Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Worried about son's height

188 replies

vitDsunshine · 29/07/2023 03:06

12.5 DS is 143cm. Always been small. His dad is 5 ft 8, I'm 5ft 2. His dad was also v small until about 15, then shot up (well, relatively!) so quite likely, DS's trajectory is similar.

I'm just worried. What if he's tiny? Far shorter than he's dad? He's already very conscious of it and as his friends start to go through puberty, I've no doubt his self-consciousness will increase. Obviously I tell him he's amazing etc, and that we all have to love and be kind to the bodies we are given...

But I've seen some awful posts on mumsnet about women's feelings about short men - there's prejudice.

I guess I worry it will affect his happiness in life.

Please, no nasty judgments. I'm just expressing fears I can't share IRL.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
EarWigJo · 29/07/2023 22:40

vitDsunshine · 29/07/2023 21:38

Thanks for sharing this. I'm sorry dating is so hard - this is my fear for my DS, if I'm honest

For me, being short among my peers at school wasn't really a problem.

If anything - I owned it and it helped me become the resilient person I am today!

As others have said - I'd either laugh along with them or give as good as I got about their pointy nose or silly freckles or whatever.

(I did get bullied for other reasons, but wouldn't say any of that was specifically for my height)

For me, it's society's attitude.

And please forgive me for saying this, but your OP is a classic example of it (absolutely not having a go at you - just pointing out the view from "down here")...

"I'm just worried. What if he's tiny"

So what if he is?

What if he's gay?

What if he's black?

Would people be looking to shovel chemicals down a kid's throat to "fix" those "problems"? Or would there be a huge global campaign to rid the world of such prejudices?

I realise I can't change the world with this thread and the solution will take a few generations to evolve, but if you're worried that he's tiny and will find the dating scene an up hill battle - Rather than trying to change HIM, how about we try to change how a lot of women perceive shorter men?

Then all short men will have an equal chance at finding their soulmate and future parents won't have to "worry that their son is tiny".

When you were growing up, did your parents consider filling you with hormones and changing you into a boy because of the glass ceiling in the workplace?

Or did they accept you for who you are and support the movement pushing for equality in the work-place?

(For the record, I'm not against the wonders of modern medicine. But I don't agree with the modern mentality that you can fix every problem in life by taking a short course of pills.)

rowanoak · 29/07/2023 22:32

One of my sons is short and small and says he likes being that way because he can fit into any space and do a lot of acrobats. He is flexible and nimble and has a charming personality and a lot of friends. He has always taken great pride about being the "smallest person in his class" even when that isn't true. There are some smaller girls and even a smaller boy but he likes being small so he just claims he is the smallest, aka the best, in his eyes. Lol

I knew at least one of our three sons would likely be short because I'm short and my husband is average or maybe on the short side of average although he's plenty taller than me so to me he's tall, lol, and my husband's brother is quite short, like 5'4". It hasn't bothered him as he is with a short small woman who is barely 5'0" and a gymnast and he himself is a gymnast/acrobat which is how he met her.

I have always complimented my son and told him he's great just how he is and he seems to have a lot of confidence that serves him well in life. Also I think there are plenty of short women like me who don't care how tall the man they date is because they are likely taller than us anyway. (I'm 5'2" or maybe not even that tall. 5'1.5"). Even if a guy was shorter than me I don't think I'd care since I'm no one to judge and I like being short. But I haven't met many who are.

So I think if you act worried that being short will limit your child's chances in life with women or otherwise he will likely pick up on that and it might become a self fulfilling prophecy. If you concentrate on the positives of being short and small, which there are truly many, and the fact that many women don't care (is he even straight? I'm not sure yet what my son's sexual preferences are, lol, because he hasn't told me yet and he's still too young for that) then he will probably be confident and it won't hold him back with the ladies... or guys. Good luck.

Yellowlegobrick · 29/07/2023 22:18

As be aware op that if you asked for a referral to endocrinology in a year or 2, you could be waiting another year for appointments and tests results, during which time if puberty hit you would miss the boat for treatment if an issue was found

146cm at 12 is actually not that short if puberty has not yet hit, but if he's noticeably smaller than peers you lose nothing at all getting things checked.

poppyseed23 · 29/07/2023 22:15

RaisinforBeing · 29/07/2023 16:12

2 of my children take growth hormone as they have a genetic condition that means they lack the protein that synthesises the body’s own growth hormone. Without the medicine they’d be less than 5ft as adults.

