Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In demand teachers should be on a higher pay grade

357 replies

Winterday1991 · 29/07/2023 20:54

Teachers who have high level degrees from good quality universities and teach in demand subjects such as maths, physics, chemistry etc should be paid at a rate equivalent to what their peers would earn in the private sector. For example starting salaries of £50k.

As I understand it, the current teacher pay scale means that drama, music teachers and low quality graduates are paid the same as high quality teachers. As teaching has low barrier to entry for graduates, and there is a shortage of teachers for certain subjects surely salaries should be treated as they would be in the private sector and paid the market rate. Why does the government not implement this to get more high quality graduates into teaching?

OP posts:
Physicsgrad1984 · 13/08/2023 15:22

FrippEnos · 12/08/2023 18:07

Physicsgrad1984

I'm not sure if you are aware but Engineering comes under Technology and Technology is nested under the creative subjects in the curriculum.

Engineering is applied Physics and Maths and I should know because I hold two masters degrees in Engineering and a doctorate in Physics, all from top 10 Russell Group universities. Britain's heavy engineering industries have either gone bankrupt or have been sold off to companies in foreign countries like India and China. Sorry to say this but Physics and Engineering subjects are not going to make a come back in the UK. Physics has been dying in Britain and British schools for the last 12 years. Last year was the worst year in Physics teacher recruitment in UK schools. A mere 17% of the total number of Physics teachers required was recruited nationwide. All the tax free bursary incentives from the government over the years of £26,000 hasn't been helping and as a Physics doctor, I can safely say that it won't make the blindest bit of good in future. Britain was once a major industrial power and many great British engineers and physicists have made tremendous contributions to the subject in Britain's past. But today, it's over for Britain, industrially. You have my condolences.

Aishah231 · 13/08/2023 06:37

Why not up the pay of all teachers. Teachers of non shortage subjects in my experience tend to be much better as there was more competition for the training place in the first instance. If STEM teachers get even more incentives then that will be an absolute kick in the face for those other teachers.

MrsHamlet · 13/08/2023 04:11

noblegiraffe · 12/08/2023 19:57

Poetry is boring tho.

Rude!

Crazyducklady · 12/08/2023 21:01

Oh, and just for the record.

Our young people need the Arts in their lives and deserve to be taught by passionate, well qualified staff. All subjects are equally valuable. We need to be raising well balanced, healthy, happy young people. We don’t have enough time for the Arts and PE in our curriculum as it is.

Primary teachers are super human. Teenagers can generally be relied on to at least walk in a straight line, get on a chair without help, tie their shoe laces, cut their own food and do up their own coat - and that’s before you try and actually teach them anything 😁

Crazyducklady · 12/08/2023 20:51

Science Grad of fabled good University and (now ex) teacher of Sciences including 2 at A level, plus psychology, for nearly 20 yrs.

Mixture of challenging inner city and very rural maintained schools with diverse range of needs in both. Loved working with all my kids and was pretty damn good at my job.

Relentless, pointless paperwork and so called initiatives, re-inventing the wheel over and over again and the constant scrutiny over irrelevant things that took me away from teaching and supporting the well being of my students drove me to leave in the end, not the money.

noblegiraffe · 12/08/2023 19:57

Poetry is boring tho.

MrsHamlet · 12/08/2023 19:37

DaveSpondoolix · 12/08/2023 17:41

@MrsHamlet whoops, back to school for me...

Come into my non-STEM classroom and I'll poetry you until you understand the true ways

FrippEnos · 12/08/2023 18:07

Physicsgrad1984

I'm not sure if you are aware but Engineering comes under Technology and Technology is nested under the creative subjects in the curriculum.

DaveSpondoolix · 12/08/2023 17:41

@MrsHamlet whoops, back to school for me...

MrsHamlet · 12/08/2023 16:16

DaveSpondoolix · 12/08/2023 15:33

@Baconisdelicious no, it's the Non-STEM-Teaching Brigade and their covert campaign to demilitarise the UK and turn us over to communism, through the medium of...books...and...knowing stuff...and things...erm...

How dare you?!

My campaign is NOT covert.

DaveSpondoolix · 12/08/2023 15:33

@Baconisdelicious no, it's the Non-STEM-Teaching Brigade and their covert campaign to demilitarise the UK and turn us over to communism, through the medium of...books...and...knowing stuff...and things...erm...

Baconisdelicious · 12/08/2023 15:28

Am I the only non-STEM subject teacher thinking eh?!

Trying to get kids to study none-STEM subjects at both GCSE and A Level is increasingly an uphill struggle. If there is a gap in STEM industry then it isn’t coming from within schools. Industry might need to have a bit of an inwards look, perhaps?

