Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Worried about son's height

188 replies

vitDsunshine · 29/07/2023 03:06

12.5 DS is 143cm. Always been small. His dad is 5 ft 8, I'm 5ft 2. His dad was also v small until about 15, then shot up (well, relatively!) so quite likely, DS's trajectory is similar.

I'm just worried. What if he's tiny? Far shorter than he's dad? He's already very conscious of it and as his friends start to go through puberty, I've no doubt his self-consciousness will increase. Obviously I tell him he's amazing etc, and that we all have to love and be kind to the bodies we are given...

But I've seen some awful posts on mumsnet about women's feelings about short men - there's prejudice.

I guess I worry it will affect his happiness in life.

Please, no nasty judgments. I'm just expressing fears I can't share IRL.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
vitDsunshine · 31/07/2023 01:54

JustBanPlasticAndSubsidiseTheTrainsAlready · 30/07/2023 23:05

I'm guessing you've put him into a height predictor - a proper one, not just halfway between the parents. I think height at age 2.5 is about half the adult height. I might be looking at it wrong but I've looked in the red book and it shows 5 foot 6 at age 19 for your son. Is that so bad? From a personal viewpoint, I'd sooner date 5 foot six than 6 foot and above - easier to reach for a start!!
My bil is a long way over 6 foot and he is single. I understand very tall men find it just as wearying to be told all the time, aren't you tall! My dad is about 5ft 4 and I'm 5ft 5.

I don't understand how you can say in one breath 'I hope you've used a correct height predictor' and then claim my son will be 5 ft 6 with some knowledge? You don't know what height he was at 2.5 etc

OP posts:
Zepherine · 30/07/2023 23:10

I’ve always liked short men.

JustBanPlasticAndSubsidiseTheTrainsAlready · 30/07/2023 23:05

I'm guessing you've put him into a height predictor - a proper one, not just halfway between the parents. I think height at age 2.5 is about half the adult height. I might be looking at it wrong but I've looked in the red book and it shows 5 foot 6 at age 19 for your son. Is that so bad? From a personal viewpoint, I'd sooner date 5 foot six than 6 foot and above - easier to reach for a start!!
My bil is a long way over 6 foot and he is single. I understand very tall men find it just as wearying to be told all the time, aren't you tall! My dad is about 5ft 4 and I'm 5ft 5.

vitDsunshine · 30/07/2023 22:53

5128gap · 30/07/2023 18:12

@EarWigJo Your suggestion women need to change their attitude to shorter men- I'd respectfully point out that the negativity you experience is not of our making. Men have long since pushed the idea at us that we should be small and weak by comparison to their size and strength. This is not for our benefit.
Unfortunately this also causes some collateral damage to smaller or weaker men. This is not our responsibility to fix.
As for the idea that women should somehow be fair and give short men an equal chance with them; what are you doing to give women an equal chance with you? You know, the ones you think aren't pretty enough, thin or fat enough or young enough for you to find attractive? Are you checking your own attitudes and giving them a fair chance?
Because if a man finds it hard to get a date, in many cases its because he's targeting women who are out of his league whilst ignoring those who might be interested because of his own sense of entitlement.

This is actually very true

OP posts:
DrManhattan · 30/07/2023 18:29

@EarWigJo I wouldn't be happy that I'd been chatting to someone who can lie so easily.

sewerrat · 30/07/2023 18:26

EarWigJo · 29/07/2023 20:23

A view from the other side...

As a 5'4 middle-aged gent I would love to see all this male height related prejudice be banished.

I'm not having a pop at anybody in particular, but so many posts on threads like this sound like:

"My son is 14 and he's only 5'0 tall - I'm worried I've given birth to a faulty one"

Then follows a load of replies that suggest:

"Pump him full of chemicals and if you're lucky you'll get a 6 Footer like mine... Not sure what to suggest if you're not lucky - Maybe send him to sports clubs to toughen him up a bit."

(When I was 14 the school health visitors said I was below average height and wanted to put me on a growth hormone.... I shut that conversation straight down and pointed out that to have an "average" - they needed tall AND short people!...

