Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu 6.20am train for a meeting

432 replies

Chantholtmouse · 29/07/2023 18:10

Is it unreasonable of my workplace to expect me to get a 6.20am train to attend work meetings and training 300 miles away? I absolutely don't mind attending but a 6.20am train seems unreasonable. It's the only one that would get me there in time. I'd have to be up at 4.45am to quickly shower, dress, walk the dog around the block (I also have to find someone to pick him up) and drive to the train station which isn't that close.

It's then 3 full days of meetings and training which I'll be shattered for. I'll get a bit of time back but it still seems a big ask. There's no option for paid accomodation to stay the night before.

Aibu?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JST88 · 26/08/2023 21:00

I was questioning the person who said, ‘plenty of people have to get up at 4:45 for work’ hence the thinking 🤔 emoji lol

Koalasparkles · 08/08/2023 23:06

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 02/08/2023 14:11

Wow that's very generous. And costly Confused

Also nonsense. I regularly left home before 6.30 for training, getting home at 9pm. No idea what job in the NHS you have to do for them to pay for this. Plus, some people work nights or leave much earlier than this as part of their regular shifts in the NHS 🤷🏼‍♀️ definitely no hotel rooms

3mma22 · 04/08/2023 18:04

dahliadream · 02/08/2023 13:53

No, I don't think it is. My little one isn't a very good sleeper and it's true that one the nights we have a lot of wakes I do feel really tired the next day, but I'd be back on track after another good sleep the next night. And if she sleeps well then a change in routine (e.g., needing to get up a couple of hours early) wouldn't phase me.

As an example we went on holiday earlier this year and all had to be up at 3am to catch our flight. I didn't get much sleep before 3am (too excited!) and whilst yes I was ready for bed nice and early that night, it didn't impact further than that whereas it sounds like it would have ruined your trip. I don't think I am unusual so would definitely get yourself checked out, it seems such a shame that you're missing out on things that you enjoy due to this xx

I’ve got one that’s a good sleeper and one that is not at all. Can’t remember the last time I had an undisturbed night tbh, even the DM/DMIL doesn’t want an overnight with the challenging sleeper!!

Yes I would completely rule out a holiday that needed me to get up that early, whereas in my 20s I flitted between shifts starting at that time and rolling in from the club at that time on my day off!

Hope you had a fantastic holiday Smile

3mma22 · 04/08/2023 17:57

EarringsandLipstick · 02/08/2023 14:04

I hope your workplace was clear with you about the requirement for some evenings/weekends.

Honestly, we don't spell this out - it's pretty clear that at times we will need to deliver events / classes in the evening, or weekends, due to the nature of third level education.

We don't ever 'force' anyone to do it - reasonable employees are aware of the need for such approaches, and they are happy to take it in turns to deliver as needed.

we don't need to demand, or have it demanded of us. it's not an issue - it's a reasonable mature approach from both employee and employer, and like OP's employer, is an appropriate expectation.

Of course then employees are compensated with time-in-lieu as needed / based on their level.

That’s good to hear.

I can gather we both agree on the importance of clear expectations on working hours (whether that’s explicitly stating or from an understanding of the nature of an industry) and a robust professional relationship between employer and employee. Where we seem to disagree is whether the expectations for OP are reasonable or not.

Given this is the first time in her 5 years in the role that this has been required it is fair to be a bit taken aback without that making her unreasonable. Which a substantial minority also agree with.

My role involves recruitment and since mid 2021 I’ve noticed a stark increase in candidates discussing better work / life balance at interview, coupled with the pandemic WFH nature, I do think people’s expectations are changing, so that reasonable and mature approach is more critical than ever, particularly for retention.

A reasonable and mature employer would surely notice if an employee with a fair length of service was feeling disgruntled and see if there was any flexibility.

I have conceded my view is possibly skewed from being abnormally affected by changes to my sleep schedule.

I would add that time off in lieu is not a given IME so influences my opinion also!

