it or get it repaired to sell it

@Idlovetoknow You say she lives a long way away but then you said you see her weekly.

Long is relative it’s about a 2hr drive, so it’s not one you can say pop by after work or really up and down In one day.

she comes up sometimes every week sometimes every other week and stays for a long weekend

she was a solo traveller but no she wasn’t single in the true sense when she was going on those hols

OP posts:
Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 12:29

UpaladderwatchingTV · 30/07/2023 12:06

It strikes me that you don't really like your mother very much OP, (from what you've told us, I can understand why) but if I'm wrong, why haven't you been to visit and find out what is really going on?

Also, I don't think you answered my previous question about how long it is since your DF died, which could be very relevant to the situation. People are giving thought to this situation to try and help you, but why post if you're not bothered enough to go and visit?

That’s really unkind actually, it’s not a case of not being bothered

my dad died 2 years ago. I have been to visit but it’s actually very difficult due to having a young family, one of which is a baby and a large non baby proofed house. We also only have one car between us as a family so visiting takes planning, she used to have a lot of weekend plans

OP posts:
SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 12:27

I doubt it's dementia.

If you read all the OP's posts, she is describing a woman who is feckless with money.

-Lost £1000s as she didn't want to tackle probate for her parents
-Has 'singles' holidays flying 1st class ( was she really 'single'?)
-won't do online banking
-doesn't seem to understand the tax system
-splurges hundreds a month on a lease car yet only drives 3K miles a year
-buys expensive jewellery
-has a 2nd home that is falling apart as she can't be bothered to sell it or get it repaired to sell it

@Idlovetoknow You say she lives a long way away but then you said you see her weekly.

SouthernLassies · 30/07/2023 12:16

@Idlovetoknow Taxation

Your mum will pay the lowest rate of tax as her combined income is less than £50K pa.

She will pay 20% on her income above £12570.

The tax on your dad's pension is deducted at source (I know this as my Mum is receiving my dad's occupational pension on top of her own state pension.)

Your mum should be getting a letter annually from your dad's pension provider with the figures - what she will receive monthly and what is deducted at source.

ALL her income - state pension, her own occupational pension, her current income and your dad's pension will be combined and taxed. So whatever comes into her bank account each month is net.

Her tax code will reflect the fact she is still working and receiving the state pension.

I don't want to come over as harsh! BUT you seem a bit passive in all of this.

For example if she says she doesn't have online banking, she will be receiving paper statements. So if she says she can't show you any statements, you need to query this and ask her how she knows what is in her accounts. Because otherwise she is lying.

I don't really believe she is struggling. I do believe she is possibly grieving and this is attention-seeking behaviour, especially as she seems quite ignorant about finances - or is determined to be that way and not learn.

You have two options

either butt out altogether and don't listen to her
or insist you see the bank statements

GellerYeller · 30/07/2023 12:09

I did know someone like this and once she was without her spouse it became clear many of the outgoings and demands on the kids were status driven. Wouldn’t pay for a gardener for example, despite more than having the means. Because her SIL should do it. How could she be seen riding (yes riding) the mower. ‘People will think my family are uncaring’. No, just busy. While you swan off to Ascot with your hired chauffeur for the car you won’t get rid of despite the fact that it does at best 10 mpg and you live 10 miles from civilisation.

LakieLady · 30/07/2023 12:08

Anotherdayanothernamechanged · 29/07/2023 22:07

I feel a bit Mumsnet stereotype here but extreme random anxiety about things like finances can be a symptom of dementia. Is this something she's become fixated about? Is there any other strange things she's doing that may spark concern if you link them together?

That was the thing that rang alarm bells for me when my DM started to display symptoms that turned out to be dementia.

She'd ring me in a panic because she only had £X in the bank, when actually it was £X thousands.

There was also more money in a savings account that she'd forgotten existed.

UpaladderwatchingTV · 30/07/2023 12:06

It strikes me that you don't really like your mother very much OP, (from what you've told us, I can understand why) but if I'm wrong, why haven't you been to visit and find out what is really going on?

