Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Worried about son's height

188 replies

vitDsunshine · 29/07/2023 03:06

12.5 DS is 143cm. Always been small. His dad is 5 ft 8, I'm 5ft 2. His dad was also v small until about 15, then shot up (well, relatively!) so quite likely, DS's trajectory is similar.

I'm just worried. What if he's tiny? Far shorter than he's dad? He's already very conscious of it and as his friends start to go through puberty, I've no doubt his self-consciousness will increase. Obviously I tell him he's amazing etc, and that we all have to love and be kind to the bodies we are given...

But I've seen some awful posts on mumsnet about women's feelings about short men - there's prejudice.

I guess I worry it will affect his happiness in life.

Please, no nasty judgments. I'm just expressing fears I can't share IRL.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
coloursquare · 29/07/2023 15:58

I don't think it's particularly limiting. I'm not very tall myself, and it never really crosses my mind except very occasionally can't reach top shelf of kitchen cupboard!

I remember reading that Rishi Sunak is 5' 6" or something - it clearly hasn't held him back!

bellac11 · 29/07/2023 15:57

CoalCraft · 29/07/2023 05:53

Well this thread is a bit depressing. We've got posts suggesting OP drug her child into tallness, others saying variation on "well, it's a shame, but hopefully he'll scrape by..."

Good lord, we're talking about being short! It's not a big deal. I know plenty of short men, both in my family, as friends and as acquaintances, and they're all doing just fine. Successful in their careers, married or engaged, and perfectly pleasant people.

Yes Im reading this thread a bit open mouthed!

vitDsunshine · 29/07/2023 15:52

I don't think I am particularly stressed about it. I don't talk to anyone in IRL about it, so I've come here to get it off my chest. Posts on this thread have been really helpful

OP posts:
vitDsunshine · 29/07/2023 15:51

coloursquare · 29/07/2023 15:46

But much to call @PassTheSnacks's opinion bigoted! I think their post is very balanced.

You sound very stressed about this, and that will potentially have more impact on your DS than his eventual height.

Possibly harsh, but using the word 'limiting' raises my shackles

OP posts:
Lysianthus · 29/07/2023 15:47

OP, i have two words.

Tom Hollander.

coloursquare · 29/07/2023 15:46

*bit much

coloursquare · 29/07/2023 15:46

But much to call @PassTheSnacks's opinion bigoted! I think their post is very balanced.

You sound very stressed about this, and that will potentially have more impact on your DS than his eventual height.

LT2 · 29/07/2023 15:40

Both my husband and my brother were small boys as children. Both mothers worried. They have both grown into average height men (think my husband is 5ft 9 or thereabouts). For both of them it was puberty that did it! Around 14/15. Now my own son is in the world and I expect he'll go the same way. He's only 18 months now but is on the small side. Think it's inevitable with his genes, but I reckon he'll grow upward when puberty hits.

Milyt · 29/07/2023 15:35

Don’t stress about it. Plenty of time yet. My brother was tiny until he was about 14 then shot up. He will likely be taller than his dad as most kids are now.

vitDsunshine · 29/07/2023 15:28

@PassTheSnacks - and how, exactly, does it restrict you financially?

OP posts:
vitDsunshine · 29/07/2023 15:27

PassTheSnacks · 29/07/2023 13:54

I mean it is limiting isn't it? In the sense that we know it disadvantages you romantically and financially. It's not great in crowded places, or for a myriad of other practical things. That said, there is some evidence that shorter people have longer life expectancies, although causation vs correlation on that one is still unclear.

But it's not something you can do much about. Genetics is the main factor. Although a childhood diet high in protein and dairy especially seems to help maximise someone's potential height, but the overall effect of that compared to genetics will be small.

Best to focus I think on ensuring your children are confident and secure and focused on their own goals and valuing themselves for who they are and their values. This is the best protective element against being overly affected by superficial judgements from others.

So, in one breath you say definitively how limiting it is (Hmm) and yet how we should be helping our short kids feel good about themselves...perhaps people could work on having less of a bigoted opinion? That might help.

OP posts:
minipie · 29/07/2023 14:50

My understanding is that any sort of treatment would only be considered if your child’s height is way out of line with their expected height based on parental height. Or if they were tracking a particular centile and then their height drastically slows/stops.

so if he is tracking a fairly consistent height centile and that is similar to your and your husband’s centile for adult height, then the chances are he is totally healthy and they wouldn’t offer any treatment.

I agree confidence is the main thing. Height is really just one small thing about a person. Teenage boys can fixate on it partly because it’s changing so much for them and at visibly different rates, but in the long run it’s really unimportant compared with eg intelligence, being hard working/determined, and being fun and good company.

Xoxoxoxoxoxox · 29/07/2023 14:46

I sympathise.
My son was smallest in his school year, smaller than most of the girls, but at 16 he's suddenly growing a lot. He is now 5,3 and still growing, voice has broken, etc.
It seemed like puberty hit him later than everyone else but he's getting there now, boys can grow until they are 18 unlike women who reach full height at 14.
It was unpleasant for him to be smallest boy in the year and he had more friends who were girls as the boys were a bit aggressive towards him but now he is friends with a mixed group and is very happy, and additionally he is very good at talking to girls!
Personally I steered clear of medicalising him as I was suspicious of long term side effects of using a drug, the thought that they might not show up for another 10-15 years. I was a bit influenced by the Lupron scandal which were used to increase height by pausing puberty and giving them growing time- It was possibly just for girls, it gave some of them brittle bones. I am certainly not up to date on the drugs that they use now to give extra height they might be perfectly safe but my son has a lovely healthy body and I think I made the right choice for him.

