Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In demand teachers should be on a higher pay grade

357 replies

Winterday1991 · 29/07/2023 20:54

Teachers who have high level degrees from good quality universities and teach in demand subjects such as maths, physics, chemistry etc should be paid at a rate equivalent to what their peers would earn in the private sector. For example starting salaries of £50k.

As I understand it, the current teacher pay scale means that drama, music teachers and low quality graduates are paid the same as high quality teachers. As teaching has low barrier to entry for graduates, and there is a shortage of teachers for certain subjects surely salaries should be treated as they would be in the private sector and paid the market rate. Why does the government not implement this to get more high quality graduates into teaching?

OP posts:
Malbecfan · 19/08/2023 09:07

@ZebraDanios what a lovely post! I agree with what you say about not specialising too early. Interestingly (well to me) is that the rest of my household who have all studied STEM degrees are all also decent musicians too. I find that A level musicians who study Maths too have a definite advantage with some aspects of the course. When I rule the world, I would push for more of a Baccalaureate qualification for school leavers to ensure breadth of experience.

ZebraDanios · 19/08/2023 00:59

@Malbecfan I have seen many an otherwise apathetic and disaffected pupil just come alive when singing or playing an instrument. It’s one of the things I love about watching my school’s productions: I get to see the kids who struggle with my subject (I am a science teacher, sorry!) absolutely light up doing something they love. And I have enormous respect for the teachers who bring that out of them.

I’ve long argued against the “two cultures” phenomenon: in particular I’ve always felt that we need scientists to communicate better and people working in the media to understand science better. I always encourage my pupils not to specialise too early and to keep their options open as long as they can.

PhotoDad · 18/08/2023 11:36

I had a very confusing (to the students, not to me) few years teaching a STEM subject (Physics, no less) and two different humanities. So you'll hear no arguments from me about the need to be well rounded!

Malbecfan · 18/08/2023 11:13

Thanks @Piggywaspushed . Nothing wrong with what you teach. I bumped into a former student last week who is on her final placement before becoming a SW. She has promised to come into school to do a talk to 6th form on careers outside STEM 😇

Piggywaspushed · 18/08/2023 10:38

Congrats malbec on fab results and on keeping the arts going.

I commit even worse sins than you. I teach sociology.

Malbecfan · 18/08/2023 10:10

@Physicsgrad1984 as an experienced teacher about to start my 30th year of secondary Music teaching, I would like to remind you that whilst there is no doubt that STEM subjects are important - indeed my DH and both DDs are STEM graduates/students/PhD - in isolation, STEM subjects are not the answer to all the country's woes. We need creative thinkers. To get creative thinkers, kids need the opportunity to be creative in a safe space with experts in delivering a broad-based creative curriculum.

My DH with his STEM PhD invented & patented a medical device which won awards, for which he credits me for giving him the idea when I dragged him round an art gallery. Seeing problems or issues through only one narrow prism without breadth of knowledge is sadly looking the way this country is going.

To the EYFS teachers here, you have my utmost respect. In the last 5 years, I have also done some primary teaching, albeit mostly subject-specific. OMG, one hour of YR and Y1 and I needed a long sleep. I did a day's supply teaching for Y4, a class I knew very well but it nearly killed me. Teaching A level Music or EPQ requires more preparation, but is less stressful.

To the other Music teachers on this thread, I hear you and respect you. This holiday I have ordered and marked up scores for the works my state school orchestra will be playing next term (sorted the music before we broke up). I still need to make arrangements of a couple of pieces for my choir, but that's always tricky because it's only Y7 & 8 and so I only know half of them until we get going. I've also drafted an itinerary for a music tour for next summer so that can be launched mid-September, to give families the maximum time to pay for it. But yes, OP, I'm just a lowly music teacher, obviously less worthy that the great STEMers (insert sarcasm emoji) and I don't get paid any extra for running extra-curricular groups every lunchtime, when my STEM colleagues piss off-site for a walk. However, I can silence a class merely by looking at them, and my EPQ results yesterday were great.