Also, I don't think you answered my previous question about how long it is since your DF died, which could be very relevant to the situation. People are giving thought to this situation to try and help you, but why post if you're not bothered enough to go and visit?

FictionalCharacter · 30/07/2023 12:01

Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 10:37

oh and also she won’t go on online banking, point blank refuses. She has a premier account and she’s top priority in the phone banking queue so she never has to wait, so won’t do it

In that case she could easily call them and ask them to send her paper copies of the statements that she "can't" produce to show you.

She doesn't want you to see them because she doesn't want you to know what she's spending on / how much cash she's sitting on. She just wants to moan, and for you to magically produce more money for her to spend on her lavish lifestyle or pile up in savings.

The "getting in a tizzy" and going off on one when you question her are working very well to keep you in the dark about her finances while still allowing her to do the woe is me act.

crowsfeet57 · 30/07/2023 11:48

When my FIL died my MIL donated some money to a charity in his memory. After she died a few years later I couldn't work out where a lot of money had gone until I checked her post. Every day there were letters from charities asking for money. Some had pictures of children on the envelope and said "I will die unless you help!"

There was a lot of money I couldn't account for, but I'm sure it went to these organisations. Check your mother isn't being fleeced by so called charitites!

ilyana · 30/07/2023 11:46

JbytheSea · 30/07/2023 09:56

Alcohol too cheap to explain this! You can can wine for £3 a bottle so even 3 bottles a day is only £63 a week so cannot explain the spending.

gambling yes

I don't think a lady of this age used to a nice lifestyle is buying £3 bottles of wine, LOL.

I'm not a big drinker, but I can't stand cheap wine, so if I do buy it, I spend £20ish on a bottle. Someone could easily spend hundreds a month on wine if they had a glass or two most days.

GettingStuffed · 30/07/2023 11:45

A lot of people on here are worrying about dementia, does she repeat herself constantly. DMil was fixated on the weather and she'd say things like it's hot today isn't it about every 5 minutes.

The other thing I thought of is that she might just be lonely and her telling you this means you spend more time talking to her. Can you visit her for a weekend or have her come to you.

1stTimeMummy2021 · 30/07/2023 11:27

@Idlovetoknow This sounds a bit like my Mother, basically she wanted me to adult for her and I did for a long time. I did the research so she could invest her money and not have to work but she never took the advice. In the end I stopped doing the research and just nodded and smiled to the despair but for many other reasons in the end I had to go NC for my mental wellbeing. I have a Walter Mitty type brother too, who in his 40s still lives with our Mother. She would complain to me about him and I would again offer advice and solutions but it all fell on deaf ears. Burying her head in the sand is exactly how I would describe my Mother's behaviour and you know what I realised after way too long, you can't help someone who can't or won't help themselves. You can't rescue your Mother from her woes and you will drive yourself potty trying. Distance yourself by not actively trying to help. Make all the right sounds when she complains but then forget it afterwards. You have your life to live and your family to look after, don't take on your Mother's stress. If there is one thing I am determined to do it is not ask of my son any of the things my Mother asked of me. Good luck.

BMW6 · 30/07/2023 11:23

I'd just keep repeating that unless she brings her bank statements TO YOU and you sit down with her and itemise her income and expenditure, you cannot do anything to help her!

justasking111 · 30/07/2023 11:20

Well HMRC have been known to cock up.

I pay an accountant to keep us on track. With pensions, investments, shares its peace of mind.

Idlovetoknow · 30/07/2023 11:14

Willmafrockfit · 30/07/2023 11:07

if she is working and receiving pension it will affect her tax, perhaps that is the issue.
or she is struggling to come to terms with less in her bank

She seems to think she’d being taxed at 50% on all earnings now, so not being a higher rate tax payer but literally 50% of pay pack taken away

OP posts:
Willmafrockfit · 30/07/2023 11:07

if she is working and receiving pension it will affect her tax, perhaps that is the issue.
or she is struggling to come to terms with less in her bank