Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this car park should ONLY be for mothers?

181 replies

HuwsLineIsItAnyway · 28/07/2023 11:59

Our local big hospital has a maternity unit.

There is one small car park in immediate proximity to the maternity unit. No other departments have an entrance from this car park.

There are three large car parks on site but all are either on the other side of the hospital or the next closest to the maternity unit means climbing a massive hill to the Mat unit.
Every single time I've been here - both in this pregnancy and my previous ones - the small car park is chock full of visiting relatives, leaving a number of heavily pregnant and postpartum mums to either have to navigate the entire hospital or tackle the hill.

I view it the same way I view dads sitting in the waiting rooms and leaving pregnant women to stand.

It would be so easy to adapt the existing barriers to scan a pass (they scan staff badges) given to expectant mums.
I'm just being grumpy and sore and refluxy but AIBU to think it?

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/07/2023 17:41

My visitors actually all came by train as it happens but o realise that doesnt help people in isolated places

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/07/2023 17:41

YarisKaris · 28/07/2023 17:11

So you'd be happy to have no visitors (or a partner with you who might need to park) if you were being long term monitored, induced or in labour? And obviously if you had a baby in scbu you'd have no need to visit as apparently visitors don't need to be there .

Want and need are different things though. I might have wanted visitors but I didn’t need them.

The pregnant women need to be there.

Obviously if visitors have a disability that’s different but most can walk from the further car park.

Sometimeswinning · 28/07/2023 17:36

Tapasgoofy · 28/07/2023 12:22

You know why I want advantages relating to pregnancy? Because it's bloody inconvenient, that's why

Dont get bloody pregnant then🤣

You've got to love the empathy! Men will never understand it but you'd like to think another woman has your back.

The op is pissed off, tired, hormonal etc. But no as per usual let's roll out the hidden disabilities which is pretty obvious she wasn't referring to. Don't get pregnant and if you do don't moan or vent about it because women should just get on with it! I'm with you op. Makes me thankful for where I gave birth.

BlossomCloud · 28/07/2023 17:28

It's worth a reminder on this thread too that we never know what disabilities or health condition someone is battling. Many conditions are invisible .

The only outward sign of my health condition (disability )is that my eyelid droops a bit, but inwardly I could be anything from so well I can walk several miles to so unwell I might need to be admitted to ICU . People with my condition often post about how they have been scolded for parking in disabled spaces even when prominently displaying their blue badges, because they are assumed to be healthy even when seriously unwell

Cosyblankets · 28/07/2023 17:18

Visitors who don't need to be there?
Do people go to hospital for fun?
The visitor might be sitting with someone dying / receiving bad news.
The parent with kids might have no one to look after them.
Hospital car parks are for people who drive to hospital and need to park the car

ancientgran · 28/07/2023 17:11

BlossomCloud · 28/07/2023 17:02

Surely the idea is the woman in labour gets dropped off then the partner/family member/friend finds a parking space? I mean that's what we did . That's why there's a drop off zone for women in labour outside our maternity unit. It's not going to be sensible to be the driver while in active labour

That's what I think.

YarisKaris · 28/07/2023 17:11

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/07/2023 13:15

Of course you’re not be unreasonable- you’re talking about visitors who don’t need to be there, not patients of the rest of the hospital who, as I understand, are better off parking in the other car parks.

Totally agree about men taking up seats in the maternity waiting room - they don’t need to be there and the pregnant women do!

So you'd be happy to have no visitors (or a partner with you who might need to park) if you were being long term monitored, induced or in labour? And obviously if you had a baby in scbu you'd have no need to visit as apparently visitors don't need to be there .

ancientgran · 28/07/2023 17:10

AcrossthePond55 · 28/07/2023 17:00

Some do, unfortunately but I expect that happens the world over. But those spots are for the mother herself and her partner/support person to get her to admissions and settled in and then re-park. I suppose if she drove herself and parked there they'd see if she could get someone to come move the car or they'd have one of the valets from valet parking move it for her.

