Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not want 19 yo DD to get a half leg sleeve tattoo?

413 replies

BlueEmerald73 · 29/07/2023 13:01

DD is booked in to have like a half leg sleeve, I have no idea what it's called but it goes from her ankle to right up top but just doesn't wrap all the way around the leg. She is travelling quite far for it which is the part I do actually respect as she has chosen the artist considerably but I do think it's a bit of a permanent, big decision at just 19. It's consisting of a few things as well, such as a reference to her favourite childhood interest, etc. basically just a bunch of things like that going up her leg. There's also my birth flower in there, which is sweet but I would rather she wasn't getting a tattoo, especially if it has a bit of a reference to me.

I realise it isn't my decision and I would never try and stop her, but AIBU to be a bit sad about it? She's still a teenager.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Catchasingmewithspiders · 05/08/2023 20:27

Tattooat16 · 05/08/2023 01:42

I got my first tattoo at 16. I didn't plan it. I only got it because I had the opportunity to get 1 for free. I went in and picked 1 that I liked. I got my second at 18 to commemorate by stillborn daughter. Again I had this done for free. I wouldn't have had any if I had to pay as I couldn't have afforded them even though they are only small and wouldn't have cost much. I don't regret either of them and never will. I didn't pick a design because it was in fashion or because I thought other people would like it. I liked it and even though it has faded now that I am 40, I still like it. It reminds my of the only period of my life, that only lasted a few months, where I was happy and care free, didn't have parents controlling me any more and didn't have any responsibility to anybody.
I don't care if anybody else likes my tattoos or not. I don't bother with makeup, nails or anything. My tattoos remind me of who I was at that age and how far I have come since then. I have never had anymore because I have better things to spend my money on.

I get that, my first tattoo I got when I was 20 and I finally realised that my abusive parents couldn't control my actions any more and I was free to do what I liked. I had left home several years earlier but it took me awhile to fully understand freedom

I've never regretted it once, and I still like the design. I don't care if people think it makes me look rough af or common or chavvy. They sound like the same sort of people who looked away when my mum was abusing me because they were middle class and abuse doesn't happen in their community. If they saw it happening it would make where they were living no better than the council estates they complained about. I have no time for people more concerned with how things look than who people are.

DrManhattan · 05/08/2023 14:39

They look rough af. Honestly seen people who's arms and necks looked like my desk at school.

Tattooat16 · 05/08/2023 01:42

I got my first tattoo at 16. I didn't plan it. I only got it because I had the opportunity to get 1 for free. I went in and picked 1 that I liked. I got my second at 18 to commemorate by stillborn daughter. Again I had this done for free. I wouldn't have had any if I had to pay as I couldn't have afforded them even though they are only small and wouldn't have cost much. I don't regret either of them and never will. I didn't pick a design because it was in fashion or because I thought other people would like it. I liked it and even though it has faded now that I am 40, I still like it. It reminds my of the only period of my life, that only lasted a few months, where I was happy and care free, didn't have parents controlling me any more and didn't have any responsibility to anybody.
I don't care if anybody else likes my tattoos or not. I don't bother with makeup, nails or anything. My tattoos remind me of who I was at that age and how far I have come since then. I have never had anymore because I have better things to spend my money on.

Maray1967 · 02/08/2023 21:30

Catchasingmewithspiders · 02/08/2023 14:42

Its not really a massive success story to bring a man up to believe if he controls the money he controls what other people do to their bodies

I mean you only need to go on a few relationships threads to see where that can lead

Teaching men (and women) that bodily autonomy cannot be bought seems a bit more important than stopping them from getting a tattoo personally

I understand that point but what any parent needs to consider is whether their 18 year old is properly exercising bodily autonomy or doing something that they might later regret under peer pressure.

My DS was talking about it in the context of a holiday abroad and that one of the other lads going was saying that they should all get tattoos done.

He is now 23 and there is nothing stopping him getting a tattoo. He has no intention of getting one. One of the mates who did get one is saving up to get his removed.

Beezknees · 02/08/2023 20:19

Tatslookawful · 02/08/2023 17:16

Can you get it removed? How much is removal, more than the original tattoo? & how effective?

It really varies, everyone charges different prices and there are different methods, some use lasers and some don't. It also depends on the tattoo. I've had laser removal, it cost £40 a session. The older the tattoo the harder it is to remove as a general rule of thumb, and black ink is easier to remove than coloured ink. Some only take a couple of sessions, others take 10+, some can be removed entirely and others can be faded a lot but not completely removed.

Gerrataere · 02/08/2023 18:16

TrickyD · 02/08/2023 17:37

I LOVE tattoo's on people, i think they shine through, bring out a personality. My OH has quite a few. My first one is currently being designed, a memorial piece.

Better make sure you get someone else to check any spelling; you wouldn’t want permanent misplaced apostrophes, would you?

Don’t be a dick 🙄

TrickyD · 02/08/2023 17:37

I LOVE tattoo's on people, i think they shine through, bring out a personality. My OH has quite a few. My first one is currently being designed, a memorial piece.

Better make sure you get someone else to check any spelling; you wouldn’t want permanent misplaced apostrophes, would you?

Tatslookawful · 02/08/2023 17:16

megletthesecond · 02/08/2023 17:09

I wish my parents had paid me to not get a tattoo. I wouldn't be regretting it every day of my life and hating how I look.

Can you get it removed? How much is removal, more than the original tattoo? & how effective?

megletthesecond · 02/08/2023 17:09

I wish my parents had paid me to not get a tattoo. I wouldn't be regretting it every day of my life and hating how I look.

RedPony1 · 02/08/2023 15:48

Catchasingmewithspiders · 02/08/2023 14:42

Its not really a massive success story to bring a man up to believe if he controls the money he controls what other people do to their bodies

I mean you only need to go on a few relationships threads to see where that can lead

Teaching men (and women) that bodily autonomy cannot be bought seems a bit more important than stopping them from getting a tattoo personally

This. 100 times over. How awful to control someone's body with money! Especially someone you love.

I LOVE tattoo's on people, i think they shine through, bring out a personality. My OH has quite a few. My first one is currently being designed, a memorial piece.

234vhh · 02/08/2023 14:53

Catchasingmewithspiders · 02/08/2023 14:42

Its not really a massive success story to bring a man up to believe if he controls the money he controls what other people do to their bodies

I mean you only need to go on a few relationships threads to see where that can lead

Teaching men (and women) that bodily autonomy cannot be bought seems a bit more important than stopping them from getting a tattoo personally

This is also true!

Catchasingmewithspiders · 02/08/2023 14:42

234vhh · 02/08/2023 14:28

Master stroke!

Its not really a massive success story to bring a man up to believe if he controls the money he controls what other people do to their bodies

I mean you only need to go on a few relationships threads to see where that can lead

Teaching men (and women) that bodily autonomy cannot be bought seems a bit more important than stopping them from getting a tattoo personally

234vhh · 02/08/2023 14:28

Maray1967 · 29/07/2023 14:00

I managed to make my DS at 18 think twice. Tattoo = no parental contribution from me for university. I’ve posted this before and some people on here call this controlling. But guess what - he’s now glad he didn’t do it, so I have no regrets whatsoever. There was nothing stopping him getting it done once he’d finished uni. I just used the financial leverage I had to delay it.

Master stroke!

Beezknees · 02/08/2023 14:12

thaegumathteth · 01/08/2023 15:21

I'm tattooed and have never done any of those things - need to catch up !!!!

Not sure casual sex and getting divorced are the same as psychopathology either......