DaveSpondoolix · 12/08/2023 15:15

@Physicsgrad1984 eh??Nobody wants to "kill off" any subjects (well, maybe P.E....*). It's not a death match of Sciences Vs Arts. What a strange, narrow and unproductive way to think about things.

*this is a joke, before I'm jumped on by a phalanx of PE people

CHIRIBAYA · 12/08/2023 14:01

You are making a fundamentally flawed assumption that teachers who are 'low quality graduates' make inferior teachers. There is way more to teaching than the academic component, you know, like emotional and social competence. Furthermore, the damage we are doing to children by conditioning them to think they only have worth if they perform well in subjects like maths is inexcusable. My life is enriched beyond measure by music, drama, history etc and I am grateful to all those 'inferior' teachers who have enabled this enjoyment.

Eleganz · 12/08/2023 13:58

Physicsgrad1984 · 12/08/2023 13:09

That's fine then. You can hold onto your creative industries as being your main source of income and let subjects like physics, maths and computer science die away in Britain! I don't anyone in Britain will notice or even care! You can create generations of British people who are illiterate in these subjects whilst other countries like India and China storm ahead!

As a Solid State Physics PhD grad, one other point that you should be aware of is that subjects like maths, physics and engineering are highly important for British national security. Not just to have highly skilled scientists to maintain Britain's nuclear deterrent but also Britain's greater weapons manufacturing industries which is still big business for Britain! If you kill off these subjects in Britain then you'll be at the mercy of other countries like China who do have booming engineering industries, to import these "goods" into Britain and develop Britain's telecoms systems. The choice is yours!

As someone with a PhD in chemical physics, postdoctoral research experience and coming up to 20 years professional experience as a chartered professional in STEM in industry doing lots of outreach work in the time, especially encouraging women I to STEM fields I am well aware of the importance of varies technical and scientific disciplines in our economy.

However, trying to act all superior and doing arts and humanities down will not advance the preservation of STEM education and skills in this country one bit. My point was that there are sectors that contribute hugely to our economy that are not fuelled by STEM graduates.

Also the reason India and China are stealing ahead in heavy industry is not a lack of STEM skills in the UK but because it is cheaper to produce in those countries with as stringent health, safety and environment legislation and toleration of human rights abuses in the sourcing of raw materials. Indeed we are educating more people in physics at university now than we were a decade ago, between 2010 and 2018 the IOP reported a 30% increase in physics students.

Physicsgrad1984 · 12/08/2023 13:09

That's fine then. You can hold onto your creative industries as being your main source of income and let subjects like physics, maths and computer science die away in Britain! I don't anyone in Britain will notice or even care! You can create generations of British people who are illiterate in these subjects whilst other countries like India and China storm ahead!

As a Solid State Physics PhD grad, one other point that you should be aware of is that subjects like maths, physics and engineering are highly important for British national security. Not just to have highly skilled scientists to maintain Britain's nuclear deterrent but also Britain's greater weapons manufacturing industries which is still big business for Britain! If you kill off these subjects in Britain then you'll be at the mercy of other countries like China who do have booming engineering industries, to import these "goods" into Britain and develop Britain's telecoms systems. The choice is yours!

Cnidarian · 12/08/2023 11:29

Winterday1991 · 29/07/2023 21:35

Of course it does, but they should be judged by the same standards as in the private sector. The teaching profession needs to be pulled up and make it a competitive option for the best graduates.

Aaah there it is, someone from the private sector with no understanding of the profession assuming they have superior knowledge and the answer to everything. "The best" grads aren't necessarily good teachers. It is a different skill set, it's why you will see in universities there are two tenure tracks, teaching and research. Academically gifted people can often be the absolute worst teachers, they do not modulate their knowledge to different abilities to get the best out of all students, they can get frustrated quickly, they don't see the investment in the pastoral elements of teaching as important all of which can be damaging to students that could thrive in other environments. This is a generalisation of course, and there are many academically gifted people who are brilliant teachers, but the answer is not as simple as "pull the standard up, get the best, listen to me, I know best"....you don't, listen to the experience of teachers. And pay them all more, they deserve it, so do the civil service.

Eleganz · 12/08/2023 11:03

Physicsgrad1984 · 12/08/2023 09:52

Says who? Do you know how tough subjects like maths, physics and engineering are? These aren't easy subjects to understand hence fewer and fewer students in the UK are taking them. Furthermore, these subjects are more useful for any nation's economy. You want to build a thriving steel industry in a country? Then you need graduates of these subjects. You want to build a thriving electronics and semiconductor industry in a country? Then you need graduates of these subjects. You want to build and maintain a nation's nuclear deterrent? Then you need graduates from these subjects. You want a booming financial services sector in your country? Then you need graduates from these subjects who are clever enough to do really complicated maths and computer programming. I'm sorry, but that's capitalism for you! Some subjects are worth more than others.

If you want a creative industry worth billions to the UK economy (which we have) you need creative degree graduates. Creative degrees are incredibly tough to do well in because they require a lot of skill and many STEM grads would not do well at them and find them difficult. The creative industry is certainly much more economically important than the steel industry in the UK.

The reality is that to have a successful economy we need lots of different skills that work together in a regulatory and legislative environment that promotes the creation of sustainable businesses. STEM grads can't do that on their own.

DaveSpondoolix · 12/08/2023 10:22

@Physicsgrad1984 RTFT

Physicsgrad1984 · 12/08/2023 09:52

ConnieTucker · 29/07/2023 20:56

low quality graduates wow.

why would an english teacher whose workload is substantially higher than a maths teacher accept £20k leas pay?

Says who? Do you know how tough subjects like maths, physics and engineering are? These aren't easy subjects to understand hence fewer and fewer students in the UK are taking them. Furthermore, these subjects are more useful for any nation's economy. You want to build a thriving steel industry in a country? Then you need graduates of these subjects. You want to build a thriving electronics and semiconductor industry in a country? Then you need graduates of these subjects. You want to build and maintain a nation's nuclear deterrent? Then you need graduates from these subjects. You want a booming financial services sector in your country? Then you need graduates from these subjects who are clever enough to do really complicated maths and computer programming. I'm sorry, but that's capitalism for you! Some subjects are worth more than others.

miniaturepixieonacid · 31/07/2023 17:14

Doggytastic - I think your post just shows how impossible it is to say what is easier or harder to teach. I am relatively confident with teaching children with SEN and, while it's definitely one of the harder parts of my job (for me), I can do it. I would never be able to teach A Level Maths in a million years. I wouldn't even have been able to pass A Level Maths! That doesn't mean it's harder to teach per se but it's harder for me. So, as long as teachers are teaching to their strengths and have the right subject and age range (not always the case at the moment, I know!) then nobody should really be having a 'harder' job than anybody else. We're all just doing the 'right' job for us.

I do however, think the type of school can make a job objectively harder. I mentioned upthread that I am paid less than colleagues in state education. That's not going to make me move into state. I am less stressed and don't work as hard as I would in state school because the classes are so much smaller and, by and large, the children are more amenable. So I don't mind being paid less. It seems a fair exchange. I wouldn't be averse to teachers in large schools in difficult areas with no resources being paid more than teachers in delightful, 'leafy' schools with more resources and budget. That seems a lot fairer to me than doing it by subject. It already happens with headteachers, doesn't it. A head of a small, rural primary school isn't earning anything like what the head of a large, inner city comprehensive is.

Doggytastic · 31/07/2023 14:02

KatherineofGaunt · 29/07/2023 21:58

Oh dear.

I'm an SEN teacher. I suppose I'll be at the bottom of the pay pile (despite my BA, PGCE, MA and PGDip) because I'm lucky if my 9 year olds can write a full sentence. How silly of me to expect decent and fair remuneration for my decades of experience, my qualifications and my constantly excellent performance management.

Stupid idea. How to make anyone not teaching STEM at A Level feel less than worthless.

Teaching SEN is the most difficult from my experience. You definitely deserve to be paid more! Teaching A-level maths is far easier.

Quoria · 31/07/2023 12:05

PhotoDad · 31/07/2023 09:19

Some people are using "private sector" to mean "private schools." Some are using it to mean "the whole private sector, i.e. companies." Both uses are common, but in education, "private sector" tends to mean just schools, so the teachers here are reading it like that.

So I think that some of these posts are being misunderstood!

Another teacher who absolutely didn't read it this way. I'd imagine most teachers have worked in the private sector at some point, even if when at university. Many of us had jobs in the private sector before career changing into teaching.

PhotoDad · 31/07/2023 11:06

ConnieTucker · 31/07/2023 10:18

I believe the misunderstanding were from people who have no knowledge or experience of the education system believing they are experts and talking utter nonsense.

ivd never met any teacher in twenty years who would refer to private schools as the private sector.

Of course you're right on both counts, for some reason my brain lurched from the two "sectors" of education to public/private, instead of maintained/independent. I think I need more coffee. Sorry!

Harrythehappypig · 31/07/2023 10:35

My DH has obviously fucked up massively along the way. He has a phd in a STEM subject from a “good quality” university. He’s 49 and is on more than £50k now but it wasn’t that long ago that he wasn’t (and he’s now at director level). Sound like the savvy thing would have been a few years ago to look out for graduate entry level roles and go for them. I don’t think he realises the new entrants that he recruits in his company are earning nearly as much as he is.

Swipe left for the next trending thread