Although when we arrived at the hospital for DS2's birth 'way back when' DH wouldn't have had time to repark, at least not for a few hours. And he wouldn't have been able to just 'drop me off' either as I needed help to get out of the car and in the door.

Yes I can see the sense for dropping off but then the driver should go back and move the car. I mean you couldn't have enough spaces for all the women who arrived in labour and then maybe stayed for a few days. A big maternity hospital would probably need hundreds of spaces.

Unless you arrive at hospital ready to push I think the driver would have time to move the car.

BlossomCloud · 28/07/2023 17:02

furby948528 · 28/07/2023 16:41

I agree OP to an extent. My hospital is similar in that the maternity has a small car park in front of it. The rest of the hospital/car parks are around opposite sides that can be a good 10/15 minute walk. I do think there should atleast be allocated parking for women who are actually in labour. Every time I visited during the day we had issues parking. I was worried I was going to have to do a full tour of the hospital whilst in labour. Luckily both times I went into labour it was in the middle of the night!

Surely the idea is the woman in labour gets dropped off then the partner/family member/friend finds a parking space? I mean that's what we did . That's why there's a drop off zone for women in labour outside our maternity unit. It's not going to be sensible to be the driver while in active labour

decaffonlypls · 28/07/2023 17:01

Frabbits · 28/07/2023 12:08

You aren't wrong, ideally there would be dedicated parking for certain departments.

The problem is, typically, that there is never enough parking at hospitals. Our hospital is very often used as a free park and ride as there are no parking charges and no ticketing system to deter people from doing that.

Wow we have park and rides to get to
our hospital because it's so expensive/impossible to park. It's also appalling so if it's an a&e job I drive 30min past it to a minor injuries in the next town which is significantly better and cheaper/easier to park.

YarisKaris · 28/07/2023 17:01

Every man/woman for themselves at visiting time OP. Most pregnant women are just as capable as walking as the next person.

BlossomCloud · 28/07/2023 17:00

Brk · 28/07/2023 12:55

Comments like yours are the reason why no one ever offers pregnant women a seat on public transport anymore.

As someone who spent the first 4 months of pregnancy feeling faint, dizzy and nauseous, and often had to sit on the train floor surrounded by men and non-pregnant women smug in their seats and their ’pregnancy is not a disability’ opinions, I find your attitude very ignorant.

For most women, pregnancy is hugely disabling.

I was very ill in the first few months - I just politely asked people if they minded giving me a seat. Someone was always happy to.

AcrossthePond55 · 28/07/2023 17:00

ancientgran · 28/07/2023 16:27

Do women drive themselves to hospital when they are in labour? The car could end up being in the reserved space for days. If someone has driven them to hospital they could drop them off and go and park somewhere else.

Some do, unfortunately but I expect that happens the world over. But those spots are for the mother herself and her partner/support person to get her to admissions and settled in and then re-park. I suppose if she drove herself and parked there they'd see if she could get someone to come move the car or they'd have one of the valets from valet parking move it for her.

Although when we arrived at the hospital for DS2's birth 'way back when' DH wouldn't have had time to repark, at least not for a few hours. And he wouldn't have been able to just 'drop me off' either as I needed help to get out of the car and in the door.

Scalottia · 28/07/2023 16:56

Tapasgoofy · 28/07/2023 12:22

You know why I want advantages relating to pregnancy? Because it's bloody inconvenient, that's why

Dont get bloody pregnant then🤣

Exactly! Logic fail.

YABU OP.

BlossomCloud · 28/07/2023 16:55

Yabu. I appreciate there are conditions that make mobility difficult in pregnancy, or mean pregnant women are ill (eg hyperemesis) but if you are health and pregnant then keeping moving is a good thing. I carried on walking miles a day right up till I went into labour in both pregnancies. I certainly didn't deserve a close space more than someone who was ill or disabled or just transporting lots of stuff for an ill relative.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 28/07/2023 16:54

It would make a lot of sense to have visitor and patient parking spaces.

