Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In demand teachers should be on a higher pay grade

357 replies

Winterday1991 · 29/07/2023 20:54

Teachers who have high level degrees from good quality universities and teach in demand subjects such as maths, physics, chemistry etc should be paid at a rate equivalent to what their peers would earn in the private sector. For example starting salaries of £50k.

As I understand it, the current teacher pay scale means that drama, music teachers and low quality graduates are paid the same as high quality teachers. As teaching has low barrier to entry for graduates, and there is a shortage of teachers for certain subjects surely salaries should be treated as they would be in the private sector and paid the market rate. Why does the government not implement this to get more high quality graduates into teaching?

OP posts:
OneTwoThreeShake · 30/07/2023 15:05

I have first class degrees in maths and engineering.

I didn't go into teaching because I don't want to teach, I want to work in engineering and maths. All the money in the world wouldn't encourage me to teach. I'd also be crap at it because I find explaining something I just understand really difficult.

Regardless of whether someone is teaching physics or french, the crux of the job and requirements is the same, so the idea of paying some subjects substantially more than others seems ludicrous. And my logical mind tells me that those who've been teaching in their non stem subjects would likely leave in droves if such a wage disparity were introduced. What a way to kick people.

spanieleyes · 30/07/2023 14:58

A level maths teachers are more than welcome to come and teach our EYFS class, we have 2 non verbal, 2 still in pull ups and one who loves throwing chairs and tables around the room. The majority can't read and write when they join us ( although we did have one reading Harry Potter on entry this year) and they all can when they finish- to a greater or lesser extent.Perhaps the OP could then explain why they would need to take a pay cut to do so!

Hankunamatata · 30/07/2023 14:55

High level degrees and so called good universities (I'm assuming you mean RG) don't necessarily make good teachers. Some of the worse teaching iv seen is in so called good universities as they can connect and engage with students or get students who don't click straight away

Echio · 30/07/2023 14:48

@jgw1 I've never once said that. You're completely mistaken.

NEmama · 30/07/2023 14:45

noblegiraffe · 30/07/2023 14:32

While also asserting that it is very difficult to manage out teachers when teachers actually in the job know that this is in fact very easy to do and have seen it done multiple times.

Agree. Union reps are so busy dealing with the shit that goes on

jgw1 · 30/07/2023 14:35

Echio · 30/07/2023 14:24

@noblegiraffe , to literally quote myself, I am no expert! Hahahaha!!!

This is a forum for exchange of views. Some have been far more bonkers than mine on this thread. Have a lovely afternoon :)

It is indeed a forum for an exchange of views. @Echio may I suggest one way that teaching could be improved.

People who do not have anything constructive to say should not call teachers low grade.

noblegiraffe · 30/07/2023 14:32

While also asserting that it is very difficult to manage out teachers when teachers actually in the job know that this is in fact very easy to do and have seen it done multiple times.

jgw1 · 30/07/2023 14:29

Echio · 30/07/2023 14:22

I'm not the one assessing so I do not need to know how to do it.

I'm not sure why your questions are in this tone, my points were not about how something should be measured, they were about how there is a difference in the treatment of performance between public and private sector.

I won't respond any more. I've no idea what your issue really is and I don't think we'll get to the bottom of it in these exchanges!

So to be clear, you think excellent teachers should be rewarded more and low grade teachers removed even though you have no idea how one would judge which teachers fell into which category.

Indeed you don't even know if it is possible to accurately measure the contribution of an individual teacher to a students leearning.

noblegiraffe · 30/07/2023 14:25

No, you are no expert, but you are here pontificating regardless.

Echio · 30/07/2023 14:24

@noblegiraffe , to literally quote myself, I am no expert! Hahahaha!!!

This is a forum for exchange of views. Some have been far more bonkers than mine on this thread. Have a lovely afternoon :)

Echio · 30/07/2023 14:22

jgw1 · 30/07/2023 14:10

So you have no idea how to judge whether or not someone has poor teaching skills.

How would you identify who an excellent teacher was, perhaps you could try and explain that?

I'm not the one assessing so I do not need to know how to do it.

I'm not sure why your questions are in this tone, my points were not about how something should be measured, they were about how there is a difference in the treatment of performance between public and private sector.

I won't respond any more. I've no idea what your issue really is and I don't think we'll get to the bottom of it in these exchanges!

jgw1 · 30/07/2023 14:10

Echio · 30/07/2023 13:35

As with all jobs, there is a natural spectrum of capability and performance. How that's assessed - well, my inexpert opinion probably isn't worth a lot compared with the mountains of research and evidence that will exist on performance management.

If you are asking me, though, it'd be an assessment that takes into account various targets, measures and broader values. Like, my PMRs in private/charity sector have taken into account a mix of measuring the skills/performance in the nitty-gritty of the role, as well as wider elements like commitment to the values of the organisation, commitment to CPD, etc etc. There are dynamic ways of tracking performance that reveal long-term trends beyond the short-term ups and downs of year groups etc. I'm sure these things exist in the teaching profession.

But my point was the ability to act in a timely and emphatic way when there is poor performance is much harder than in private sector. I think a bit of movement towards a centre-ground from both ends of the spectrum would be a good thing. Likewise, the ability to reward an excellent teacher is also much more limited. Swings and roundabouts!

How would you assess it yourself?

So you have no idea how to judge whether or not someone has poor teaching skills.

How would you identify who an excellent teacher was, perhaps you could try and explain that?

noblegiraffe · 30/07/2023 13:46

You don't know what you're talking about, Echio

Bluevelvetsofa · 30/07/2023 13:42

The teacher with the highest level of qualifications I knew was completely incompetent in the classroom, to the extent that I spent a great deal of time in his classroom trying to alleviate the chaos that went on and of which he was mostly oblivious.

The most effective, charismatic and competent teacher I knew, was a drama graduate I employed as a teaching assistant and then persuaded into teaching. She had effortless classroom management skills, could explain in a way that every child could understand, was supportive to all of them and managed productions with flair and skill. Oh and her students all achieved high GCSE grades.

I know which I’d prefer teaching my children.

Echio · 30/07/2023 13:35

jgw1 · 30/07/2023 13:07

@Echio could you perhaps tell us how you would judge whether a teacher had a poor level of teaching skills?

As with all jobs, there is a natural spectrum of capability and performance. How that's assessed - well, my inexpert opinion probably isn't worth a lot compared with the mountains of research and evidence that will exist on performance management.

If you are asking me, though, it'd be an assessment that takes into account various targets, measures and broader values. Like, my PMRs in private/charity sector have taken into account a mix of measuring the skills/performance in the nitty-gritty of the role, as well as wider elements like commitment to the values of the organisation, commitment to CPD, etc etc. There are dynamic ways of tracking performance that reveal long-term trends beyond the short-term ups and downs of year groups etc. I'm sure these things exist in the teaching profession.

But my point was the ability to act in a timely and emphatic way when there is poor performance is much harder than in private sector. I think a bit of movement towards a centre-ground from both ends of the spectrum would be a good thing. Likewise, the ability to reward an excellent teacher is also much more limited. Swings and roundabouts!

How would you assess it yourself?

noblegiraffe · 30/07/2023 13:30

It's extremely difficult for a teacher to be performance-managed out for generally poor level of teaching skills

And yet it is exceptionally easy to manage a teacher out for whatever reason SLT decide to take against them.

jgw1 · 30/07/2023 13:07

Echio · 30/07/2023 09:19

@Postapocalypticcowgirl
I might be wrong but I imagine what they're getting at is the job security that comes with a being a teacher. It's extremely difficult for a teacher to be performance-managed out for generally poor level of teaching skills (gross misconduct is another matter), whereas in the private sector they'd get made redundant a lot more easily. Unionisation etc is behind this. Not a bad thing necessarily, but does mean there can be some piss poor teachers hanging around far longer than they would in other sectors.

Obviously, the majority are fine/good/excellent etc. And there's a balance to be struck between job-for-life security of public sector vs competitive nature of private sector, etc etc.

@Echio could you perhaps tell us how you would judge whether a teacher had a poor level of teaching skills?

Theimpossiblegirl · 30/07/2023 09:58

noblegiraffe · 30/07/2023 09:53

Those saying that this is the stupidest thing ever need to be aware that it is exactly what Gillian Keegan is promoting as the solution to the teacher recruitment crisis.

Including paying primary less than secondary.

I said the op was a pissed Gillian Keegan fairly early on.
Looks like I was right...

noblegiraffe · 30/07/2023 09:53

Those saying that this is the stupidest thing ever need to be aware that it is exactly what Gillian Keegan is promoting as the solution to the teacher recruitment crisis.

Including paying primary less than secondary.

Notellinganyone · 30/07/2023 09:49

This is one of the daftest things I’ve heard. How on earth would you implement it? You clearly have no idea how schools work. As other OPs have said while subject knowledge is important it doesn’t necessarily make you a great teacher. The solution is to make it more atand it will therefore become more selective. My school is a popular academic independent school In a popular city. That means we have lots of well qualified candidates applying for jobs so can be selective.

Greywhippet · 30/07/2023 09:44

Winterday1991 · 29/07/2023 21:29

I'm sticking up for teachers and saying that the good and in demand ones should be paid more fgs.

You’re just spouting nonsense to whip up opinion in a way typical of people who have zero understanding of the realities of teaching and schools.

NEmama · 30/07/2023 09:39

borntobequiet · 30/07/2023 09:34

I can assure you that that they are not on MPS

Uh?

I've worked with loads of Mps maths teachers.

I would argue that having a first in maths and a master's or PhD could actually mean than someone is an absolutely shite maths teacher.

Worked with an nqt, young guy who was really highly qualified. Was not able to understand why the students didn't "get it" struggled to make new concepts accessible as he just understood how to do it himself.

So no I don't agree with you. He left teaching to work in accounting. Taking his £27000 bursary

thecatsthecats · 30/07/2023 09:35

You can't pay your way out of recruiting more teachers, at least not in the way you're arguing OP.

If you offered any of the finance people I know a pay bump to go teach standard deviation to a bunch of surly 15yo, they'd laugh in your face and go back to their spreadsheets.

In fact, I do know someone who made the move from finance to teaching - and took a massive paycut to do so. Because it was what she really wanted to do.

borntobequiet · 30/07/2023 09:34

I can assure you that that they are not on MPS

Uh?