Just as well 'cos a few years later that hormone was found to cause some quite serious side-effects & complications!!)

Why not just accept your children for the miracles they are??

And then educate them to be accepting of EVERYBODY regardless of their differences!

Can you imagine if the the thread was someone worried their daughter was still quite flat-chested at 14 and people suggested pumping her full of chemicals to "fix" her. Or, failing that, send her to drama club so she feels less shit about how society views her.

And while we're on the subject - can we ditch the "short man syndrome" retort. That is about as offensive & ignorant to us shorties as the "PMS/Time of the Month" retort is for ladies.

If "Short man syndrome" were a thing... and all the tall men were such a catch - why are there so many single parents? Why aren't they all living the fairy-tale life with their tall, protective, alpha-male partners?

There is nothing wrong with any of your children. The problem is with how society views and treats people.

Fortunately, from what I've observed in my years on this planet, the younger generations coming up through the ranks are a lot more tolerant & accepting of people's differences than that of my elders whom I learned from. So hopefully in a few generations time all these sort of issues can be flushed out.

The biggest problems I've faced as a short bloke are when it comes to buying clothes or dating.

Hardly anybody makes trousers or jeans "this short". And when I went through a phase of being a bit "portly" - nobody makes them "this short & that wide"!

And online dating - over a couple of years I sent out hundreds of introductions and either got no reply or replies to the effect of "Sorry, but I'm looking for someone taller". One response was even "ha ha ha - that's tiny!"

At this point, I'd given up, but as a test I kept everything the same and just changed my height to about 5'10 - Got plenty of replies. Engaged in a couple of messages back & forth to establish that I DID have it in me to strike up a conversation... Then confessed my real height - dropped like a stone!

So for short blokes, the dating world feels very much like the equivalent of the glass ceiling ladies find in the workplace - Both are wrong and need to attitudes change.

women are treated exactly like that. not sure why you think you're so ground breaking

TheFormidableMrsC · 30/07/2023 18:24

I think it's really difficult to tell. I know a family where Dad is around 5ft 6 and Mum under 5ft but both boys are six foot plus. My brother was very small until he was around 13/14 when he suddenly shot up and by adulthood was 6ft 4. I understand your fears though. Just make sure he's confident in himself bless him.

5128gap · 30/07/2023 18:12

@EarWigJo Your suggestion women need to change their attitude to shorter men- I'd respectfully point out that the negativity you experience is not of our making. Men have long since pushed the idea at us that we should be small and weak by comparison to their size and strength. This is not for our benefit.
Unfortunately this also causes some collateral damage to smaller or weaker men. This is not our responsibility to fix.
As for the idea that women should somehow be fair and give short men an equal chance with them; what are you doing to give women an equal chance with you? You know, the ones you think aren't pretty enough, thin or fat enough or young enough for you to find attractive? Are you checking your own attitudes and giving them a fair chance?
Because if a man finds it hard to get a date, in many cases its because he's targeting women who are out of his league whilst ignoring those who might be interested because of his own sense of entitlement.

BogRollBOGOF · 30/07/2023 16:29

DS1 is about 150cm and isn't far from turning 13. I'm 5'2", DH is 6'. Both of us were slight children with a later puberty, and DS is following a similar pattern. Slight change to his skin in recent months, but not much significant change yet. DH had a small mum too, but ended up as the tallest in his family in a late growth spurt at 18+.

I find that people's perceptions of being "small" are also affected by build. I'm certainly below average, but not unusually so, but a smaller top half seems to accentuate people's perception of me being small. Both DSs have a slight build, so the overall effect is of being small, and accentuates the reality.

Girls get the head start on growth spurts, I know several 10yo girls now towering above me, let alone DS1 who's 2 years older than them, and that also accentuates the effect on boys who are smaller than average to begin with. By y9, it's not uncommon to look like a stray little boy has drifted into a room full of teenagers, but the hormones do tend to kick in and the catch-up is rapid by then.

Traditional sport can be quite hard on small boys. Mine do running, swimming and karate out of school which are a good package for their all round fitness, and it's confidence boosting to do something that isn't done in school, and where body mass is of less importance.