Not sure specific privileges for mother is the best idea. Other patients could have mobility issues, intense pain etc. as well. Why shouldn`t they get one of these spots (if available)?

stayathomer · 28/07/2023 16:50

When people want free parking at hospitals because people are ill I always wonder if the bus to the hospital should be free as well, the bus user might be poorer than the car owner.
Went to a private hospital the other day with my son. Payed 250€ for a five minute consultation in a place that was like a palace, then told my other son to wander into the cafe and see if he could get anything as we’d rushed out. He came back and said a ham and cheese sandwich was €8! Then parking was €2.50 for less than an hour. Scary stuff!

furby948528 · 28/07/2023 16:41

I agree OP to an extent. My hospital is similar in that the maternity has a small car park in front of it. The rest of the hospital/car parks are around opposite sides that can be a good 10/15 minute walk. I do think there should atleast be allocated parking for women who are actually in labour. Every time I visited during the day we had issues parking. I was worried I was going to have to do a full tour of the hospital whilst in labour. Luckily both times I went into labour it was in the middle of the night!

stayathomer · 28/07/2023 16:35

Yabu - I’m only saying that because it’s a hospital and have had to stop because of parking in the past when running in with a child for accident and emergency. A pregnant lady having to walk further is no way more important then what could possibly be something life threatening

AutumnCrow · 28/07/2023 16:34

I view dads sitting in the waiting rooms and leaving pregnant women to stand. - OP

Maybe the standing pregnant women are more comfortable standing up. - Gilead Central

Just when you've think you've seen it all on MN. YANBU, @HuwsLineIsItAnyway

ancientgran · 28/07/2023 16:27

AcrossthePond55 · 28/07/2023 15:11

One of the (US) hospitals near where I live has a few spaces near the ER entrance (also the maternity entrance) marked 'mothers in labour only' or something similar in the same row but further down than the disabled placard slots. I don't think that's a bad idea.

But wholesale 'mothers only'? Nope. There weren't even disabled slots for those who needed them let alone parent/child slots when I was pregnant/had small DC and we managed to survive.

Unless one has a 2ndary condition making mobility difficult then walking is good for a pregnant woman. And if one does have a 2ndary condition in the US one can get a temp placard, does the UK not have that?

Do women drive themselves to hospital when they are in labour? The car could end up being in the reserved space for days. If someone has driven them to hospital they could drop them off and go and park somewhere else.

Willmafrockfit · 28/07/2023 16:26

yabu
unless you mean New Parents.

ancientgran · 28/07/2023 16:21

My local hospital is a short walk from a railway station and commuters to the local city would park at the hospital as it was free. I was thrilled to bits when they started charging and I could park. Commuters using a space from say 8 am to 6 pm was a real cheek.

When people want free parking at hospitals because people are ill I always wonder if the bus to the hospital should be free as well, the bus user might be poorer than the car owner. How about petrol should the local garage give us some free because we are going to a hospital?

crossedwood · 28/07/2023 15:25

scaredofpate · 28/07/2023 12:53

One of our hospitals has several car parks all of which are pay and display. The one car park which is free of charge is for the cancer unit which is right at the back of the hospital down a hill. People have now realised this and park there leaving no room for cancer patients to park. Now that pisses me off.

When my dad was a cancer patient we'd provide car reg to the receptionist so the barrier would rise without payment.

AcrossthePond55 · 28/07/2023 15:11

One of the (US) hospitals near where I live has a few spaces near the ER entrance (also the maternity entrance) marked 'mothers in labour only' or something similar in the same row but further down than the disabled placard slots. I don't think that's a bad idea.

But wholesale 'mothers only'? Nope. There weren't even disabled slots for those who needed them let alone parent/child slots when I was pregnant/had small DC and we managed to survive.

Unless one has a 2ndary condition making mobility difficult then walking is good for a pregnant woman. And if one does have a 2ndary condition in the US one can get a temp placard, does the UK not have that?

Swipe left for the next trending thread