PhotoDad · 18/08/2023 08:47

@Physicsgrad1984 That is worrying, a reverse after several years of growth. As someone who left the ranks of physics teachers yourself, what would have persuaded you to stay? (I also left, but only to teach a subject with even fewer specialists...)

Physicsgrad1984 · 18/08/2023 08:09

Piggywaspushed · 14/08/2023 10:16

The number of people taking physics A level is rising. What is showing no rise whatsoever is the number of people signing up to teach physics.

I genuinely don't understand what your recruitment strategy for physics teachers is, when you seem to want all graduates to work in industry. Which ones become teachers?

Wrong! Physics is down 2.5% in popularity from 2021 to 2023. This makes sense. 1 in 5 Physics lessons in UK schools is taught by someone who doesn't have a degree in Physics or Engineering. Kids aren't stupid. They know if they're being taught by a teacher who doesn't know what they are talking about. They won't risk taking a subject, taught by an unqualified teacher, and get a crap grade.

Physicsgrad1984 · 17/08/2023 22:22

Eleganz · 14/08/2023 13:04

My comment about human rights abuses was more aimed at china than India. We can talk about the legacy of empire all we like but that really has little to do with what is happening in heavy industry right now. India benefits from low pay and low safety standards compared to the UK and that reduces the cost base - this has nothing to do with a colonial legacy and everything to do with the choices made by the Indian government. I've toured a number of Indian production facilities and they are nowhere near the standard they would need to be to operate here in the UK.

As for failing industries, most if it is market forces, but the UK government has also compounded this by making poor choices on industrial policy over the years.

However, there are a lot of international engineering consultancies that operate from the UK or with major bases in the UK. UK engineers are well respected globally.

As for recruitment of teachers, the problem is obviously low pay and poor working conditions. This is true across the sector. Specific issues with physics are a relatively small number of grads available and the fact that in my view a lower % of hard science grads feel a vocation to teach in the first place.

Well that's actually a bit of a cheap shot to compare India's industrial standards to Britain's. You're forgetting that India, as the nation that you see today, is only 76 years old. Whereas Britain is a much more established country and if I am being candid with you, yes colonial legacy matters. It's no coincidence that the funding of the industrial revolution kicked off in Britain at roughly the same time as Robert Clive of the British East India Company captured Bengal in 1757 and later Hector Munroe secured British rights in 1765 via the Treaty of Allahabad to collect taxes from the Indian population. Most of that Indian tax money was then pumped directly back to Britain. This is just one example of how Britain stole trillions of pounds from India. The country was just used as a resource to exploit by Britain for almost 200 years. You should go and read up on your history.

But that's the past. Let's get back to the present. Why don't you compare the industrial and economic progress gradients between Britain and India today. I think that's a lot fairer. I think you'll find that India's economic progress gradient is a sharp positive one with a young vibrant and educated population, whereas Britain with it's ageing population is on a sharp decline. Even Indian kids growing up in Britain today are pound for pound, the second highest academic achievers in Britain. Only Chinese kids offer our kids any reasonable level of academic competition. Whereas native white British kids, especially boys, are somewhere at the bottom of the academic league tables at GCSE and A-level. Where Britain's physical sciences and engineering industries are winding down, India's are literally catapulting to the stratosphere. I'm sure you must have heard of the Indian Space Research Organisation launching a lunar mission to land on the moon's as yet unexplored southern pole? It's not just Indian engineering companies like TATA that own massive chunks of Britain's flailing steel and automotive engineering sectors, Indian biotech companies like the Serum Institute of India is the world's largest vaccine producer.

I work as a data scientist now, but I have experience working in Britain's steel industry in Redcar and Teesside, when it transitioned from Corus to TATA Steel some 13 years ago. In my opinion, the problem with Britain's failing industries is as much to do with the industrial culture that has emerged in Britain over the last 80 years and the behavior of British engineers as much as it is to do with Britain's industrial policies that have been implemented by politicians. To put it bluntly, British engineers no longer have the drive to truly innovate and build industries anymore. They simply want to pocket as high a salary as possible and as quickly as possible, and I witnessed this sort of behavior amongst senior engineers and managers at Steel R&D site at Teesside, which is now called the Materials Processing Institute. The drive for quick capital returns has become the culture of Britain. Even university education is seen as big business in Britain. It's one of the only businesses that Britain has left today: to get as much money as possible from foreign students, studying undergrad and postgrad degree courses even at some of Britain's lowest ranked universities.

