Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think America Ferrera’s speech in Barbie isn’t that great?

180 replies

Prrambulate · 28/07/2023 13:40

BARBIE SPOILERS BELOW

Everyone seems to be raving about this moment in the Barbie movie - possibly worthy of an Oscar nomination, and a quintessential characterisation of what it’s like to be a women in modern society.

I thought it was lacklustre. There are parts of it that ring true - the incessant need to be likeable - but they’re kind of cliched. And other parts I just don’t agree with (love your kids but don’t talk about them all time, ie retain a semblance of identity beyond motherhood. Isn’t that a good thing? And who’s saying we always have to be grateful? I feel there’s much more collective understanding now about the challenges of being a woman and/or mother…)

*

Speech:

”It is literally impossible to be a woman. You are so beautiful, and so smart, and it kills me that you don’t think you’re good enough. Like, we have to always be extraordinary, but somehow we’re always doing it wrong.

You have to be thin, but not too thin. And you can never say you want to be thin. You have to say you want to be healthy, but also you have to be thin. You have to have money, but you can’t ask for money because that’s crass.

You have to be a boss, but you can’t be mean. You have to lead, but you can’t squash other people’s ideas. You’re supposed to love being a mother, but don’t talk about your kids all the damn time. You have to be a career woman, but also always be looking out for other people.

You have to answer for men’s bad behavior, which is insane, but if you point that out, you’re accused of complaining. You’re supposed to stay pretty for men, but not so pretty that you tempt them too much or that you threaten other women because you’re supposed to be a part of the sisterhood.

But always stand out and always be grateful. But never forget that the system is rigged. So find a way to acknowledge that but also always be grateful. You have to never get old, never be rude, never show off, never be selfish, never fall down, never fail, never show fear, never get out of line.

It’s too hard! It’s too contradictory and nobody gives you a medal or says thank you! And it turns out in fact that not only are you doing everything wrong, but also everything is your fault.

I’m just so tired of watching myself and every single other woman tie herself into knots so that people will like us. And if all of that is also true for a doll just representing women, then I don’t even know.”

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
user9630721458 · 29/07/2023 12:46

vivainsomnia · 29/07/2023 09:01

I'm with you OP, 100% and in real life many others are.

I'm so tired of the fashionable message 'being a woman is soooooo hard' boohoo me.

Being a person is hard. Many of what she mentions apply to men just the same. Men experience similar pressures and other pressures. Why make it a competition?

I really feel sorry for young adult men who are expected to swallow all their own issues because it can never be as bad whilst expected to show full empathy of how women have it so hard because it's just the in trend right now. Films like this is just going to make it worse.

I agree with you. I find it narcissistic, self absorbed and completely tone deaf to the real inequalities people face around the world. Plus it defines women in a subservient way, always worried about what others think.

WeetabixTowels · 29/07/2023 12:03

Wanderingowl · 29/07/2023 08:23

No, not every woman experiences anything even remotely like this. The fact is that we live in the easiest, most luxurious and safe society humans have ever experienced. Life has literally never been better for anyone. And it's pretty much proven that constantly dwelling on what we don't have makes us feel bad, like a form of anti-CBT. So instead of being really fucking glad almost all the time about the wonderful lives we can have, we make up shit to get us down. It's honestly so fucking stupid.

There are things that suck about being women. We are physically weaker and slower. That makes us very vulnerable to a particular type of man. We are also, mostly, sexual and romantically attracted to men and have very limited ways of telling in advance if the man we fall for is someone who will take advantage of our vulnerability. We get pregnant, which makes us more physically vulnerable, which is often the point where those men feel most secure in being violent. Our ability to get pregnant and our physical weakness, also for a millennia and still in a lot of the world, led to a horrible society wide suppression of women. But that is not what Barbie's audience are currently living through.

Pregnancy can cause physical discomfort, sickness, pain and long term damage. Not getting pregnant and breastfeeding can increase risk of multiple illnesses. We have periods every fucking month which are, at the absolute best, a boring tiresome, pain in the arse. I haven't gone through it yet, but I believe menopause is also very unpleasant and I'm not looking forward to that. And then, in a cruel twist of fate, there are women who don't get periods and that's actually worse because it's a symptom of a medical issue that will come with other problems. Women who don't have periods and women post-menopause have much greater risk of sarcopenia and osteopenia/osteoporosis than men.

