Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids, new partner and ex

111 replies

ConflictedDad · 29/07/2023 02:26

heyyyy… so, yes, I’m a dad (and thus, not technically a “mum”) but I feel this is really the best place to ask this.

my new partner is absolutely set against meeting my ex, which is something that after our break up a few years ago, we agreed to do. So I’m in a bit of an awkward situation in that I have agreed to introduce any new partner to my ex (in the agreement a few years ago) but am 5 months into what has become a stable, happy new relationship and would like to start discussing this with my kids (all are over 8) within the next month or so, and would of course inform my ex that I am planning to introduce new partner to kids.

my question is, though it genuinely upsets me to break an agreement, would I be being unreasonable to do this without ex and new partner meeting?

OP posts:
AuntieStella · 29/07/2023 18:59

I think it is still too early to be introducing a new GF to your DC,

So buy time - work towards introductions somewhere between a year and 18months). Tell XP (maybe at about the 9 month point) that you think it may be serious and are thinking of introducing the DC some time next year. Listen to what she says. Pause and reflect on what she says.

Then find out (if she's not said upfront) how she sees your previous agreement to meet new GF before any introductions.

Don't badger your new GF about meeting the DC's DMum. Let the subject drop completely. I can see why she doesn't feel inclined to put herself forward for "ex inspection". In the longer run, it may however be better for everyone to have met. But setting immutable conditions isn't going to foster that going forwards.

I think it's laudable that you are trying to live up to your exact words. But think now is the time to slow down and, idc, negotiate carefully

Liverpool52 · 29/07/2023 18:55

It's all very well making the agreement between you and your ex, but it's an agreement that involves a third person who wasn't part of the agreement. Some may be ok with it and some may not, that's just the way it is. They don't have to go along with something that they never ageed to.

ConflictedDad · 29/07/2023 18:53

lots of very helpful responses here, I’ll respond to later on when I can get on my PC.

just to note, I don’t believe I said that my partner has refused to EVER meet my ex, though from re reading it, I can see how that may have been implied when I said “flat out refused” - that’s my mistake and I apologise. She said she wouldn’t want to meet just for the sake of it, at a one on one meeting or at my exes house etc. at a party etc with other parents around would be fine with her.

OP posts:
wordler · 29/07/2023 18:50

Caprisunny · 29/07/2023 18:40

But why wouldn’t that just happen naturally?

why does that have to be set up before the partner can meet the children? What is the huge benefit to anyone for a quick, prearranged ‘hi how are you?’.

If the partner can’t meet the kids until this passing hello has happened, it has to be a prearrange meeting. When else would the ex and new partner bump into eachother, where there’s no kids involved?

I don’t disagree with you - probably better for a casual meeting at a mutual event with the kids there than an awkward ‘vetting’ meeting but I was commenting more on the OP saying that the new partner never wants to meet the ex. And those who also commented that they’ve gone 10-15 years without meeting ex.

Perhaps OPs new partner isn’t thinking long term yet. In which case maybe don’t meet kids at all yet. But is she’s thinking longterm to moving in etc then it’s going to facilitate a better long term relationship to at least be open to meeting the kids’ mother.

TwinsPlusAnotherOne · 29/07/2023 18:50

Tapasgoofy · 29/07/2023 17:22

Not wanting to meet an ex doesn’t make you insecure or immature. What a stupid statement.

This!

Naturally meeting each other, by both being present at a drop off/pick up, or both going to a sports day or something like that, is normal. Arranging a specific meeting, so your partner can be plonked in front of someone, for them to form a judgement on her, is not.

This is only ever a stipulation by controlling people, who think they have the right to "vet" and mark their territory ("MY kids and don't you forget it") instead of the correct way forward, which is to understand it's fuck all of their business and for their ex partner to exercise their own judgement.

You were a bit foolish back then to even entertain this nonsense OP, because you might have agreed to introduce someone, to keep the ex sweet, but you are making that agreement on behalf of someone else, and you can't tell people they need to do as your ex says, just because you agreed to something stupid on their behalf, years ago.

GoodChat · 29/07/2023 18:49

@Caprisunny have you grown up in a blended household?

I don't think the girlfriend is behaving like an adult here, to be honest.

I understand that you don't think it's important but I do and, more importantly, the OP and his ex agreed that it's what's best for their children.

Caprisunny · 29/07/2023 18:46

GoodChat · 29/07/2023 18:35

@Caprisunny and the kids know the adults are all ok with each other and it's safe to welcome the new partner into their lives without worrying about upsetting mom or be able to discuss homelife without upsetting dads new girlfriend

Kids aren’t stupid. They can read body language. Seeing the adults be pleasant at pick or drop off, isn’t enough to fool them. They will be able to tell how the adults feel about the other household being mentioned. The new partner and ex don’t have to meet.

and the kids wouldn’t have even met the new partner at this meeting. What if the ex doesn’t like the new partner? That’s not going to help relations or improve anything for the kids.