I don't know how tall my DSs will be, and I suspect that always having had bigger hands and feet, that DS2 has the advantage, but both DCs eat well and are energetic so I have no concerns at this stage.

poppyseed23 · 30/07/2023 16:09

user1471530109 · 30/07/2023 15:59

@poppyseed23 I honestly can't remember. Afaik, she isn't growth hormone deficient. She was born at 29 weeks and for the first four years, they were convinced she'd catch up. But didn't. They ran so many tests, including CF and genetic tests. She came back clear each time. She did at one point get diagnosed with Russel silver syndrome, but all the drs since have said they don't think she has it, just v small. She is still small on the GH. But she doesn't stand out now. She fits with her peers. She still gets a bit upset about her height though. I think kids have been unpleasant to her in the past and comments now hurt. The GH has made her stronger and fitter. She is also less 'ill' with colds etc. It's not just about height. The endo really pushed us to put her on it. She will only be on it until puberty.

Thank you so much for coming back to me.
Interestingly DD was 5 weeks early and it was always thought that she would catch up but hasn't.
The hormone test is quite invasive, blood sugars are brought down to the floor over a few hours then tested to see if growth hormone kicks in. Then high sugar food to bring it back again.
There are 5 year olds taller than her at school x

user1471530109 · 30/07/2023 15:59

@poppyseed23 I honestly can't remember. Afaik, she isn't growth hormone deficient. She was born at 29 weeks and for the first four years, they were convinced she'd catch up. But didn't. They ran so many tests, including CF and genetic tests. She came back clear each time. She did at one point get diagnosed with Russel silver syndrome, but all the drs since have said they don't think she has it, just v small. She is still small on the GH. But she doesn't stand out now. She fits with her peers. She still gets a bit upset about her height though. I think kids have been unpleasant to her in the past and comments now hurt. The GH has made her stronger and fitter. She is also less 'ill' with colds etc. It's not just about height. The endo really pushed us to put her on it. She will only be on it until puberty.

Johnisafckface · 30/07/2023 15:01

a lot of the men I see lately are my height or shorter and I’m 5’6.5”. I feel like men are trending to be shorter or it could be where I live 😂. But I’m sure your son will be fine.

poppyseed23 · 30/07/2023 14:09

user1471530109 · 30/07/2023 10:44

Hi OP,

My DD (10) is on growth hormone and has been for a number of years. But her height and weight were well below the 0.4th percentile. She started school in age 2 clothes and her classmates used to pick her up and put her in the toy pram like a doll. She is now around 25th.
I've had a v quick look and it appears your ds is around the 10th percentile. I'm not sure that's low enough for any intervention/concern, but I may be wrong.
The growth hormone therapy (daily injections) was really encouraged for DD. It wasn't just about height. I also know it's mega bucks and they held off applying before they tried everything else first (like v high calorie diet).

I am a secondary school teacher. There is a huge range of heights in any one class. The smaller students don't have any bother socially.

Please can I ask if your DD had to have the growth hormone test and whether she was diagnosed with any type of condition?

My DD 7 is short for her age - below the 0.4 centile for height but 10th for weight.
She's been under endo since she was 2. DH and I are short so it's no surprise she is small but neither of us were short children if that makes sense.
They are on the cusp of doing the hormone test dependent on her next 6 month measurements.
She's had a few blood tests to rule out turners. Up to the last measurement her grow has been steady every year with no growth spurts just a gentle rising slope which is why they have been reluctant to do the test

Thanks in advance x

UrsulaBelle · 30/07/2023 13:26

user1471530109 · 30/07/2023 10:44

Hi OP,

My DD (10) is on growth hormone and has been for a number of years. But her height and weight were well below the 0.4th percentile. She started school in age 2 clothes and her classmates used to pick her up and put her in the toy pram like a doll. She is now around 25th.
I've had a v quick look and it appears your ds is around the 10th percentile. I'm not sure that's low enough for any intervention/concern, but I may be wrong.
The growth hormone therapy (daily injections) was really encouraged for DD. It wasn't just about height. I also know it's mega bucks and they held off applying before they tried everything else first (like v high calorie diet).

