Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Worried about son's height

188 replies

vitDsunshine · 29/07/2023 03:06

12.5 DS is 143cm. Always been small. His dad is 5 ft 8, I'm 5ft 2. His dad was also v small until about 15, then shot up (well, relatively!) so quite likely, DS's trajectory is similar.

I'm just worried. What if he's tiny? Far shorter than he's dad? He's already very conscious of it and as his friends start to go through puberty, I've no doubt his self-consciousness will increase. Obviously I tell him he's amazing etc, and that we all have to love and be kind to the bodies we are given...

But I've seen some awful posts on mumsnet about women's feelings about short men - there's prejudice.

I guess I worry it will affect his happiness in life.

Please, no nasty judgments. I'm just expressing fears I can't share IRL.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
PassTheSnacks · 29/07/2023 13:55

Or, if bothered, they can always move to a country of small people, like France or Japan. 🤣🤣 Just avoid the Nordics. 😁

PassTheSnacks · 29/07/2023 13:54

I mean it is limiting isn't it? In the sense that we know it disadvantages you romantically and financially. It's not great in crowded places, or for a myriad of other practical things. That said, there is some evidence that shorter people have longer life expectancies, although causation vs correlation on that one is still unclear.

But it's not something you can do much about. Genetics is the main factor. Although a childhood diet high in protein and dairy especially seems to help maximise someone's potential height, but the overall effect of that compared to genetics will be small.

Best to focus I think on ensuring your children are confident and secure and focused on their own goals and valuing themselves for who they are and their values. This is the best protective element against being overly affected by superficial judgements from others.

gingerguineapig · 29/07/2023 13:47

Don't forget someone referring to being short as "life limiting". I hadn't realised I should be expecting an early demise from my short husband

I always think MN's use of "life-limiting" rather odd - for me something that is life-limiting, limits your life, like a disability might. Rather than being life-threatening or shortening. Happily I don't think being shorter than average fits either category :)

gingerguineapig · 29/07/2023 13:44

We have a mix of heights in our family with some of the men being 5 foot 4 and others being well over 6 foot. My father was over 6 foot and so is my nephew.

But my husband is only about 5 foot 5.5 and DS is 5 foot 7 (I am just under 5 foot 4). On the plus side we can all drive the cars interchangably without having to move the seats etc :)

I still have my son's red baby book and he was always around the 9th centile. He did have a slight growth spurt around the age of 14. I think he was probably about the same height as your son at the same age.

The nastiness about small men is very annoying but reflects more badly on those who make such remarks - much like the people who like to close down women by calling them Karen, they close down men by talking about "small man syndrome". It's all very childish and smaller men need to rise above it.

As for comparing height with breast size, words fail me!

VeridicalVagabond · 29/07/2023 13:38

My mam is 5'3" and my dad is 5'9" and somehow me and all my siblings ended up taller than average, I'm actually the shortest at 5'7", my oldest brother is 6'3"! Convinced there was growth hormones in the water where we grew up.

He may shoot up when he has his teenage growth spurt, happened at about 15 for all my brothers. But even if he doesn't and remains average or slightly below, it's hardly the end of the world. I have lots of male friends who are the same height or shorter than me and they all get on perfectly fine in life. Good careers, partners, families. Happiness and health are not height restricted!

KimberleyClark · 29/07/2023 13:32

HairyKitty · 29/07/2023 07:59

OP, shorter men have a huge “marriage pool” of shorter women, and there are plenty of shorter women. I know society judges men on height, but it judges men and women on many many things, this is just one of them.

Unfortunately there are plenty of short women who won’t date shorter men.

ditalini · 29/07/2023 13:26

Move to Scotland. Yes there are tall people here, but 5'8" is bang average and certainly not worthy of comment. I'm 5'6" and see men around my height or slightly taller all the time.

My dh gets called "big man"* at 5'8” 😂😂

(*Most men get called big man tbh and it's probably more down to him being built like a brink shithouse)

HappyJoyousFree · 29/07/2023 13:19

Oh dear, my boys are all scuppered then as not only do they take after their dad heightwise (I'm 6ft but clearly haven't balanced them out) but they're red heads 🤣

OP I'd try not to worry. There will always be something kids will pick on in school - height, weight, hair colour, nose size etc. If they're healthy and happy don't over think it. People come in all shapes and sizes and it doesn't have to define them. I wouldn't put any emphasis on it.

j1307 · 29/07/2023 13:05

If you want him to build confidence I suggest him trying out coxing for a boat-club. Most important job in the boat, so in many boat-clubs coxes are treated really well since they can make or break a race. Also once he’s used to having 4-8 rowers listen to his every word he can handle any team-leading situation.

Frenchthing · 29/07/2023 12:55

A boy at school with me in the 1970s was short. He was treated with some sort of growth hormone and became oddly barrel-chested and muscular, but not tall.

Tessisme · 29/07/2023 12:54

CinnamonBunAndCoffee · 29/07/2023 12:19

My DS is short for his age. He’s younger than your DS, but is comforted by the fact Mark Owen, Ant &Dec, Tom Cruise and many other very successful male celebrities are short and it certainly hasn’t held them back. I’m a big believer in personality is more important than anything else.

That's a great attitude for your son to have. DS2 is almost 11 and short for his age. He is quite self conscious, which isn't helped by the fact that his 15yo brother is 6'1" and EVERYONE comments on it as if it's a great achievement.

It's so sad that many people view being on the small side as a disadvantage. My mum is small and is obsessed with other people's height. She was brought into A&E last night and I spent two hours listening to her commenting on the height of everyone who walked past. I could use her Alzheimer's as an excuse for her lack of a filter, but she was always the same!

rosepetals2023 · 29/07/2023 12:34

I wouldn’t worry, my brother (18 months difference) was always a lot shorter than me and had a slight frame growing up. Shot up when he was about 15 now he’s 6”4 😊

SpamIAm · 29/07/2023 12:32

CoalCraft · 29/07/2023 05:53

Well this thread is a bit depressing. We've got posts suggesting OP drug her child into tallness, others saying variation on "well, it's a shame, but hopefully he'll scrape by..."

Good lord, we're talking about being short! It's not a big deal. I know plenty of short men, both in my family, as friends and as acquaintances, and they're all doing just fine. Successful in their careers, married or engaged, and perfectly pleasant people.

Don't forget someone referring to being short as "life limiting". I hadn't realised I should be expecting an early demise from my short husband...

CinnamonBunAndCoffee · 29/07/2023 12:19

My DS is short for his age. He’s younger than your DS, but is comforted by the fact Mark Owen, Ant &Dec, Tom Cruise and many other very successful male celebrities are short and it certainly hasn’t held them back. I’m a big believer in personality is more important than anything else.

lljkk · 29/07/2023 12:13

There are a lot of short just finished yr7 boys. I helped out at 2ndry school disco a few weeks ago & was quite struck by the many shorties.

Barleysugar86 · 29/07/2023 11:56

My husband is 5ft 7. He hasn't had any problems in life as he is confident and charismatic. I'm sure men have it easier if they are taller but besides some jokes about being short over and over he's had a good life.

I did have a preference for dating tall men. But when I met him he was my soul mate. Personality is so much- you take someone like Richard Hammond he is hot regardless!

I'm prepared to help my son through it if he is also small, and similarly help my daughter if she inherits my barely there boobs.

I am trying to get them both stage lessons to help with their confidence generally as I think that will carry a kid through anything.

KeepQuietAndMoveAlong · 29/07/2023 11:49

You're short, your man is slightly below average. Your son might end up being short, but there's nothing you can do to prevent it - so why worry? If he is, so what?