Cooperpops · 04/08/2023 07:47

It’s not unreasonable to be expected to get a 6:20am train for a 10am start, they will be covering costs for train fare and there is hotel provided for the days that are over night. It would be unreasonable to expect a hotel the night prior and I doubt this would be accommodated. 6:20 isn’t an early train ride, if it was prior to 6am then I’d appreciate the resistance. I hear the pain of getting care for the dog but that’s not down to the employer that’s something you’d have to swallow. Do not listen to advice of don’t go, this isn’t helpful and will only cause issues.

zurala · 03/08/2023 22:46

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 02/08/2023 14:11

Wow that's very generous. And costly Confused

Not very costly, it's only a premier Inn, and we don't do that many site visits requiring early starts. Usually we travel same day.

Fairhsa · 02/08/2023 14:53

My husband caught the 5:30am train for years to commute from Birmingham to London. His rail pass cost more than our mortgage! Doing it as a one off for training is totally normal. Training is a GOOD THING. It's an investment in your future. I actually find your posts to be pretty wierd to be honest. Most people would be happy to get a few nights away from home.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 02/08/2023 14:13

I work in an exams office in a secondary school and during GCSES leave home just after 6.30 every am to be in for 7am.

And that's just a walk down the road.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 02/08/2023 14:11

zurala · 29/07/2023 18:40

I work for the NHS and if you would have to leave home before 6.30am to attend a meeting then they will pay for a hotel the night before, so on that basis YANBU.

I think it's unreasonable to have to start that early, I know people do it but it really is incredibly early.

Wow that's very generous. And costly Confused

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 02/08/2023 14:10

Chantholtmouse · 29/07/2023 18:28

Sorry I should have explained a bit more. Travelling 6.20am on Tuesday. Meeting starts 10am. Meetings/training Tuesday, Weds, Thurs. I don't have to travel back each day. I have accomodation for the other days. They won't pay for the Monday night to avoid such an early start though (fair enough but would have preferred meetings to start at maybe 11 as several people will have really early starts including my 4.45am alarm). I'll get the train back Thursday night and will get home between 9.30pm-10pm if trains are on time. Each night will be filled with networking stuff so there will be no chance to catch up on sleep.

I'd network for an hour tops after dinner then make a polite excuse to get back to my room. You won't be the only one!

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 02/08/2023 14:08

That used to be pretty standard in my last role (trainer) and about once a fortnight

EarringsandLipstick · 02/08/2023 14:04

I hope your workplace was clear with you about the requirement for some evenings/weekends.

Honestly, we don't spell this out - it's pretty clear that at times we will need to deliver events / classes in the evening, or weekends, due to the nature of third level education.

We don't ever 'force' anyone to do it - reasonable employees are aware of the need for such approaches, and they are happy to take it in turns to deliver as needed.

we don't need to demand, or have it demanded of us. it's not an issue - it's a reasonable mature approach from both employee and employer, and like OP's employer, is an appropriate expectation.

Of course then employees are compensated with time-in-lieu as needed / based on their level.

dahliadream · 02/08/2023 13:53

3mma22 · 02/08/2023 13:47

@dahliadream thanks for the advice. Certainly seems like it’s not the normal experience.

Eye opening thread - sorry for derailing OP.

No, I don't think it is. My little one isn't a very good sleeper and it's true that one the nights we have a lot of wakes I do feel really tired the next day, but I'd be back on track after another good sleep the next night. And if she sleeps well then a change in routine (e.g., needing to get up a couple of hours early) wouldn't phase me.

As an example we went on holiday earlier this year and all had to be up at 3am to catch our flight. I didn't get much sleep before 3am (too excited!) and whilst yes I was ready for bed nice and early that night, it didn't impact further than that whereas it sounds like it would have ruined your trip. I don't think I am unusual so would definitely get yourself checked out, it seems such a shame that you're missing out on things that you enjoy due to this xx

3mma22 · 02/08/2023 13:47

@dahliadream thanks for the advice. Certainly seems like it’s not the normal experience.

Eye opening thread - sorry for derailing OP.