I am a secondary school teacher. There is a huge range of heights in any one class. The smaller students don't have any bother socially.

@vitDsunshine According to my son’s height chart which I posted earlier, you DS is about halfway between the 25th and 50th centiles currently and on course for about 174-175cm which is roughly 5’ 8.5” unless his growth isn’t following a typical pattern. The average growth spurt is smoothed out on a growth chart as it averages across a lot of data including those who hit puberty earlier and those who hit it later. My DS2 hit it later and seemed to fall down the centiles until puberty when he jumped back up again. DS3 didn’t really have a big growth spurt and just followed the average line up across puberty.

HairyKitty · 30/07/2023 13:04

I think there are 2 different things.

Dropping centiles due to delayed puberty, hopefully the child will catch up when they are older.

Being an extremely low centile in the first place, growth hormones or other treatments may be offered.

vitDsunshine · 30/07/2023 11:35

user1471530109 · 30/07/2023 10:44

Hi OP,

My DD (10) is on growth hormone and has been for a number of years. But her height and weight were well below the 0.4th percentile. She started school in age 2 clothes and her classmates used to pick her up and put her in the toy pram like a doll. She is now around 25th.
I've had a v quick look and it appears your ds is around the 10th percentile. I'm not sure that's low enough for any intervention/concern, but I may be wrong.
The growth hormone therapy (daily injections) was really encouraged for DD. It wasn't just about height. I also know it's mega bucks and they held off applying before they tried everything else first (like v high calorie diet).

I am a secondary school teacher. There is a huge range of heights in any one class. The smaller students don't have any bother socially.

I don't think being on the tenth percentile is enough of a reason for hormone therapy tbh. I think if you plot it against parent predictor - he comes out at 5.7 - which is ok. If he makes that!

I prob would only consider hormone treatment if we went to an endocrinologist and they said there was an issue. Being short is not enough of a reason,IFYSWIM

OP posts:
user1471530109 · 30/07/2023 10:44

Hi OP,

My DD (10) is on growth hormone and has been for a number of years. But her height and weight were well below the 0.4th percentile. She started school in age 2 clothes and her classmates used to pick her up and put her in the toy pram like a doll. She is now around 25th.
I've had a v quick look and it appears your ds is around the 10th percentile. I'm not sure that's low enough for any intervention/concern, but I may be wrong.
The growth hormone therapy (daily injections) was really encouraged for DD. It wasn't just about height. I also know it's mega bucks and they held off applying before they tried everything else first (like v high calorie diet).

I am a secondary school teacher. There is a huge range of heights in any one class. The smaller students don't have any bother socially.

OneTC · 30/07/2023 10:29

EarWigJo · 29/07/2023 22:40

For me, being short among my peers at school wasn't really a problem.

If anything - I owned it and it helped me become the resilient person I am today!

As others have said - I'd either laugh along with them or give as good as I got about their pointy nose or silly freckles or whatever.

(I did get bullied for other reasons, but wouldn't say any of that was specifically for my height)

For me, it's society's attitude.

And please forgive me for saying this, but your OP is a classic example of it (absolutely not having a go at you - just pointing out the view from "down here")...

"I'm just worried. What if he's tiny"

So what if he is?

What if he's gay?

What if he's black?

Would people be looking to shovel chemicals down a kid's throat to "fix" those "problems"? Or would there be a huge global campaign to rid the world of such prejudices?

I realise I can't change the world with this thread and the solution will take a few generations to evolve, but if you're worried that he's tiny and will find the dating scene an up hill battle - Rather than trying to change HIM, how about we try to change how a lot of women perceive shorter men?

Then all short men will have an equal chance at finding their soulmate and future parents won't have to "worry that their son is tiny".

When you were growing up, did your parents consider filling you with hormones and changing you into a boy because of the glass ceiling in the workplace?

Or did they accept you for who you are and support the movement pushing for equality in the work-place?

(For the record, I'm not against the wonders of modern medicine. But I don't agree with the modern mentality that you can fix every problem in life by taking a short course of pills.)

