Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Worried about son's height

188 replies

vitDsunshine · 29/07/2023 03:06

12.5 DS is 143cm. Always been small. His dad is 5 ft 8, I'm 5ft 2. His dad was also v small until about 15, then shot up (well, relatively!) so quite likely, DS's trajectory is similar.

I'm just worried. What if he's tiny? Far shorter than he's dad? He's already very conscious of it and as his friends start to go through puberty, I've no doubt his self-consciousness will increase. Obviously I tell him he's amazing etc, and that we all have to love and be kind to the bodies we are given...

But I've seen some awful posts on mumsnet about women's feelings about short men - there's prejudice.

I guess I worry it will affect his happiness in life.

Please, no nasty judgments. I'm just expressing fears I can't share IRL.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Violinist64 · 29/07/2023 09:03

Why is being short considered a problem? I have three children - all three were either the smallest in the class or almost so. My daughter, who is the youngest, was the smallest in the school for three years. Her first school shoes were an infant size 6 and she started high school in size 13 1/2. She is in her twenties now and is a petite size 6/8 5’1 with size 2 shoes. Small but not unusually so. Her brothers are around 5’5 and 5’7: both wear size 7 shoes. Again, absolutely fine. My middle son, who is the tallest, asked me during his adolescent growth spurt what his chances were of reaching six feet. I looked him in the eye and said “absolutely none.”

89redballoons · 29/07/2023 08:52

MissesMorkan · 29/07/2023 08:42

Give us a clue about the band???

Grin would be outing! And they are pretty obscure now, though if you were into the 80s indie/C86 scene you'd have heard of them at the time.

Wiki actually tells me it was a no.4 and not a no.2 hit. Maybe it was FIL's height that kept them off the top spot!

MissesMorkan · 29/07/2023 08:42

89redballoons · 29/07/2023 07:57

FFS. How would we all feel if it was a man posting here, worried that his teenage DD had small breasts and all the women in the families did and he just hoped she developed at least B cups so it wouldn't be anything "life limiting"?

143cm at 12.5 is between the 9th and 25th centile, according to the WHO growth charts. So it doesn't sound like OP's DS is anywhere near outside the normal and healthy range of heights for his age.

My DH is 5'8 and the tallest out of the men on both sides of his family. DH's height has never held him back - he's married obviously (I'm 5'6"), used to play County level cricket, has a good job. His dad, who was shorter than him, was in a successful band in the 80s - there's a picture of baby DH in Smash Hits magazine as his dad had a song at no.2 in the charts when DH was born. I also had a couple of boyfriends on the shorter side before I met DH. I can't believe what some women are like when it comes to men's height 🙄 ridiculous.

Give us a clue about the band???

Oblomov23 · 29/07/2023 08:39

I'd ask GP to be referred to consultant. I wouldn't be fobbed off. And I'd do it now, because as silver arch says if you leave it too late into puberty nothing can be done. Lots of people chose not to do anything, because it's slightly contentious : do you act or not. But at least you'd have the choice, if you leave it you might not even have that choice.

StaySpicy · 29/07/2023 08:37

I have similar worries with my son (he's only 5!). I'm about 5'1 and my DH is about 5'7 or 5'8. Already our son is noticeably smaller than lots of his peers and I'm just hoping that he will grow to be at least as tall as his dad.

I totally agree with teaching body confidence and having hobbies that don't focus on height. DS currently enjoys gymnastics.

It doesn't help though that my sibling is over 6', their partner is 6' and their 13 year old child is nearly 6'. I hate the family commenting on it every single time we go to visit. I'll have to ask them to stop because I don't want it made into a big thing in my son's mind.

ZairWazAnOldLady · 29/07/2023 08:32

I think if it weeds out the nonsense women who are choosing partners on height (WTF!) it’s a good thing. In real life only arseholes care about height like that.
I’ve been married to my shorter husband for nearly 30 years and I can assure you he was and is extremely “well thought of” as husband material.

Archeron · 29/07/2023 08:30

I have a friend who is 5ft6 and absolutely gorgeous. I would jump at the chance to get physical (not gonna happen because he’s way out of my league for various reasons). Height is not a deal breaker if you’re good looking and confident.