3mma22 · 02/08/2023 13:30

EarringsandLipstick · 02/08/2023 08:40

whilst I would do it, I’d still be an little annoyed if I was asked to work a weekend or evening now!

Many many jobs require such flexibility & is usually covered by a catch-all phrase in employees' contracts (eg 'as required by the employer' or 'at the direction of the [head of organisation]')

In my workplace (academic), which is very much a standard working hours for most staff, they will be required to work some evenings / weekends - we can usually manage this on request, rather than mandating certain people do it, but everyone takes their turn.

It's a very normal part of many workplaces.

Apologies @EarringsandLipstick by asked I meant rhetorically asked i.e. mandated.

My contract does have a “to meet business needs” clause. In reality though it is at my discretion, so if I want to do an evening networking event, team building, client meeting etc it would be my choice. The team is large enough for any training to be done in our contracted location. Equally if I ever ask any of my staff to do something outside of their normal hours I make it clear it is an option with no pressure to accept as I understand they have a life outside of work and that’s why they chose such a job too.

I know many, many jobs do require more flexibility than mine- good employers are honest about the true extent at interview stage IME. I hope your workplace was clear with you about the requirement for some evenings/weekends.

From the sound of it OP has also chosen her work based on it being set hours at one location because that works for her other commitments.

Bearing in mind salaries are often lower and roles limited because of the better work/life balance - you can’t have it all!

3mma22 · 02/08/2023 11:40

CornishGem1975 · 02/08/2023 10:25

If anything, having kids made it easier for me to adjust to getting up earlier or going to bed later.

I'd say if you feel that bad you must have a medical reason.

For the majority, getting up a bit earlier in the morning is going to do nothing more than making you feel a bit tired.

Oh! Maybe?

I’ve had it from all angles that tiredness is part and parcel of having kids. I used to work 70+ hour weeks on shift patterns regularly pre kids with no issues.

Always thought other working Mums coped better with the ‘hungover-y-ness’. 🤷🏻‍♀️🙈

So a 6.20am train isn’t unreasonable for the majority then!!😂

dahliadream · 02/08/2023 11:21

3mma22 · 02/08/2023 08:06

Also, to all those who can happily get 3.30am flights, late finishes etc.
Is it really that easy for you to catch up on sleep?

Changing my sleep schedule by 2 or so hours on 1 day leaves me reeling for weeks, to the extent I’ve stopped holidays abroad, nights out etc.
Guess I’m doing something wrong!

Honestly I would be seeing your GP about this. I'm 35 with a two year old and no, I don't believe it's normal for a change in schedule to make you feel unwell like this, or to throw you out for days at a time x

Mumof2teens79 · 02/08/2023 10:26

Chantholtmouse · 29/07/2023 18:10

Is it unreasonable of my workplace to expect me to get a 6.20am train to attend work meetings and training 300 miles away? I absolutely don't mind attending but a 6.20am train seems unreasonable. It's the only one that would get me there in time. I'd have to be up at 4.45am to quickly shower, dress, walk the dog around the block (I also have to find someone to pick him up) and drive to the train station which isn't that close.

It's then 3 full days of meetings and training which I'll be shattered for. I'll get a bit of time back but it still seems a big ask. There's no option for paid accomodation to stay the night before.

Aibu?

The 6.20 train isn't that unreasonable. Previously you would even get time back for travel but now my company is better at that. But if you live that far from the train station....who is paying for parking if you are gone 3 days? And who is looking after the dog if you are the only one that can walk him?

But travelling the night before might mean not as early a start but you are away for longer and more issues?

CornishGem1975 · 02/08/2023 10:25

If anything, having kids made it easier for me to adjust to getting up earlier or going to bed later.

I'd say if you feel that bad you must have a medical reason.

For the majority, getting up a bit earlier in the morning is going to do nothing more than making you feel a bit tired.