Secondly, the strength of the Pound Sterling and the drive to keep Britain's currency as strong as possible seems to be the sole fiscal economic policy. Keeping the Pound strong at any cost is indirectly another factor that has led to the death of British industry. When I was at Corus/TATA steel, Britain was already importing iron ore from China as opposed to mining it in Britain, despite having large iron ore deposits across the country. In fact Britain imports an extraordinary amount, including electricity from places like Norway. As opposed to importing just about everything, selling of patent licences and pocketing the returns for a select few (especially senior British engineers), perhaps Britain should start investing in it's own people and make better use of it's own resources.

Thirdly, there's too much "red tape" in Britain today and this has pushed manufacturing in Britain off the cliff. Yes, I agree, adequate health and safety policy is required in manufacturing but what has happened in Britain today is that health and safety policy has gone to the extreme where it has now become impossible to produce anything without traversing a great deal of costly red tape. In fact reviewing and administering even more stringent health and safety policy has itself become a greater business in Britain today. So instead of applying common sense to safety guidelines and giving engineers and engineering companies in Britain the freedom to manufacture safely, you've tied their hands together with a culture of being too cautious. But at the end of the day, even though I was EPSRC funded (UK tax payer) to do my PhD, Britain's dying industries are not my problem.

jgw1 · 17/08/2023 07:39

PhotoDad · 16/08/2023 08:58

@jgw1 Absolutely. When I taught Physics, one HoD was keen that we ask for student opinion. I always put on the questionnaire, "should we have more practical lessons?" Opinion was always evenly split, which amused me and helped me make the point that the students don't really know what they need. Unfortunately that trend is coming back in my school.

An awful lot of weight is put on the National Student Survey at university level.

I had a HoD who loves student surveys.
Spends hours pouring over the results and gets very upset when asked the vailidity of the results from a student who puts agrees strongly for the first 5 answers then disagrees strongly for the next 5, or within a class results that say the teacher frequently sets homework and rarely sets homework. Hmm.

Which could lead us onto what the value in setting homework is of course.

jgw1 · 17/08/2023 07:37

Wenfy · 16/08/2023 14:04

In good private primaries the fundamentals of maths are often taught by subject matter experts (msc as a minimum) - which allows kids to learn them properly and with the right methods and minimises the amount of relearning. Example - in DD’s class Indian origin clasmates had often memorised times tables to 20 (as that is how their grandparents were taught and these kids spent a lot of time with them). I’m dyslexic and so was taught a different way (various number theories, by a maths graduate) which I taught to her. This meant while she hadn’t memorised her tables she could, in 3 seconds flat, calculate any multiplication and had the basics for pretty much everything.

I do think if we split primary into it’s subjects and employed experts in these fields it would make them more engaging at secondary. One of the biggest reasons why white British kids (girls especially) drop STEM subjects is because they aren’t taught it properly in the first place.

This is an excellent example of how the performance of learning times tables is given more importance by some than the actual long term learning of how to use maths.
The Blair government's National Numeracy Strategy was very successful at raising attainment in students by the end of primary school. Pupils were able to perform much better in KS2 tests. There was subsequently no increase in maths ability at GCSE for those students, because they had learnt to perform KS2 tests, not learnt maths.

Wenfy · 16/08/2023 14:06

Kazzyhoward · 16/08/2023 11:05

I'd agree with that. ALL levels of teaching are of equivalent importance, as most subjects, especially Maths, English and science, build upon prior knowledge and skills.

However good is the Maths teacher, the pupil is always going to be at a disadvantage if they were never taught the basics such as prime numbers, low number times tables, fractions, percentages, multiplication and division. You simply can't progress without solid foundations.

Maths and language are the fundamentals. Without them all other subjects are useless including music and cookery and history.