If all the adults involved can’t act like adults and not be upset when someone else is mentioned, there’s a bigger problem.

A brief meeting of ex and new partner isn’t going to assure kids all is ok. What will is how they act the rest of the time. It actually could make it worse. Especially if one doesn’t like the other.

Again, a meeting isn’t required to ensure kids feel comfortable.

HoneyIShrunkThePizza · 29/07/2023 18:41

I don't understand. Will your new girlfriend never come to your kids birthdays, school events or weddings? She can't avoid ex forever in a normal relationship.

Caprisunny · 29/07/2023 18:40

wordler · 29/07/2023 18:12

But that was exactly my point - who says it has to be some long special ‘meeting’ of two households. A quick hi, nice to meet you etc.

To me it’s more weird that the new partner has said they NEVER want to meet the ex. And those who say they have never met their exDH new partner in 10-15 years.

What about school plays, sports days, graduations, big birthdays, engagements, weddings, christenings, etc

Unless there is already conflict of some sort why wouldn’t you want to be on pleasant speaking terms with someone so involved in your child’s life / the parent of the child you are taking care of.

I can’t believe I’m such an outlier on this issue - I assumed most people would opt for harmony and good will.

But why wouldn’t that just happen naturally?

why does that have to be set up before the partner can meet the children? What is the huge benefit to anyone for a quick, prearranged ‘hi how are you?’.

If the partner can’t meet the kids until this passing hello has happened, it has to be a prearrange meeting. When else would the ex and new partner bump into eachother, where there’s no kids involved?

CrazyHedgehogLover · 29/07/2023 18:38

Absolutely ridiculously, grow a backbone and tell your ex there’s no need to have an agreement that isn’t natural, why does your partner need to meet your ex? What do you expect to happen? For them to be best buddies and get along? (Some people are this way, I usually find it’s the people who ALL actually agree to meeting up tho)

my husband’s ex had this attitude towards me, had to meet me first, we was together a year and I was on my way home from work asked what my husband was up to, he said he was on the park around the corner so I met him there he obviously had his girls with him and she went ballistic (this was after us meeting), some people can come across as extremely controlling.

she then got a partner and told the girls to lie and say he was a friend and to “not tell daddy”, the girls ended up having a breakdown refusing to go home to there mum because she caused something so unnecessary!

we’re all civil now, I was anyway, just dropped them off here and there etc, I said a quick hello and goodbye..

basically what I’m trying to say is sometimes these agreements are certainly not what’s best at all, if your ex bumps into your partner and they chat etc fair enough, why force it tho? It’s the children who end up stuck in the middle of it all.

your partner has every right to say if she’s not comfortable with it, her feelings should trump your exs feelings btw, If this was my friend in this situation I’d be telling her to run for the hills!

wordler · 29/07/2023 18:38

GoodChat · 29/07/2023 18:35

@Caprisunny and the kids know the adults are all ok with each other and it's safe to welcome the new partner into their lives without worrying about upsetting mom or be able to discuss homelife without upsetting dads new girlfriend

This is a really good point - as the new partner it’s not always easy to hear about or discuss your partner’s ex but being able to take about and discuss the whole blended family in each other’s presence does make it easier for the kids in the long run.

Aprilx · 29/07/2023 18:38

ConflictedDad · 29/07/2023 16:41

To me personally, I don’t think it makes a difference. It might make things a little easier and avoid an argument between me and my ex about it, but I don’t think forcing a meeting that one doesn’t want is either 1. An acceptable part of a relationship, or 2. Something that would create a positive natural relationship (though they’re very different, that may be unlikely anyway)

So why did you agree to it then? It was a stupid thing to agree to because you were committing somebody you were yet to even meet into doing something.

I would say no to this too, I am not going to be paraded in front of an ex, for what purpose exactly, is she going to be able to veto me?

GoodChat · 29/07/2023 18:35

@Caprisunny and the kids know the adults are all ok with each other and it's safe to welcome the new partner into their lives without worrying about upsetting mom or be able to discuss homelife without upsetting dads new girlfriend

billy1966 · 29/07/2023 18:30

OP, think long and hard about pushing this on a new partner.

She has every right to refuse this and to take it as a red flag.

If she posted on here and said her new boyfriend is pushing her to meet his ex, to humour her.....I would be saying....dump.