3mma22 · 02/08/2023 10:21

GlitteringUnicorn · 02/08/2023 09:17

This makes me laugh.
All those people working shifts that you will rely on.
Maybe next time you call an ambulance/police out at night, or need to go to ED at 3am, get a night flight somewhere etc you will have a little thought for those shift workers. How do you think they manage regularly shifting their body clocks by many, many hours and often for not massive wages.

It makes you laugh that I can’t go on ‘proper’ holidays or socialise because it would take me weeks to recover?

I have a lot of empathy for everyone in emergency services, travel, logistics, hospitality, events industries. For a decade I was one of them, working in environments needing 24/7 cover, plenty of on call shifts, dealing with critical situations - when something goes wrong your shift doesn’t stop. I miss it massively, the adrenaline of dealing with the unexpected, the camaraderie you build is incomparable. And yes you do it for the love of it not the money!!

I’m only late 30s but assumed it was age and young kids that stopped me coping and that the few Mums that have stayed in my industry must be somehow coping with a constant brain fog, nausea, aches, hang over type feeling each day - this thread doesn’t seem that way, it implies that most people can easily shake off getting up or going to bed 3 hours earlier / later than usual - so what am I doing wrong?

Please don’t get me wrong, whilst I miss my career, I am grateful that my skills allowed me to transfer successfully to a 9-5 role that I enjoy, and gives me time with DC. The very odd time I need to work significantly later or earlier I do it, however I’ve learnt the hard way in the last few years that 16 hour shifts are not safe for me any more or productive for my company. If I need to advocate that I can and they would accommodate. It’s the kind of company that truly encourage a work/life balance rather than it being all talk.

GlitteringUnicorn · 02/08/2023 09:17

3mma22 · 02/08/2023 08:06

Also, to all those who can happily get 3.30am flights, late finishes etc.
Is it really that easy for you to catch up on sleep?

Changing my sleep schedule by 2 or so hours on 1 day leaves me reeling for weeks, to the extent I’ve stopped holidays abroad, nights out etc.
Guess I’m doing something wrong!

This makes me laugh.
All those people working shifts that you will rely on.
Maybe next time you call an ambulance/police out at night, or need to go to ED at 3am, get a night flight somewhere etc you will have a little thought for those shift workers. How do you think they manage regularly shifting their body clocks by many, many hours and often for not massive wages.

Doone21 · 02/08/2023 09:05

I'd just pay for my own accommodation the night before I think. Or can you demonstrate to them it'll save them on rail tickets if they send you up night before

EarringsandLipstick · 02/08/2023 08:40

whilst I would do it, I’d still be an little annoyed if I was asked to work a weekend or evening now!

Many many jobs require such flexibility & is usually covered by a catch-all phrase in employees' contracts (eg 'as required by the employer' or 'at the direction of the [head of organisation]')

In my workplace (academic), which is very much a standard working hours for most staff, they will be required to work some evenings / weekends - we can usually manage this on request, rather than mandating certain people do it, but everyone takes their turn.

It's a very normal part of many workplaces.

3mma22 · 02/08/2023 08:06

Also, to all those who can happily get 3.30am flights, late finishes etc.
Is it really that easy for you to catch up on sleep?

Changing my sleep schedule by 2 or so hours on 1 day leaves me reeling for weeks, to the extent I’ve stopped holidays abroad, nights out etc.
Guess I’m doing something wrong!

3mma22 · 02/08/2023 08:00

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 01/08/2023 11:01

yes, of course. especially if given advance notice.

Fair enough - thank you.

I got the impression that OP was asking if it was unreasonable to be asked to spend 2/3 hours travelling when she wouldn’t usually be at work whereas it seems a lot of posters are saying it is a reasonable start time and quoting their commutes.

I didn’t think it was about commutes though, generally we factor in what we personally feel is an acceptable daily commute, be it a daily 6am train or a 20 minute walk, into our choice of work. This is about extra working time no?

Personally I swapped from shifts to weekday 9-5 when my kids started school, whilst I would do it, I’d still be an little annoyed if I was asked to work a weekend or evening now!

What if you have a second job?