Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this car park should ONLY be for mothers?

181 replies

HuwsLineIsItAnyway · 28/07/2023 11:59

Our local big hospital has a maternity unit.

There is one small car park in immediate proximity to the maternity unit. No other departments have an entrance from this car park.

There are three large car parks on site but all are either on the other side of the hospital or the next closest to the maternity unit means climbing a massive hill to the Mat unit.
Every single time I've been here - both in this pregnancy and my previous ones - the small car park is chock full of visiting relatives, leaving a number of heavily pregnant and postpartum mums to either have to navigate the entire hospital or tackle the hill.

I view it the same way I view dads sitting in the waiting rooms and leaving pregnant women to stand.

It would be so easy to adapt the existing barriers to scan a pass (they scan staff badges) given to expectant mums.
I'm just being grumpy and sore and refluxy but AIBU to think it?

OP posts:
shakeitoffsis · 28/07/2023 15:08

Yabu. Most pregnant women can still walk and it's good for you anyway.

WeWereInParis · 28/07/2023 15:04

Spirallingdownwards · 28/07/2023 12:04

Maybe the standing pregnant women are more comfortable standing up. I know I used to be when I had issues with my pelvis which were pregnancy related.

I'd assume OP means situations where she goes into the waiting room wanting a seat, and there a men sitting down who don't offer her theirs. That happened to me on a few occasions.

greyhairnomore · 28/07/2023 14:49

How do you know the small car park is full
of visitors?

MRex · 28/07/2023 14:48

You'd have been shocked by me walking to hospital to have DS, including up a hill. It's a hospital, some of those cars are driven by people who have difficulty walking, others are dropping or collecting someone who has difficulty walking, others should have taken a bus. They all have the same right as you to a parking space. If you genuinely can't walk then you need to ask for a wheelchair.

WiddlinDiddlin · 28/07/2023 14:26

Lachimolala · 28/07/2023 13:01

The walk from Hallamshire hospital parking to Jessop Maternity Hospital is up a humongous hill with sharp bends.

I dunno why people are doubting hospitals built on hilly sites...

Worcester Royal is a pain in the arse - its built on one side of a hill, with much of the parking down the valley and up the other side, and even the parking on the same side as the hospital is on a steep slope - not do-able in a manual wheelchair, extremely uncomfortable in a power chair for many - dangerous to reverse a powerchair down a rear ramp pointing downhill (and thats the only way you can do it as you can't reverse park and unload into a bush!) - drop off points all full with people parked in them...

I don't think there is a practical and efficient way of organising parking though, it would cost so much to enforce it, it would be really complicated and confusing as well.

Alargeoneplease89 · 28/07/2023 14:23

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 28/07/2023 12:52

I'm pretty sure DM and the other cancer patients that attend her chemo unit find their conditions pretty inconvenient too. They'd love dedicated parking.

Exactly and alot aren't entitled to blue badges, yet being pregnant is practically a disability according to some on here 😂

JenniferBarkley · 28/07/2023 14:18

Naem · 28/07/2023 14:15

Well there is also pregnant and pregnant. My DH had to drop me at the end of a long walkway down the outside of the hospital while he went off to find parking - longest walk of my life. Heavily, heavily having contractions as I tried to walk down in, then had a couple in front of everybody in the lift up to the labour ward, then had the baby very shortly after getting up there - DH did manage to join me in time for the actual birth, just - but don't think I was there more than about 10-15 minutes if that, and he can't have been there more than five before DC3. I definitely could have done with somewhere closer for us to park (and for me to be dropped). Admittedly not everybody tends towards precipitous labour

Yes but @SnowSnows 's point is that this will be the same for loads of other patients attending the hospital for a huge variety of reasons. There should be set down areas for patients unable to walk (including labouring women), most hospitals do have them, really poor if yours doesn't.

Reallybadidea · 28/07/2023 14:16

however woman is a more social/spiritual (I.e “the whole person” construct

I genuinely don't understand what you mean by this.

Naem · 28/07/2023 14:15

SnowSnows · 28/07/2023 13:27

I used to think this when I was pregnant. Since having a child, I now work in a hospital and have realised that pregnant ladies are usually by far the healthiest patients in the hospital. There are plenty of other patients who should have priority over parking.

Well there is also pregnant and pregnant. My DH had to drop me at the end of a long walkway down the outside of the hospital while he went off to find parking - longest walk of my life. Heavily, heavily having contractions as I tried to walk down in, then had a couple in front of everybody in the lift up to the labour ward, then had the baby very shortly after getting up there - DH did manage to join me in time for the actual birth, just - but don't think I was there more than about 10-15 minutes if that, and he can't have been there more than five before DC3. I definitely could have done with somewhere closer for us to park (and for me to be dropped). Admittedly not everybody tends towards precipitous labour

FluffMagnet · 28/07/2023 14:13

OP, an option to put to the hospital (do they have a patient group you can join?) would be to have patients in the hospital to have reduced parking and visitors paying full whack (especially in the maternity car park). Our hospital does that, although the carpark is privately run with a little kiosk desk by the payment machines, so you can take your appointment letter or stamped ticket to prove you were there as a patient. Pregnant/postpartum women or those in labour do often have mobility issues, and most visitors will not, so I do agree that it would be preferable to encourage more thought from visitors. Signs might help guilt trip some visitors too (i.e. Patients only - visitors continue to main carpark). My local hospital has ridiculously tight spaces in all their carparks, which is a nightmare when heavily pregnant/with young children/elderly/injured. However, space is at a premium and public transport a bit rubbish, so I guess needs must.

WeetabixTowels · 28/07/2023 14:13

however woman is a more social/spiritual

@HeFellOffaDivingBoardinGuernsey van you tell me what a social or spiritual woman looks like please?

Daphnis156 · 28/07/2023 14:12

Would there be separate sections for "Planned Pregnancy" and "Accidental Pregnancy" with the latter having a longer walk?

HeFellOffaDivingBoardinGuernsey · 28/07/2023 14:12

I’m not saying I identify as a horse, just to be clear

HeFellOffaDivingBoardinGuernsey · 28/07/2023 14:11

nebulae · 28/07/2023 14:10

Sigh.

Woman = adult human female. Sex is not a social construct. Gender is a social construct. Just if we're being pedantic.

Only women can get pregnant, that is a fact.

Other people can think themselves a woman if they wish, it doesn't make them one. I can consider myself a giraffe if I wish, doesn't mean I could give birth to a baby giraffe.

Sigh

you can lead a horse to the etymological water but

nebulae · 28/07/2023 14:10

HeFellOffaDivingBoardinGuernsey · 28/07/2023 14:01

If we are all going down the “only women can be pregnant” route

female is the grammatically correct way really which indicates biological sex. So “only females can get pregnant” is scientifically correct.

however woman is a more social/spiritual (I.e “the whole person” construct so really women can only get pregnant is not correct because many people may not see themselves as a woman but can still get pregnant.

just if we were to be pedantic 😉

it does actually baffle me sometimes that people who loudly demand respect for themselves/their group, whoever they are, seem to be the ones who also show little regard for different groups who also are trying to be fairly treated. It’s literally one word that people aren’t even necessarily asking you to use all the time. Just trying to be empathetic to others in a borderline group

Sigh.

Woman = adult human female. Sex is not a social construct. Gender is a social construct. Just if we're being pedantic.

Only women can get pregnant, that is a fact.

Other people can think themselves a woman if they wish, it doesn't make them one. I can consider myself a giraffe if I wish, doesn't mean I could give birth to a baby giraffe.

HeFellOffaDivingBoardinGuernsey · 28/07/2023 14:05

@fitzwilliamdarcy thats awful, I was in a similar position in my local hospital and I would say that was also one of the worst days of my life. I really hope however things have turned out, they are good 💚

JenniferBarkley · 28/07/2023 14:03

That's awful @fitzwilliamdarcy , I'm so sorry.

HeFellOffaDivingBoardinGuernsey · 28/07/2023 14:01

If we are all going down the “only women can be pregnant” route

female is the grammatically correct way really which indicates biological sex. So “only females can get pregnant” is scientifically correct.

however woman is a more social/spiritual (I.e “the whole person” construct so really women can only get pregnant is not correct because many people may not see themselves as a woman but can still get pregnant.

just if we were to be pedantic 😉

it does actually baffle me sometimes that people who loudly demand respect for themselves/their group, whoever they are, seem to be the ones who also show little regard for different groups who also are trying to be fairly treated. It’s literally one word that people aren’t even necessarily asking you to use all the time. Just trying to be empathetic to others in a borderline group

WimbyAce · 28/07/2023 14:00

I remember when I was in labour we struggled to find a parking space near the unit and I am staff! I think we parked where we shouldn't in the end. The provision is q bad in my opinion.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 28/07/2023 13:54

My local hospital put the maternity patients and the gynae oncology patients in the same car park and waiting room.

Imagine waiting hours for an overrunning clinic to find out if you have cancer, having had an open surgery hysterectomy 8 weeks prior, surrounded by bumps and toddlers running about. Then being glared at, the entire time, for taking up a seat whilst not pregnant.

That’s the kind of scenario in which two groups should’ve been separated. I’d have given anything for segregation that day.

I realise that your scenario probably isn’t this one but neither did any of those women giving me filthy looks that day. I still think about it a lot - probably one of the worst days of my life.

WeetabixTowels · 28/07/2023 13:53

But not all ‘people’ are women, and only women can be childbearing.

I wouldn’t approve of people with prostates either. It’s men. Why are some people so afraid to use men/women. What do you think will happen?!

nebulae · 28/07/2023 13:51

I mean “people” is just easier and encompasses it all doesn’t it. Or do you not class yourself as a person? It’s just like saying “people from Australia” or “people who like pies"

No it's not the same at all. "People from Australia" could refer to women or men. Only women (and girls) can get pregnant. It might seem trivial to you but if we allow this to go unchallenged we're allowing the erasure of women as a class of people.

Hufflepods · 28/07/2023 13:46

YABU it would never occur to me that the parking at the maternity unit was not also for people visiting the maternity unit.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 28/07/2023 13:45

“Women who are pregnant and people who are biologically female but do not use “woman” who are also pregnant”

Why don't we just go the whole hog and start referring to 'pregnant mammals' or 'animated incubators'?

queenofthewild · 28/07/2023 13:44

I had to have someone drive me to all my appointments in late pregnancy as the spaces were so narrow I couldn't actually get out of the car when parked up. I had no issues with mobility or fitness, I was just enormous. Parking spaces at hospitals are never large enough for pregnant women or people with many other issues.