No. Dating is not an equal rights thing. No one needs to try and want something different to what they actually want.

I've never used OLD but have seen tinder and that kind of thing and yeah there are loads of profiles that specify height and same on here you'd definitely get the impression that short men are doomed to a lonely single life. Add in some real world sampling though and the evidence is clear. It might mean some people don't find you attractive, maybe even quite a lot of people, but unless my life has been an illusion there are lots of women who don't think about height at all.

Also comparing racism and homophobia to the hardships of being 5'4" is pretty offensive

5128gap · 30/07/2023 09:30

KimberleyClark · 30/07/2023 06:54

I think its fair to say that many if not most women, if asked, would express a preference for a tall man.

Not me. I’m 5ft 2 and I don’t like being loomed over. DH is 5ft 7and he’s perfect.

And has any one ever called you shallow? Have you seen any threads from mums of tall sons suggesting women like you are bigoted, and worrying about their 6' sons dating prospects? I'd imagine not, because not enough women feel that way to make it an issue of note, which was my point really.

10HailMarys · 30/07/2023 08:56

Chances are your son will end up about 5’8” or 5’9” and will have absolutely no problem meeting women.

He’s 12. He hasn’t had his teenage growth spurt yet. He’ll be fine.

Clawdy · 30/07/2023 08:54

When I was at college, one of the most popular boys there was about 5ft 5in, he was handsome, cute and funny with mesmerising blue eyes, and he had most of the girls there wanting him! Including me. 🙂

EarWigJo · 30/07/2023 07:56

vitDsunshine · 30/07/2023 01:32

a@EarWigJo - yes, you're right. It's my attitude that needs to change

For other posters, for the record, I don't bring up height with my son, and I am very very positive and clear with him if he brings it up - 'we are who we are, we have to love what healthy bodies we have, that everyone has something about themselves that they don't like and others may joke about etc etc' I teach him to defend himself against the mockery - without picking on others physical attributes etc.

Also, the figures have gone askew as the thread has gone on - he's 143cm.

Also, his dad went through puberty later - 15 ish. So I've also been very clear with son that delayed puberty is quite possible. But it also means we've seen no puberty driven growth spurt yet.

I'm sorry if I e come across as shallow etc - I completely realise there are much worse things than height. That he's an amazing person who will do amazing things with his life

But what is Mumsnet, if not a place where we can anonymously discuss our parenting fears?

You definitely don't sound shallow.

You're genuinely concerned and that comes from a good place. Completely admirable.

I'm sure your Son will be fine. It sounds like he's got a good grounding from his parents.

Developed nations have come on in leaps and bounds in the last few decades in terms of tolerance and acceptance of people's differences. There's still a long long way to go, but hopefully by the time your Son is at that stage we'll be on the right track. 🙂

Purpleboat · 30/07/2023 07:03

OP I don’t think you come across shallow at all. It’s natural to have concerns about the prejudices and unconscious bias of some others and the negative impact that might have on our loved ones. Well done you for caring IMO.

KimberleyClark · 30/07/2023 06:54

I think its fair to say that many if not most women, if asked, would express a preference for a tall man.

Not me. I’m 5ft 2 and I don’t like being loomed over. DH is 5ft 7and he’s perfect.

vitDsunshine · 30/07/2023 01:32

a@EarWigJo - yes, you're right. It's my attitude that needs to change

For other posters, for the record, I don't bring up height with my son, and I am very very positive and clear with him if he brings it up - 'we are who we are, we have to love what healthy bodies we have, that everyone has something about themselves that they don't like and others may joke about etc etc' I teach him to defend himself against the mockery - without picking on others physical attributes etc.

Also, the figures have gone askew as the thread has gone on - he's 143cm.

Also, his dad went through puberty later - 15 ish. So I've also been very clear with son that delayed puberty is quite possible. But it also means we've seen no puberty driven growth spurt yet.

I'm sorry if I e come across as shallow etc - I completely realise there are much worse things than height. That he's an amazing person who will do amazing things with his life

But what is Mumsnet, if not a place where we can anonymously discuss our parenting fears?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread