Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My sister and me

35 replies

Bristoluser · 29/07/2023 14:43

Hello everybody,

I just wanted everybody’s opinion about something that's really upsetting me.

It’s a long story. My sister and I inherited some money recently, we're both in our 40s with three children and stepchildren each.

I suggested about a year ago that following bereavements of the family and my husband being seriously ill a couple of years ago we should buy a property together abroad and use it as a holiday home for the two families. We’ve always been really close and the cousins are too.
I’ve also always been very close to my sister and her husband and I thought it’d be an ideal way to all spend time together.

My sister and I and my husband and her husband all seemed really keen on the idea.
We started looking at properties and even engaged an agent. I did loads of research and after discussing it lots of times we asked if they were really sure and they assured us they were. My sister booked flights, my husband and I both cancelled work for that week and everything seemed to be really good.

At the last minute though my sister changed her mind. I totally understand if she decided that she couldn't afford it or changed just changed her mind, however she told me by text and didn’t even really apologise.

My husband and I were really upset about it her seemingly casual attitude to it all. We expected a proper apology or explanation.

We then went to their house over Christmas and I admit I wasn’t in a very good mood when we went there as I was still hoping for an apology but she didn’t mention it.

The atmosphere wasn't good that day and since they have decided not to speak to us again. I admit I should have been in a better mood on that day and i really regret it, however I think they really let us down. There’s more to it but it could be really outing so I have to be careful...

Time has gone on now, and it's now about eight months since we went there and it seems that they will never speak to us again. I don’t know what to do. I wrote them a letter saying how we felt about the property but apologising for my mood that day. I said how much I cared about them and how sad it was for the children who were close cousins. They haven’t answered us and I don’t know how to move forward with all this.

Can anyone offer any advice? I would be really grateful.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SerenChocolateMuncher · 30/07/2023 11:01

"Just a bit quiet" is exactly how my toxic family member would justify the SBD treatment. "You upset me so much I struggle to speak."

People don't cut off close family members for being "a bit quiet". Ignoring someone or being "a bit quiet" because you are angry or disappointed in them is toxic behaviour. If you think it is an acceptable way to deal with conflict you are going to lose more people you think you are close to.

Gadolinite · 29/07/2023 23:28

Bristoluser · 29/07/2023 18:42

It was not Christmas day. It was not a tantrum or sulk. I was quieter than normal.

i wrote a letter afterwards to try to mend things, that's all.

i had asked her if she still wanted to get the property and was sure and she said '"yes, 100%' and booked the flights for all of us while we were on the phone. I then booked leave from my job and my husband turned down work for that week (he's freelance so lost quite a bit of money).

I do think we were both in the wrong.

If you were ‘just a bit quiet’ then what was there to apologise for?

poppitypop1 · 29/07/2023 21:16

She probably was very keen but on crunching the numbers further down the line changed her mind which she was free to do. Appreciate your husband lost money and it was frustrating to have the rug pulled out from underneath you, but if you were prepared to purchase a holiday home in the area you could have just treated it like a holiday. Expecting an apology is a bit much. Is there not anywhere in your budget, or did you need their investment?

Bristoluser · 29/07/2023 18:44

I think trust has been damaged on both sides.

OP posts:
Bristoluser · 29/07/2023 18:43

We weren't staying there by the way.

OP posts:
Bristoluser · 29/07/2023 18:42

It was not Christmas day. It was not a tantrum or sulk. I was quieter than normal.

i wrote a letter afterwards to try to mend things, that's all.

i had asked her if she still wanted to get the property and was sure and she said '"yes, 100%' and booked the flights for all of us while we were on the phone. I then booked leave from my job and my husband turned down work for that week (he's freelance so lost quite a bit of money).

I do think we were both in the wrong.

OP posts:
Caprisunny · 29/07/2023 17:02

CherryMaDeara · 29/07/2023 15:36

You seem to have made up your own story.

And OP doesn’t even say they were there on Christmas Day, you’ve just made that up.