SleepingStandingUp · 29/07/2023 18:28

Anyway, this is MN. Surely the point is you should never introduce another woman to her until the child are adults, and if you do date make sure she knows you can never have kids with her

SleepingStandingUp · 29/07/2023 18:26

I think the issue potentially is how will she be if she's home, you're not and Mom needs to drop the kids over? How will she be if the kids have a celebration that they need you both at? Will she be polite or will she ignore her and pretend she doesn't exist? What if the kids talk about Mom to her?

Is it about not feeling she needs your ex's approval or wanting to whitewash the past so she's you're only ever true love?

Ebenezergenerous · 29/07/2023 18:25

Is there conflict between you and your ex ? If there is don’t push the new partner to meet them . There is so much vitriol on MN aimed at step mum figures. It comes from somewhere.

It would be a nice thing for them to meet in passing but there is no need for more than that . My husbands ex was just horrible . It’s 20 years now and she never got any more grown up .

Pissedoffandcovidy · 29/07/2023 18:23

You can’t force a person to comply with an agreement they were never a party to. I think YANBU to plan to introduce your kids to your gf without this meeting happening. I wouldn’t like it either in your gf’s position, it indicates that your ex has a say or some kind of vetting role in your relationship that she just doesn’t have.

Scienceadvisory · 29/07/2023 18:17

ThreeLittleDots · 29/07/2023 17:10

You could walk past someone in the street and not know they'd helped give your child their dinner? I wouldn't like that.

So you've met all the teachers, TAs and lunchtime staff at your kids school? Because anyone of these could help your child with a meal. What about anyone else your ex brought around your children? You can't control that.

wordler · 29/07/2023 18:12

Testina · 29/07/2023 18:03

@wordler “Why wouldn’t all the adults involved in taking care of children that move between two households want to meet occasionally or at least be on smiling and nodding terms if you saw each other in the street.”

You don’t need a deliberately contrived two household meeting to achieve the latter. First time I saw ex’s girlfriend at “my” school gates I said - “Carlos’s mum?” and she said, “yeah - Jake, right?” I said, “Hope he’s settling in OK?” and that was that. I see her more in the local Aldi really 🤣

What did we need to meet for? So I could tell her that Jake prefers potatoes mashed extra smooth? That’s his dad’s job 🤷🏻‍♀️

But that was exactly my point - who says it has to be some long special ‘meeting’ of two households. A quick hi, nice to meet you etc.

To me it’s more weird that the new partner has said they NEVER want to meet the ex. And those who say they have never met their exDH new partner in 10-15 years.

What about school plays, sports days, graduations, big birthdays, engagements, weddings, christenings, etc

Unless there is already conflict of some sort why wouldn’t you want to be on pleasant speaking terms with someone so involved in your child’s life / the parent of the child you are taking care of.

I can’t believe I’m such an outlier on this issue - I assumed most people would opt for harmony and good will.

Testina · 29/07/2023 18:08

My friend has a pompous controlling arse who insisted on meeting her future boyfriends - and of course she said yes on the way out of the marriage to shut him up. Her boyfriend thought it was pointless but agreed for her. There followed a coffee where pompous arsehole lectured that the child was his “Princess” and he’d kill any man that would hurt her. My friend’s boyfriend was just 🤨 and said he was welcome to do a Clare’s Law application.

Caprisunny · 29/07/2023 18:06

GoodChat · 29/07/2023 18:03

Because they're going to have an impact on your children's lives and the children should be the priority?

Ok.

So you meet and then what? If you have no need to really see each other what next

They still have an impact on the child. That’s not improved by the meeting. How does the ex meeting the new partner, improve something for the kids. Especially where the ex and new partner won’t even meet on a regular occasion.

Caprisunny · 29/07/2023 18:03

ThreeLittleDots · 29/07/2023 17:10

You could walk past someone in the street and not know they'd helped give your child their dinner? I wouldn't like that.

That could happen with your child in school?

or a holiday club. Or your ex partner could have a had a friend you don’t know baby sit or round for a meal and what changed if you meet them?

What would change if the person passes you on the street and you met them once?

GoodChat · 29/07/2023 18:03

Fuckingfuming1 · 29/07/2023 17:33

Ive never met my ex’s wife, why would I want to associate with somebody with such poor judgement?

Because they're going to have an impact on your children's lives and the children should be the priority?

Testina · 29/07/2023 18:03

@wordler “Why wouldn’t all the adults involved in taking care of children that move between two households want to meet occasionally or at least be on smiling and nodding terms if you saw each other in the street.”

You don’t need a deliberately contrived two household meeting to achieve the latter. First time I saw ex’s girlfriend at “my” school gates I said - “Carlos’s mum?” and she said, “yeah - Jake, right?” I said, “Hope he’s settling in OK?” and that was that. I see her more in the local Aldi really 🤣

What did we need to meet for? So I could tell her that Jake prefers potatoes mashed extra smooth? That’s his dad’s job 🤷🏻‍♀️