And that's it. The universal experience of womanhood. And now, in a truly bizarre turn of events, all of the validation of miserable naval-gazing has brought us to a point where it's created a society that validates men who say they are women and allows them access to spaces where we are in a lot of our most vulnerable moments. While many of our more vulnerable girls are groomed to cut their breasts off. So we've also got that to contend with. I wouldn't call it universal as it's really not something most women through history, or hopefully the future women. But it is a symptom of a society where people have learned to focus more on what they don't have than what they do.

I don’t even know where to begin with this misogynistic embarrassing garbage but you certainly don’t speak for every woman. Especially if you think being a being today is brilliant and we should be grateful and the hardest thing we face is wondering if men fancy us enough.

Don’t you just live it when women are blamed for men’s sexism too

Ponoka7 · 29/07/2023 11:43

Prrambulate · 29/07/2023 10:11

My point isn’t that lots of films do that - it’s that this film employs irony / metaness as a kind of defense mechanism. You want to make any criticisms of Mattel, for instance, and you can’t really, because the movie has already acknowledged that, lampooned them, and moved on. And so on.

Name the film's and we can see if groups of young women and girls who need this message are likely to see them and take note. Every few years are girls who don't know what we know, haven't read, or watched. We never stop anti racist messages, why not, anti sexism messages?

Ponoka7 · 29/07/2023 11:39

I live in a deprived lower working class area. I. My Facebook every weekend/festival is young women looking like fully made up, over sexualised dolls with lads who've barely had a haircut, wearing a tracksuit. The women/girls are doing all the household stuff and earning money. Then spending a good portion of injections, tanning etc to hang on to scrotes who tell them how they aren't good enough. It's a different world to the majority of MN and shows that this message is still needed. It's like whenever someone posts an outrageous scenario of abusive behaviour and posters ask, do you think it's ok? Well yes, they doubt themselves because that's what they've grown up with, are being told to put up with in their peer group. I despair at the amount of DV, the everyday sexism etc still around in my DD's peer groups.

Sigmama · 29/07/2023 11:38

Issuefroth - you felt sorry for the men in the audience? Did you actually ask them? Because I know a bunch of young men who went with their girlfriends and they all loved it. Maybe they're OK with and agree with the message, unlike their older counterparts I'd imagine

Prrambulate · 29/07/2023 11:36

DrSbaitso · 29/07/2023 11:17

Don't you think that's kind of clever?

Yes, it’s incredibly clever.

OP posts:
JamSandle · 29/07/2023 11:29

It felt old hat to me but I think the point is for your girls and teenagers it's a message they need to hear.

coeurnoir · 29/07/2023 11:27

As someone who learnt about feminism from her bra burning, Greenham common protesting mother, I'm shocked that younger women don't know about feminism.

But what pisses me right off is when as a woman I'm reduced to what my reproductive organs have or have not done.

NashvilleQueen · 29/07/2023 11:24

If I wanted to watch a mainstream truly feminist positive message film that doesn't pander to the cliches then what should I watch? Genuinely looking for recommendations as I'm not very knowledgeable.

DrSbaitso · 29/07/2023 11:17

Prrambulate · 29/07/2023 10:11

My point isn’t that lots of films do that - it’s that this film employs irony / metaness as a kind of defense mechanism. You want to make any criticisms of Mattel, for instance, and you can’t really, because the movie has already acknowledged that, lampooned them, and moved on. And so on.

Don't you think that's kind of clever?

Spectre8 · 29/07/2023 11:08

YouAreNotBatman · 29/07/2023 09:56

It is literally impossible to be a woman. You are so beautiful, and so smart, and it kills me that you don’t think you’re good enough. Like, we have to always be extraordinary, but somehow we’re always doing it wrong.

You have to be thin, but not too thin. And you can never say you want to be thin. You have to say you want to be healthy, but also you have to be thin. You have to have money, but you can’t ask for money because that’s crass.

You have to be a boss, but you can’t be mean. You have to lead, but you can’t squash other people’s ideas. You’re supposed to love being a mother, but don’t talk about your kids all the damn time. You have to be a career woman, but also always be looking out for other people.

So, two paragraphs about being beautiful and thin.
But the paragraph about being a mother and they leave out the fact that you HAVE to want to be and be a mother.
Why would they leave something so big and important out, while so much talk about looks?
That made the whole speech seem extremely shallow.

Chelsea Handler’s ’this barbie is chilfree’ twitter post showed the sheer vitriol and misogyny childfree women face.
https://twitter.com/chelseahandler/status/1683146826684448768?s=20
Check the comments.
Nothing but anger towards woman who made her own choice.

It would have been really powerful had they shown a light to the path less traveled on.
That you don’t have to be someone’s girlfriend, wife or mother.
That you can actually be independent and have amazing life just like that.

This really didn’t start, go nor end up anywhere, really.

Those comments are just awful that the only purpose in life is to have a beautiful family otherwise your lonely and got noone. Wtf!

NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/07/2023 11:08

MrsStrangeViews · 29/07/2023 10:39

Why do people keep mentioning Barbies genitals?
What’s that about?

It's the big reveal/joke/bombshell at the end of the movie that she's got them.

IamAlso4eels · 29/07/2023 10:59

MrsStrangeViews · 29/07/2023 10:39

Why do people keep mentioning Barbies genitals?
What’s that about?

Because she has none. The men who objectify her are literally sexualising something/one who has no sexual organs thus showing that the patriarchy would attempt to fuck the crack of dawn if they could.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 29/07/2023 10:40

MadamWhiteleigh · 29/07/2023 07:33

I didn’t identify with it at all. I’ve never felt I ‘have’ to be any of those things she mentions. I don’t tie myself in knots so that people like me. I’m just myself.

I honestly think women pile all this imaginary pressure and angst on themselves. Men don’t waste time on all this stuff.

Lucky you. I'm honestly jealous. I've spent my whole childhood being told I'm girling wrong. Too fat, too sporty, too loud, too quiet, too friendly, too introverted ,too active, too tomboyish, too dirty etc.

To the point I spent a few years wishing I was a boy, trying to look like a boy, and saying "I have a boy's brain in a girl's body".

Sexual assaults were my fault, bullying was my fault. Everything was my fault because I was the wrong kind of girl.

Yes I spent years trying to get people to like me and accept me and trying on different masks and copying others. You tend to be like that when your own mother doesn't like you and sees you as a disappointment and society and most adults around you play the same tune.

I'm over it now and have been for many years, because I stopped trying and decided that if my place is always in the wrong, I might just as well enjoy/please myself. Let's not pretend though that it's that easy to escape /ignore things that have been drummed into us since childhood.

MrsStrangeViews · 29/07/2023 10:39

Why do people keep mentioning Barbies genitals?
What’s that about?

AtlasOfBirds · 29/07/2023 10:37

CaptainWarbeck · 29/07/2023 10:00

For the PP who are team ken - really? The Kendom subjugated the Barbies and reduced them to sex objects who's only role was to serve the Kens. At least in Barbieland (also not perfect) the Barbies were just indifferent to the Kens, in the way that preteen groups of girls are to boys who they're not that interested in playing with.

There’s this awful trend in culture at the moment that all art has to be somehow “correct” and “moral”. Good art for any age and at any level is challenging, entertaining, moving, even disturbing.

The Kens were funny, interesting, odd, challenging, sometimes dickheads, often loving, foolish, mistaken, and were so much more interesting to me to watch than the Barbies (except President Barbie, who was excellent). Ken went on a journey of boring no one to self-hating incel to loving friend who’d learned he needed to discover himself. I’d say that’s a much richer arc and much more successful art than Barbie’s I’m perfect > I’m miserable > I’m fixed because teamwork and have a vagina!

AtlasOfBirds · 29/07/2023 10:29

Fri stately = deliberately

AtlasOfBirds · 29/07/2023 10:28

DrSbaitso · 29/07/2023 09:42

Tiresome? When was the last time you saw a film that did all that?

I think @Prrambulate means this shutting down of any non-supportive debate around the film is tiresome. It can be good that there is feminist discourse in a blockbuster, good to have a female director make a film this size, good to have a big film with so many different types of Barbie, and it also be bad at dialogue and have disappointingly shallow thinking. Disagreeing with something a woman does creatively isn’t necessarily anti-feminist - it’s how any art develops and improves.

As for this being a welcome change from the 80s & 90s films where women were just arm candy, please don’t tell the makers of Beaches, Heavenly Creatures, Fried Green Tomatoes, Steel Magnolias, Thelma & Louise, Working Girl, Clueless, Baby Boom, Alien, The Colour Purple, and
Nine to Five, all of which contained much more intelligent writing and subtlety, and none of which had any clunky speeches about how terrible life is if we constantly compare ourselves and dictate our happiness levels by people we see on the internet.

Also agree with @Wanderingowl that the film makes us overall worse with that view - that everyone hates women, and that succeeding at work fixes everything. It’s such a narrow, very very of the moment type of thinking, and there’s so many other fascinating aspects of female existence that I think are far more day to day than “lol my body type isn’t what society likes I’m having a crisis”. Like, go for a fucking walk or something, help at a charity, read a book, write a letter. This Barbie feminism isn’t empowering, it’s closely and Fri stately tied with capitalism so we leave the cinema and buy the Barbie t-shirt, the Ken hoodie, the pink coffee cup, the sparkly sunglasses, because that’s the society we live in and that’s the model this film is actually pushing.

It’s like the old thing about how you can’t make an anti-war film that doesn’t end up glamorising war - you can’t make a big studio big-budget feminism film, because we’d be tearing the seats up and setting fire to the complex if it actually did anything meaningful to our awareness and opinions.

That said, Ken was a cracking foil and I think said way more about the silliness, destructiveness and arbitrariness of patriarchy than Barbie managed. And with a dance number!

IamAlso4eels · 29/07/2023 10:17

Issuefroth · 29/07/2023 10:10

Hands up who wants their daughters to grow up thinking the best way to make their boyfriend treat them better is to go with his best mate - using/ damaging the both young men and themselves in the process? Anyone?
That is just one of the takeaways from this film for 12A viewers.

How did you take that away?

The film acknowledges that patriarchy harms men just as much as it harms women and shows the effects of toxic masculinity on a naive, impressionable mind (e.g., teens encountering the likes of Andrew Tate). The Barbie's use the Ken's toxic masculinity against them to snap them out of it, they have their big battle and realise that it's stupid and they're just hurting each other.

I liked that in the end Barbie rejects Ken even though he tries to say that they're supposed to be together because they're Barbie and Ken, instead they go off to be just Barbie and just Ken.

CaptainWarbeck · 29/07/2023 10:16

Issuefroth · 29/07/2023 10:10

Hands up who wants their daughters to grow up thinking the best way to make their boyfriend treat them better is to go with his best mate - using/ damaging the both young men and themselves in the process? Anyone?
That is just one of the takeaways from this film for 12A viewers.

I don't think this was the takeaway.

That part was a distraction

Prrambulate · 29/07/2023 10:11

DrSbaitso · 29/07/2023 09:42

Tiresome? When was the last time you saw a film that did all that?

My point isn’t that lots of films do that - it’s that this film employs irony / metaness as a kind of defense mechanism. You want to make any criticisms of Mattel, for instance, and you can’t really, because the movie has already acknowledged that, lampooned them, and moved on. And so on.

OP posts:
Issuefroth · 29/07/2023 10:10

Hands up who wants their daughters to grow up thinking the best way to make their boyfriend treat them better is to go with his best mate - using/ damaging the both young men and themselves in the process? Anyone?
That is just one of the takeaways from this film for 12A viewers.

Kimfluencer · 29/07/2023 10:07

I agree, OP. But I’m a 45 yr old radfem Grin.

I think this is probably aimed at the social media-lovin’ younger generation who like their feminism fairly light and delivered in cute, relatable little quotes.

It was a mildly entertaining film and I quite enjoyed it, but groundbreaking it wasn’t.

Zodfa · 29/07/2023 10:02

People don't go to the movies for insightful new philosophy. They go to be told stuff they already think.

CaptainWarbeck · 29/07/2023 10:00

For the PP who are team ken - really? The Kendom subjugated the Barbies and reduced them to sex objects who's only role was to serve the Kens. At least in Barbieland (also not perfect) the Barbies were just indifferent to the Kens, in the way that preteen groups of girls are to boys who they're not that interested in playing with.

Swipe left for the next trending thread