Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In demand teachers should be on a higher pay grade

357 replies

Winterday1991 · 29/07/2023 20:54

Teachers who have high level degrees from good quality universities and teach in demand subjects such as maths, physics, chemistry etc should be paid at a rate equivalent to what their peers would earn in the private sector. For example starting salaries of £50k.

As I understand it, the current teacher pay scale means that drama, music teachers and low quality graduates are paid the same as high quality teachers. As teaching has low barrier to entry for graduates, and there is a shortage of teachers for certain subjects surely salaries should be treated as they would be in the private sector and paid the market rate. Why does the government not implement this to get more high quality graduates into teaching?

OP posts:
Echio · 30/07/2023 09:19

@Postapocalypticcowgirl
I might be wrong but I imagine what they're getting at is the job security that comes with a being a teacher. It's extremely difficult for a teacher to be performance-managed out for generally poor level of teaching skills (gross misconduct is another matter), whereas in the private sector they'd get made redundant a lot more easily. Unionisation etc is behind this. Not a bad thing necessarily, but does mean there can be some piss poor teachers hanging around far longer than they would in other sectors.

Obviously, the majority are fine/good/excellent etc. And there's a balance to be struck between job-for-life security of public sector vs competitive nature of private sector, etc etc.

Justashley · 30/07/2023 08:30

For some subjects the pay and opportunities are better in teaching.

Justashley · 30/07/2023 08:30

I don't know I mean it's clumsily worded and I don't agree that the uni matters as such, but there are definitely some subjects that have a harder time attracting teachers for a myriad of reasons and these should perhaps be addressed separately. Computing, the sciences and maths for example. I don't think they're more important as an all round education is important and there are lots of very talented teachers across all subjects; but when you can work on stuff you're passionate about (sciences), earn a load with great prospects (maths and IT) then what can you do to encourage people to teach?

Sherrystrull · 30/07/2023 08:16

No, just wrong. Wrong and offensive.

Tryingmuchharder · 30/07/2023 00:24

@Winterday1991 you have triggered a lot of teachers. Guess you are either right or wrong then.

DiaryOfaTTCer · 29/07/2023 23:35

Winterday1991 · 29/07/2023 20:54

Teachers who have high level degrees from good quality universities and teach in demand subjects such as maths, physics, chemistry etc should be paid at a rate equivalent to what their peers would earn in the private sector. For example starting salaries of £50k.

As I understand it, the current teacher pay scale means that drama, music teachers and low quality graduates are paid the same as high quality teachers. As teaching has low barrier to entry for graduates, and there is a shortage of teachers for certain subjects surely salaries should be treated as they would be in the private sector and paid the market rate. Why does the government not implement this to get more high quality graduates into teaching?

Because having a high quality degree from a top university doesn't necessarily mean you will have the skill set to be a good teacher

Olderandolder · 29/07/2023 23:16

Winterday1991 · 29/07/2023 21:35

Of course it does, but they should be judged by the same standards as in the private sector. The teaching profession needs to be pulled up and make it a competitive option for the best graduates.

People in the private sector are judged on what they can earn for the business. Even when they are required to have STEM degrees, this isn’t all they are judged on.

Govt involvement is education is the problem.

If regulation were lifted and competition allowed from new suppliers then you could find the right price for your services.

Doggytastic · 29/07/2023 23:14

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 29/07/2023 23:05

What standards are people held to in the private sector that teachers aren't held to, honestly?

I feel like as a teacher, there's far more accountability and having to prove I'm doing my job than when I worked in industry...

Absolutely!

Doggytastic · 29/07/2023 23:12

Winterday1991 · 29/07/2023 21:08

Stupid comment primary teaching is not equivalent to teaching chem, maths etc up to Alevel standard.

I speak from experience having taught both primary and secondary. Teaching primary is fat more challenging and requires excessive working hours compared to secondary teaching. What makes you an expert to judge which is the most worthy job equating to a higher salary? Everyone thinks they have an opinion on teaching as we have all been to school but unless you have done the job, I suggest you train to be a teacher, live and bloody breathe the job before commenting.

RootbeerLolly · 29/07/2023 23:08

Boomboom22 · 29/07/2023 21:01

People with very good maths and science degrees often make poor teachers as they understood it all first time, plus don't have the people skills / argument skills that other humanities and English grads have.

Indeed. And we're never going to catch up the Chinese in maths anyway.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 29/07/2023 23:05

What standards are people held to in the private sector that teachers aren't held to, honestly?

I feel like as a teacher, there's far more accountability and having to prove I'm doing my job than when I worked in industry...

Stomacharmeleon · 29/07/2023 23:03

My best friend is a cover in a school. Never went to uni but kids get her and what she is trying to put over. She does all the long term cover in our local grammar. She can literally read a lesson and teach it.
She was head hunted from her last school. I have the utmost respect for her.

I, on the other hand, teach several subjects in a PRU and feel constantly five minutes from a breakdown and have loads of qualifications!