My husband is 5ft 9, I'm 5ft 1. Sons are 5ft 10 and 6ft 2

Tessisme · 29/07/2023 11:45

My dad was 5'7" and my mum is 5'1", so both small. Somehow my brother is 6ft, I am 5'7" and my sister was 5'6". I have no idea where we all got our height. There were plenty of jokes about the milkman etc! When I think about it, though, all my mum's siblings are tall, so I guess we must have inherited our height from our grandparents and Mum must have inherited her shortness from perhaps one of her grandparents.

vitDsunshine · 29/07/2023 11:45

RedGreenBlueSky · 29/07/2023 09:05

My DS is a year older and a couple of centimetres taller. Me & his dad are both 5'8. He has a very tough time at school because of it so I understand it's worrying. He was referred to endocrinologist by GP for some tests and so far everything seems normal except for delayed puberty. They have said he can have testosterone now to kick start things (he's decided he doesn't want it yet) and are seeing him every 6 months to check things are progressing.

Perhaps see GP to begin process of ruling out medical problems? In theory I agree with everyone saying don't worry there's nothing wrong with being a short man - but it does make their school life a lot harder than people expect. It's the relentless comments, everyday that get him down. Being pushed around and not being able to do much about it (he's more than a foot shorter than many in his year). Patronising or surprised comments from people (adult and children) who meet him and hear his age. It's tough.

I really emphasise with this

OP posts:
vitDsunshine · 29/07/2023 11:44

*All the posters not players!

OP posts:
vitDsunshine · 29/07/2023 11:44

HairyKitty · 29/07/2023 11:32

@vitDsunshine please do not rush to see a consultant without researching the options that will be available.

As far as I understand, excepting any actual medical issue, “growth hormones” only accelerate the increase in height, but do not increase (sometimes even causing a reduction) the final height.
If this is correct then consider whether medicalising the situation will benefit or harm your child’s self esteem and identity around their height, I guess each child might be different here.

Yes, I'm aware of the issues with hormonal treatment - I def won't be rushing. I think that if by 13.5 we haven't seen any growth, I'd go to a consultant to just check everything is ok. My husband is completely opposed to hormone treatment unless necessary - I agree.

I am very grateful for al the players who are so positive - I'm completely aware there are far worse things. And I know he has a huge, charismatic personality which will define him far more than his height. Plus, I've been out with enough tall dickheads to know height is not everything.

But as one poster said, school life is tough when the differences are obvious. I just don't want him to be relentlessly mocked - he already gets loads of comments. Whilst he's pretty resilient, I don't want it to become internalised.

OP posts:
HairyKitty · 29/07/2023 11:32

@vitDsunshine please do not rush to see a consultant without researching the options that will be available.

As far as I understand, excepting any actual medical issue, “growth hormones” only accelerate the increase in height, but do not increase (sometimes even causing a reduction) the final height.
If this is correct then consider whether medicalising the situation will benefit or harm your child’s self esteem and identity around their height, I guess each child might be different here.

PurpleParrotfish · 29/07/2023 10:09

Something weird happened there, I wrote a long post and it posted the two sentences I originally wrote before editing it!
Proper version:
DS1 has always been fairly short, he’s almost 14 now. And he’s one of the youngest in his year so all his friends are now post-pubescent and about a foot taller than him. He hasn’t shown any signs of puberty yet. Fortunately he’s confident and cheery, and his mates are a nice bunch of lads, so we’re just treating it as a waiting game, trying not to be unnerved that he looks so different from his friends right now.

PurpleParrotfish · 29/07/2023 10:05

DS1 has always been fairly short, he’s almost 14 now. and hasn’t gone through puberty yet.

RedGreenBlueSky · 29/07/2023 09:05

My DS is a year older and a couple of centimetres taller. Me & his dad are both 5'8. He has a very tough time at school because of it so I understand it's worrying. He was referred to endocrinologist by GP for some tests and so far everything seems normal except for delayed puberty. They have said he can have testosterone now to kick start things (he's decided he doesn't want it yet) and are seeing him every 6 months to check things are progressing.

Perhaps see GP to begin process of ruling out medical problems? In theory I agree with everyone saying don't worry there's nothing wrong with being a short man - but it does make their school life a lot harder than people expect. It's the relentless comments, everyday that get him down. Being pushed around and not being able to do much about it (he's more than a foot shorter than many in his year). Patronising or surprised comments from people (adult and children) who meet him and hear his age. It's tough.