Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset she changed her mind?

282 replies

Primgo · 28/07/2023 21:53

I'm really confused over if I'm being completely unreasonable to be upset about this.

I basically got into quite bad financial trouble because I owned my own business for many years but got seriously ill and went out of business while I was ill.

I ended up unable to pay rent etc so I have been staying with people for about a year.

All this was very hard to cope with. I'd always done well and losing everything while being so ill was hard and I still feel completely depressed all the time.

To cut a very long story short, my sister (very happily) agreed to help me out by being a guarantaur on a loan to help me sort out the various problems.

Not a huge loan by her standards as she's very wealthy.

On the day due to sign the papers, she changed her mind.

I'd arranged everything around the understanding she was doing this and now I'm completely screwed and whatever problems I had before are now 10 x worse.

I wish she'd just said no to begin with rather than waiting until the day to do it.

She wasn't apologetic, she was sort of mean about it. Judgemental. And I just feel incredibly let down.

Am I being unreasonable here? I know nobody owes you to guarantee a loan, but I just feel absolutely bereft and panicked.

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 29/07/2023 00:57

saltinesandcoffeecups · 29/07/2023 00:52

Honestly… this sounds a bit of a pattern for you OP. Why are you making arrangements on things that haven’t happened yet? Exactly how many people do you owe?

You’ve paid all of the deposits and have moved in? Now focus on staying current in your rental agreement and work on paying your debts.

If you’ve moved in already then she wasn’t acting as a guarantee otherwise you wouldn’t have moved in. Or am I missing something. This really does sound like a shell game with debt.

Ok reread a third time, the guarantee was was for a personal loan and not for the place to live.

I don’t think that changes my answer to be honest. You don’t get out of debt by borrowing money.

yogasaurus · 29/07/2023 00:57

Guarantor loans are very risky, and not provided by any of the mainstream lenders. The APR’s are high, and in all honesty, it’s all risk and no return for the guarantor. Any financial advisor would advise against them.

Finding out last minute is very difficult, but I can see why she wouldn’t want to sign.

You say you need to find another guarantor, it does sound a bit like you don’t see how much of a big ask this is.

I’m sorry for the position you are in.

Parvolax · 29/07/2023 00:57

£6.5k is a lot of money for a monthly wage. I think you may have over estimated your sisters income and not take tax etc in to account

saltinesandcoffeecups · 29/07/2023 00:52

Honestly… this sounds a bit of a pattern for you OP. Why are you making arrangements on things that haven’t happened yet? Exactly how many people do you owe?

You’ve paid all of the deposits and have moved in? Now focus on staying current in your rental agreement and work on paying your debts.

If you’ve moved in already then she wasn’t acting as a guarantee otherwise you wouldn’t have moved in. Or am I missing something. This really does sound like a shell game with debt.

Primgo · 29/07/2023 00:51

@TangledbabyI'm afraid not, she'd need a guarantaur too. I just have to find another guarantaur but I really can't think of anybody.

There isn't really anything I can do. I guess face the music on Monday. I just feel ill.

OP posts:
AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 29/07/2023 00:38

"She says it would put her in a precarious position"....

Sounds to me like something had changed for her in her life and acting as guarantor would make things hard for her. Perhaps she's not as well off as you think? Perhaps she's got her own debts to pay off and she is embarrassed, backing out at the last minute to hide it? Perhaps she's just been fired and doesn't want to say yet?

You sound pretty judgey about her financed tbh

determinedtomakethiswork · 29/07/2023 00:27

She sounds cruel and spiteful. She has shown her true colours and if I were you, I would back away from her now.

Tangledbaby · 29/07/2023 00:20

So sorry you’re going through this. You found lovely OP.

What are your other options? Can your daughter get a loan in her own name and you pay it back?

1037370E · 29/07/2023 00:05

Perhaps things have changed for her too, or maybe being a guarantor will have an impact on something that she wants to do.

Primgo · 28/07/2023 23:36

I agree she doesn't owe me the favour. I just wish she'd not spent three months acting completely fine with it because I could have had opportunity to organise something else.

I admit, I do feel a but like she should just loan it to me because I know it's not very much money to her and I'd lend it to her in a heartbeat as we're very close.

I feel guilty for saying that though. Hence the AIBU. I realise my problems aren't anyone else's. I just think it's really crap to offer to help somebody with something so serious if you're going to let them down.

OP posts:
Primgo · 28/07/2023 23:31

No I'm not still homeless. The annoying context to this was that when I started back at work a few months ago, I told her I couldn't afford to get a roof over my head until I'd paid these two things. She said to go ahead and get a place so my daughter had a home to come back to during university holiday. She said not to worry and she'd help me out with guaranteeing a loan so that way we could have a home again AND pay these things.

So I paid a deposit, moved in at considerable upfront cost on the basis of this plan. Again, something I could have decided differently if I'd had the opportunity. I don't mind sacrificing or whatever, I just wanted to get this all sorted so everyone else was okay.

So I needed a home for my daughter more than myself, but also I haven't been able to sort much with debtors because I didn't have an address! I didn't feel able to use someone else's address for debtors in case I impacted them.

I could easily afford the monthly repayments on the loan, that wouldn't be an issue. Just because I was not working for two years and have and credit from many defaults during my illness I can't get a loan by myself.

I wasn't expecting to be ill. I made no plan for iit.i wasn't able to communicate with debtors. I'm a single pparent. I barely managed. I had lots of savings but they paid the rent for and bills and after a year they were gone.

I am trying to get back on my feet.

OP posts:
pinkdelight · 28/07/2023 23:25

I don't know, you're having to borrow more to pay back other people you've borrowed from and can't pay back. I understand you're desperate but that doesn't mean she owes you this favour. The way you talk about her wealth makes it sound like you think it's nothing to her and she should just give it to you. It's all very well for you to say you'd give her the shirt off your back etc, but you're in no position to do so and she doesn't need it so it's an easy thing to say hypothetically with no risk of it coming to pass. It was wrong of her to not say sooner but maybe it was only the reality of going through with it that made her change her mind.

Siblings often have complicated relationships and she may simply have not wanted to sully your relationship with loans. You're upset with her now, but sure she'd be seriously upset with you if you defaulted on the loan. You're already talking like it's no big deal to her so she couldn't be sure you'd make good on it if you decided she could afford to cover the cost so easily herself. Quite apart from the money, it's aggro she doesn't need, as it's already proving with this fall out.

People who are well off often tend to be that way by holding onto their money. Just because they earn a lot, doesn't mean they don't value it.

Crikeyalmighty · 28/07/2023 23:13

You sound a very lovely lady and shit like this can happen to anyone, I think if she's comfortably off and knows your situation she should just have offered you it. I'm sorry she acted like this.

changeyerheadworzel · 28/07/2023 23:06

She definitely should not have left it till the last minute. That was pretty shit. I can understand her changing her mind though. Borrowing from one person to pay back someone else you borrowed from is never a good idea.
Are you still homeless and how did you propose to pay her back?

Primgo · 28/07/2023 22:59

Thanks so much. The debts I promised to repay aren't ones you can do a deal on.

One is a loan from a friend who helped out when I was sick and who needs it back now because she has a house purchase coming up.

The other is a deposit for my daughters university accommodation for next term.

So it is basically lump sums I need to pay people that will cause major problems for others if I have to go back to them now and tell them.

If she'd not said yes I'd have had time to find other solutions and I just feel so anxious now.

My sister is texting me saying I'm being manipulative by making her feel guilty. All I said was that she should not have waited until today to change her mind.

She says it would be putting her in a precarious position. But if she felt that, why not say earlier? At least then i could have done something

OP posts:
Usernamev9 · 28/07/2023 22:33

Given your updates I'll confirm you're not being unreasonable and that was a shitty thing to do on her part. I'm not sure what else you can do or what I can suggest to help your situation though I'm afraid.

Speak to citizens advice and they can make sure your getting any benefits you might be entitled to until you get back on your feet. Also there are lots of debt advice services and they can point you in the direction of legitimate ones. Your local solicitors may also do free walk in advice sessions if you need anything like that.

Good luck, there is always a way out of everything and things will get better.

Primgo · 28/07/2023 22:25

It's £6500.

A lot of money I know, but considerably less than her monthly salary.

OP posts:
Totalwasteofpaper · 28/07/2023 22:23

Accidentally posted too soon.

Money saving expert and similar always say ypu should never bail out or act as guarantors.

I am a bit of a hypocrite though because while i wouldnt bail out my sibling id prob give them up to about £10k if they needed help to get back on their feet. However we have good savings and are very close to them

Primgo · 28/07/2023 22:23

It's a long story but she agreed about three months ago and we've discussed it several times since. She never gave any indication of any kind that she had a problem. Right up until the minute I emailed her the contact she was saying no problem. I never dreamed in a million years she'd let me down.

OP posts:
Daffodilwoman · 28/07/2023 22:22

I would lend my sister the money. It’s not very kind of her op.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 28/07/2023 22:20

Power * not lower

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 28/07/2023 22:20

It sounds like a weird lower play from her if you were my sister I'd lend you the money I wouldn't let you take out a bank loan x

Totalwasteofpaper · 28/07/2023 22:20

You can use all these multipliers but how much was it actually for.
£1k? £5k? 10k?

I think its a bit naff she left it until the last minute but honeslty she prob felt pressured and then couldnt go through with it at the last minute. She most likely did the right thing.

Wondeyr · 28/07/2023 22:18

At least you know the truth now, OP.

Use this as more motivation to getting yourself back on track.

And if she ever needs help, you know what to say!

Primgo · 28/07/2023 22:14

She didn't really give much of a reason. More a very judgey speech. I know this sounds like a wanker thing to say but I know for a fact the entire loan is less than a bonus she got at work last month. She's got 5x the amount sitting in her bank, and if the boot were on the other foot I'd give her the shirt off my back. I'd just lend her the cash myself. Maybe that's an awful thing to say but I wouldn't think twice.

Even if I died or something and couldn't pay it back, the monthly repayment is pittance to her. It really is. So it just feels like all she had to do was sign a paper. It won't affect her credit rating. It won't affect her at all. And I'm really struggling with what I'm going to do now.

OP posts: