Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu 6.20am train for a meeting

432 replies

Chantholtmouse · 29/07/2023 18:10

Is it unreasonable of my workplace to expect me to get a 6.20am train to attend work meetings and training 300 miles away? I absolutely don't mind attending but a 6.20am train seems unreasonable. It's the only one that would get me there in time. I'd have to be up at 4.45am to quickly shower, dress, walk the dog around the block (I also have to find someone to pick him up) and drive to the train station which isn't that close.

It's then 3 full days of meetings and training which I'll be shattered for. I'll get a bit of time back but it still seems a big ask. There's no option for paid accomodation to stay the night before.

Aibu?

OP posts:
RichardMarxisinnocent · 30/07/2023 10:36

YouAndMeAndThem · 29/07/2023 20:55

Go to bed early the night before so even with an early start you'll not have lost any sleep. Don't stay up to late, if every day starts at 10am, you'll be able to have a lie in. I think you're being ridiculous. Loads of people commute to work at 6.30. even if not for 300 miles. Have a nap on the train!

I can't answer for the OP but going to bed early the night before wouldn't work for me. If I went to bed 2 hours earlier to allow for getting up 2 hours earlier, I would absolutely lose sleep because I wouldn't be able to fall asleep at 9pm. I'd spend at least an hour and a half just lying awake in bed with my eyes closed, because it's too much earlier than my normal bedtime and I'm not at all tired.

lionsleepstonight · 30/07/2023 10:25

I wouldnt go, but my company wouldn't expect me to do a 4./4.30am wake up and would allow a hotel the night before.

Mayhem3 · 30/07/2023 10:21

Chantholtmouse · 29/07/2023 19:10

My normal commute is about an hour to my local office. My contract states my local office and nothing about working from other offices.

Can you not refuse to go?

I’m a single parent and there’s no way I could go.

You’ve worded your thread completely wrong.

You’ve made it about the time you need to get a train but it sounds like you’re more annoyed about having to go at all, which is completely fair enough.

wombat1a · 30/07/2023 01:22

I think as a one-off there is no problem with this, this is your problem not their problem.
I would go as far to say that if made you catch this train once a month it would still be reasonable.
Plenty of people catch these trains, which is one of the reasons that exist.

PrittStix · 30/07/2023 01:13

neverbeenskiing · 29/07/2023 18:51

I'm surprised too. I worked for the NHS for years in a clinical role and had to leave the house at 5.30am every day to get to work, sometimes earlier if I had a meeting or training course at a different venue. If this is true then I think it's a waste of resources to be honest.

another one here - I leave the house at 6am for my clinical role. I’ve been on many training days where I’ve had to leave that early, rearrange childcare etc. My boss had to be in the office for a one off 6.30 start the other day.

I have never heard of this?

weeonionetta · 30/07/2023 01:06

Had to do similar journeys through work but would return on same day. A few days I had to arrange childcare from 5.30am to school drop off and from 3pm until 9pm which cost hundreds as certain hours classed as out of hours. This was not claimable.
I slept on both train journeys as I didn't get TOIL for the journeys.

It's tiring but not awful.
Hope it goes OK for you.

SleepingStandingUp · 30/07/2023 01:05

Chantholtmouse · 29/07/2023 18:28

Sorry I should have explained a bit more. Travelling 6.20am on Tuesday. Meeting starts 10am. Meetings/training Tuesday, Weds, Thurs. I don't have to travel back each day. I have accomodation for the other days. They won't pay for the Monday night to avoid such an early start though (fair enough but would have preferred meetings to start at maybe 11 as several people will have really early starts including my 4.45am alarm). I'll get the train back Thursday night and will get home between 9.30pm-10pm if trains are on time. Each night will be filled with networking stuff so there will be no chance to catch up on sleep.

So peak train fare on the first morning

Price up train fare the night before and a cheaper hotel for the first night.

Used to be cheaper to send me a night early and I'd book a cheap b&b, that go up for a 9.30 start

Tessabelle74 · 30/07/2023 00:57

Chantholtmouse · 29/07/2023 19:07

And I've explained that I did a commute at that time for years and why I feel this is different. There is no reason to call me rediculous so stop being unpleasant.

It's one early start, you ARE being ridiculous and if you don't want honest opinions then don't post on public forums! They're not asking you to take that train every day for the foreseeable future, it's ONE day

Leftbutcameback · 29/07/2023 23:08

It also benefits your employer if you stay the night before as you’re guaranteed to be on time for the training. I had to do a long south-north (and cross London) journey for an 11am start which would have been fine if not for the very sad incident on the line. Eventually made it just after lunch. Try selling the benefits to them of you being awake and guaranteed to be there with no issues.

Leftbutcameback · 29/07/2023 22:51

Chantholtmouse · 29/07/2023 19:10

My normal commute is about an hour to my local office. My contract states my local office and nothing about working from other offices.

I think if this is going to happen several times a years you need to make more of a fuss about it now. I don’t function if I have to get up that early, and I wouldn’t sleep either with worry about the alarm. The money spent on training would be wasted as I wouldn’t be very awake at least for the first day. Maybe explain it that way to your employer. As they’re paying for three days of it, it must be important training / meetings for you to attend and to perform well.

My employer (tight as they are being public sector) would still allow me to stay in a hotel the night before as it’s such an early start. I appreciate lots of people start that early for their jobs but I would never chose to do a job where I did that and it sounds as though you’re the same OP.

Ishallgototheball · 29/07/2023 22:50

@Twyford if you read the OP’s posts you’d know that there is no such contractual requirement, rendering your posts irrelevant.

Your bias is showing btw.

Have you something to add that hasn’t been said already? Helpful even…

Elvis1956 · 29/07/2023 22:47

Ah ha ha ha ha ha...my ex employer saw nothing wrong with me driving from Bristol to Manchester for 11am to 5pm conference. Then to Swansea(no motorway) to train external clients staff the next day 9 to 4. Then drive to the city of London to meet client CEO 10-2. Then back to Bristol where I popped into the office to catch up on email cos it was the naughties and I wasn't important enough (though meeting CEO 's of international banks) to have email at home.
Oh and my boss was not happy that I wanted to leave our head office in Halifax at 2pm to go home to Bristol the next week...God I hope the feedback I gave hr about not having any relationship with him cos I never spent any time with him as he never came to Bristol and was that he rude made sure he was made redundant the same time as me....I'd already set up an alternative business which the redundancy money funded!

zurala · 29/07/2023 22:46

GlitteringUnicorn · 29/07/2023 18:43

Really?? Never heard of that one and I also work for the NHS.
Hundreds of junior doctors leave work before 630am every single day and are not offered that. Are you clinical?

No not clinical. But it's true of the regional and national teams. I did loads of site visits last year and that was the rule on when to get a hotel the night before.

Sothisiit · 29/07/2023 22:45

Discuss how the additional hours are going to be compensated,check your contract.
Ask for time in lieu.

JudgeRudy · 29/07/2023 22:20

As a one off it doesn't seem unreasonable. Many people catch a train at that time when commuting. Presumably you will get expenses (petrol/train fare) back, but it does seem a bit stingey not to pay the extra night.

Just a thought but would it be worth you driving say 40miles to a town that's on a more direct line - so claim petrol and train fair back. If the meetings start on a Monday, would the train fair be cheaper if you travelled on a Sunday? If so it might be that Sunday train plus extra night might not be much more expensive than Monday train.

You could of course decline if it's not in your contract.

40andoverit · 29/07/2023 22:08

YANBU

unless the contract you have with your employer states that you are expected to travel for training then I can see why you are feeling annoyed.
I wonder how many people that have commented stating that they have to do long commutes and early starts regularly are earning a hell of a lot more than 30k per year and they would of been aware of commutes and expected working hours before taking on the role.

If you are working longer than your contracted hours you will be due back time from the employer also.

check the ACAS website but I’m sure your travel time may have to be paid as you are not going to your normal place of work but again it will depend on your contract.

RubyWedding · 29/07/2023 22:03

DP leaves for work at 6.50am every day. Neighbours husband goes out about 5.45am.
It's not that early, esp as a one-off.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 29/07/2023 22:00

I would expect them to pay a taxi to the train station. A 10am meeting 300 miles away is from can they move the first one to later?

Bonfire23 · 29/07/2023 21:59

I would imagine the people who are doing this as a daily commute aren't doing it for 30k either

Twyford · 29/07/2023 21:59

Soapyspuds · 29/07/2023 21:18

As someone who regularly had to get a 0500 train to get to work (leaving at 0430) and now has to get an 0455 bus to get to work (also leaving at 0430), I say Suck it up, Buttercup

But that was your choice to take that job knowing the place of work and where you live. Therefore comments like that are of no relevance to ops scenario.

Whilst she has only put limited information it appears that meetings held far away are NOT in ops contract. However she should really clarify this point.

I'd be prepared to bet that this is covered in the contract. It's absolutely standard for employment contracts to say that the employee must work where directed by the employer or as required for the purposes of the work the company does - not least because no employer can guarantee that the place of work will stay the same. That terminology includes being directed to attend a conference out of the office.

timegoingtooquickly · 29/07/2023 21:57

GlitteringUnicorn · 29/07/2023 18:30

Plenty of people do this as a daily commute.

Yes but they know this when they agree to the job. This is not the same at all 🤷🏼‍♀️

SpringleDingle · 29/07/2023 21:55

I have to get up at 3 next month for a flight for work, will land and go straight to the office for the rest of the day, client dinner, overnight stay and a full day the following day before a late flight home. It’s shit but it’s normal for work travel.

LuluBlakey1 · 29/07/2023 21:51

I am quite often sent to London on training or to meetings (by that I mean probably once a month/6 weeks). They always start at 10am which means a VERY early train from Newcastle and we live a 30 minute drive into Newcastle so I ended up leaving the house about 4.00am. I got up at 3am.

I was so fed up I said it was unreasonable and I wasn't prepared to do it. I now go the afternoon before and stay overnight in a hotel in Westminster. I meet my cousin for dinner and drinks in Soho, (not paid for of course) and sleep in a big bed with no DC waking me up or DH radiating heat like a volcano and wrapping himself round me. I have breakfast delivered via room service and it is absolute bliss (I pay for the room service).

I look forward to it now but to be honest it is a complete waste of time and money- the training/meeting could be done online but the government insist one of us attends so work send me.

Twyford · 29/07/2023 21:50

LindorDoubleChoc · 29/07/2023 20:46

All of this is completely irrelevant. You obviously want some sort of medal for how great you are, but that is YOUR job, not OP's job.

I would totally point blank refuse in OP's position and challenge my employer to attempt to fire me.

Good luck with that challenge. If, as is highly likely, this is a contractual requirement, an employee who refused to go would certainly earn a disciplinary, up to and including sacking, and would be laughed out of the tribunal if they attempted to claim for it.

Twyford · 29/07/2023 21:45

TaigaSno · 29/07/2023 20:35

"@SouthernLassies
I don't think you are living in the real world!
Many companies would just laugh at someone if they refused to work because of a dog they had to care for. And ditto the paying on a credit card.
Having a dog is a choice. It's a responsibility and people who work and have n backup need to think if a dog is practical for their lifestyle."

I can assure you I do live in the real world.
I'm one of the most senior employees at my company. I would never expect an employee to do something for a work purpose that would cause them financial difficulty in their personal life, regardless of what it was.
Yes, having a dog is a choice. It's a choice the OP made based on her being contracted to work in an office near her home that she returns to every evening. Having to pay for care for being away three days, and not being able to afford that, would make it reasonable for her to decline the trip. Training and networking 300 miles away is optional, not compulsory.

What is your evidence for saying "Yes, having a dog is a choice. It's a choice the OP made based on her being contracted to work in an office near her home that she returns to every evening"? It's incredibly likely that her contract includes a requirement or her to attend events of this nature.

Swipe left for the next trending thread