If you have concerns, track your sons growth regularly and take these and any childhood measurements you may have, plus your family’s measurements and go to the GP. They should refer you to Endocrinology for further investigations.

Please could I ask the name of the genetic condition?

Many thanks x

5128gap · 29/07/2023 22:14

The dating thing...
I think its fair to say that many if not most women, if asked, would express a preference for a tall man. Just as most men would express a preference for a beautiful women. However, what we might want and what might be available to us are often two entirely different things.
The fact is there are not enough 6' men or beautiful women to go around everyone who might prefer one. So just like less beautiful women are not going to be able to walk into a room and have any and every man they fancy hanging on their every word, short men aren't going to get to date any and every women they fancy, because some women prefer tall men.
This is in no way the same as saying short men will never find a date. If this were so then all short men would be single which is clearly not the case.

Yellowlegobrick · 29/07/2023 22:03

Look at the child growth foundation facebook page.

While there's nothing wrong with being short, a very short child of much taller parents is unusual and warrants investigation. My cousin was like this and found to have some endocrine problems, he needed growth hormone & testosterone. It isn't just about height, poor growth/lack of growth hormone can cause other health issues. Its not drugging a child to make them taller, some children have serious endocrine deficiencies and need growth hormone and other treatments to keep them healthy.

Fififafa · 29/07/2023 21:57

I wouldn’t discuss his height unless he brings it up. Maybe focus more on building his self esteem and developing his skills. There isn’t any point in people telling you that being a short man isn’t an issue.
Although a man’s height isn’t the be all and end all, it’s well known that short men have a tougher time than their taller counterparts when it comes to dating, careers etc.

Grumpy101 · 29/07/2023 21:46

My DP was very short growing up (he's "only" 5'7" now) and only went into puberty when he was about 16. He does sometimes mention how hard it was , being a bit behind his peers in that way, and frustrating. It actually spurred him on to do a sport professionally though, he's a good looking (I think) middle aged man, well adjusted and pretty happy.

What I'm trying to say is - teenage years might be hard (and it's hard for many kids for various reasons!) but it's really not life limiting or the end of the world. He has good parents that clearly love and support him. He'll be ok!

vitDsunshine · 29/07/2023 21:41

Ironically, I have never felt small. I realise that there is still a gender divide about this stuff, and it's far more acceptable for girls to be 'petite' but it's always interesting to be reminded of my short stature as in my mind, I'm pretty tall! Or, at least, I'm not short.

OP posts:
vitDsunshine · 29/07/2023 21:38

EarWigJo · 29/07/2023 20:23

A view from the other side...

As a 5'4 middle-aged gent I would love to see all this male height related prejudice be banished.

I'm not having a pop at anybody in particular, but so many posts on threads like this sound like:

"My son is 14 and he's only 5'0 tall - I'm worried I've given birth to a faulty one"

Then follows a load of replies that suggest:

"Pump him full of chemicals and if you're lucky you'll get a 6 Footer like mine... Not sure what to suggest if you're not lucky - Maybe send him to sports clubs to toughen him up a bit."

(When I was 14 the school health visitors said I was below average height and wanted to put me on a growth hormone.... I shut that conversation straight down and pointed out that to have an "average" - they needed tall AND short people!...

Just as well 'cos a few years later that hormone was found to cause some quite serious side-effects & complications!!)

Why not just accept your children for the miracles they are??

And then educate them to be accepting of EVERYBODY regardless of their differences!

Can you imagine if the the thread was someone worried their daughter was still quite flat-chested at 14 and people suggested pumping her full of chemicals to "fix" her. Or, failing that, send her to drama club so she feels less shit about how society views her.

And while we're on the subject - can we ditch the "short man syndrome" retort. That is about as offensive & ignorant to us shorties as the "PMS/Time of the Month" retort is for ladies.

If "Short man syndrome" were a thing... and all the tall men were such a catch - why are there so many single parents? Why aren't they all living the fairy-tale life with their tall, protective, alpha-male partners?

There is nothing wrong with any of your children. The problem is with how society views and treats people.

Fortunately, from what I've observed in my years on this planet, the younger generations coming up through the ranks are a lot more tolerant & accepting of people's differences than that of my elders whom I learned from. So hopefully in a few generations time all these sort of issues can be flushed out.

The biggest problems I've faced as a short bloke are when it comes to buying clothes or dating.