Madmother63 · 29/07/2023 08:27

My xDH was 5ft 6 and me 5ft 3. My DS didn't start really growing until 17. He's now 5ft 8. I'm from a family of short people and my DH is only 5ft 5, so suits me perfectly. I actually don't like tall men. Who wants to be standing on tip toes for a kiss 💋

Pythonesque · 29/07/2023 08:23

I think the ages of 12-14 can be hard on boys who are growing later than others. My son grew early and was probably 5'8 or 9 when he turned 12, and very nearly 6' turning 13. Having been used to being the tallest he then had many friends sail past him over the following couple of years.

If you have a smaller child, as long as puberty doesn't seem advanced, you can reassure them that the longer they have to grow, slowly, before they have their final puberty growth spurt, the taller they are likely to end up. But that's only something to say if they themselves are bringing up the subject of their height.

towriteyoumustlive · 29/07/2023 08:23

His height is completely within the normal range at that age, and given both his parents are below average height then all is normal!

CatsOnTheChair · 29/07/2023 08:20

Please don't worry about your son.
He is a tiny bit shorter than my 50th centile 12-and a bit year old. So, not unusually short at all - and far off growth hormones etc.
Yes, he looks dinky compared to some of his friends - but they are giant, adult sized, pre teens.
His older brother was dinky (i used to get asked if they were twins with a 2 year age difference). At 15, he's now nearly DHs height, and only a tiny bit shorter than me. Is he likely to make his grandfather's 6'+height? Nope. But he doesn't look out of place in his peer group, needs age appropriate trousers (for legs, but not waist)

CheeseSauce · 29/07/2023 08:18

I was reading that red meat has growth hormones in it, which has helped the population grow.

Could you look at his diet, to support him growing, if you don't already?

Gymrabbit · 29/07/2023 08:16

There is no point worrying about it at all since there’s nothing you can do unless it’s to the extreme that he needs hormone help. As other posters said plenty of shorter men are successful.
having said that to suggest it is in no way an issue is also a little naive.
many studies have suggested that overall taller men are more successful.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3088322/amp/Taller-people-RICHER-Scientists-biggest-leap-income-takes-place-5-4-5-6-6-no-effect.html

and it’s true that many women would be reluctant to date a shorter man.

and rubbish to suggest that Hollywood actors are ‘mostly short’ - Tom Cruise is short (and is famous for being so) and some of the older proper actors are such as al Pacino but the new crop of successful actors are all over 6 foot for example all the marvel stars.

Size really does matter: Taller people earn more, claims study

Researchers at Ohio State University found that the nutrition people received as a child, which affects both height and intelligence, is an important factor in determining salary

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3088322/amp/Taller-people-RICHER-Scientists-biggest-leap-income-takes-place-5-4-5-6-6-no-effect.html

HairyKitty · 29/07/2023 07:59

OP, shorter men have a huge “marriage pool” of shorter women, and there are plenty of shorter women. I know society judges men on height, but it judges men and women on many many things, this is just one of them.

89redballoons · 29/07/2023 07:57

FFS. How would we all feel if it was a man posting here, worried that his teenage DD had small breasts and all the women in the families did and he just hoped she developed at least B cups so it wouldn't be anything "life limiting"?

143cm at 12.5 is between the 9th and 25th centile, according to the WHO growth charts. So it doesn't sound like OP's DS is anywhere near outside the normal and healthy range of heights for his age.

My DH is 5'8 and the tallest out of the men on both sides of his family. DH's height has never held him back - he's married obviously (I'm 5'6"), used to play County level cricket, has a good job. His dad, who was shorter than him, was in a successful band in the 80s - there's a picture of baby DH in Smash Hits magazine as his dad had a song at no.2 in the charts when DH was born. I also had a couple of boyfriends on the shorter side before I met DH. I can't believe what some women are like when it comes to men's height 🙄 ridiculous.

Threenow · 29/07/2023 07:23

CoalCraft · 29/07/2023 05:53

Well this thread is a bit depressing. We've got posts suggesting OP drug her child into tallness, others saying variation on "well, it's a shame, but hopefully he'll scrape by..."

Good lord, we're talking about being short! It's not a big deal. I know plenty of short men, both in my family, as friends and as acquaintances, and they're all doing just fine. Successful in their careers, married or engaged, and perfectly pleasant people.