Me neither! I live a pretty boring life by all accounts. I go to work, look after teen child, go out for coffee. Been celibate for 4 years actually! Never been married to get divorced and never had any issues with my mental health. Did smoke a bit of weed in the past, but then plenty of women on MN drink wine every day which is just as unhealthy and which I don't do.

Beezknees · 02/08/2023 14:09

Tatslookawful · 01/08/2023 15:28

I go to an upmarket health club, the glossy women in class don’t have them, the instructors do. Same at any of the top restaurants. The wait staff have them, the clientele, not so much.

I know this prob makes me classist, but it’s an observation.

Kate Middleton & Meghan M, no obs tats. If Meghan had an obvious sleeve/s PH prob wouldn’t have fallen as hard or married her IMO.

I don’t get the recent trend for the drawn on with bic biro type look, couldn’t you get it from using a pen?

What’s the next phase for tats? More easily removable? What follows?

OK, but I don't want to be Kate Middleton or a "glossy woman". That's not who I am. And they're not automatically better people than I am. Being upper class or wealthy doesn't make you a good person.

Beezknees · 02/08/2023 14:07

TrickyD · 02/08/2023 10:30

DS2 gave DH an imitation tattoo sleeve. It was very realistic, one end fitted under his short shirt sleeve, the other under his watch.

He wore it to a friend’s party. None of our friends have tattoos, and when the host spotted DH’s arm I thought he would pass out in shock.

DH also wore it to a ‘British Night’ party on a cruise. I noticed the sneers from people who spotted it. Yes, they may not be people whose opinion we care about but no denying tattooed people are judged.

Sorry, but we judge too. Rule of thumb: the posher the hotel, the fewer the tattoos.

I'm heavily tattooed and been to a few posh hotels including the Shangri-la. Never noticed any sneers, maybe I'm just thick skinned. And the people who sneer are people I'd want nothing to do with anyway!

JazbayGrapes · 02/08/2023 11:37

Most people I know regret some of their tattoos what was appealing and meant something to them in their 20’s doesn’t in the 40’s

Exactly. Tattoo removal is a very lucrative business.

Grapewrath · 02/08/2023 10:57

Some of these posts are hilarious

TrickyD · 02/08/2023 10:30

DS2 gave DH an imitation tattoo sleeve. It was very realistic, one end fitted under his short shirt sleeve, the other under his watch.

He wore it to a friend’s party. None of our friends have tattoos, and when the host spotted DH’s arm I thought he would pass out in shock.

DH also wore it to a ‘British Night’ party on a cruise. I noticed the sneers from people who spotted it. Yes, they may not be people whose opinion we care about but no denying tattooed people are judged.

Sorry, but we judge too. Rule of thumb: the posher the hotel, the fewer the tattoos.

SparklyFrogg · 02/08/2023 01:49

To anyone who may read/look at the summary of the paper posted above by another user

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1047279711002870

To provide a balanced view:
Whilst the paper is interesting it’s correlational. There’s a relationship (which is interesting!) but no cause and effect. It’s not necessarily the tattoos causing any of those things listed. Its likely to be that women with different risk factors are also likely to get tattoos so nothing to do with the tattoos themselves. Or a whole host of confounding factors.

Firstly, this paper is only generalisable to Brazilian women (the sample type).

Next looking at the figures, the differences are often very small between those with and without tattoos.

ie to quote the paper:

’As regards the participants’ sexual life, the major- ity of both non-tattooed (87.9%) and tattooed (82.3%) participants reported having had two or less sexual partners in the previous year, whereas 10.2% of the non-tattooed ones and 13.3% of the tattooed ones cited 3 to 5 sexual partners in the same period; the same per- centage (1.9%) in both groups had had between 6 and 10 sexual partners’

Thats just one thing they looked at yes. But the differences are pretty small throughout.

Bigger differences with both types of smoking, yes. But that just means in this sample more people with tattoos were smokers- not that smoking is necessarily associated with the tattoos themselves. Also, it was self report- ie the participants were asked about their behaviours.
Maybe those with tattoos were just more honest than those without? We can’t know etc, confounding factors.

It also says that women who display more psychopathology also more often have tattoos- ie those with mental health issues etc. Easy to misread this as psychopathy!
The tattoos haven’t caused the mental health issues.

I’ve seen other papers looking at how those with mental health issues often show more creativity - maybe this influences? This is often seen as positive!
Or of course, maybe many other factors too.

The paper also says the differences between those with and without tattoos are reduced.

98% were satisfied with their appearance after getting tattoos and 3 quarters of the sample said they wouldn’t remove their tattoos. This is pro tattoo to me!

I am not saying the user who linked the paper thinks the paper is causational but I just want to provide some clarity as some commenters may not realise, have time to read it all, or the access.

OP- It was suggested you show this paper to your DD. This paper has very little to do with your DD, unless she potentially lives in Brazil.

As for the second paper it’s 2am and I don’t have time to read it as well. It too is correlational and is more than 10 years old, so should be taken with the knowledge that society has greatly adapted in the last 10 years and thus results may not still be as representative.

Honestly I’m not sure what the inclusion of these papers was actually trying to prove relevant to this post. Why OP would need to show them to her daughter? It’s got nothing to do with her daughter wanting a tattoo in my view.
Anyway, I did find interest in reading what I did so a win I guess!

SparklyFrogg · 01/08/2023 20:41

@Tatslookawful Luckily this is changing. Most employers allow tattoos now (providing they are not hate symbols etc) and even those who often don’t (say teaching) most can be easily covered with a sleeve or trouser leg. Most public roles including healthcare, emergency services etc allow non offensive tattoos.
Im sure most corporate roles wouldn’t even know most people had tattoos, as most are covered by clothes anyway.
I have never come across a higher educational institution that has not allowed tattoos and piercings. In fact many professors themselves have tattoos etc.

I cannot think of a job where most tattoos would be an issue at all.

Piercing removal for sport careers and food hygiene logically makes sense- this is not to do with judgement but safety.

Perhaps employers who judge tattoos should be challenged rather than someone with the lunar cycle or a mountain or whatever it is that’s non offensive, tattooed on them?

SparklyFrogg · 01/08/2023 20:35

Everyone on here is entitled to their opinion. This comment is not directed at OP but rather overall to the thread.

Tattoos and piercings say nothing about an individual bar the fact they like tattoos and piercings. That is literally it.

But calling people with tattoos and their tattoos nasty times and likening them to being disfigured or using offensive language regarding poorer people (multiple people have made similar comments to this, this is not directed at any person specifically) may indicate you need to approach the world with a more open, less judgemental mind.

No one has to like tattoos- it’s ok to prefer so called ‘natural beauty’. But the language and tone of some of these comments made me really sad. Some seemed quite hateful, which I don’t think is ok. Why are we being so judgemental of something so unimportant to a persons overall character? They are probably full of kindness, love, achievements, qualifications… and all some commenters seem to think matters is their so called ‘ugly’ tattoos, which could just be a non-offensive flower.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 01/08/2023 17:27

Tatslookawful · 01/08/2023 16:31

The point is many young people think they are super edgy & cool but they can also hold you back & be limiting. Depending.

I don't think tattoos are what's holding a waitress back from being Kate Middleton. I think it's intergenerational wealth and a class system personally. Throw in a little private schooling, some rich friends etc

sophiasnail · 01/08/2023 17:00

You are definitely not being unreasonable for feeling as you do (I really dislike any tattoos) but you would be unreasonable to share your feelings with her at this stage.

You might have to appreciate the art in itself when it is finished, and try not to think about where it is. You can still share the fact she is really pleased with it (hopefully) without actually being pleased.

Tatslookawful · 01/08/2023 16:31

The point is many young people think they are super edgy & cool but they can also hold you back & be limiting. Depending.