Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset she changed her mind?

282 replies

Primgo · 28/07/2023 21:53

I'm really confused over if I'm being completely unreasonable to be upset about this.

I basically got into quite bad financial trouble because I owned my own business for many years but got seriously ill and went out of business while I was ill.

I ended up unable to pay rent etc so I have been staying with people for about a year.

All this was very hard to cope with. I'd always done well and losing everything while being so ill was hard and I still feel completely depressed all the time.

To cut a very long story short, my sister (very happily) agreed to help me out by being a guarantaur on a loan to help me sort out the various problems.

Not a huge loan by her standards as she's very wealthy.

On the day due to sign the papers, she changed her mind.

I'd arranged everything around the understanding she was doing this and now I'm completely screwed and whatever problems I had before are now 10 x worse.

I wish she'd just said no to begin with rather than waiting until the day to do it.

She wasn't apologetic, she was sort of mean about it. Judgemental. And I just feel incredibly let down.

Am I being unreasonable here? I know nobody owes you to guarantee a loan, but I just feel absolutely bereft and panicked.

OP posts:
Olderandolder · 29/07/2023 11:28

Gettinagoldtoof · 29/07/2023 09:03

This is so sad. On that salary I would gift that amount to one of my siblings, not expecting a penny back. I’d be delighted to and would expect the same back if I myself ever needed. Even if it meant I had to go without some luxuries I’d do it in a heartbeat for my sister or brother. OP, I know that doesn’t help you, but I don’t think your deal was unreasonable in the slightest.

Agree with practical advice to contact DD’s uni. Can you make a repayment plan with friend buying house? Can you find ways to
make extra money? Dog sitting/walking after work, rent parking space etc.

This isn’t a good idea. The issue will happen again and the numbers will increase. Resentment all round.

I have already told my teen sons that I will never bail them out. Obvs I will pay for stuff upfront, which is entirely different.

FWIW, legal advice I had from a solicitor on being a guarantor was “Don’t do it. I always say “a guarantor is an idiot with a pen””.

On this occasion, having promised, and OP having acted to her detriment in reliance on that promise, the sister should do it, if only in the short term.

WannaBeRecluse · 29/07/2023 11:28

I've reviewed OP's posts and they all say that sister was fine with it until the moment she was sent the contract. There's something in the contract that has changed her mind. Something she no doubt didn't know about before that would have been a deal breaker earlier, if she'd known then. It's not really sister's fault she didn't get to see the contract till the last minute. I'd be really curious to read that contract, because I bet it would be easy to pick what's scared her off.

MySugarBabyLove · 29/07/2023 11:26

Mintleafcocktail · 29/07/2023 10:58

MN is strange. If someone came on here saying they’d said they’d be a guarantor for their sister but only got sent the contract the day before due to sign and it had loads of fees on it, and it was to pay back another loan the sister had borrowed from a friend I am quite sure they’d be advised to take time to think about the repercussions 🤷🏻‍♀️

And if someone posted that their DP had said they would go guarantor on a loan for their sibling who had:

Lost their home
lost their business
been living rent-free for a year and still couldn’t afford to pay for things.
was considered a bad credit risk.

They would be told unanimously that their dp was in the wrong to risk their credit, and family money for this.

It’s very sad that the OP has been ill. But the reality is that if her health is such that she’s ended up in that kind of debt, then it likely could regress to a state where the sister would be saddled with her debts.

billy1966 · 29/07/2023 11:20

WarmButteryCrumpets · 29/07/2023 09:17

This.

She was "teaching you a lesson".

You can never trust her again.

I hope you get your money sorted op. There will be other solutions.

Agree with this.

I wouldn't want to be around someone who would so easily cause me such upset.

This would irrevocable change my view and I most definitely be spelling out to her that what she has done has really messed me about.

Then completely step away.

Good family do not behave like this.

MsRosley · 29/07/2023 11:14

Horrible thing for her to do. If she had objections, she should have been open about them from the get-go. I'm not sure I could get past it, and in your shoes, would rapidly revise my assumption that it was a close relationship.

Olderandolder · 29/07/2023 11:13

Batalax · 29/07/2023 10:12

I think I’d say I was sorry for the fact she’s feeling guilty but actually if you’d known to begin with then you wouldn’t have done x, y and z and you’d have had time to make alternative arrangements so yes, her changing her mind has badly impacted your decisions and screwed you over. I think you do need to be blunt and if there is fall out there is fall out, because that’s the truth. Sometimes the truth hurts.

Excellent advice!

changeyerheadworzel · 29/07/2023 11:07

Why on earth did it take you 3 months to send the contract? Sounds like she looked at it, read the small print and decided not a hope in hell. All was ok until the contract.
It feels like you are so flippant about her money. All this she wouldn’t miss it if I defaulted, it’s less than her bonus, she earns loads etc etc. Nah don’t like that attitude. You are borrowing from from a lending institution with probable very high interest rates and repercussions for her if you can’t manage it to pay back some other friend you borrowed from so she can buy a house? That’s madness. You waited 3 MONTHS to send her the contact which rings alarm bells for me, were you hoping she would barely scan it and just sign? I’d imagine the interest rates are dire given your recent and current financial position.
I think blaming your sister for your money woes is wrong. You should have sent the contract and it’s potential consequences ages ago, let her read it and sign it if she was happy and THEN told your friend you were paying her back. You did it arse about face.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 29/07/2023 10:59

topnoddy · 29/07/2023 10:41

Don't you only need a guarantor if you are at high risk of not be able to pay ?

Guarantor loans are for those that have a dodgy credit history. And yes, OP might have a history of non-payment, as if you read the OP, she lost her home.

Undoubtedly if she could have got a standard loan she would have.

Mintleafcocktail · 29/07/2023 10:58

MN is strange. If someone came on here saying they’d said they’d be a guarantor for their sister but only got sent the contract the day before due to sign and it had loads of fees on it, and it was to pay back another loan the sister had borrowed from a friend I am quite sure they’d be advised to take time to think about the repercussions 🤷🏻‍♀️

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 29/07/2023 10:57

Wow, lots of people on this thread that are just mean as fuck tbh.

YANBU OP and your sister is cruel to have pulled the rug at the last minute, unless she's going to surprise you with a gift of £6.5k.

topnoddy · 29/07/2023 10:54

There's not many jobs that earn 220K despite a lot of posters on here saying they are "high earners" !

NowItsLikeSnowAtTheBeach · 29/07/2023 10:50

If your sister earns £220,000 and wouldn't loan you £6500 after promising to for 3 months, and then gave you a judgmental speech instead, she's a bitch.

You were ill. You lost everything. This is not a pattern. This is a 'life happened' and you got hammered by it. And this was primarily about ensuring your daughter can still go to uni.

I'm sorry, but she's a bitch if that's accurate numbers.

topnoddy · 29/07/2023 10:42

being not be !

Needs an edit option on here

topnoddy · 29/07/2023 10:41

Don't you only need a guarantor if you are at high risk of not be able to pay ?

Denimdreams · 29/07/2023 10:28

viques · 29/07/2023 09:19

I think your sister has looked at your past and current financial dealings and realised what a risk being your guarantor would be.

your business went bust
you couldn’t pay your rent
you have been living rent free with other people for a year and still can’t get your financial ducks in a row.

If she acts as your guarantor she perhaps risks messing up her own credit score when things go belly up, which they will as it sounds as if you aren’t well enough to run a successful business.

I expect she could afford to give you the money, but maybe she would rather give it to a charity than watch you waste it.

Be realistic, get a paid job and sort out your personal finances before you risk other peoples money on your pipedream.

Agree with this.
I think your DS has realised she is enabling you in further poor money management.
All your posts are about why she should bail you out.
Her money is not your money.
I'm sorry you have been unwell but you need to formally sort out your finances with a debt management company via either IVA or bankruptcy.
I'm afraid it's always people who are in debt who protest they would " give the shirt off their back" when they never ever actually have the money to do this anyway.

Maddy70 · 29/07/2023 10:16

It seems as if your sister has cold feet at the last minute. It's a horrible situation for you but honestly if I were your sister I may well have done the same

She was obviously happy to help you out but then she's been discussing it , thinking about it.

If you default she is liable for your debt but also could affect her own credit ratings etc which would have long term implications for her.

You're right to be disappointed but she's not wring for backing out

Madamlulu · 29/07/2023 10:15

PussInBin20 · 29/07/2023 10:02

I think she is totally out of order. She would have known the risks when she initially agreed to it. Personally I think she should have loaned you the money herself if she is that well off.

Agree with this. I would have loaned the money to my sister myself or given it - in a heartbeat.

Emmamoo89 · 29/07/2023 10:12

YANBU X

Batalax · 29/07/2023 10:12

I think I’d say I was sorry for the fact she’s feeling guilty but actually if you’d known to begin with then you wouldn’t have done x, y and z and you’d have had time to make alternative arrangements so yes, her changing her mind has badly impacted your decisions and screwed you over. I think you do need to be blunt and if there is fall out there is fall out, because that’s the truth. Sometimes the truth hurts.

WannaBeRecluse · 29/07/2023 10:10

PussInBin20 · 29/07/2023 10:02

I think she is totally out of order. She would have known the risks when she initially agreed to it. Personally I think she should have loaned you the money herself if she is that well off.

Would she have known the risks though? I've never been a guarantor. If someone asked me to be a guarantor on a 6K loan, I'd imagine that was what I was risking. If they then gave me a contract that said, plus interest on defaults, collections fees, admin fees for collecting, I'd go, "Hang on a moment."

Of course that's they key thing, like you said - IF she is that well off. It's easy to assume about other people.

Batalax · 29/07/2023 10:05

It’s the 10x worse that she is responsible for. Have you explicitly told her that?

Hoppinggreen · 29/07/2023 10:05

The last minute change of mind isn’t great but perhaps she was advised not to do it.
Happens on here regularly

PussInBin20 · 29/07/2023 10:02

I think she is totally out of order. She would have known the risks when she initially agreed to it. Personally I think she should have loaned you the money herself if she is that well off.

Viviennemary · 29/07/2023 09:55

I think the day before was far too short notice. But asking for loans or asking for guarantors does put people in an awkward position.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 29/07/2023 09:49

The issue is not her not lending you the money or not being a guarantor. She can say no for any reason or no reason at all.

However, it was extremely shitty of her to say yes, play along for 3 months, encourage you to spend money/make plans and then pull out at the last minute. For 3 months she strung you along , thus preventing you from making other arrangements. I don't blame you for being angry and upset.

You've learned that you can't count on her., all you can do now is try your best to sort things out in a different way.

Swipe left for the next trending thread