Thank goodness - a sensible post! I'm 5ft 7 and I see men shorter than I am. I don't gaze in them in wonder and feel sorry for them, and they all seem to have partners. One man who lives near me has a tall wife and I've yet to see strangers stop and stare at them.

Stop obsessing about your son's potential height and just get on with life.

WildFeathers · 29/07/2023 07:06

within my circle of friends, as they’ve got to teenage years, a few of our children have struggled a little with body confidence, for a variety of reasons. One friend focused on giving her child confidence through sport and their child loves doing CrossFit at a gym, which has special classes for teens. It’s caught on like wildfire within the group and most of our kids go. The positive impact on body confidence has been really noticeable. It’s a class that’s set up to challenge you individually and doesn’t set people up in competition with each other so naturally ability isn’t a factor.

HelpNeededBeforeIHaveABreakdown · 29/07/2023 06:44

heartbroken40 · 29/07/2023 05:32

@vitDsunshine please look up growth hormone deficiency. Can you see an endo privately? They can do a hand X-ray to determine bone age and some blood tests. Good luck

It is worth having some medical checks, coeliac is another reason children don't reach their full potential height.

TerfTalking · 29/07/2023 06:29

Hi OP, my DH is 5ft 8, DS is 5ft 7 and DD 5ft 2. DS has never been short of girlfriends and played rugby union for our county until he was 20. Plays great golf now and has a well paid job. Getting married soon.

DD’s BF is 5ft 6, a very successful accountant with bags of confidence who does triathlons. They are engaged.

please, please stop this, embrace and encourage him to be his best self and thank goodness you have a healthy child.

IME his mates will take the piss, but they will still be his mates, and there will 100% be reciprocated banter with them if you encourage confidence.

xPeaceXx · 29/07/2023 06:20

You're right, the things you read on here. In real life, a good looking short man who is funny and respectful is going to be well-liked and a tall awful man is just going to be a man who is awful and there's more of him. I'm 5'1'' and somehow my son is 6'' but some kids do have a delayed puberty. My son went through puberty early but I think the biggest difference was between 13 and 14 when some of his friends still looked like little choir boys. People were asking, ''did he stay back a year''. It's evened out now, they are all post that first growth spurt now, but at 17 he's still the first to look like he should start shaving.... So, I don't think you can even decide if you need to feel bad for him yet. In the real world women aren't so heightist.

StampOnTheGround · 29/07/2023 06:16

My DH is about 5 foot 6 and our DS is only 18 months but a dinky dot really. He'll be absolutely fine 😊

BusMumsHoliday · 29/07/2023 06:15

Agree with @CoalCraft that this is massively depressing! There's nothing wrong with short men. My mum is an inch taller than my dad, whose 5'5". My husband is 5'8" and one of the taller ones in his family. I'm 5'6", so taller than him if I wear heels and neither of us care. I'm not sure any of the short men in my family feel it's affected them profoundly - it's just a thing about them.

Boys and men will find something to rib each other about. And as for women's prejudice - would you really want your son partnered with someone who thought like that? What people are more likely to pick up on and respond to is a self consciousness or any sense of bitterness that develops.

OP, if your son needs a confidence boost, could you get him involved in a sport where being smaller can be an advantage (my small, light father was a good distance runner at school), or a martial art that separates by weight class? Sometimes sport can be a bit divisive in the teens. My brother was a summer born with a late growth spurt and he had to stop playing club rugby for a bit because some of the lads were so much bigger (his then best mate was 6' at 14) and he got hurt a lot.

XelaM · 29/07/2023 06:05

It's the short men who get all the beautiful women! Look at Hollywood actors who are all mostly short.

bert3400 · 29/07/2023 06:01

My DS was very small at 12, no change at 13, no change at 14, smallest in his year ....he is now nearly 15 and has shot up the last few months, voice broken, lost all his puppy fat and the transformation has been incredible. Your son is still very young - please don't stress.

PinkButtercups · 29/07/2023 05:55

Our heights are the same even our DP's.

My DS (4) is dinky. Everyone always comments on just how small he is which is a bit annoying but he's also a summer born child so of course his peers who are older are going to look older 🙄.