Hardly anybody makes trousers or jeans "this short". And when I went through a phase of being a bit "portly" - nobody makes them "this short & that wide"!

And online dating - over a couple of years I sent out hundreds of introductions and either got no reply or replies to the effect of "Sorry, but I'm looking for someone taller". One response was even "ha ha ha - that's tiny!"

At this point, I'd given up, but as a test I kept everything the same and just changed my height to about 5'10 - Got plenty of replies. Engaged in a couple of messages back & forth to establish that I DID have it in me to strike up a conversation... Then confessed my real height - dropped like a stone!

So for short blokes, the dating world feels very much like the equivalent of the glass ceiling ladies find in the workplace - Both are wrong and need to attitudes change.

Thanks for sharing this. I'm sorry dating is so hard - this is my fear for my DS, if I'm honest

OP posts:
Sundayrain · 29/07/2023 21:36

My DH is 5 foot 5 and very handsome (lots of people say it so it's not just my subjective view!) as well as being hilarious and an all round beautiful person. His height has never been an issue in his life, he's always had lots of female attention and it's never affected his self esteem. He does get stupid jokes about it from male friends but he just comes straight back with jokes about hairlines, beer bellies etc, it doesn't bother him in the slightest. I really wouldn't give it another thought!

brokenlore · 29/07/2023 21:29

You know many male 'heart throb' actors are short? In fact I'd say there are probably more short male actors than there are tall, hasn't stopped them being very successful, or having partners. Camera angles and hidden wedges in shoes mean the audience aren't always aware of an actor's height. I'd have no issue dating a short man, personality is far, far more of an attraction.

PenguiInaThong · 29/07/2023 21:02

I'm 5 foot 3 and its commented on a lot. A 5 foot 3 woman is not an outlier! My son is likely to be about 5 foot 8. That too is not tiny. People are odd

Echobelly · 29/07/2023 20:29

My brother was absolutely titchy until he was about 14, and our parents were about the same height as you and your DP. But he shot up then and is now about 5ft 8. And in my mum's family there a few guys (including her dad) who were barely over 5ft, but still didn't get passed down to anyone in the family.

My son is about to turn 12 and tracking a little below the average, but it's much less so than my brother was so I'm pretty confident he will have his growth spurt although he may be the last of his peers to do so as he is August born.

But, as others have said, I don't think height for men is the issue people think it is really so let it be what it is.

EarWigJo · 29/07/2023 20:23

A view from the other side...

As a 5'4 middle-aged gent I would love to see all this male height related prejudice be banished.

I'm not having a pop at anybody in particular, but so many posts on threads like this sound like:

"My son is 14 and he's only 5'0 tall - I'm worried I've given birth to a faulty one"

Then follows a load of replies that suggest:

"Pump him full of chemicals and if you're lucky you'll get a 6 Footer like mine... Not sure what to suggest if you're not lucky - Maybe send him to sports clubs to toughen him up a bit."

(When I was 14 the school health visitors said I was below average height and wanted to put me on a growth hormone.... I shut that conversation straight down and pointed out that to have an "average" - they needed tall AND short people!...

Just as well 'cos a few years later that hormone was found to cause some quite serious side-effects & complications!!)

Why not just accept your children for the miracles they are??

And then educate them to be accepting of EVERYBODY regardless of their differences!

Can you imagine if the the thread was someone worried their daughter was still quite flat-chested at 14 and people suggested pumping her full of chemicals to "fix" her. Or, failing that, send her to drama club so she feels less shit about how society views her.

And while we're on the subject - can we ditch the "short man syndrome" retort. That is about as offensive & ignorant to us shorties as the "PMS/Time of the Month" retort is for ladies.

If "Short man syndrome" were a thing... and all the tall men were such a catch - why are there so many single parents? Why aren't they all living the fairy-tale life with their tall, protective, alpha-male partners?

There is nothing wrong with any of your children. The problem is with how society views and treats people.

Fortunately, from what I've observed in my years on this planet, the younger generations coming up through the ranks are a lot more tolerant & accepting of people's differences than that of my elders whom I learned from. So hopefully in a few generations time all these sort of issues can be flushed out.

The biggest problems I've faced as a short bloke are when it comes to buying clothes or dating.

Hardly anybody makes trousers or jeans "this short". And when I went through a phase of being a bit "portly" - nobody makes them "this short & that wide"!