Let’s try this again.

I haven’t made anything up.

I roll ‘over Christmas’ to mean staying over Christmas, including Christmas Day.

It doesn’t really matter. Either Op ruined a Christmas family event, sulking at the people hosting her. Or she ruined actual Christmas.

Both are PA behaviour and not usually done in isolation.

I have given my opinion. Not made anything up. You claimed you think the sister wanted her to be grinning and bowing. Is that made up or your opinion?

SerenChocolateMuncher · 29/07/2023 16:46

Bristoluser · 29/07/2023 14:55

I was just quiet. Nothing more.

I hope I'm wrong about this and I apologise if I am, but it sounds like you gave them the "silent but deadly treatment" while a guest in their home. If you did, I don't blame them for not wanting to speak to you again.

People who use this passive-aggressive strategy rarely do it as a one-off. It sounds like you might have form and your behaviour at Christmas was the straw that broke the camel's back.

A member of my family came to stay with us for Christmas a few years ago and gave me the SBD treatment while she was here, because I refused to comply with an unreasonable demand she made of me. It wasn't the first time she's behaved this way (in fact she's been doing it my whole life), but on this occasion I saw red. I was furious that she thought it was OK to treat me like it while a guest in our home and to spoil Christmas for my family and me because she wasn't getting everything her own way.

We had bent over backwards to make her stay as enjoyable as possible and she rewarded our hospitality with her toxic and abusive behaviour (because that is what SBD treatment is).

Her relationship to me and other family members means that I still have to have some contact with her, but I keep it to a minimum (thankfully she lives over 800 miles away) and she will NEVER cross our threshold again.

Gadolinite · 29/07/2023 16:21

I can fully understand you feeling put out at them cancelling on you with no real explanation – especially after you’d made travel plans and booked time off from work.

I think it was probably a mistake to go round there for the day feeling pissed off and resentful. Can totally understand you feeling upset, but this will obviously have made things far worse and given them reason to feel aggrieved. Imagine family coming to your home on Christmas Day and creating a weird atmosphere by sulking and being off with you – when you’ve put yourself out by hosting and want your kids to have a special day.

Don’t understand why a poster upthread has said writing a letter is weird – I think this wasn’t a bad way to apologise and give them time and space to process what you’ve said. I suppose the difficult bit is that the ball is in their court now and they may take their time to respond.

Frustrating as it is, I think you have to give them some space now and let the dust settle a bit. I think for them it’s probably damaged their trust in the relationship and will take some time to rebuild things. I’m sure you’ll be back on speaking terms at some point. You’ve said your piece, you can’t rush them, you just have to allow them space.

Hoppinggreen · 29/07/2023 16:08

Could she have backed out by text because she’s frightened of your reaction?
Sounds like you had a tantrum then a sulk followed by a letter that might not have been too pleasant

Heyhoherewegoagain · 29/07/2023 16:04

Bristoluser · 29/07/2023 14:55

I was just quiet. Nothing more.

So you were in the huff!

Caprisunny · 29/07/2023 16:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Someoneonlyyouknow · 29/07/2023 15:55

How big a property were you planning to buy if you thought it would give you the opportunity to spend more time together? Surely only one family would be there at a time? Perhaps your sister and her husband realised that constant negotiations would be needed if you co-owned a property.
Regardless, when she texted that they had changed their minds what was your response? Did you text or call back "That's a shame hope everything is OK?" Or did you wait months to visit at Christmas and sulk all day? Even your letter (not really less formal than a text, just more words) was part blame, part apology. If you want to say sorry just do that. Your sister may 'owe' you an apology for letting you invest time and energy into looking for a holiday home but she doesn't have to explain why she changed her mind.

Macaroni46 · 29/07/2023 15:47

Did you actually tell her that you were upset? To me, that seems the obvious thing to do rather than 'expecting an apology' and 'being quiet over Christmas'. Just use your words rather than being passive aggressive.
Your sister's allowed to change her mind but I do agree that she would've been better talking to you about it in person. Sounds like communication is poor in your family.

Thatboymum · 29/07/2023 15:44

Caprisunny · 29/07/2023 15:31

I am guessing if this was her point of view the telling you by text is directly connected to the behaviour you displayed.

I bet she would say you behaviour at Christmas isn’t a one off. She knew your reaction would be extreme so told you by text. Then you spoilt their Christmas. If yiu were going to be obviously moody, you should have just not gone. Letting someone host you when you intend to be rude all day is really poor behaviour. Especially at Christmas. Not like it was just a run of the mill Sunday lunch.
You say she didn’t ‘ even really apologise’. So she didn’t apologise to some degree. Just not the proper apology you wanted.

So she apologised, just not as profusely as you wanted. And she didn’t give a full explanation. You aren’t entitled to an explanation. They changed their minds. That’s all you are entitled to know. Again, your assumption you should be entitled to a full explanation , reveals your attitude towards her. That’s probably why she isn’t speaking to you. Your general attitude and entitlement has pissed her off. That might be why she decided no to the property as well.

If you can’t afford a holiday home without them adding in money, that’s your issue. No one else’s. No one else has to justify why they don’t want to help you out.

Agree with this I’ve taken from your op that she didn’t feel able to communicate to you in person because of your reaction, which you proved her rite about at Xmas but also that she may have felt coerced into the idea to keep you happy or please you so you didn’t then behave how you are now. I can kind of see why she’s cut her ties

quietnightmare · 29/07/2023 15:37

They changed their mind

Let it go

CherryMaDeara · 29/07/2023 15:36

Caprisunny · 29/07/2023 15:31

I am guessing if this was her point of view the telling you by text is directly connected to the behaviour you displayed.

I bet she would say you behaviour at Christmas isn’t a one off. She knew your reaction would be extreme so told you by text. Then you spoilt their Christmas. If yiu were going to be obviously moody, you should have just not gone. Letting someone host you when you intend to be rude all day is really poor behaviour. Especially at Christmas. Not like it was just a run of the mill Sunday lunch.
You say she didn’t ‘ even really apologise’. So she didn’t apologise to some degree. Just not the proper apology you wanted.

So she apologised, just not as profusely as you wanted. And she didn’t give a full explanation. You aren’t entitled to an explanation. They changed their minds. That’s all you are entitled to know. Again, your assumption you should be entitled to a full explanation , reveals your attitude towards her. That’s probably why she isn’t speaking to you. Your general attitude and entitlement has pissed her off. That might be why she decided no to the property as well.

If you can’t afford a holiday home without them adding in money, that’s your issue. No one else’s. No one else has to justify why they don’t want to help you out.

You seem to have made up your own story.

And OP doesn’t even say they were there on Christmas Day, you’ve just made that up.

CherryMaDeara · 29/07/2023 15:33

YANBU, they should have communicated their decision better.

It sounds like you were supposed to be grinning and bowing to them at Christmas to appease them. Are you usually the one who backs down?

Could you purchase a smaller property yourselves?

Caprisunny · 29/07/2023 15:31

I am guessing if this was her point of view the telling you by text is directly connected to the behaviour you displayed.

I bet she would say you behaviour at Christmas isn’t a one off. She knew your reaction would be extreme so told you by text. Then you spoilt their Christmas. If yiu were going to be obviously moody, you should have just not gone. Letting someone host you when you intend to be rude all day is really poor behaviour. Especially at Christmas. Not like it was just a run of the mill Sunday lunch.
You say she didn’t ‘ even really apologise’. So she didn’t apologise to some degree. Just not the proper apology you wanted.

So she apologised, just not as profusely as you wanted. And she didn’t give a full explanation. You aren’t entitled to an explanation. They changed their minds. That’s all you are entitled to know. Again, your assumption you should be entitled to a full explanation , reveals your attitude towards her. That’s probably why she isn’t speaking to you. Your general attitude and entitlement has pissed her off. That might be why she decided no to the property as well.

If you can’t afford a holiday home without them adding in money, that’s your issue. No one else’s. No one else has to justify why they don’t want to help you out.

Nadal1966 · 29/07/2023 15:25

I think they changed their minds in investing in property abroad, and IMO rather than texting their change if heart, which is easy to convey their feelings, but in this case a face to face conversation would have had more chance to resolve, why, and dìscuss on both sides, practical and emotional feelings. Texting is really not appropriate and a cop out. But hey I am not perfect, my husband isn't and my family arent either. I can understand why you did not feel like shari g Christmas cheer with her, but and I am not saying you are right, but why is it you apologised for Christmas, but from I have read no resolving c9nversation has been forthcoming from them. Yes, perhaps it has made the situation more strained with Christmas day, but what is done is done. Has your husband tried to speak to them? The sooner you can sit all together and discuss the problem, the longer it will go on and they really need to explain why their change of heart. You and your husband can either agree to disagree and move on, but at least everone will know howmeach other is feeling. Hope you resolve this and wish you good luck.

WhineWhineWhineWINE · 29/07/2023 15:22

It's hard to say without all the details of the other stuff you don't want to mention, but on the face of it it sounds like she maybe backed out by text the way she did because she was afraid of your reaction? Then you went for Christmas and sulked the whole time and that made her decide to detach completely. It sounds like there were issues in your relationship already and this might have been a final straw? Have you always been able to discuss your differences face to face, or is this a pattern? Is the dynamic of your relationship such that she could have felt pressured or bullied? As I said, impossible to tell without all the details and probably way off the mark. However it doesn't sound like how two people with an equal and healthy relationship would behave?

Trying2understand · 29/07/2023 15:09

@Bristoluser I can see you are hurting about the loss of the relationship. Something I try to remember is people often put into text what they are nervous/ashamed/worried about sharing on the phone or in person. Try not to let that be a 'thing' it really just shows maybe it was too hard to talk about and see/hear your reaction.

I don't think it was fair to give the cold shoulder b/c they didn't buy into a property with you. But I also see it's really clear you see that and have said sorry.

It must feel like a big loss for everyone.

If it were me I'd maybe wait until it's been a year (so another 4 months) and write a letter telling her again that you accept you really should have handled it better and it was wrong to expect more of them than they could do. Maybe ask how the kids can remain in contact if they still want space from you and your husband and that you love them etc but respect their need for space. Not sure how old the kids are but it's really unfortunate they are caught up in this. Maybe making it about them - are they old enough to go to the cineama together? Or a trampoline place? and take the pressure off your relationship.

Another thought, is there someone that could mediate?

I'm sure you are very hurt and feel this as a big loss. Hoping somehow things can get back on track.

Aquamarine1029 · 29/07/2023 15:04

How did you expect your sister to know you were so upset if you didn't tell her? Granted, most people have enough emotional intelligence to understand that if they back out of a big plan at the last minute, the other people involved are going to be upset. The fact is, we don't know if your sister fully realised how angry you actually were, and instead of talking to her about how you felt, you showed up at Christmas ruined it with your attitude.

So until you fill us in on the massive drip feed you inevitably have, YABU.

xPeaceXx · 29/07/2023 15:02

I think it's for the best that this plan fell apart early. Buying a house abroad would involve a lot of administration and organisation and practical work. Sharing this labour out would be a constant negotiation. It's a bad idea.

Use your money to give yourselves a holiday place. Or take a trip. Just spend your half your way. But expected 4 adults and children and step children to all find one plan that everybody is happy with is a tall fukcin' order and that's not a reflection on any one individual here.

MichelleScarn · 29/07/2023 15:02

SadKen82 · 29/07/2023 14:49

Meh. They changed their minds about spending a very large amount of their own money, which they're entitled to do.

I don't really understand the need for a big formal apology. You seem to think they've done something terrible to you?

This, you want them to apologise for not wanting to spend their money as you wanted to?
They booked flights, had you? Was the letter you sent chastising them again?