Wenfy · 16/08/2023 14:04

Kazzyhoward · 16/08/2023 11:05

I'd agree with that. ALL levels of teaching are of equivalent importance, as most subjects, especially Maths, English and science, build upon prior knowledge and skills.

However good is the Maths teacher, the pupil is always going to be at a disadvantage if they were never taught the basics such as prime numbers, low number times tables, fractions, percentages, multiplication and division. You simply can't progress without solid foundations.

In good private primaries the fundamentals of maths are often taught by subject matter experts (msc as a minimum) - which allows kids to learn them properly and with the right methods and minimises the amount of relearning. Example - in DD’s class Indian origin clasmates had often memorised times tables to 20 (as that is how their grandparents were taught and these kids spent a lot of time with them). I’m dyslexic and so was taught a different way (various number theories, by a maths graduate) which I taught to her. This meant while she hadn’t memorised her tables she could, in 3 seconds flat, calculate any multiplication and had the basics for pretty much everything.

I do think if we split primary into it’s subjects and employed experts in these fields it would make them more engaging at secondary. One of the biggest reasons why white British kids (girls especially) drop STEM subjects is because they aren’t taught it properly in the first place.

164tI21 · 16/08/2023 13:51

@Kazzyhoward sorry but @noblegiraffe is absolutely correct. Most students just want an easy life. And yes good looking, male teachers always get the best feedback.

Kazzyhoward · 16/08/2023 11:05

Spirallingdownwards · 16/08/2023 10:59

Surely your comment is just as stupid. If they don't get the basics taught well at primary level and EY then stats show this impacts their later learning performace levels.

I'd agree with that. ALL levels of teaching are of equivalent importance, as most subjects, especially Maths, English and science, build upon prior knowledge and skills.

However good is the Maths teacher, the pupil is always going to be at a disadvantage if they were never taught the basics such as prime numbers, low number times tables, fractions, percentages, multiplication and division. You simply can't progress without solid foundations.

Kazzyhoward · 16/08/2023 11:01

@noblegiraffe

Student opinion is along the lines of 'the teacher that doesn't give us any homework is a legend, and we need more computer room lessons (because they are a doss)'.

Are there published research/studies to support that, as I think it's a very strange and unlikely opinion for the majority of pupils.

I hated "informal" lessons with a passion. I loved the formal subjects and especially the stricter teachers. I chose my O and A level options based on that. In earlier years, I hated the "doss" lessons because almost always, they'd be the ones with poorer behaviour.

Despite what people think, I'm pretty sure most pupils actually want to learn and want to do well at school. It's their surroundings, peers, etc that scupper it!

I know I got better results with proper structure, stricter teachers, etc and I think others did too! I know it's just anecdote rather than data, but it's certainly my experience.

My son chose his GCSEs and A levels using a similar thought process, and he, too, hated the informal lessons and was always keen to do written work, tests, exams, etc., as he liked to challenge himself and wanted a "metric" to see progress.

Spirallingdownwards · 16/08/2023 10:59

Winterday1991 · 29/07/2023 21:08

Stupid comment primary teaching is not equivalent to teaching chem, maths etc up to Alevel standard.

Surely your comment is just as stupid. If they don't get the basics taught well at primary level and EY then stats show this impacts their later learning performace levels.

noblegiraffe · 16/08/2023 10:35

Student opinion is along the lines of 'the teacher that doesn't give us any homework is a legend, and we need more computer room lessons (because they are a doss)'.

Even Ofsted stopped grading teachers from lesson observations because the evidence showed that a charismatic, good-looking teacher would get outstanding more often than the mousy quiet one; they would grade teacher personality over lesson content.

What makes a good teacher? At the most very basic level it's one who shows up every day. So many kids have their education affected by not having a consistent teacher.

PhotoDad · 16/08/2023 08:58

@jgw1 Absolutely. When I taught Physics, one HoD was keen that we ask for student opinion. I always put on the questionnaire, "should we have more practical lessons?" Opinion was always evenly split, which amused me and helped me make the point that the students don't really know what they need. Unfortunately that trend is coming back in my school.