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/health/women-fear-drug-they-used-to-halt-puberty-led-to-health-problems

Women fear drug they used to halt puberty led to health problems

Despite questions about Lupron’s lasting side effects and minimal study into its safety, the FDA sped approval of the drug to market.

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/health/women-fear-drug-they-used-to-halt-puberty-led-to-health-problems

incognito50me · 29/07/2023 14:27

My DDs boyfriend (15) is 5'7" and self-conscious about it. He grew early and has now reached his adult height (has been shaving for a year), friends are still growing or starting their growth spurt. His parents are both around 5'4".

This boy has many girls coming on to him and I suspect it'll be the case in adulthood, too, as he is handsome, sporty and has a great personality. Honestly, if my daughter hadn't told me he was self-conscious, it would never occur to me as something noteworthy about him at all.

rosepetals2023 · 29/07/2023 14:17

@PassTheSnacks he's 18 months younger 😊I was always one of the tallest and quite hefty until I stopped growing around 13 (5’7) . Also went through puberty quite young. My brother was probably a few inches shorter than me at the same age then shot up once he went through puberty a few years after (around 15).
Seeing as you’re both very tall I would presume your kids to be aswell. It can happen that they will be short but in general I think it’s mostly to do with genetics.
My DS was a small baby born on the 25% centile which surprised me as I’m 5”7 and XH is 6”8 but at almost 2 he is now off the centile chart for height. Xx

Wertie · 29/07/2023 14:13

Mumsnet isn’t the place to ask. I’m happily married to a 5ft 8 man, shorter than me. I know two happily married men significantly shorter who are successful and happy. 5’7 certainly isn’t odd or anything! My grandfather was even under 5ft, he managed 8 children and a good life.
I find it odd all these women claim to be so bothered tbh.

KimberleyClark · 29/07/2023 14:13

primoseyellow · 29/07/2023 14:11

@vitDsunshine I would make sure he has a very good diet with maximum daily amount of protein. Diet makes a difference definitely.

I had loads of cheese and dairy as a child and am only 5ft 2.

primoseyellow · 29/07/2023 14:11

@vitDsunshine I would make sure he has a very good diet with maximum daily amount of protein. Diet makes a difference definitely.

Notsureofname2 · 29/07/2023 14:08

Shortness isn’t a disability! I’m 4’10 & it pisses me right off when people comment on my height. I don’t comment on people’s weight/fat-shame so no need to comment on my height. I now say sometimes “easier to be short than fat” as everyone has something they’re unhappy with.
My son seems like he’ll be taller than me soon. Not sure if this notion of a “good height” is helpful.
if short coz of disability/anyone has a disability then hell would break loose if that was viewed badly. There’s worse things in life than being short aren’t there?

PassTheSnacks · 29/07/2023 14:06

AnnaNims · 29/07/2023 14:04

This was a worry of mine. It shouldn’t matter, but it does. My husband is only 5’9 and very self conscious about his height and he still gets teased about it, believe it or not. He’s the tallest of 4 brothers. We both come from short families, although I’m 5’8, I have 3 sisters that are very short.

Both of our sons are well over 6ft and the younger one is still growing.

This is quite possibly to do with diet improvement across the generations then, if there is no family history of anyone tall before the current generation.

AnnaNims · 29/07/2023 14:04

This was a worry of mine. It shouldn’t matter, but it does. My husband is only 5’9 and very self conscious about his height and he still gets teased about it, believe it or not. He’s the tallest of 4 brothers. We both come from short families, although I’m 5’8, I have 3 sisters that are very short.

Both of our sons are well over 6ft and the younger one is still growing.

DrManhattan · 29/07/2023 14:04

I don't like the posts that are saying women actively chose not to date short men, its not that straightforward as it's more of a genetic thing. I reckon most women don't even consciously think about it, they just don't feel attracted to them.

PassTheSnacks · 29/07/2023 13:59

rosepetals2023 · 29/07/2023 12:34

I wouldn’t worry, my brother (18 months difference) was always a lot shorter than me and had a slight frame growing up. Shot up when he was about 15 now he’s 6”4 😊

18 months older or younger?

I find this interesting because I am the smallest of my siblings at 5'11". My father is well over 6' but my mother tiny (5'4" I think). Ex-husband also well over 6'.

My kids are almost the same height but my daughter is 18 months younger than my son. People often think they are twins. But they are only 5 and 6.5 now. I wonder if he will suddenly shoot up in teenage years. He is perhaps slightly above average height in his peer group and she is well above. Do girls and boys grow on different trajectories compared to their final adult height, even in early childhood?

JethroTullandhishorse · 29/07/2023 13:56

All the short men hate lol

Swipe left for the next trending thread