Thriwit · 29/07/2023 23:00

I have an MSc in chemistry, and earn just over £30k with over a decade of experience. Looking at it, I could earn more teaching, long-term (& would have more holidays therefore save on childcare too). Not a chance I’d actually go into teaching though. Every teacher seems to say don’t do it, it’s awful for a hundred reasons. Pay is really not the main issue for attracting STEM teachers.

carduelis · 29/07/2023 22:47

Absolutely agree that being brilliant at your subject does not make you a brilliant teacher: it’s harder to make something accessible to someone else if it’s effortless for you.

I went to Oxford and I teach chemistry, and one of the things that really bothers me is the reaction I get from people when they find out I went to Oxford: that I could have done so much better than teaching. That kind of attitude - that teaching is not a job you do if you have any kind of brains - is certainly not going to do much to help the recruitment/retention crisis.

Echio · 29/07/2023 22:39

@lula103 Most sensible response on this thread!

Justashley · 29/07/2023 22:35

Of course it does, but they should be judged by the same standards as in the private sector. The teaching profession needs to be pulled up and make it a competitive option for the best graduates.

The 'best' graduates don't always make the best teachers though, subject knowledge is an important part of course, but so many other soft skills are what actually makes a decent teacher. I do agree that for some subjects especially computing etc the salary will never be competitive unless its out of step with other teachers (which wouldn't go down well) and it won't be an appealing career to many regardless. Not sure of the solution, maybe a flexible approach where SMEs come in and deliver lessons without all of the associated unnecessary crap teachers are expected to do? My DH works in tech, he'd enjoy teaching but not as a full time job.

watersprites · 29/07/2023 22:30

The best teachers imo are not necessarily the ones who know everything.

ASoapImpressionOfHisWifeWhichHeAte · 29/07/2023 22:30

I can't believe that people are engaging with @Winterday1991 ... their username might as well be "@BoredAndGoady".

watersprites · 29/07/2023 22:29

There aren't loads of graduate jobs starting on 50k.

miniaturepixieonacid · 29/07/2023 22:28

Ouch! I teach Drama, Dance and Musical Theatre to Years 3 - 8. I teach, do clubs and rehearse before school, in breaks, at lunchtimes, after school, on Saturdays and in holidays. I put on around 20 productions a year and get 90 children a year through national qualifications. And I have the same curriculum, reporting etc requirements as 'proper' subjects. My degree is a 2:1 from one of the highest ranked universities in the UK and I have 4 As at A2 level.

I do not believe that my subject is as important as maths and englush, no. But i resent the suggestion that I should be paid less than those colleagues, many of whom 'just' teach their 8:30 - 5:00 then go home with their marking. They're not stuck in school till midnight rehearsing then building sets, painting scenert programming lights and altering costumes. It might not be academic but it's long, hard hours.

moggiek · 29/07/2023 22:27

Winterday1991 · 29/07/2023 21:04

But their subject is in demand!

You don’t really know what a teacher is, do you?

labamba007 · 29/07/2023 22:19

Winterday1991 · 29/07/2023 21:03

The fact is that people with maths and science degrees do not go into teaching as they earn more in the private sector working in finance etc. How can the government incentivise these graduates to have a career in teaching when the salary is not competitive?

You could probably have said this without saying 'low qualified graduates' which is obviously going to get people's backs up.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 29/07/2023 22:19

Tbf, in terms of starting salaries, most maths/physics ECTs can negotiate starting on M2, if they want to- not in every school, but in a lot. Obviously they can't negotiate higher pay than UPS3, but for maths at least, there are also retention payments throughout their early career as well.

It doesn't seem to make much difference to whether they leave. Also, as others have said, schools now often struggle to recruit for everything from MFL to DT to Geography- so you'd just end up paying nearly everyone the higher rate. And what happens when people teach outside of specialism, as well?

Anecdotally, for physics teachers, the biggest issue isn't pay, but being asked to teach outside their subject area- especially biology. A lot of them hate it, more so than biology teachers being asked to cover physics. But it's often necessary at KS3 at least to make timetables work, now- and teachers of other sciences aren't so common that schools can afford to screw them with the timetabling- even if they theoretically could.

Another issue is the pressure of having to take on a lot of exam classes early career- often a physics ECT will be teaching multiple Y11 classes + Y12 and 13 from the start- and it's a lot to deal with in terms of both pressure and workload.

I think, in a lot of cases, you'd be better off giving science teachers more PPA to take into account the fact we're often planning and teaching 3 subjects, rather than necessarily more pay. I'm sure the pay is a factor in people not choosing teaching to start with, but workload is a much bigger factor in causing people to leave.

Overthebow · 29/07/2023 22:18

What are all these £50k starting salary jobs in the private sector? There aren't many of them. A teacher starts on £30k which is actually quite good and similar for many private sector jobs. You also need to take into account the pension and benefits, including holidays, that teachers get. It's surely the salaries for experienced teachers that needs sorting out as that isn't equivalent to decent private sector jobs, there isn't much in it between newly qualified teachers and experienced ones and whilst private sector staff of the same years experience and degrees are on £50k- £60k, experienced teachers are on £40k.

Lapland123 · 29/07/2023 22:16

There is a recruitment crisis across teaching and the salaries need to be significantly boosted- but the government have no interest in investing in state education any more than they have in the police or NHS

They are just busy rinsing us for tax and never investing in public services

Swipe left for the next trending thread