An awful lot of weight is put on the National Student Survey at university level.

jgw1 · 16/08/2023 08:54

PhotoDad · 16/08/2023 08:39

@jgw1 Here it is! I might even read beyond the abstract. 😀
https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w14081/w14081.pdf

There are multiple studies, I don't have the book that references them to hand, that students are very poor at judging what they have truly learnt for the long term. In fact more often than not they think they have learnt things because they can parrot them at the end of the lesson, if anyone went back and tested them again in a weeks time they would discover they did not know them.

Eleganz · 16/08/2023 08:50

Phineyj · 15/08/2023 17:45

It's not "basic Economics". It's year 2 of A-level labour market microeconomics.

Teaching is a monopsony - one employer (the government, essentially) determines the wage (private schools and academies can set their own wages, in theory, but in practice, the government determined pay scales are very important).

The govt as majority employer aims to push down the wage as far as possible because they face a huge wage bill, need to attempt to control inflation, etc. This is countered to some extent by union collective bargaining which aims to force the wage upwards.

Paying teachers by their perceived value as e g. Physics teachers would require a competitive market where they could be rewarded based on their marginal revenue product (value of their work).

But it is very challenging to determine value of work in something like teaching with no easily measurable output.

It's not quite as you describe. We have one funder, but many employers as teachers are employed either by local authorities or, increasingly, by academy trusts. The latter certainly have more flexibility around pay to an extent so perhaps the market may have more opportunities to exert itself although I think the heavy unionisation of the workforce will make that difficult. All academies would need to do would be to get rid of a few of the ridiculously high paid non-teaching management roles and they could afford to fund further teaching posts.

PhotoDad · 16/08/2023 08:39

@jgw1 Here it is! I might even read beyond the abstract. 😀
https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w14081/w14081.pdf

PhotoDad · 16/08/2023 08:36

jgw1 · 16/08/2023 08:28

It is vitally important to establish what is meant by best. Best at getting students to jump through arbitary hoops at a particular point in time, or best at ensuring that students have completely learnt and understood a concept so that they can use it in future. The two are often very different.

That reminds me of a study I heard about (I might try to track it down). One of the US military academies looked at student satisfaction surveys and end-of-year results, tracking a cohort through their education. They found that there were some teachers/lecturers whom students really didn't like, and with average end-of-year results; but the students of those teachers hugely outperformed the students of other teachers at the next level of education.

jgw1 · 16/08/2023 08:28

PhotoDad · 15/08/2023 11:41

@Lokipinoki I agree with pretty much everything you say!

I was also interested in the comments on how difficult it is to differentiate between different teachers in terms of performance related pay. My kids seem to have no difficulty in judging who are the best teachers.

This is a really tricky one, because there are so many different versions of "best" floating around. The teachers that are engaging and popular are not necessarily those who obtain the highest results. Consider a maths department; in an ideal world all of the teachers would be engaging and student-centred. However, in the real world, there is a range, and it's probably "better" for the department and for the students if the "best" teachers are put with the lower-ability groups. "Value added" is measured, sure, but it doesn't tend to include things like enthusiasm for the subject or continuation rates in non-compulsory subjects.

It is vitally important to establish what is meant by best. Best at getting students to jump through arbitary hoops at a particular point in time, or best at ensuring that students have completely learnt and understood a concept so that they can use it in future. The two are often very different.

Phineyj · 15/08/2023 17:45

It's not "basic Economics". It's year 2 of A-level labour market microeconomics.

Teaching is a monopsony - one employer (the government, essentially) determines the wage (private schools and academies can set their own wages, in theory, but in practice, the government determined pay scales are very important).

The govt as majority employer aims to push down the wage as far as possible because they face a huge wage bill, need to attempt to control inflation, etc. This is countered to some extent by union collective bargaining which aims to force the wage upwards.

Paying teachers by their perceived value as e g. Physics teachers would require a competitive market where they could be rewarded based on their marginal revenue product (value of their work).

But it is very challenging to determine value of work in something like teaching with no easily measurable output.