And online dating - over a couple of years I sent out hundreds of introductions and either got no reply or replies to the effect of "Sorry, but I'm looking for someone taller". One response was even "ha ha ha - that's tiny!"

At this point, I'd given up, but as a test I kept everything the same and just changed my height to about 5'10 - Got plenty of replies. Engaged in a couple of messages back & forth to establish that I DID have it in me to strike up a conversation... Then confessed my real height - dropped like a stone!

So for short blokes, the dating world feels very much like the equivalent of the glass ceiling ladies find in the workplace - Both are wrong and need to attitudes change.

RedGreenBlueSky · 29/07/2023 20:22

dearJayne · 29/07/2023 19:35

What is an endo? What department is that? I want to do this for ds

Endocrinology. You don't have to go private. GP can refer

moodypromises · 29/07/2023 19:55

The first thing my mum said when I said I'm having a son

"Let's hope he's not short like his father"

It made me think very differently of her. She makes jokes of my husbands height all the time and I'm sick of it.

Funny enough my little toddler is bigger than most 2 year olds his age but I'm not worried about his likely not tallness as a adult. He's a gorgeous boy and will hopefully have the personality to match!

AnnaNims · 29/07/2023 19:47

My son was under an endo for his delayed puberty. Wouldn’t hesitate to recommend this route for the thorough testing that results. My son needed no treatment but it was reassuring when we were concerned about his lack of height/development.

OneTC · 29/07/2023 19:38

KimberleyClark · 29/07/2023 17:54

Shorter people are less likely to have gone breaking falls as they age, due to a lower centre of gravity.

And we experience the world faster 😅

OneTC · 29/07/2023 19:37

I'm 5'2" on a tall day.

Aside from the fact that my height is apparently remarkable, in the literal sense, and that I have to ask people to get things off a tall shelf for me I've never really noticed any real drawbacks to being small. I've got an identical sized partner of nearly 30 years, we can swap clothes, I fucken rule at the sports I do, I've been successful in my work and any problems I do have in life are nothing to do with my height. The MN trope of height being a deal-breaker doesn't seem to be anything I've ever encountered when it comes to meeting people, although admittedly I haven't tried for a good long while

The people that seem most insecure about height are blokes that are around the 5'8" point, or at least they're the ones that feel the need to point out my height most often

dearJayne · 29/07/2023 19:35

heartbroken40 · 29/07/2023 05:32

@vitDsunshine please look up growth hormone deficiency. Can you see an endo privately? They can do a hand X-ray to determine bone age and some blood tests. Good luck

What is an endo? What department is that? I want to do this for ds

sewerrat · 29/07/2023 19:14

some exercise and stretching routines are proven to help growth vertically. dangling with his arms fully stretched from a monkey bar supposedly works.
also hot yoga! best of luck x

Charliebrow · 29/07/2023 19:05

SilverArch · 29/07/2023 04:34

My family is average to tall. My husband is tall, both his parents are tall and so are his brothers - all the men are around 6 feet. My mother was tall, my father was 5 foot 8 so shortish and I'm slightly above average height at 5 foot 5. Our son was short and we too thought he would shoot up later.

The paediatrician disabused us of this notion - he was already too far into puberty for that to be a possibility. If we had had him checked earlier there would have been things that could have been done with growth hormone and so on but it was too late to do anything.

I am thankful he got to be 5 foot 7 which while short isn't life limiting. If you have concerns I would have him checked now because if something is to be done it should be done sooner rather than later - it's too late when you realise he hasn't had the growth spurt. (My husband did remember at some point that his grandfather was a jockey and strangely our short, skinny son was a natural rider with a lots of guts and a great seat and, strangely, the jockey fathered tall children).

We do have another son who had medical reasons for only making it to 5 foot 7 too and he has to practically fight off women with sticks. He just has a very attractive personality and a wide range of interests.

So if a relative was a jockey then surely he just inherited short genes rather than had a condition where he wasn’t producing enough growth hormone. Does synthetic growth hormone make any child grow taller or only those who have a medical condition where they don’t produce enough growth hormone?

Charliebrow · 29/07/2023 19:04

So if a relative was a jockey then surely he just inherited short genes rather than had a condition where he wasn’t producing enough growth hormone. Does synthetic growth hormone make any child grow taller or only those who have a medical condition where they don’t produce enough growth hormone?

PassTheSnacks · 29/07/2023 18:18

That makes sense @KimberleyClark ! Gravity and general clumsiness are the enemy of tall gangly folks. 🤣🤣